The European Region of the World Health Organization (WHO) recently published revised recommendations for transportation noise exposure intended to limit adverse health effects. WHO's newly recommended “safe” limit for aircraft noise exposure is about an order of magnitude lower than the limits currently adopted by most European countries. WHO defines “safe exposure” as the level corresponding to an annoyance prevalence rate of 10% highly annoyed. The revised recommendations are based on a limited selection of post-2000 publications. About half of the cited studies rely on nonstandard questionnaires, respondent selection, and definitions of annoyance prevalence rates which over-estimate annoyance. A re-analysis of a larger and more representative selection of studies that relies on standard procedures shows that no meaningful changes in prevalence rates of high annoyance with aircraft noise have occurred and that existing evidence does not support WHO's revised recommendations.
References
1.
Alexandre
, A.
(1970
). “Prévision de la gêne due autour des aéroports et perspectives sur les moyens d'y remédier
” (“Prediction of annoyance due to noise around airports and speculations on the means for controlling it”), in Anthropologie Appliquee
(Centre D'etudes et de Recherches D'anthropologie Appliquee, Paris), pp. 1
–151
.2.
Atkins
, C.
, Nurse
, K.
, and Richmond
, C.
(1984
). 1982 Aircraft Noise Index Study: Tabulations of the Responses to the Social Surveys
(Civil Aviation Authority
, London, UK
).3.
Babisch
, W.
, Houthuijs
, D.
, Pershagen
, G.
, Cadum
, E.
, Katsouyanni
, K.
, Velonakis
, M.
, Dudley
, M-L.
, Marohn
, H-D.
, Swart
, W.
, Breugelmans
, O.
, Bluhm
, G.
, Selander
, J.
, Vigna-Taglianti
, F.
, Pisani
, S.
, Haralabidis
, A.
, Dimakopoulou
, K.
, Zachos
, I.
, and Järuo
, L.
(2009
). “Annoyance due to aircraft noise has increased over the years—Results of the HYENA study
,” Environ. Int.
35
, 1169
–1176
.4.
Baldwin
, E.
, and Fidell
, S.
(1983
). Evaluation of Noise Exposure and Community Response Due to Temporary Reinstitution of Night Landings at Westchester County Airport, Spring 1982
(Bolt, Beranek and Newman, Inc
., Cambridge, MA
).5.
Bartels
, S.
(2014
). Aircraft Noise-Induced Annoyance in the Vicinity of Cologne/Bonn Airport
(Technical University Darmstadt
, Darmstadt, Germany
).6.
Bassarab
, R.
, Sharp
, B.
, and Robinette
, B.
(2009
). An Updated Catalog of 628 Social Surveys of Residents' Reactions to Environmental Noise (1943–2008)
(Wyle Laboratories
, Cambridge, MA
).7.
Birnie
, S.
, Hall
, F.
, and Taylor
, S.
(1980
). “Community response to noise from a general aviation airport
,” Noise Cont. Eng. J.
15
, 37
–45
.8.
Borsky
, P.
(1983
). “Integration of multiple aircraft noise exposures over time by residents living near US Air Force bases
,” in Proceedings of the 4th ICBEN Congress,
June 21–25, Torino, Italy, pp. 1049
–1060
.9.
Breugelmans
, O.
, van Wiechen
, C.
, van Kamp
, I.
, Heisterkamp
, S.
, and Houthuijs
, D.
(2007
). Blootstelling-Responsrelaties Voor Geluidhinder in Slaapverstoring
(Exposure-Response Functions for Noise Annoyance and Sleep Disturbance) (RIVM
, Bilthoven, the Netherlands
).10.
Breugelmans
, O.
, van Wiechen
, C.
, van Kamp
, I.
, Heisterkamp
, S.
, and Houthuijs
, D.
(2005
). Tussenrapportage Monitoring Gezondheitskundige Evaluatie Schiphol
(Monitoring Health Around Schiphol - Interim Report) (Rijksinstituut voor Volksgezondheit en Milieu
, Amsterdam, the Netherlands
).11.
Brink
, M.
(2019
). “A survey on exposure-response relationships for road, rail and aircraft noise annoyance. Differences between continuous and intermittent noise
,” Environ. Int.
125
, 277
–290
.12.
Brink
, M.
, Schaeffer
, B.
, Pieren
, R.
, and Wunderli
, J. M.
(2018
). “Conversion between noise exposure indicators Leq24h, Lday, Levening, Lnight, Ldn and Lden: Principles and practical guidance
,” J. Hyg. Environ. Health
221
, 54
–63
.13.
Brink
, M.
, Wirth
, K.
, Schierz
, C.
, Thomann
, G.
, and Bauer
, G.
(2011
). “Annoyance response to stable and changing aircraft noise exposure
,” J. Acoust. Soc. Am.
124
, 791
–806
.14.
Bugge
, J.
(1994
). “Community response to noise from short term military aircraft exercises at airports serving both civil and military traffic
,” in Proceedings of Internoise 94
, August 29–31, Yokohama, Japan
, pp. 243
–246
.15.
Bullen
, R.
, and Hede
, A.
(1983
). “Reliability and validity of reaction variables in community noise research
,” in Proceedings of the 4th ICBEN Congress
, June 21–25, Torino, Italy
, pp. 1105
–1115
.16.
Civil Aviation Authority
(2017
). Survey of Noise Attitudes 2014, Aircraft, SoNA
(CAA, Aviation House
, Gatwick Airport, West Sussex, UK
).17.
Connor
, W.
, and Patterson
, H.
(1976
). Analysis of the Effect of Numbers of Aircraft Operations on Community Annoyance
(NASA
, Washington, DC
).18.
Diamond
, I.
, and Walker
, J.
(1986
). “An international study of the influence of residual noise on community disturbance to aircraft noise
,” in Proceedings of Internoise 86
, July 21–23, Cambridge, MA
, pp. 941
–946
.19.
Directorate of Operational Research and Analysis
(1967
). Aircraft Noise in the Neighborhood of London Heathrow Airport
(Directorate of Operational Research and Analysis
, London, UK
).20.
Fidell
, S.
(2000
). “Developing a criterion for the annoyance of low frequency aircraft noise
,” in Proceedings of Internoise 2000
, August 27–30, Nice France.21.
Fidell
, S.
, Barber
, D.
, and Schultz
, T.
(1991
). “Updating a dosage-effect relationship for the prevalence of annoyance due to general transportation noise
,” J. Acoust. Soc. Am.
89
, 221
–233
.22.
Fidell
, S.
, and Fletcher
, E.
(1995
). Social Survey of Community Response to Noise Exposure Near Vancouver International Airport
(Bolt, Beranek and Newman, Inc
., Canoga Park, CA
).23.
Fidell
, S.
, and Jones
, G.
(1975
). “Effects of cessation of late-night flights on an airport community
,” J. Sound. Vib.
42
, 411
–427
.24.
Fidell
, S.
, Mestre
, V.
, Schomer
, P.
, Berry
, B.
, Gjestland
, T.
, Vallet
, M.
, and Reid
, T.
(2011
). “A first principles model for estimating the prevalence of annoyance with aircraft noise exposure
,” J. Acoust. Soc. Am.
130
, 791
–806
.25.
Fidell
, S.
, Pearsons
, K.
, Silvati
, L.
, and Sneddon
, M.
(2002
). “Relationship between low-frequency aircraft noise and annoyance due to rattle and vibration
,” J. Acoust. Soc. Am.
111
, 1743
–1750
.26.
Fidell
, S.
, and Silvati
, L.
(1989
). Effect of Additional Flight Operations at LBG on the Prevalence of Aircraft Noise Annoyance (Bolt
, Beranek and Newman, Inc
., Cambridge, MA)
.27.
Fidell
, S.
, and Silvati
, L.
(1991
). “An assessment of the effect of residential acoustic insulation on prevalence of annoyance in an airport community
,” J. Acoust. Soc. Am.
89
, 244
–247
.28.
Fidell
, S.
, and Silvati
, L.
(1999
). Empirical Study of South San Francisco's Aircraft Noise Insulation Program
(Bolt, Beranek and Newman, Inc
., Cambridge, MA)
.29.
Fidell
, S.
, Silvati
, L.
, and Howe
, R.
(1996
). Social Survey of Community Preference for Aircraft Noise Mitigation Measures (Bolt
, Beranek and Newman, Inc
., Canoga Park, CA
).30.
Fidell
, S.
, Silvati
, L.
, and Pearsons
, K.
(1995
). Social Survey of Community Response to Noise Near Seattle-Tacoma International Airport (Bolt
, Beranek and Newman, Inc
., Canoga Park, CA
).31.
Fidell
, S.
, Silvati
, L.
, Pearsons
, K.
, Lind
, S.
, and Howe
, R.
(1999
). “Field study of the annoyance of low-frequency runway sideline noise
,” J. Acoust. Soc. Am.
106
, 1408
–1415
.32.
Fidell
, S.
, and Sneddon
, M.
(2005
). Field Measurements of Aircraft Noise and Community Response in Western Hamilton County, OH
(Hamilton County Board of Commissioners
, Cincinnati, OH
).33.
Gelderblom
, D.
, Gjestland
, T.
, Fidell
, S.
, and Berry
, B.
(2017
). “On the stability of community tolerance for aircraft noise
,” Acta Acust. united Ac.
103
, 17
–27
.34.
Gjestland
, T.
(2018
). “A systematic review of the basis for WHO's new recommendations for limiting aircraft noise annoyance
,” Int. J. Environ. Res. Pub. Health
15
, 2717
.35.
Gjestland
, T.
, Liasjø
, K.
, Granøien
, I.
, Bøhn
, H.
, and Gaustad
, A.
(1990
). “A noise survey around Oslo airport Fornebu
,” in Proceedings of Internoise 90
, August 13–15, Gothenburg, Sweden, pp. 451
–454
.36.
Grandjean
, E.
, Graf
, P.
, Meier
, H.
, and Mueller
, R.
(1976
). “Survey on the effects of aircraft noise around three civil airports in Switzerland
,” in Proceedings of Internoise 76
, April 5–7, Washington, DC, pp. 85
–90
.37.
Guski
, R.
, Schreckenberg
, D.
, and Schuemer
, R.
(2017
). “WHO environmental noise guidelines for the European Region. A systematic review on environmental noise and annoyance
,” Int. J. Environ. Res. Pub. Health
14
, 1539
.38.
Guski
, R.
, Schreckenberg
, D.
, Schuemer
, R.
, Brink
, M.
, and Stansfeld
, S.
(2019
). “Comment on Gjestland, T. A Systematic Review of the Basis for WHO's New Recommendation for Limiting Aircraft Noise Annoyance, Int. J. Env. Res. Pub. Health 2018, 15, 2717
,” Int. J. Environ. Res. Pub. Health
16
, 1088
.39.
Hörmann
, H. E.
(1974
). Fluglärmwirkungen. Eine interdisziplinäre Untersuchungen über die Auswirkungen den Fluglärms auf den Menschen
(Effects of Aircraft Noise: An Interdisciplinary Study of the Effect of Aircraft Noise on People) (Harald Bolt Verlag KG
, Bonn, Germany
).40.
ISO
(2003
). ISO/TS 15666:2003: Acoustics—Assessment of Noise Annoyance by Means of Social and Socio-Acoustic Surveys
(International Standardization Organization
, Geneva, Switzerland
).41.
Jonckheere
, R.
(1984
). “Noise assessment around the Brussels International Airport
,” in Proceedings of the 4th FASE Congress
, August 21–24, Sandefjord, Norway, pp. 317
–320
.42.
Kastka
, J.
(1999
). Untersuchung der Fluglärmbelastung und Belästigungssituation der Allgemeinbevölkerung der Umgebung des Flughafen Frankfurt
(A Study of the Effect of Aircraft Noise Exposure on Residents Near Frankfurt Airport) (Heinrich-Heine Universität
, Düsseldorf, Germany
).43.
Kastka
, J.
, Mau
, U.
, Muth
, T.
, and Siegmann
, S.
(1996
). “Standings and results of the research on aircraft noise—Longitudinal study at Düsseldorf airport
,” in Proceedings of Internoise 96
, July 30–August 2, Liverpool, UK, pp. 305
–310
.44.
Le Masurier
, P.
, Bates
, J.
, Taylor
, J.
, Flindell
, I.
, Humpheson
, D.
, Pownall
, C.
, and Woolley
, A.
(2007
). Attitudes to Noise From Aviation Sources in England (ANASE)
, Final Report
(MVA Consultancy
, Woking, UK
).45.
Lim
, C.
(2007
). “The relationship between civil aircraft noise and community annoyance in Korea
,” J. Sound. Vib.
299
, 575
–586
.46.
McKennell
, A.
(1963
). Aircraft Noise Around London (Heathrow) Airport (The Wilson Committee on the Problem of Noise
, UK Central Office of Information
, London, UK
).47.
Miedema
, H.
, and Vos
, H.
(1998
). “Exposure-response relationships for transportation noise
,” J. Acoust. Soc. Am.
104
, 3432
–3445
.48.
Nguyen
, T.
(2012a
). “Aircraft and road traffic noise annoyance in Da Nang City, Vietnam
,” in Proceedings of Internoise 2012
, August 19–22, New York, NY.49.
Nguyen
, T.
(2012b
). “Comparison of models to predict annoyance from combined noise in Ho Chi Minh City and Hanoi
,” Appl. Acoust.
73
, 952
–959
.50.
Nguyen
, T. Lan.
, Nguyen
, T. Linh.
, and Yano
, T.
(2015
). “Social surveys around Noi Bai airport before and after the opening of the new terminal building
,” in Proceedings of Internoise 2015
, August 9–12, San Francisco, CA.51.
Oliva
, C.
(1998
). Belastung der Bevölkerung durch Flug und Strassenlärm. Eine Lärmstudie am Beispiel der Flughafen Genf und Zürich
(The Impact of Noise from Aircraft and Road Traffic on People: A Study of Examples from Geneva and Zurich Airports) (Dunker und Humbolt
, Berlin, Germany
).52.
Rylander
, R.
, and Björkman
, M.
(1997
). “Annoyance by aircraft noise around small airports
,” J. Sound. Vib.
205
, 533
–537
.53.
Schomer
, P.
(1983
). “A survey of community attitudes towards noise near a general aviation airport
,” J. Acoust. Soc. Am.
74
, 1773
–1781
.54.
Schreckenberg
, D.
(2007
). Effects of Aircraft Noise on Noise Annoyance and Quality of Life Around Frankfurt Airport
(ZEUS GmbH, Bochum
, Germany
).55.
Schreckenberg
, D.
, and Meis
, M.
(2007
). “Noise annoyance around an international airport planned to be extended
,” in Proceedings of Internoise 2007
, August 28–31, Istanbul, Turkey.56.
Silvati
, L.
, Pearsons
, K.
, Lind
, L.
, and Howe
, R.
(1983
). Survey of Opinions About Living Conditions in Two Neighborhoods Near Greater Pittsburgh International Airport (Bolt
, Beranek and Newman, Inc
., Cambridge, MA
).57.
Vincent
, B.
, Vallet
, M.
, Olivier
, D.
, and Paque
, G.
(2000
). “Evaluation of variations of the annoyance due to aircraft noise
,” in Proceedings of Internoise 2000
, August 27–30, Nice, France.58.
WHO
(2018
). WHO Environmental Noise Guidelines for the European Region
(WHO
, Copenhagen, Denmark
).59.
Withfield
, A.
(2003
). “Assessment of noise annoyance in three distinct communities living in close proximity to a UK regional airport
,” Int. J. Environ. Health Res.
13
(4
), 361
–372
.60.
Yamada
, I.
, and Kaku
, J.
(1996
). “Changes in people's attitudes toward airport resulting from decrease in number of flights
,” in Proceedings of Internoise 96
, July 30–August 2, Liverpool, UK, pp. 2079
–2084
.© 2020 Acoustical Society of America.
2020
Acoustical Society of America
You do not currently have access to this content.
