This paper reports on two experiments that investigated the expressive means through which musicians well versed in groove-based music signal the intended timing of a rhythmic event. Data were collected from 21 expert electric guitarists and 21 bassists, who were instructed to perform a simple rhythmic pattern in three different timing styles—“laid-back,” “on-the-beat,” and “pushed”—in tandem with a metronome. As expected, onset and peak timing locations corresponded to the instructed timing styles for both instruments. Regarding sound, results for guitarists revealed systematic differences across participants in the duration and brightness [spectral centroid (SC)] of the guitar strokes played using these different timing styles. In general, laid-back strokes were played with a longer duration and a lower SC relative to on-the-beat and pushed strokes. Results for the bassists indicated systematic differences in intensity (sound-pressure level): pushed strokes were played with higher intensity than on-the-beat and laid-back strokes. These results lend further credence to the hypothesis that both temporal and sound-related features are important indications of the intended timing of a rhythmic event, and together these features offer deeper insight into the ways in which musicians communicate at the microrhythmic level in groove-based music.
References
1.
Algom
, D.
, and Fitousi
, D.
(2016
). “Half a century of research on Garner interference and the separability–integrality distinction
,” Psychol. Bull.
142
(12
), 1352
–1383
.2.
Bechtold
, T. A.
, and Senn
, O.
(2018
). “Articulation and dynamics influence the perceptual attack time of saxophone sounds
,” Front. Psychol.
9
, 1692
.3.
Berliner
, P.
(1994
). Thinking in Jazz: The Infinite Art of Improvisation
(University of Chicago Press
, Chicago
).4.
Butterfield
, M. W.
(2006
). “The power of anacrusis: Engendered feeling in groove-based musics
,” Music Theory Online
12
(4
).5.
Butterfield
, M. W.
(2010
). “Participatory discrepancies and the perception of beats in jazz
,” Music Percept.
27
(3
), 157
–175
.6.
Butterfield
, M. W.
(2011
). “Why do jazz musicians swing their eighth notes?
,” Music Theory Spect.
33
(1
), 3
–26
.7.
Câmara
, G. S.
(2016
). “Swing in early funk and jazz-funk (1967–1971): Micro-rhythmic and macro-structural investigations
,” Master's dissertation, University of Oslo
, Oslo, Norway.8.
Câmara
, G. S.
, and Danielsen
, A.
(2019
). “Groove
,” in The Oxford Handbook of Critical Concepts in Music Theory
, edited by A.
Rehding
and S.
Rings
(Oxford University Press
, New York
), pp. 271
–294
.9.
Clarke
, E. F.
(1987
). “Categorical rhythm perception: An ecological perspective
,” in Action and Perception in Rhythm and Music
, edited by A.
Gabrielsson
(Royal Swedish Academy of Music
, Stockholm
), pp. 19
–34
.10.
Clarke
, E. F.
(1989
). “Generative principles in music performance
,” in Generative Processes in Music
, edited by J. A.
Sloboda
(Clardendon
, Oxford, UK
), pp. 1
–26
.11.
Dahl
, S.
(2000
). “The playing of an accent—Preliminary observations from temporal and kinematic analysis of percussionists
,” J. New Music Res.
29
, 225
–233
.12.
Dahl
, S.
(2004
). “Playing the accent—Comparing striking velocity and timing in an ostinato rhythm performed by four drummers
,” Acta Acoust. Acoust.
90
(4
), 762
–776
.13.
Danielsen
, A.
(2006
). Presence and Pleasure: The Funk Grooves of James Brown and Parliament
(Wesleyan University Press
, Middletown, CT
), Chap. 5.14.
Danielsen
, A.
(2010
). “Here, there and everywhere: Three accounts of pulse in D'Angelo's ‘Left and right’
,” in Musical Rhythm in the Age of Digital Reproduction
, edited by A.
Danielsen
(Ashgate
, Farnham, UK
), pp. 19
–36
.15.
Danielsen
, A.
(2018
). “Pulse as dynamic attending: Analysing beat bin metre in neo soul grooves
,” in The Routledge Companion to Popular Music Analysis: Expanding Approaches
, edited by C.
Scotto
, K. M.
Smith
, and J.
Brackett
(Routledge
, London
), pp. 179
–189
.16.
Danielsen
, A.
, Nymoen
, K.
, Anderson
, E.
, Câmara
, G. S.
, Langerød
, M. T.
, Thompson
, M.
, and London
, J.
(2019
). “Where is the beat in that note? Effects of attack, duration and frequency on the perceived timing of musical and quasi-musical sounds
,” J. Exp. Psychol. Hum. Percept. Perform.
45
(3
), 402
–418
.17.
Danielsen
, A.
, Waadeland
, C. H.
, Sundt
, H. G.
, and Witek
, M. A. G.
(2015
). “Effects of instructed timing and tempo on snare drum sound in drum kit performance
,” J. Acoust. Soc. Am.
138
(4
), 2301
–2316
.18.
Davies
, M.
, Madison
, G.
, Silva
, P.
, and Gouyon
, F.
(2013
). “The effect of microtiming deviations on the perception of groove in short rhythms
,” Music Percept.
30
, 497
–510
.19.
Doffman
, M.
(2019
). “Practical time consciousness in performance
,” in Music and Consciousness II
, edited by D.
Clarke
, E.
Clarke
, and R.
Herbert
(Oxford University Press
, Oxford, UK
), pp. 170
–186
.20.
Donnadieu
, S.
(1987
). “Mental representation of the timbre of complex sounds
,” in Analysis, Synthesis, and Perception of Musical Sounds: The Sound of Music
, edited by J. W.
Beauchamp
(Springer
, New York
), pp. 272
–319
.21.
Drake
, C.
, and Palmer
, C.
(1993
). “Accent structures in music performance
,” Music Percept.
10
, 343
–378
.22.
Elliott
, D. N.
, Riach
, W. D.
, Sheposh
, J. P.
, and Trahiotis
, C.
(1966
). “Discrimination performance of high school sophomores on a battery of auditory tests
,” Acta. Otolaryngol. Suppl.
216
, 1
–59
.23.
Fischer
, R.
, and Milfont
, T. L.
(2010
). “Standardization in psychological research
,” Int. J. Psychol. Res.
3
(1
), 88
–96
.24.
Frane
, A. V.
, and Shams
, L.
(2017
). “Effects of tempo, swing density, and listener's drumming experience on swing eetection thresholds for drum rhythms
,” J. Acoust. Soc. Am.
141
, 4200
–4208
.25.
Friberg
, A.
, and Sundberg
, J.
(1995
). “Time discrimination in a monotonic, isochronous sequence
,” J. Acoust. Soc. Am.
98
(5
), 2524
–2531
.26.
Friberg
, A.
, and Sundström
, A.
(2002
). “Swing ratios and ensemble timing in jazz performance: Evidence for a common rhythmic pattern
,” Music Percept.
19
, 333
–349
.27.
Frühauf
, J.
, Kopiez
, R.
, and Platz
, F.
(2013
). “Music on the timing grid: The influence of microtiming on the perceived groove quality of a simple drum pattern performance
,” Music. Sci.
17
, 246
–260
.28.
Gabrielsson
, A.
(1974
). “Performance of rhythm patterns
,” Scand. J. Psychol.
15
, 63
–72
.29.
Gabrielsson
, A.
(1999
). “The performance of music
,” in The Psychology of Music
, edited by D.
Deutsch
(Academic
, New York
), pp. 501
–602
.30.
Goebl
, W.
(2001
). “Melody lead in piano performance: Expressive device or artifact?
,” J. Acoust. Soc. Am.
110
(1
), 563
–572
.31.
Goebl
, W.
, and Parncutt
, R.
(2002
). “The influence of relative intensity on the perception of onset asynchronies
,” in Proceedings from ICMPC7
, Sydney, Australia, edited by C.
Stevens
, D.
Burnham
, G.
McPherson
, E.
Schubert
, and J.
Renwick
(Causal Productions for AMPS
, Adelaide
), pp. 613
–616
.32.
Gordon
, J. W.
(1987
). “The perceptual attack time of musical tones
,” J. Acoust. Soc. Am.
82
(1
), 88
–105
.33.
Iyer
, V.
(2002
). “Embodied mind, situated cognition, and expressive microtiming in African-American music
,” Music Percept.
19
, 387
–414
.34.
Janata
, P.
, Tomic
, S. T.
, and Haberman
, J. M.
(2012
). “Sensorimotor coupling in music and the psychology of the groove
,” J. Exp. Psychol.
141
, 54
–75
.35.
Jesteadt
, W.
, Wier
, C. C.
, and Green
, D. M.
(1977
). “Intensity discrimination as a function of frequency and sensation level
,” J. Acoust. Soc. Am.
61
, 169
–177
.36.
Johnson
, D. M.
, Watson
, C. S.
, and Jensen
, J. K.
(1987
). “Individual differences in auditory capabilities
,” J. Acoust. Soc. Am.
81
, 427
–438
.37.
Keil
, C.
(1987
). “Participatory discrepancies and the power of music
,” Cult. Anthropol.
2
, 275
–283
.38.
Kernfeld
, B.
(2003
). “Groove (i)
,” Grove Music Online, available at https://www.oxfordmusiconline.com/grovemusic/view/10.1093/gmo/9781561592630.001.0001/omo-9781561592630-e-2000582400 (Last viewed 11 Dec. 2019).39.
Kilchenmann
, L.
, and Senn
, O.
(2011
). “ ‘Play in time, but don't play time’: Analyzing timing profiles in drum performance
,” in Proceedings of the International Symposium on Performance Science 2011
, edited by A.
Williamon
, D.
Edwards
, and L.
Bartel
(European Association of Conservatoires
, Utrecht
, The Netherlands), pp. 593
–598
.40.
Kilchenmann
, L.
, and Senn
, O.
(2015
). “Microtiming in swing and funk affects the body movement behavior of music expert listeners
,” Front. Psych.
6
, 1232
.41.
Lartillot
, O.
, Toiviainen
, P.
, and Eerola
, T.
(2008
). “A MATLAB Toolbox for music information retrieval
,” in Data Analysis, Machine Learning and Applications, Studies in Classification, Data Analysis, and Knowledge Organization
, edited by C.
Preisach
, H.
Burkhardt
, L.
Schmidt-Thieme
, and R.
Decker
(Springer
, Berlin
), pp. 261
–268
.42.
London
, J.
, Nymoen
, K.
, Langerød
, M. T.
, Thompson
, M. R.
, Code
, D. L.
, and Danielsen
, A.
(2019
). “A comparison of methods for investigating the perceptual center of musical sounds
,” Atten. Percept. Psychophys.
81
(6
), 2088
–2101
.43.
Madison
, G.
(2006
). “Experiencing groove induced by Music: Consistency and phenomenology
,” Music Percept.
24
(2
), 201
–208
.44.
Madison
, G.
, Gouyon
, F.
, Ullén
, F.
, and Hörnström
, K.
(2011
). “Modeling the tendency for music to induce movement in humans: First correlations with low-level audio descriptors across music genres
,” J. Exp. Psychol.
37
, 1578
–1594
.45.
Madison
, G.
, and Sioros
, G.
(2014
). “What musicians do to induce the sensation of groove in simple and complex melodies, and how listeners perceive it
,” Front. Psychol.
5
, 894
.46.
Melara
, R. D.
, and Marks
, L. E.
(1990
). “Interaction among auditory dimensions: Timbre, pitch, and loudness
,” Attn. Percept. Psychophys.
48
, 169
–178
.47.
Monson
, I.
(1996
). Saying Something: Jazz Improvisation and Interaction
(University of Chicago Press
, Chicago
), Chap. 3.48.
Morton
, J.
, Marcus
, S.
, and Frankish
, C.
(1976
). “Perceptual centers (P-centers
),” Psychol. Rev.
83
(5
), 405
–408
.49.
Palmer
, C.
(1996
). “On the assignment of structure in music performance
,” Music Percept.
14
(1
), 23
–56
.50.
Povel
, D. J.
, and Okkerman
, H.
(1981
). “Accents in equitone sequences
,” Attn. Percept. Psychophys.
30
, 565
–572
.51.
Pressing
, J.
(2002
). “Black Atlantic rhythm: Its computational and transcultural foundations
,” Music Percept.
19
, 285
–310
.52.
Repp
, B. H.
(1996
). “Patterns of note onset asynchronies in expressive piano performance
,” J. Acoust. Soc. Am.
100
(6
), 3917
–3932
.53.
Repp
, B. H.
(2005
). “Sensorimotor synchronization: A review of the tapping literature
,” Psychon. Bull. Rev.
12
(6
), 969
–992
.54.
Repp
, B. H.
, and Doggett
, R.
(2007
). “Tapping to a very slow beat: A comparison of musicians and non-musicians
,” Music Percept.
24
(4
), 367
–376
.55.
Repp
, B. H.
, and Su
, Y.-H.
(2013
). “Sensorimotor synchronization: A review of recent research (2006–2012)
,” Psychon. Bull. Rev.
20
(3
), 403
–452
.56.
Rossing
, T. D.
, Moore
, F. R.
, and Wheeler
, P. A.
(2002
). The Science of Sound
, 3rd ed. (Addison Wesley
, San Francisco
).57.
Schubert
, E.
, and Wolfe
, J.
(2006
). “Does timbral brightness scale with frequency and spectral centroid?
,” Acta Acust. Acust.
92
, 820
–825
.58.
Scott
, S. K.
(1998
). “The point of P-centres
,” Psychol. Res.
61
, 4
–11
.59.
Senn
, O.
, Bullerjahn
, C.
, Kilchenmann
, L.
, and von Georgi
, R.
(2017
). “Rhythmic density affects listeners' emotional response to microtiming
,” Front. Psychol.
8
(10
), 1709
.60.
Senn
, O.
, Kilchenmann
, L.
, von Georgi
, R.
, and Bullerjahn
, C.
(2016
). “The effect of expert performance microtiming on listeners' experience of groove in swing or funk music
,” Front. Psychol.
7
, 1487
.61.
Seton
, J. C.
(1989
). “A psychophysical investigation of auditory rhythmic beat perception
,” Ph.D. thesis, University of York
, York, UK.62.
Skaansar
, J.
, Laeng
, B.
, and Danielsen
, A.
(2019
). “Microtiming and mental effort: Onset asynchronies in musical rhythm modulate pupil size
,” Music Percept.
37
(2
), 111
–133
.63.
Tekman
, H. G.
(2002
). “Perceptual integration of timing and intensity variations in the perception of musical accents
,” J. Gen. Psychol.
129
, 181
–191
.64.
Villing
, R.
(2010
). “Hearing the moment: Measures and models of the perceptual centre
,” Ph.D. dissertation, National University of Ireland
, Maynooth, Ireland.65.
Vos
, P. G.
, Mates
, J.
, and van Kruysbergen
, N. W.
(1995
). “The perceptual centre of a stimulus as the cue for synchronization to a metronome: Evidence from asynchronies
,” Quart. J. Exp. Psychol.
48
(A4
), 1024
–1040
.66.
Waadeland
, C. H.
(2006
). “Strategies in empirical studies of swing groove
,” Stud. Musicolog. Norv.
32
, 169
–191
.67.
Windsor
, W. L.
(1993
). “Dynamic accents and the categorical perception of metre
,” Psychol. Music.
21
(2
), 127
–140
.68.
69.
Wright
, M. J.
(2008
). “The Shape of an Instant: Measuring and Modeling Perceptual Attack Time with Probability Density Functions
,” Ph.D. dissertation, Stanford University
, Stanford, CA.© 2020 Acoustical Society of America.
2020
Acoustical Society of America
You do not currently have access to this content.
