The ANSI Z136.1-2014 Standard for Safe Use of Lasers is the eighth revision of the guideline which was first issued in 1973 and subsequently updated in 1976, 1980, 1986, 1993, 2000, 2007 and 2014. The 1973 Maximum Permissible Exposure (MPE) guidance was based upon the best (but limited) laser induced injury threshold data available at that time. Laser bioeffects researchers have continued to develop new insights into the nature of laser/tissue interaction and to expand the laser-induced injury threshold database. The MPE guidance has evolved to accommodate the new data, though normally with some lag as the new data was assimilated and understood. The 2014 edition of the standard has caught up with the new data and understanding and has confronted the laser safety community with a greater number of changes with greater impact on the MPE guidance than had been introduced in any other edition of the standard. As the user community, has digested the new guidance, the impact on laser Classes, which are based on the MPE, has been questioned. This paper will compare the guidance of each the eight editions to the best laser-induced injury threshold data available at the time that edition was issued with the goal of understanding how the historic relationship between the threshold data and the MPE.

1.
ANSI, American National Standard for the Safe Use of Lasers
Z136.1-1980,
American National Standards Institute
,
New York, NY
,
1980
.
2.
ANSI, American National Standard for the safe use of lasers
, Z136.1-1986,
Laser Institute of America
,
Toledo, OH
,
1986
.
3.
ANSI, American National Standard for Safe Use of Lasers
, Z136.1-1993,
Laser Institute of America
,
Orlando, FL
,
1993
.
4.
ANSI, American National Standard for Safe Use of Lasers
, Z136.1-2000,
Laser Institute of America
,
Orlando FL
,
2000
.
5.
ANSI, American National Standard for Safe Use of Lasers
, Z136.1-2007,
Laser Institute of America
,
Orlando FL
,
2007
.
6.
ANSI, American National Standard for Safe Use of Lasers
Z136.1-2014,
Laser Institute of America
,
Orlando, FL
,
2014
.
7.
ANSI., American National Standard for the safe use of Lasers
, Z136.1-1973
American National Standards Institute
,
New York, NY
,
1973
.
8.
D.J.
Lund
,
P.R.
Edsall
,
B.E.
Stuck
,
Spectral dependence of retinal thermal injury
,
Journal of Laser Applications
,
20
(
2008
)
76
82
.
9.
J.A.
Zuclich
,
D.J.
Lund
,
B.E.
Stuck
,
Wavelength dependence of ocular damage thresholds in the near-IR to far-IR transition region: Proposed revisions to MPEs, Health Physics
,
92
(
2007
)
15
23
.
10.
D.J.
Lund
, The action spectrum for retinal thermal injury, in:
R.
Mathes
,
D.H.
Sliney
(Eds.)
Measurements of optical radiation hazards, Markl-Druck
,
Munchen
,
1999
, pp.
209
228
.
11.
D.J.
Lund
,
P.R.
Edsall
,
B.E.
Stuck
,
Ocular hazards of Q-switched blue wavelength lasers
,
SPIE
,
4246
(
2001
)
44
53
.
12.
D.J.
Lund
,
P.R.
Edsall
,
B.E.
Stuck
,
Ocular hazards of Q-switched near-infrared lasers
,
SPIE
,
4943
(
2003
)
85
90
.
13.
J.
Zuclich
,
D.
Lund
,
B.
Stuck
,
P.
Edsall
,
Ocular effects and safety standards implications for highpower lasers in the 1.3-1.4 μm wavelength range. Brooks City-Base, TX, Air Force Research Laboratory, Optical Radiation Branch:AFRL-HE-BR-TR-2004-0187
,
2004
.
14.
W.T.
Ham
, Jr.
,
H.A.
Mueller
,
D.H.
Sliney
,
Retinal sensitivity to damage from short wavelength light
,
Nature
,
260
(
1976
)
153
155
.
15.
J.A.
Zuclich
,
P.R.
Edsall
,
D.J.
Lund
,
B.E.
Stuck
,
S.J.
Till
,
R.C.
Hollins
,
P.K.
Kennedy
,
L.N.
McLin
,
New data on the variation of laser-induced retinal damage threshold with retinal image size
,
JLA
,
20
(
2008
)
83
88
.
16.
C.P.
Cain
,
C.A.
Toth
,
C.D.
DiCarlo
,
C.D.
Stein
,
G.D.
Noojin
,
D.J.
Stolarski
,
W.P.
Roach
,
Visible retinal Lesions from ultrashort laser pulses in the primate eye
,
IOVS
,
36
(
1995
)
879
888
.
17.
B.J.
Lund
,
D.J.
Lund
,
P.R.
Edsall
,
Laser-induced retinal damage threshold measurements with wavefront correction
,
Journal of Biomedical Optics
,
13
(
2008
)
064011
.
18.
B.J.
Lund
,
D.J.
Lund
,
M.L.
Holmes
, Retinal damage thresholds in the 1 ns to 100 ns exposure duration range, in:
Proceedings of the ILSC
,
Laser Institute of America
,
San Jose, CA
,
2011
, pp.
183
186
.
19.
W.
Roach
,
T.
Johnson
,
B.
Rockwell
,
Proposed maximum permissible exposure limits for ultrashort pulses
,
Health Physics
,
76
(
1999
)
349
354
.
20.
B.
Rockwell
,
R.
Thomas
,
A.
Vogel
,
Ultrashort laser pulse retinal damage mechanisms and their impact on thresholds
,
Medical Laser Application
25
(
2010
)
84
92
.
21.
B.E.
Stuck
,
D.J.
Lund
,
E.S.
Beatrice
, Repetitive pulse laser data and permissible exposure limits.
Letterman Institute of Research Report No. 58
,
San Francisco, CA
,
1978
.
22.
D.J.
Lund
,
D.
Sliney
,
A new understanding of multiple-pulsed laser-induced retinal injury thresholds
,
Health Physics
,
106
(
2014
)
505
515
.
23.
T.
Bergqvist
,
B.
Kleman
,
B.
Tengroth
,
Retinal lesions produced by Q-switched lasers
,
Acta Ophth
,
44
(
1966
)
853
863
.
24.
E.S.
Beatrice
,
G.D.
Frisch
,
Retinal laser damage thresholds as a function of the image diameter
,
Archives Environmental Health
,
27
(
1973
)
322
326
.
25.
R.G.
King
,
W.T.
Geeraets
,
The effect of Q-switched ruby laser on retinal pigment epithelium
in vitro,
Acta Ophthalmol
,
46
(
1968
)
617
631
.
26.
A.
Vassiliadis
,
R.C.
Rosan
,
R.R.
Peabody
,
H.C.
Zweng
,
R.C.
Honey
,
Investigations of retinal damage using a Q-switched ruby laser (AD489476)
.
Stanford Research institute, Menlo Park CA
,
1966
.
27.
E.S.
Beatrice
,
P.D.
Shawaluk
,
Q-switched neodymium laser retinal damage in rhesus monkey
.
Frankford Arsenal Report No. M73-9-1
,
Philadelphia, PA
1973
.
28.
W.T.
Ham
, Jr.
,
W.T.
Geeraets
,
H.A.
Mueller
,
R.C.
Williams
,
A.M.
Clarke
,
S.F.
Cleary
,
Retinal burn thresholds for the helium-neon laser in the rhesus monkey
,
Arch Ophthalmol
,
84
(
1970
)
797
809
.
29.
A.I.
Goldman
,
W.T.J.
Ham
,
H.A.
Mueller
,
Ocular damage thresholds and mechanisms for ultrashort pulses of both visible and infrared laser radiation in the rhesus monkey
,
Exp Eye Res
,
24
(
1977
)
45
56
.
30.
D.J.
Lund
, Variation of ED50 with retinal irradiance diameter - 850 nm Erbium laser.
Letterman Army Institute of Research Laboratory Notebook U0023-G
,
San Francisco, CA
,
1977
, pp.
28
49
.
31.
D.J.
Lund
, Variation of ED50 with retinal irradiance diameter - 599 nm Flashlamp-pumped dye laser.
Letterman Army Institute of Research Laboratory Notebook U0023-G
,
San Francisco, CA
,
1979
, pp.
8
52
.
32.
R.G.
Borland
,
D.H.
Brennan
,
J.
Marshall
,
J.P.
Viveash
,
The role of fluorescein angiography in the detection of laser-induced damage to the retina: A threshold study for Q-switched neodymium and ruby lasers
,
Exp Eye Res
,
27
(
1978
)
471
493
.
33.
D.J.
Lund
,
E.S.
Beatrice
,
Ocular hazards of short-pulse argon laser irradiation
,
Health Physics
,
36
(
1979
)
7
11
.
34.
G.A.
Griess
,
M.F.
Blankenstein
,
G.G.
Williford
,
Ocular damage from multiple-pulse laser exposure, Health Physics
,
39
(
1980
)
921
927
.
35.
J.A.
Zuclich
,
M.F.
Blankenstein
,
Additivity of retinal damage for multiple pulse laser exposures
.
USAF School of Aerospace Medicine Report No. TR-88-24
,
Brooks AFB TX
,
1988
.
36.
J.A.
Zuclich
,
D.J.
Lund
,
P.R.
Edsall
,
R.C.
Hollins
,
P.A.
Smith
,
B.E.
Stuck
,
L.N.
McClin
,
Experimental study of the variation of laser-induced retinal damage with retinal image size (microsecond pulsewidths)
,
Nonlinear Optics
,
21
(
1999
)
18
27
.
37.
D.J.
Lund
,
B.E.
Stuck
,
E.S.
Beatrice
, Biological research in support of project MILES.
Letterman Army Institute of Research Institute Report 96
,
Presidio of San Francisco, CA
,
1981
.
38.
B.J.
Lund
,
D.J.
Lund
,
P.R.
Edsall
,
Damage threshold from large retinal spot size repeitive-pulse laser exposures
,
Health Physics
,
107
(
2014
)
292
299
.
39.
D.J.
Lund
,
P.R.
Edsall
,
B.E.
Stuck
,
K.
Schulmeister
,
Variation of laser-induced retinal injury with retinal irradiated area: 0.1 s, 514 nm exposures
,
J. Biomed. Opt.
,
12
(
2007
)
06180
.
40.
K.
Schulmeister
,
J.
Husinski
,
B.
Seiser
,
F.
Edthofer
,
B.
Fekete
,
L.
Farmer
,
D.J.
Lund
,
Ex vivo and computer model study on retinal thermal laser-induced damage in the visible wavelength range
,
J. Biomed. Opt.
,
13
(
2008
)
054038
.
41.
K.
Schulmeister
,
B.E.
Stuck
,
D.J.
Lund
,
D.H.
Sliney
,
Proposed changes for the retinal thermal MPE
, in:
Proceedings of the International Laser Safety Conference (ILSC)
, ISBN 0-912035-86-2,
Laser Institute of America: Orlando
,
San Francisco
,
2007
, pp.
48
57
.
This content is only available via PDF.
You do not currently have access to this content.