While there are deterministic rules laid down in IEC 60825-1 regarding how to determine the accessible emission for the nominal output and classify a laser product, there are also aspects where a probabilistic risk analysis is important. With the revision of IEC 60825-1 (third edition), the role of risk analysis will be emphasized and somewhat widened. Examples where risk analysis plays a role are: is a single fault relevant for classification (i.e. reasonably foreseeable); is additional functional safety (automated power reduction for case of fault) needed; is it permitted that automated power reduction is not fast enough to assure AEL is not exceeded; design of scanning safeguards; and reliability of interlocks. Also, independent of the above issues of functional safety, it should be noted that governmental market surveillance agencies in Europe use risk analysis to decide if a product (such as a Class 3R laser) is acceptable to be marketed as consumer product or not. In this paper, the principles of risk analysis will be discussed as well as examples given where risk analysis has an important role for the manufacturer of a laser product. This paper offers a first input to develop guidance how risk analysis and IEC 61508 in particular can be applied in the design of a laser product.

1.
IEC 60825-1 Ed. 2.0 (
2007
)
Safety of Laser Products – Part 1: Equipment classification and requirements
2.
Vose
D.
,
Risk Analysis
, 3rd ed.
John Weiley
,
2008
.
3.
Functional safety
; (
2007
)
Josef Börcsök
,
Hüthig Verlag Heidelberg
4.
Smith
D.
,
Simpson
K.
(
2010
) Safety Critical Systems Handbook;
Butterworth-Heinemann
5.
ISO/IEC Guide 51 (
1999
)
Safety aspects – Guidelines for their inclusion in standards
6.
61508-5 Ed 2.0 (
2010
)
Functional safety of electrical/electronic/programmable electronic safety related systems
7.
European Union Commission Decision 2010/15/EU,
Risk Assessment Guidelines for Consumer products
, page
33
64
8.
Schulmeister
K
The widely varying risk from Class 3R laser products in light of the revision of IEC 60825-1
;
ILSC 2011 Paper 103
, p.
72
75
9.
Schulmeister
,
Sliney
,
Mellerio
,
Hödlmoser
,
Sonneck
;
ESA Report Human Risk Analysis Simulator for Space Lidars
(
2001
)
10.
Bedford
T.
and
Cooke
R. M.
, Probabilistic risk analysis – Foundations and Methods,
Cambridge Univ Press
,
2001
.
11.
Starr
C.
,
Social benefits vs. technological risk; what is our society willing to pay for safety?
Science
165
,
1232
1238
,
1969
.
12.
Starr
C.
,
Benefit-Cost Relationships in Socio-Technical Systems
,
Proc. IAEA Symposium on Environmental Aspects of Nuclear Power Stations
,
895
916
,
New York
,
August 1970
, IAEA-SM-146/47,
1970
.
13.
EU
,
Nuclear and non-nuclear risk – An exercise in comparability
.
Final Report, Pollution Prevention (Consultants) Ltd, Crawley, England, EUR 6417 EN, 1980
.
14.
Versteeg
M. F.
,
External safety policy in the Netherlands; an approach to risk management
,
IAEA-TECDOC 524
, Vienna,
1989
.
15.
Green
C.H.
and
Brown
R.A.
,
Counting Lives
,
Journ. Occupational Accidents
2
,
55
70
,
1978
.
16.
Starr
C.
,
Rudman
R
,
Whipple
C
,
Philosophical basis for risk analysis
.
Annual Review of Energy
1
,
629
662
,
1976
.
17.
Mole
R. H.
,
Accepting risks for other people
,
Proc. Royal Society of Medicine
69
,
107
113
,
1976
.
18.
Wilson
R.
and
Crouch
E.
,
Risk/Benefit Analysis
,
Ballinger Publ. Co.
,
Cambridge, Mass.
,
1982
.
19.
Sliney
DH
,
Mellerio
J
,
Gabel
VP
,
Schulmeister
K.
(
2002
)
What is the meaning of threshold in laser injury experiments? Implications for human exposure limits
.
Health Phys
82
:
335
347
.
20.
Schulmeister
K
,
Stuck
BE
,
Lund
DJ
,
Sliney
DH
,
Review of thresholds and recommendations for revised exposure limits for laser and optical radiation for thermally induced retinal injury
;
Health Physics
100
,
210
220
;
2011
.
21.
Schulmeister
K
,
Jean
M
(
2011
)
Modelling of laser induced injury of the cornea
;
ILSC 2011
, p.
214
217
22.
Schulmeister
K.
,
Jean
M.
(
2010
)
The risk of retinal injury from Class 2 and visible Class 3R lasers
;
Medical Laser Application
25
,
99
110
.
23.
Schulmeister
K
,
Hödlmoser
H
,
Mellerio
J
,
Sliney
DH
,
Second Order PRA Model for Ocular Laser Damage Proceedings ILSC 2003
,
LIA
, p
229
237
24.
Schulmeister
,
Sonneck
,
Rattay
,
Hödlmoser
,
Sliney
,
Mellerio
,
Culoma
,
Preyssl
(
2002
)
A Probabilistic Risk Analysis Model for Receiving Laser Eye Injury from Space Based Lasers
;
ESA SP-486, Proc Joint ESA NASA Space Flight Safety Conf
,
Noordwijk
, p.
109
113
25.
ISO 14971 (
2012
)
Medical devices
. Application of risk management to medical devices
This content is only available via PDF.
You do not currently have access to this content.