David Kramer’s piece “Capture alone isn’t sufficient to bottle up carbon dioxide” (Physics Today, July 2023, page 22) focuses on the need in the US to create a massive CO2 sequestration capacity, which is indeed in need of attention. But the story was deficient in one respect and inaccurate in another.
In Oklahoma, induced earthquakes over the past decade have mainly been attributed to wastewater disposal—in particular, high injection rates—but some have been associated with hydraulic fracturing, or “fracking.”1,2 Those relationships suggest that high-rate injection of supercritical CO2 into deep saline aquifers may lead to seismicity. Indeed, the Intergovernmental Panel on Climate Change foresaw that possibility in 2005.3 Because the physical properties of supercritical CO2 differ from those of wastewater, it’s uncertain whether they will have identical seismogenic effects. But there is a need for regulations, guided by independent research, that ensure that CO2 sequestration is performed in a manner that does not lead to earthquakes.
Carbon dioxide is heavier than air, and therefore its airborne dispersion characteristics are altogether different from those of natural gas, and CO2 pre-sents an increased danger to both land-based and aquatic life. Indeed, contrary to Kramer’s assertion that no one was injured in the 2020 CO2 pipeline rupture near Satartia, Mississippi, the event led to the hospitalization of at least 45 people in addition to the evacuation of over 200.4
Given that risk, the environmental hazards, and the potential for violating the rights of Indigenous communities, CO2 pipelines have unsurprisingly been met with public opposition. The carbon capture and sequestration community should respond by building trust with the public—starting with repurposing existing natural gas pipelines to transport CO2—and by strictly adhering to environmental protection regulations, treaties with Indigenous communities, and existing legal requirements. Rules and regulations must be changed to ensure that the characteristics of CO2 are fully accounted for, both in its transportation and in its sequestration, and not to accelerate the laying of new pipelines.
