Understanding speech in noisy environments, such as classrooms, is a challenge for children. When a spatial separation is introduced between the target and masker, as compared to when both are co-located, children demonstrate intelligibility improvement of the target speech. Such intelligibility improvement is known as spatial release from masking (SRM). In most reverberant environments, binaural cues associated with the spatial separation are distorted; the extent to which such distortion will affect children's SRM is unknown. Two virtual acoustic environments with reverberation times between 0.4 s and 1.1 s were compared. SRM was measured using a spatial separation with symmetrically displaced maskers to maximize access to binaural cues. The role of informational masking in modulating SRM was investigated through voice similarity between the target and masker. Results showed that, contradictory to previous developmental findings on free-field SRM, children's SRM in reverberation has not yet reached maturity in the 7–12 years age range. When reducing reverberation, an SRM improvement was seen in adults but not in children. Our findings suggest that, even though school-age children have access to binaural cues that are distorted in reverberation, they demonstrate immature use of such cues for speech-in-noise perception, even in mild reverberation.
References
1.
Acoustical Society of America
(2002
). “ANSI/ASA S12.60-2002 (R2009) American National Standard Acoustical Performance Criteria, Design Requirements, and Guidelines for Schools
,” Stand. Secr.2.
Beutelmann
, R.
, and Brand
, T.
(2006
). “Prediction of speech intelligibility in spatial noise and reverberation for normal-hearing and hearing-impaired listeners
,” J. Acoust. Soc. Am.
120
, 331
–342
.3.
Blauert
, J.
(1997
). Spatial Hearing: The Psychophysics of Human Sound Localization
(MIT Press
, Cambridge, MA
).4.
Blauert
, J.
, and Lindemann
, W.
(1986a
). “Spatial mapping of intracranial auditory events for various degrees of interaural coherence
,” J. Acoust. Soc. Am.
79
, 806
–813
.5.
Blauert
, J.
, and Lindemann
, W.
(1986b
). “Auditory spaciousness: Some further psychoacoustic analyses
,” J. Acoust. Soc. Am.
80
, 533
–542
.6.
Boersma
, P.
, and Weenink
, D.
(2021
). “Praat: doing phonetics by computer,” http://www.praat.org/ (Last viewed August 30, 2020).7.
Bomhardt
, R.
, and Fels
, J.
(2014
). “Analytical interaural time difference model for the individualization of arbitrary head-related impulse responses
,” in Audio Engineering Society Convention 137
, Audio Engineering Society
.8.
Bomhardt
, R.
, Lins
, M.
, and Fels
, J.
(2016
). “Analytical ellipsoidal model of interaural time differences for the individualization of head-related impulse responses
,” J. Audio Eng. Soc.
64
, 882
–894
.9.
Bomhardt
, R.
, Patiño Mejía
, I. C.
, Zell
, A.
, and Fels
, J.
(2018
). “Required measurement accuracy of head dimensions for modeling the interaural time difference
,” J. Audio Eng. Soc.
66
, 114
.10.
Brown
, A. D.
, Stecker
, G. C.
, and Tollin
, D. J.
(2015
). “The precedence effect in sound localization
,” J. Assoc. Res. Otolaryngol.
16
, 1
–28
.11.
Buss
, E.
, Leibold
, L. J.
, Porter
, H. L.
, and Grose
, J. H.
(2017
). “Speech recognition in one- and two-talker maskers in school-age children and adults: Development of perceptual masking and glimpsing
,” J. Acoust. Soc. Am.
141
, 2650
–2660
.12.
Cabrera
, L.
, Varnet
, L.
, Buss
, E.
, Rosen
, S.
, and Lorenzi
, C.
(2019
). “Development of temporal auditory processing in childhood: Changes in efficiency rather than temporal-modulation selectivity
,” J. Acoust. Soc. Am.
146
, 2415
.13.
Cameron
, S.
, and Dillon
, H.
(2007
). “Development of the listening in spatialized noise-sentences test (LISN-S)
,” Ear Hear.
28
, 196
–211
.14.
Cameron
, S.
, Glyde
, H.
, and Dillon
, H.
(2011
). “Listening in spatialized noise—sentences test (LiSN-S): Normative and retest reliability data for adolescents and adults up to 60 years of age
,” J. Am. Acad. Audiol.
22
, 697
–709
.15.
Ching
, T. Y. C.
, van Wanrooy
, E.
, Dillon
, H.
, and Carter
, L.
(2011
). “Spatial release from masking in normal-hearing children and children who use hearing aids
,” J. Acoust. Soc. Am.
129
, 368
–375
.16.
Clifton
, R. K.
, Gwiazda
, J.
, Bauer
, J. A.
, Clarkson
, M. G.
, and Held
, R. M.
(1988
). “Growth in head size during infancy: Implications for sound localization
,” Dev. Psychol.
24
, 477
–483
.17.
Corbin
, N. E.
, Buss
, E.
, and Leibold
, L. J.
(2017
). “Spatial release from masking in children: Effects of simulated unilateral hearing loss
,” Ear Hear.
38
, 223
–235
.18.
Deroche
, M. L. D.
, Culling
, J. F.
, Lavandier
, M.
, and Gracco
, V. L.
(2017
). “Reverberation limits the release from informational masking obtained in the harmonic and binaural domains
,” Atten. Percept. Psychophys.
79
, 363
–379
.19.
Fels
, J.
(2008
). “From children to adults: How binaural cues and ear canal impedances grow
,” J. Acoust. Soc. Am.
124
(6
), 3359
.20.
Fels
, J.
, Buthmann
, P.
, and Vorländer
, M.
(2004
). “Head-related transfer functions of children
,” Acta Acust. united Acust.
90
(5
), 918
–927
.21.
Fels
, J.
, and Vorländer
, M.
(2009
). “Anthropometric parameters influencing head-related transfer functions
,” Acta Acust. united Acust.
95
(2
), 331
–342
.22.
Field
, A.
, Miles
, J.
, and Field
, Z.
(2012
). Discovering Statistics Using R
(Sage Publications
, London, UK
).23.
Freyman
, R. L.
, Helfer
, K. S.
, McCall
, D. D.
, and Clifton
, R. K.
(1999
). “The role of perceived spatial separation in the unmasking of speech
,” J. Acoust. Soc. Am.
106
, 3578
–3588
.24.
Frund
, I.
, Haenel
, N. V.
, and Wichmann
, F. A.
(2011
). “Inference for psychometric functions in the presence of nonstationary behavior
,” J. Vis.
11
, 16
.25.
Goupell
, M. J.
, and Hartmann
, W. M.
(2006
). “Interaural fluctuations and the detection of interaural incoherence: Bandwidth effects
,” J. Acoust. Soc. Am.
119
, 3971
–3986
.26.
Goupell
, M. J.
, Yu
, G.
, and Litovsky
, R. Y.
(2012
). “The effect of an additional reflection in a precedence effect experiment
,” J. Acoust. Soc. Am.
131
, 2958
–2967
.27.
Griffin
, A. M.
, Poissant
, S. F.
, and Freyman
, R. L.
(2019
). “Speech-in-noise and quality-of-life measures in school-aged children with normal hearing and with unilateral hearing loss
,” Ear Hear.
40
, 887
–904
.28.
Hall
, J. W.
, and Grose
, J. H.
(1994
). “Development of temporal resolution in children as measured by the temporal modulation transfer function
,” J. Acoust. Soc. Am.
96
, 150
–154
.29.
Hartmann
, W. M.
(1983
). “Localization of sound in rooms
,” J. Acoust. Soc. Am.
74
, 1380
–1391
.30.
Hawley
, M. L.
, Litovsky
, R. Y.
, and Culling
, J. F.
(2004
). “The benefit of binaural hearing in a cocktail party: Effect of location and type of interferer
,” J. Acoust. Soc. Am.
115
, 833
–843
.31.
Hidaka
, T.
, Beranek
, L. L.
, and Okano
, T.
(1995
). “Interaural cross‐correlation, lateral fraction, and low‐ and high‐frequency sound levels as measures of acoustical quality in concert halls
,” J. Acoust. Soc. Am.
98
, 988
–1007
.32.
Hochmair-Desoyer
, I.
, Schulz
, E.
, Moser
, L.
, and Schmidt
, M.
(1997
). “The HSM sentence test as a tool for evaluating the speech understanding in noise of cochlear implant users
,” Am. J. Otol.
18
(6 Suppl.
), S83
–S83
.33.
Houtgast
, T.
, and Steeneken
, H. J. M.
(1985
). “A review of the MTF concept in room acoustics and its use for estimating speech intelligibility in auditoria
,” J. Acoust. Soc. Am.
77
, 1069
. 34.
Johnson
, C. E.
(2000
). “Childrens' phoneme identification in reverberation and noise
,” J. Speech Lang. Hear. Res.
43
, 144
–157
.35.
Johnson
, D.
, and Lee
, H.
(2019
). “Perceptual threshold of apparent source width in relation to the azimuth of a single reflection
,” J. Acoust. Soc. Am.
145
, EL272
–EL276
.36.
Johnstone
, P. M.
, and Litovsky
, R. Y.
(2006
). “Effect of masker type and age on speech intelligibility and spatial release from masking in children and adults
,” J. Acoust. Soc. Am.
120
, 2177
–2189
.37.
Kidd
, G.
, Mason
, C. R.
, Brughera
, A.
, and Hartmann
, W. M.
(2005
). “The role of reverberation in release from masking due to spatial separation of sources for speech identification
,” Acta Acust. united Acust.
91
, 526
–536
.38.
Klatte
, M.
, Lachmann
, T.
, and Meis
, M.
(2010
). “Effects of noise and reverberation on speech perception and listening comprehension of children and adults in a classroom-like setting
,” Noise Heal.
12
, 270
.39.
Kuttruff
, H.
(2009
). Room Acoustics
, 5th ed. (CRC Press
, London, UK
).40.
Leibold
, L. J.
, and Buss
, E.
(2013
). “Children's identification of consonants in a speech-shaped noise or a two-talker masker
,” J. Speech Lang. Hear. Res.
56
, 1144
–1155
.41.
Leibold
, L. J.
, and Buss
, E.
(2019
). “Masked speech recognition in school-age children
,” Front. Psychol
42.
Leibold
, L. J.
, and Neff
, D. L.
(2007
). “Effects of masker-spectral variability and masker fringes in children and adults
,” J. Acoust. Soc. Am.
121
, 3666
.43.
Leibold
, L. J.
, and Neff
, D. L.
(2011
). “Masking by a remote-frequency noise band in children and adults
,” Ear Hear.
32
, 663
–666
.44.
Levitt
, H.
(1971
). “Transformed up‐down methods in psychoacoustics
,” J. Acoust. Soc. Am.
49
, 467
–477
.45.
Litovsky
, R. Y.
(1997
). “Developmental changes in the precedence effect: Estimates of minimum audible angle
,” J. Acoust. Soc. Am.
102
, 1739
–1745
.46.
Litovsky
, R. Y.
(2005
). “Speech intelligibility and spatial release from masking in young children
,” J. Acoust. Soc. Am.
117
, 3091
–3099
.47.
Litovsky
, R. Y.
, Colburn
, H. S.
, Yost
, W. A.
, Guzman
, S. J.
, Litovsky
, R. Y.
, and Colburn
, H. S.
(1999
). “The precedence effect
,” J. Acoust. Soc. Am.
106
, 1633
–1654
.48.
Litovsky
, R. Y.
, and Godar
, S. P.
(2010
). “Difference in precedence effect between children and adults signifies development of sound localization abilities in complex listening tasks
,” J. Acoust. Soc. Am.
128
, 1979
–1991
.49.
Ljung
, R.
, Sörqvist
, P.
, Kjellberg
, A.
, and Green
, A.-M.
(2009
). “Poor listening conditions impair memory for intelligible lectures: Implications for acoustic classroom standards
,” Build. Acoust.
16
, 257
–265
.50.
Maccutcheon
, D.
, Pausch
, F.
, Füllgrabe
, C.
, Eccles
, R.
, van der Linde
, J.
, Panebianco
, C.
, Fels
, J.
, and Ljung
, R.
(2019
). “The contribution of individual differences in memory span and language ability to spatial release from masking in young children
,” J. Speech Lang. Hear. Res.
62
, 3741
–3751
.51.
Marrone
, N.
, Mason
, C. R.
, and Kidd
, G.
(2008
). “The effects of hearing loss and age on the benefit of spatial separation between multiple talkers in reverberant rooms
,” J. Acoust. Soc. Am.
124
, 3064
–3075
.52.
Masiero
, B.
, and Vorländer
, M.
(2014
). “A framework for the calculation of dynamic crosstalk cancellation filters
,” IEEE Trans. Audio Speech Lang. Process.
22
, 1345
–1354
.53.
McCreery
, R. W.
, Walker
, E. A.
, Spratford
, M.
, Lewis
, D.
, and Brennan
, M.
(2019
). “Auditory, cognitive, and linguistic factors predict speech recognition in adverse listening conditions for children with hearing loss
,” Front. Neurosci.
13
, 1093
.54.
Middlebrooks
, J. C.
(1999
). “Individual differences in external-ear transfer functions reduced by scaling in frequency
,” J. Acoust. Soc. Am.
106
, 1480
.55.
Misurelli
, S. M.
, and Litovsky
, R. Y.
(2012
). “Spatial release from masking in children with normal hearing and with bilateral cochlear implants: Effect of interferer asymmetry
,” J. Acoust. Soc. Am.
132
, 380
–391
.56.
Misurelli
, S. M.
, and Litovsky
, R. Y.
(2015
). “Spatial release from masking in children with bilateral cochlear implants and with normal hearing: Effect of target-interferer similarity
,” J. Acoust. Soc. Am.
138
, 319
–331
.57.
Muñoz
, R. V.
, Aspöck
, L.
, and Fels
, J.
(2019
). “Spatial release from masking under different reverberant conditions in young and elderly subjects: Effect of moving or stationary maskers at circular and radial conditions
,” J. Speech Lang. Hear. Res.
62
, 3582
–13595
.58.
Nábělek
, A. K.
, Letowski
, T. R.
, and Tucker
, F. M.
(1989
). “Reverberant overlap- and self-masking in consonant identification
,” J. Acoust. Soc. Am.
86
, 1259
–1265
.59.
Nãbelek
, A. K.
, and Robinson
, P. K.
(1982
). “Monaural and binaural speech perception in reverberation for listeners of various ages
,” J. Acoust. Soc. Am.
71
, 1242
–1248
.60.
Neuman
, A. C.
, Wroblewski
, M.
, Hajicek
, J.
, and Rubinstein
, A.
(2010
). “Combined effects of noise and reverberation on speech recognition performance of normal-hearing children and adults
,” Ear Hear.
31
, 336
–344
.61.
Neuman
, A. C.
, Wroblewski
, M.
, Hajicek
, J.
, and Rubinstein
, A.
(2012
). “Measuring speech recognition in children with cochlear implants in a virtual classroom
,” J. Speech Lang. Hear. Res.
55
, 532
–540
.62.
Oberem
, J.
, Seibold
, J.
, Koch
, I.
, and Fels
, J.
(2018
). “Intentional switching in auditory selective attention: Exploring attention shifts with different reverberation times
,” Hear. Res.
359
, 32
–39
.63.
Pausch
, F.
, Aspöck
, L.
, Vorländer
, M.
, and Fels
, J.
(2018
). “An extended binaural real-time auralization system with an interface to research hearing aids for experiments on subjects with hearing loss
,” Trends Hear.
22
, 233121651880087
.64.
Pausch
, F.
, and Fels
, J.
(2020
). “Localization performance in a binaural real-time auralization system extended to research hearing aids
,” Trends Hear.
24
, 233121652090870
.65.
Pelzer
, S.
, Aspöck
, L.
, Schröder
, D.
, and Vorländer
, M.
(2014
). “Interactive real-time simulation and auralization for modifiable rooms
,” Build. Acoust.
21
, 65
.66.
Peng
, Z. E.
, and Wang
, L. M.
(2016
). “Effects of noise, reverberation and foreign accent on native and non-native listeners' performance of English speech comprehension
,” J. Acoust. Soc. Am.
139
, 2772
–2783
.67.
Prodi
, N.
, Visentin
, C.
, and Feletti
, A.
(2013
). “On the perception of speech in primary school classrooms: Ranking of noise interference and of age influence
,” J. Acoust. Soc. Am.
133
, 255
–268
.68.
Rakerd
, B.
, and Hartmann
, W. M.
(1985
). “Localization of sound in rooms II: The effects of a single reflecting surface
,” J. Acoust. Soc. Am.
78
, 524
–533
.69.
Rakerd
, B.
, Hartmann
, W. M.
, and Rakerd
, B.
(2010
). “Localization of sound in rooms. V. Binaural coherence and human sensitivity to interaural time differences in noise
,” J. Acoust. Soc. Am.
128
, 3052
–3063
.70.
Rennies
, J.
, Brand
, T.
, Kollmeier
, B.
, and Brand
, T.
(2011
). “Prediction of the influence of reverberation on binaural speech intelligibility in noise and in quiet
,” J. Acoust. Soc. Am.
130
, 2999
–3012
.71.
Rennies
, J.
, and Kidd
, G.
(2018
). “Benefit of binaural listening as revealed by speech intelligibility and listening effort
,” J. Acoust. Soc. Am.
144
, 2147
–2159
.72.
Robinson
, P. W.
, Pätynen
, J.
, Lokki
, T.
, Suk Jang
, H.
, Yong Jeon
, J.
, and Xiang
, N.
(2013
). “The role of diffusive architectural surfaces on auditory spatial discrimination in performance venues
,” J. Acoust. Soc. Am.
133
, 3940
–3950
.73.
Ruggles
, D.
, Shinn-Cunningham
, B.
, and Unningham
, B. A. S. H.
(2011
). “Spatial selective auditory attention in the presence of reverberant energy: Individual differences in normal-hearing listeners
,” J. Assoc. Res. Otolaryngol.
12
, 395
–405
.74.
Schimmel
, S. M.
, Müller
, M. F.
, and Dillier
, N.
(2009
). “A fast and accurate ‘shoebox’ room acoustics simulator
,” in 2009 IEEE International Conference on Acoustics, Speech and Signal Processing
(IEEE
, New York
), pp. 241
–244
.75.
Schmidt
, A.
(1995
). “A new digital artificial head measurement system
,” Acta Acust. united Acust.
81
, 416
–520
.76.
Schröder
, D.
, and Vorländer
, M.
(2011
). “RAVEN: A real-time framework for the auralization of interactive virtual environments
,” in Proceedings of Forum Acusticum
, Aalborg
, Denamrk
, pp. 1541
–1546
.77.
Shinn-Cunningham
, B. G.
, Kopco
, N.
, and Martin
, T. J.
(2005
). “Localizing nearby sound sources in a classroom: Binaural room impulse responses
,” J. Acoust. Soc. Am.
117
, 3100
–3115
.78.
Swaminathan
, J.
, Mason
, C. R.
, Streeter
, T. M.
, Best
, V.
, Kidd
, G.
, and Patel
, A. D.
(2015
). “Musical training, individual differences and the cocktail party problem
,” Sci. Rep.
5
, 11628
.79.
Vaillancourt
, V.
, Laroche
, C.
, Giguère
, C.
, and Soli
, S. D.
(2008
). “Establishment of age-specific normative data for the Canadian French version of the hearing in noise test for children
,” Ear Hear.
29
, 453
–466
.80.
Valente
, D. L.
, Plevinsky
, H. M.
, Franco
, J. M.
, Heinrichs-Graham
, E. C.
, and Lewis
, D. E.
(2012
). “Experimental investigation of the effects of the acoustical conditions in a simulated classroom on speech recognition and learning in children
,” J. Acoust. Soc. Am.
131
, 232
–246
.81.
Van Deun
, L.
, Van Wieringen
, A.
, and Wouters
, J.
(2010
). “Spatial speech perception benefits in young children with normal hearing and cochlear implants
,” Ear Hear.
31
(5
), 702
–713
.82.
Wefers
, F.
(2015
). “Partitioned convolution algorithms for real-time auralization
,” Ph.D. dissertation, RWTH Aachen Univ.
83.
Whitmer
, W. M.
, Seeber
, B. U.
, and Akeroyd
, M. A.
(2013
). “Measuring the apparent width of auditory sources in normal and impaired hearing
,” Adv. Exp. Med. Biol.
787
, 303
–310
.84.
Whitmer
, W. M.
, Seeber
, B. U.
, and Akeroyd
, M. A.
(2014
). “The perception of apparent auditory source width in hearing-impaired adults
,” J. Acoust. Soc. Am.
135
, 3548
–3559
.85.
Wightman
, F. L.
, Kistler
, D. J.
, and O'Bryan
, A.
(2010
). “Individual differences and age effects in a dichotic informational masking paradigm
,” J. Acoust. Soc. Am.
128
, 270
–279
.86.
Wróblewski
, M.
, Lewis
, D. E.
, Valente
, D. L.
, and Stelmachowicz
, P. G.
(2012
). “Effects of reverberation on speech recognition in stationary and modulated noise by school-aged children and young adults
,” Ear Hear.
33
, 731
–744
.87.
Yang
, W.
, and Bradley
, J. S.
(2009
). “Effects of room acoustics on the intelligibility of speech in classrooms for young children
,” J. Acoust. Soc. Am.
125
, 922
–933
.88.
Yuen
, K. C. P.
, and Yuan
, M.
(2014
). “Development of spatial release from masking in mandarin-speaking children with normal hearing
,” J. Speech Lang. Hear. Res.
57
, 2005
–2023
.© 2021 Acoustical Society of America.
2021
Acoustical Society of America
You do not currently have access to this content.
