The Air Force has led a research effort to investigate the thresholds and mechanisms for retinal damage from ultrashort laser pulses [i.e. nanosecond (10−9 sec) to femtosecond (10−15 sec) pulse durations] for the past several years. The outcome is a recommendation for the establishment of maximum permissible exposure limits in the visible and near infrared. We review the progress made in determining trends in retinal damage1 from laser pulses from one nanosecond to one hundred femtoseconds duration at visible and near-infrared wavelengths including variations in spot size and number of pulses. We discuss the most likely damage mechanisms operative in this pulse width regime and discuss relevance to laser safety.
REFERENCES
1.
The animals involved in this study were procured, maintained, and used in accordance with the Federal Animal Welfare Act and die “Guide for the Care and Use of Laboratory Animals”, prepared by the Institute of Laboratory Animal Resources - National Research Council.
2.
Cain
C. P.
, Toth
C. A.
, DiCarlo
C. D.
, Stein
C. D.
, Noojin
G. D.
, Stolarski
D. J.
, Roach
W. P.
. “Visible Retinal Lesions from Ultrashort Laser Pulses in the Primate Eye
”. Investigative Ophthalmology and Visual Science
Vol. 36
: (1995
). pp. 879
–888
.3.
Cain
C. P.
, Toth
C. A.
, DiCarlo
C. D.
, Noojin
G. D.
, Amnotte
R. E.
, Caruthers
V.
, and Rockwell
B. A.
. “Visible Lesion Thresholds from Near-Infrared Pico and Nanosecond Laser Pulses in the Primate Eye
”, in Laser-Tissue Interaction VIII
, Steven
L.
Jacques
, Ed., Proc. SPIE
Vol. 2975
: (1997)
. pp. 133
–137
.4.
Cain
Clarence P
, Toth
Cynthia A
, Noojin
Gary D
, Stolarski
David J
, Rockwell
Benjamin A.
. “Femtosecond laser pulses in the near-infrared produce visible lesions in the primate eye
”, in Laser-Tissue Interaction, Tissue Optics, and Laser Welding III
, Delacretaz
Guy P.
; Svaasand
Lars O.
; Steiner
Rudolf W.
, Pini
Roberto
; Godlewski
Guilhem
; Eds. Proc., SPIE
Vol. 3195
: (1998
). pp. 121
–126
.5.
Cain
C. P.
, Toth
C. A.
, Noojin
G. D.
, Stolarski
D.J.
, Payne
D.J.
and Rockwell
B. A.
. “Visible Lesion Thresholds Dependency on Retinal Spot Size for Ultrashort Laser Pulses in the Near-Infrared
”, in Laser-Tissue Interaction IX
, Steven
L.
Jacques
, Ed., Proc. SPIE
Vol. 3254
: (1998
). pp. 126
–129
.6.
Cain
C. P.
, Toth
C.A.
, Noojin
G.D.
, Stolarski
D.J.
and Rockwell
B.A.
. “Visible Lesion Thresholds from Multiple Pulse Near-Infrared Ultrashort Laser Pulses in the Retina
”, submitted to Health Physics, December 1998
.7.
Rockwell
B.A.
, Kennedy
P.K.
, Thomas
R.J.
, Roach
W.P.
and Rogers
M.E.
. “The Effect of Nonlinear Optical Phenomena on Retinal Damage
”, in Laser-Tissue Interaction VI
, Steven L.
Jacques
, Editor, Proc. SPIE
2391
: (1995
). pp. 89
–99
.8.
Rockwell
Benjamin A.
, Hammer
D.X.
, Hopkins
R.A.
, Payne
D.J.
, Toth
C.A.
, Roach
W.P.
, Druessel
J.J.
, Kennedy
P.K.
, Amnotte
R.E.
, Eilert
B.
, Phillips
S.
, Noojin
G.D.
, Stolarski
D J.
and Cain
C.
. “Ultrashort Laser Pulse Bioeffects and Safety
”. Proceedings of the International Laser Safety Conference
Vol. 3
: (1997
). pp. 159
–165
.9.
Cain
C.P.
, Noojin
G.D.
, Hammer
D.X.
, Thomas
R.J.
and Rockwell
B.A.
. “Artificial Eye for In-vitro Experiments of Laser Light Interaction with Aqueous Media
”. Jour. Biomedical Optics
Vol. 2
: (1997
). pp. 88
–94
.10.
Hammer
D. X.
, Thomas
R. J.
, Noojin
G. D.
, Rockwell
B. A.
, Kennedy
P. K.
, and W. P.
, Roach
. “Experimental Investigation of Ultrashort Pulse Laser-Induced Breakdown Thresholds in Aqueous Media
”. IEEE Jour. Quant. Electronr.
Vol. 32
: (1996
). pp. 670
–678
.11.
Cain
C. P.
, DiCarlo
C. D.
, Rockwell
B. A.
, Kennedy
P. K.
, Noojin
G. D.
, Stolarski
D. J.
, Hammer
D. X.
, Toth
C. A.
, and Roach
W. P.
. “Retinal Damage and Laser-Induced Breakdown Produced by Ultrashort-Pulse Lasers
”. Graefe’s Archive for Clinical and Experimental Ophthalmology
Vol. 234
: suppl. 1
: (1996
). pp. S28
–S37
.12.
Cain
C. P.
, DiCarlo
C. D.
, Noojin
G. D.
, Amnotte
R. E.
, Rockwell
B. A.
and Roach
W. P.
. “In-Vivo Laser-induced Bubbles in the Primate Eye with Femtosecond Pulses
”, in Laser-Tissue Interaction VII
, Steven
L
. Jacques
, Ed., Proc. SPIE
Vol. 2681A
: (1996
). pp. 382
–388
.13.
Cain
C.P.
, Toth
C.A.
, Stein
C.D.
, Noojin
G.D.
, Stolarski
D.J.
, Rockwell
B.A.
, Boppart
S.A.
and Roach
W.P.
. “Femtosecond laser threshold: retinal damage versus induced breakdown mechanisms
”, in Laser-Tissue Interaction V
, Steven
L.
Jacques
, Ed., Proc. SPIE
Vol. 2134A
: (1994
). pp. 22
–27
.14.
Payne
D. J.
, R. A.
Hopkins
Jr., Eilert
B.G.
, Noojin
G.D.
and Rockwell
B.A.
. “Threshold Energies in the Artificial Retina
”. Laser-Tissue Interaction IX
, Steven
L.
Jacques
Ed., Proc. SPIE
Vol. 3254
: (1998
). pp. 130
–134
.15.
Payne
D. J.
, Jost
T.R.
, Eilert
B.G.
, Noojin
G.D.
, Elliot
J.J.
, Lot
L.
, Lot
K.
, Lin
C.P.
and Rockwell
B.A.
. “Cavitation Thresholds in the Rabbit Retina Pigmented Epithelium”. Laser-Tissue Interaction X
, Steven
L
. Jacques
Ed., in press.16.
Watanabe
S.
, Anderson
R.R.
, Brorson
S.
, Dalickas
G.
, Fujimoto
J.G.
and Flotte
T.J.
. “Comparative studies of femtosecond to microsecond laser pulses on selective pigmented cell injury in skin
”. Photochem. and Photobiol.
Vol. 55
: (1991
). pp. 757
–762
.17.
Jacques
S.
, Oraevsky
A.A.
, Thompson
R.
and Gerstman
B.S.
. “A working theory and experiments on photomechanical disruption of melanosomes to explain the threshold for minimal visible retinal lesions for sub-ns laser pulses
”, in Laser-Tissue Interaction V
, Steven
L
. Jacques
, Ed., Proc. SPIE
Vol. 2134A
: (1994
). pp. 54
–65
.18.
Rockwell
B.A.
, Kennedy
P.K.
, Thomas
R.J.
, Roach
W.P.
and Rogers
M.E.
. “The Effect of Nonlinear Optical Phenomena on Retinal Damage
”, in Laser-Tissue Interaction VI
, L. Steven
Jacques
, Editor, Proc. SPIE
Vol. 2391
: (1995
). pp. 89
–99
.19.
Rockwell
Benjamin A.
, Hammer
D.X.
, Hopkins
R.A.
, Payne
D.J.
, Toth
C.A.
, Roach
W.P.
, Druessel
JJ.
, Kennedy
P.K.
, Amnotte
R.E.
, Eilert
B.
, Phillips
S.
, Noojin
G.D.
, Stolarski
D.J.
and Cain
C.
. “Ultrashort Laser Pulse Bioeffects and Safety
”. Proceedings of the International Laser Safety Conference
Vol. 3
: (1997
). pp. 159
–165
.20.
Rockwell
B.A.
, Hammer
D.X.
, Hopkins
R.A.
, Payne
D.J.
, Toth
C.A.
, Roach
W.P.
, Druessel
J.J.
, Kennedy
P.K.
, Amnotte
R.E.
, Eilert
B.G.
, Philips
S.
, Noojin
G.D.
, Stolarski
D.J.
, and Cain
C.P.
. “Ultrashort Laser Pulse Bioeffects and Safety
”, Journal of Laser Applications
Vol. 11
(3
): (1998
).21.
Roach
W. P.
, Johnson
T. E.
and Rockwell
B. A.
. “Proposed Maximum Permissible Exposure Limits for Ultrashort Laser Pulses
”, accepted by Health Physics, August 1998
.22.
ANSI Standard Z136.1
. American national standard for the safe use of lasers
. American National Standards Institute, Inc.
, New York
. 1993
.23.
Koschinski
W.
, Schirmacher
A.
and Sutter
E.
, “Induced transmittance of eye-protective laser filters
”, Jour. Laser Appl.
Vol. 10
: (June 1998
). pp. 126
–130
.
This content is only available via PDF.
© 1999 Laser Institute of America.
1999
Laser Institute of America
You do not currently have access to this content.