Little is known about the minimum sample length required for the stable acoustic assessment of speech in Parkinson's disease (PD). This study aimed to investigate the effect of the duration of the reading passage on the determination of reliable acoustic patterns in individuals with PD treated with subthalamic nucleus deep brain stimulation. A phonetically balanced reading text of 313 words was collected from 32 Czech persons with PD, and 32 age- and sex-matched healthy controls. The reading passage was segmented to produce ten sub-texts of increasing length ranging from a one- to a ten-segment-long sub-text. An error rate analysis was used to estimate the required stabilization value by evaluating the differences between the sub-texts and the entire text across seven hypokinetic dysarthria features. The minimum length of a reading passage equal to 128 words was found to be necessary for acoustic assessment, with similar lengths being required for the controls (120 words) and the two PD subgroups, including Parkinsonian individuals with a mild (126 words) and moderate (128 words) dysarthria severity. The current study provides important guidelines for the necessary sample length for future expert instrumental dysarthria assessments and assists in decreasing the time required for clinical speech evaluations.
References
1.
Ardussi Mines
, M. A.
, Hanson
, B. F.
, and Shoup
, J. E.
(1978
). “Frequency of occurrence of phonemes in conversational English
,” Lang. Speech
21
(3
), 221
–241
.2.
Brabenec
, L.
, Mekyska
, J.
, Galaz
, Z.
, and Rektorova
, I.
(2017
). “Speech disorders in Parkinson's disease: Early diagnostics and effects of medication and brain stimulation
,” J. Neural Transm.
124
(3
), 303
–334
.3.
Darley
, F. L.
, Aronson
, A. E.
, and Brown
, J. R.
(1969
). “Differential diagnostic patterns of dysarthria
,” J. Speech Hearing Res.
12
(2
), 246
–269
.4.
Duffy
, J. R.
(2013
). Motor Speech Disorders: Substrates, Differential Diagnosis, and Management.
(Elsevier Mosby
, Amsterdam, the Netherlands
).5.
Dromey
, C.
(2003
). “Spectral measures and perceptual ratings of hypokinetic dysarthria
,” J. Medical Speech Lang. Pathol.
11
, 85
–94
.6.
Fairbanks
, G.
(1960
). Voice and Articulation Drillbook
, 2nd ed. (Harper & Row
, New York
).7.
Grigas
, G.
, and Juskeviciene
, A.
(2018
). “Letter frequency analysis of languages using latin alphabet
,” Int. Linguist. Res.
1
, 18
–31
.8.
Hlavnička
, J.
(2018
). “Automated analysis of speech disorders in neurodegenerative diseases
,” Ph.D. thesis, Czech Technical University
, Prague, Czech Republic
.9.
Hlavnička
, J.
, Čmejla
, R.
, Tykalová
, T.
, Šonka
, K.
, Růžička
, E.
, and Rusz
, J.
(2017
). “Automated analysis of connected speech reveals early biomarkers of Parkinson's disease in patients with rapid eye movement sleep behaviour disorder
,” Sci. Rep.
7
(1
), 12
.10.
Ho
, A. K.
, Bradshaw
, R.
, and Iansek
, R.
(2008
). “For better or worse: The effect of levodopa on speech in Parkinson's disease
,” Movement Disord.
23
, 574
–580
.11.
Ho
, A. K.
, Iansek
, R.
, Marigliani
, C.
, Bradshaw
, J. L.
, and Gates
, S.
(1999
). “Speech impairment in a large sample of patients with Parkinson's disease
,” Behav. Neurol.
11
(3
), 131
–137
.12.
Illner
, V.
, Sovka
, P.
, and Rusz
, J.
(2020
). “Validation of freely-available pitch detection algorithms across various noise levels in assessing speech captured by smartphone in Parkinson's disease
,” Biomed. Signal Process. Control
58
, 101831
.13.
Little
, S.
, Tripoliti
, E.
, Beudel
, M.
, Pogosyan
, A.
, Cagnan
, H.
, Herz
, D.
, Bestmann
, S.
, Aziz
, T.
, Cheeran
, B.
, Zrinzo
, L.
, Hariz
, M.
, Hyam
, J.
, Limousin
, P.
, Foltynie
, T.
, and Brown
, P.
(2016
). “Adaptive deep brain stimulation for Parkinson's disease demonstrates reduced speech side effects compared to conventional stimulation in the acute setting
,” J. Neurol. Neurosurg. Psychiatry
87
(12
), 1388
–1389
.14.
Logemann
, J. A.
, Fisher
, H. B.
, Boshes
, B.
, and Blonsky
, E. R.
(1978
). “Frequency and cooccurrence of vocal tract dysfunctions in the speech of a large sample of Parkinson patients
,” J. Speech Hearing Disorders
43
(1
), 47
–57
.15.
Moisan
, F.
, Kab
, S.
, Mohamed
, F.
, Canonico
, M.
, Le Guern
, M.
, Quintin
, C.
, Carcaillon
, L.
, Nicolau
, J.
, Duport
, N.
, Singh-Manoux
, A.
, Boussac-Zarebska
, M.
, and Elbaz
, A.
(2016
). “Parkinson disease male-to-female ratios increase with age: French nationwide study and meta-analysis
,” J. Neurol. Neurosurg. Neuropsychiat.
87
(9
), 952
–957
.16.
Nishio
, M.
, and Niimi
, S.
(2008
). “Changes in speaking fundamental frequency characteristics with aging
,” Folia Phoniatr. Logopaed.
60
(3
), 120
–127
.17.
Nordenberg
, M.
, and Sundberg
, J.
(2004
). “Effect on LTAS of vocal loudness variation
,” Logoped. Phoniatr. Vocol.
29
(4
), 183
–191
.18.
Patel
, R. R.
, Awan
, S. N.
, Barkmeier-Kraemer
, J.
, Courey
, M.
, Deliyski
, D.
, Eadie
, T.
, Paul
, D.
, Švec
, J. G.
, and Hillman
, R.
(2018
). “Recommended protocols for instrumental assessment of voice: American speech-language-hearing association expert panel to develop a protocol for instrumental assessment of vocal function
,” Am. J. Speech Lang. Pathol.
27
(3
), 887
–905
.19.
Patel
, R.
, Connaghan
, K.
, Franco
, D.
, Edsall
, E.
, Forgit
, D.
, Olsen
, L.
, Ramage
, L.
, Tyler
, E.
, and Russell
, S.
(2013
). “ ‘The caterpillar’: A novel reading passage for assessment of motor speech disorders
,” Am. J. Speech Lang. Pathol.
22
(1
), 1
–9
.20.
Poewe
, W.
, Seppi
, K.
, Tanner
, C. M.
, Halliday
, G. M.
, Brundin
, P.
, Volkmann
, J.
, Schrag
, A.-E.
, and Lang
, A. E.
(2017
). “Parkinson disease
,” Nat. Rev. Disease Primers
3
, 17013
.21.
Reilly
, J.
, and Fisher
, J. L.
(2012
). “Sherlock Holmes and the Strange case of the missing attribution: A historical note on "the grandfather passage
,” J. Speech Lang. Hear. Res.
55
(1
), 84
–88
.22.
Robb
, M. P.
, Maclagan
, M. A.
, and Chen
, Y.
(2004
). “Speaking rates of American and New Zealand varieties of English
,” Clin. Ling. Phon.
18
(1
), 1
–15
.23.
Rusz
, J.
, Čmejla
, R.
, Růžičková
, H.
, Klempíř
, J.
, Majerová
, V.
, Picmausová
, J.
, Roth
, J.
, and Růžička
, E.
(2013
). “Evaluation of speech impairment in early stages of Parkinson's disease: A prospective study with the role of pharmacotherapy
,” J. Neural Transm. (Vienna)
120
(2
), 319
–329
.24.
Rusz
, J.
, Hlavnička
, J.
, Tykalová
, T.
, Novotný
, M.
, Dusek
, P.
, Sonka
, K.
, and Růžička
, E.
(2018
). “Smartphone allows capture of speech abnormalities associated with high risk of developing Parkinson's disease
,” IEEE Trans. Neural Syst. Rehabil. Eng.
26
(8
), 1495
–1507
.25.
Rusz
, J.
, Tykalová
, T.
, Ramig
, L. O.
, and Tripoliti
, E.
(2021
). “Guidelines for speech recording and acoustic analyses in dysarthrias of movement disorders
,” Movement Disord.
36
, 803
–814
.26.
Sarkar
, S.
, Raymick
, J.
, and Imam
, S.
(2016
). “Neuroprotective and therapeutic strategies against Parkinson's disease: Recent perspectives
,” Int. J. Mol. Sci.
17
(6
), 904
.27.
Skodda
, S.
, Grönheit
, W.
, and Schlegel
, U.
(2012
). “Impairment of vowel articulation as a possible marker of disease progression in Parkinson's disease
,” PLoS One
7
(2
), e32132
.28.
Tanaka
, Y.
, Tsuboi
, T.
, Watanabe
, H.
, Nakatsubo
, D.
, Maesawa
, S.
, Kato
, S.
, Kajita
, Y.
, Sato
, M.
, Oodake
, R.
, Hattori
, M.
, Yamamoto
, M.
, Wakabayashi
, T.
, Katsuno
, M.
, and Sobue
, G.
(2020
). “Longitudinal speech change after subthalamic nucleus deep brain stimulation in Parkinson's disease patients: A 2-year prospective study
,” J. Parkinsons Dis.
10
(1
), 131
–140
.29.
Tjaden
, K.
, Sussman
, J. E.
, Liu
, G.
, and Wilding
, G.
(2010
). “Long-term average spectral (LTAS) measures of dysarthria and their relationship to perceived severity
,” J. Med. Speech Lang. Pathol.
18
(4
), 125
–132
.30.
Tripoliti
, E.
, Zrinzo
, L.
, Martinez-Torres
, I.
, Frost
, E.
, Pinto
, S.
, Foltynie
, T.
, Holl
, E.
, Petersen
, E.
, Roughton
, M.
, Hariz
, M. I.
, and Limousin
, P.
(2011
). “Effects of subthalamic stimulation on speech of consecutive patients with Parkinson disease
,” Neurology
76
(1
), 80
–86
.31.
Whitfield
, J. A.
, Gravelin
, A.
, Kriegel
, Z.
, and Mehta
, D.
(2018
). “Duration of connected speech needed to accurately estimate the articulatory-acoustic vowel space of a reading passage
,” J. Acoust. Soc. Am.
143
(3
), 1870
.32.
Zraick
, R. I.
, Birdwell
, K. Y.
, and Smith-Olinde
, L.
(2005
). “The effect of speaking sample duration on determination of habitual pitch
,” J. Voice
19
(2
), 197
–201
.© 2021 Acoustical Society of America.
2021
Acoustical Society of America
You do not currently have access to this content.
