The purpose of this study was to determine the threshold energy for retinal damage by a blue light-emitting diode (LED) as determined by clinical observation, physiologic measurements and histology. Seven adult male rhesus monkeys were anesthetized, paralyzed with pancuronium bromide to immobilize eye muscles and maintained on a respirator. A Topcon slit-lamp microscope was adapted to hold an LED which was used to expose a portion of the macula. Measurement at 460nm produced a power of 0.85 mW at the objective lens placed before the eye and was calculated to range from 0.612 joules (J) to a maximum of 4.59J on the retina. Time increments were tested from 12 to 90 min and changes monitored at 2 and 30 days post-exposure by fundoscopy, confocal scanning laser retinal tomography, S-cone macular electroretinography (ERG) and digital fluorescein angiography (FAG). The contralateral eye served as internal control. Two days after exposure, a reproducible, optically pale, subretinal lesion measuring about 1.8-2.0 mm in diameter was observed between 40 (2.04J) and 90min(4.59J) of exposure which overlapped approximately 10-13% of the macula. In supra-threshold experiments, FAG showed leakage of dye and retinal tomography showed damaged outer retina within the lesion at all exposures >30 min, the S-cone threshold decreased at 2 days post exposure relative to L-cone signals and by 30 days, had returned to baseline. Morphological examination revealed a selective pathology related to the outer retinal layers. At maximum exposure the total retinal thickness was reduced by 28% i.e., 145 μm for LED vs. 200 μm (unaffected area). Changes were also seen adjacent to the lesion (175 μm) suggesting extension beyond the clinically observed margin. These changes were not regularly observed below 34 min of exposure. Based on the most sensitive clinical measure, an increase of the ERG at just above 30 min, may represent a damage threshold level. Prolonged exposure may pose a toxic hazard for the human retina. This is the first time a potential safety level for an incoherent blue LED light has been reported.

1.
Sliney
D.
Laser and LED eye hazards: safety standards
.”
Optics & Photonics News
(Sept
1997
), pp
31
37
.
2.
Lawwill
T.
Three major pathological processes caused by light into primate retina: a search for mechanisms
.”
Tr Am Ovhthal Soc
(
LXXX
,
1983
), pp
519
79
.
3.
Robertson
D
and
McLaren
J
. “
Photic retinopathy from the operating microscope
.”
Arch Ophthalmol
107
(
1989
), pp
373
75
.
4.
Ham
W
,
Mueller
H
,
J
Ruffolo
Jr
,
Guerry
D
and
Guerry
RK
. “
Action spectrum for retinal injury from near-ultraviolet in the aphakic money
.”
Am J Ophthalmol
93
(
1982
), pp
299
306
.
5.
Sykes
S
,
WG
Robison
Jr
,
Waxier
M
and
Kuwakara
T
. “
Damage to the monkey retina by broad-spectrum fluorescent light
.”
Invest Ophthalmol Vis Sci
20
(
1981
), pp
425
33
.
6.
Toth
C
,
Narayan
D
,
Cain
C
,
Noojin
G
,
Winter
K
,
Rockwell
B
and
Roach
W
. “
Pathology of macular lesions from subnanosecond pulses of visible laser energy
.”
Invest Ophthalmol Vis Sci
38
(
1997
), pp
2204
13
.
7.
Sperling
H
. “
Spectral sensitivity, intense spectral light studies and the color receptor mosaic of primates
.”
Vision Res
26
(
1986
), pp
1557
72
.
8.
Organisciak
D
and
Winkler
B
. “
Retinal light damage: practical and theoretical considerations
.”
Pros Retinal Eve Res
13
(
1994
), pp
1
29
.
9.
Ham
W.
“The photopathology and nature of blue-light and near-UV retinal lesion produced by lasers and other optical sources.”
Laser Avvlication in Medicine and Biology
.
Wolbarscht
M.
, ed.
Plenum Press
,
New York
, (
1989
), pp
191
246
.
10.
Simonsen
S
and
Rosenberg
T
. “
Reappraisal of a short-wave length-sensitive (S-cone) recording technique in routine clinical electroretinographv
.”
Doc Ophthlamol
91
(
1995-6
), pp
323
32
.
11.
Gouras
T
,
MacKay
C
and
Yamamoto
S
. “
The human S-cone electroretinogram and its variation among subj ects with and without L and M-cone function
.”
Invest Ophthalmol Vis Sci
34
(
1993
), pp
2437
42
.
12.
Ahnelt
P
,
Kolb
H
and
Pflug
R
. “
Identification of a subtype of cone photoreceptors likely to be blue sensitive, in the human retina
.”
J Comp Neurol
255
(
1987
), pp
18
34
.
13.
Lawwill
T
,
Crockett
S
and
Currier
G
. “
Retinal damage secondary to chronic light exposure
.”
Doc Ophthalmol
44
(
1977
), pp
379
402
.
14.
Gorgels
T
and
van Norren
D
. “
Ultraviolet and green light cause different types of damage in rat retina
.”
Invest Ophthalmol Vis Sci
36
(
1995
), pp
851
63
.
15.
Cain
C
,
Toth
C
,
DiCarlo
C
,
Stein
C
,
Noojin
G
,
Stalarski
D
and
Roach
W
. “
Visible retinal lesions from ultrashort laser pulses in the primate eye
.”
Invest Ophthalmol Sci
36
(
1995
), pp
879
88
.
16.
Tajnai
J.
Eye safety standards impacting infrared lased communication
.”
Infrared Data Assoc.
(
1997
), pp
1
4
.
17.
Curcio
C
,
Allen
K
,
Sloan
K
,
Lerea
C
,
Hurlay
J
,
Klodz
I
and
Milann
A
.
Distribution and morphology of human cone photoreceptors stained with anti-blue opsin
.
J Comp Neurol
312
(
1991
), pp
610
24
.
18.
The IESNA Committee
.
American National Standard Recommended Practice for Photobiological Safety for Lamps
-
Risk Group Classification and Labeling Illuminating Engineering Society of North America
,
NY
, (
1996
), pp
1
16
.
19.
Abler
AS
,
Chang
CJ
,
Ful
J
,
Tso
MO
and
Lam
TT
. “
Photic injury triggers apoptosis of photoreceptor cells
.”
Res Commun Mol Pathol Pharmacol
92
(
1996
), pp
177
89
.
This content is only available via PDF.
You do not currently have access to this content.