Multiple measures of vowel overlap have been proposed that use F1, F2, and duration to calculate the degree of overlap between vowel categories. The present study assesses four of these measures: the spectral overlap assessment metric [SOAM; Wassink (2006). J. Acoust. Soc. Am. 119(4), 2334–2350], the a posteriori probability (APP)-based metric [Morrison (2008). J. Acoust. Soc. Am. 123(1), 37–40], the vowel overlap analysis with convex hulls method [VOACH; Haynes and Taylor, (2014). J. Acoust. Soc. Am. 136(2), 883–891], and the Pillai score as first used for vowel overlap by Hay, Warren, and Drager [(2006). J. Phonetics 34(4), 458–484]. Summaries of the measures are presented, and theoretical critiques of them are performed, concluding that the APP-based metric and Pillai score are theoretically preferable to SOAM and VOACH. The measures are empirically assessed using accuracy and precision criteria with Monte Carlo simulations. The Pillai score demonstrates the best overall performance in these tests. The potential applications of vowel overlap measures to research scenarios are discussed, including comparisons of vowel productions between different social groups, as well as acoustic investigations into vowel formant trajectories.
References
1.
Adank
, P.
, Smits
, R.
, and van Hout
, R.
(2004
). “A comparison of vowel normalization procedures for language variation research
,” J. Acoust. Soc. Am.
116
(5
), 3099
–3107
.2.
Barreda
, S.
(2015
). “phonTools: Functions for phonetics in R
” (R package version 0.2-2.1) [computer program], available at https://cran.r-project.org/web/packages/phonTools/index.html (Last viewed January 6, 2020).3.
Barreda
, S.
, and Nearey
, T. M.
(2018
). “A regression approach to vowel normalization for missing and unbalanced data
,” J. Acoust. Soc. Am.
144
(1
), 500
–520
.4.
Bray
, J. H.
, and Maxwell
, S. E.
(1985
). Multivariate Analysis of Variance
(Sage
, Beverly Hills, CA
), Quantitative Applications in the Social Sciences, Vol. 54
.5.
Fox
, J.
, Friendly
, M.
, and Monette
, G.
(2018
). “heplots: Visualizing tests in multivariate linear models (R package version 1.3-5) [computer program]
,” available at https://CRAN.R-project.org/package=heplots (Last viewed January 6, 2020).6.
Freeman
, V.
(2014
). “Bag, beg, bagel: Prevelar raising and merger in Pacific Northwest English
,” Univ. Wash. Work. Pap. Linguist.
32
, 1
–23
.7.
Fridland
, V.
, and Kendall
, T.
(2017
). “Speech in the silver state
,” Publ. Am. Dialect Soc.
102
(1
), 139
–164
.8.
Friendly
, M.
(2007
). “HE plots for multivariate general linear models
,” J. Comput. Graphic. Stat.
16
(4
), 421
–444
.9.
Ghorshi
, S.
, Vaseghi
, S.
, and Yan
, Q.
(2008
). “Cross-entropic comparison of formants of British, Australian and American English accents
,” Speech Commun.
50
(7
), 564
–579
.10.
Hall-Lew
, L.
(2010
). “Improved representation of variance in measures of vowel merger
,” Proc. Meet. Acoust.
9
, 060002
.11.
Hall-Lew
, L.
, Eiswirth
, M.
, Valentinsson
, M.-C.
, and Cotter
, W.
(2017
). “Northern Arizona vowels
,” Publ. Am. Dialect Soc.
102
(1
), 59
–82
.12.
Hay
, J.
, Warren
, P.
, and Drager
, K.
(2006
). “Factors influencing speech perception in the context of a merger-in-progress
,” J. Phonetics
34
(4
), 458
–484
.13.
Haynes
, E. F.
, and Taylor
, M.
(2014
). “An assessment of acoustic contrast between long and short vowels using convex hulls
,” J. Acoust. Soc. Am.
136
(2
), 883
–891
.14.
Hillenbrand
, J.
, Getty
, L. A.
, Clark
, M. J.
, and Wheeler
, K.
(1995
). “Acoustic characteristics of American English vowels
,” J. Acoust. Soc. Am.
97
(5
), 3099
–3111
.15.
Inman
, H. F.
(1984
). “Behavior and properties of the overlapping coefficient as a measure of agreement between distributions (association, dissimilarity)
,” Ph.D. dissertation, The University of Alabama at Birmingham
, available at http://search.proquest.com/docview/303295844/abstract/6A03AD442D6C405BPQ/1 (Last viewed January 6, 2020).16.
Kain
, A.
, Giudice
, M. D.
, and Tjaden
, K.
(2017
). “A comparison of sentence-level speech intelligibility metrics
,” in Interspeech 2017, ISCA
, pp. 1148
–1152
, available at http://www.isca-speech.org/archive/Interspeech_2017/abstracts/0567.html (Last viewed January 6, 2020).17.
Kelley
, M. C.
, and Tucker
, B. V.
(2019
). “Supplementary files for 'A comparison of four vowel overlap measures
,” available at (Last viewed January 6, 2020).18.
Lobanov
, B. M.
(1971
). “Classification of Russian vowels spoken by different speakers
,” J. Acoust. Soc. Am.
49
(2B
), 606
–608
.19.
Luan
, Y.
, Wright
, R.
, Ostendorf
, M.
, and Levow
, G.-A.
(2014
). “Relating automatic vowel space estimates to talker intelligibility
,” in INTERSPEECH-2014
, available at https://www.isca-speech.org/archive/interspeech_2014/i14_2238.html (Last viewed January 6, 2020).20.
Mairano
, P.
, Bouzon
, C.
, Capliez
, M.
, and De Iacovo
, V.
(2019
). “Acoustic distance, Pillai scores, and LDA classification scores as metrics of L2 comprehensibility and nativelikeness
,” in Proceedings of the 19th International Congress of Phonetic Sciences
, edited by S.
Calhoun
, P.
Escudero
, M.
Tabain
, and P.
Warren
, Melbourne, Australia, pp. 1104
–1108
.21.
Morrison
, G. S.
(2008
). “Comment on ‘A geometric representation of spectral and temporal vowel features: Quantification of vowel overlap in three linguistic varieties,’ J. Acoust. Soc. Am. 119, 2334–2350 (2006)]
,” J. Acoust. Soc. Am.
123
(1
), 37
–40
.22.
Nearey
, T. M.
(1978
). Phonetic Feature System for Vowels
(Indiana University Linguistics Club
, Bloomington, IN
).23.
Nearey
, T. M.
, and Assmann
, P. F.
(1986
). “Modeling the role of inherent spectral change in vowel identification
,” J. Acoust. Soc. Am.
80
(5
), 1297
–1308
.24.
Nearey
, T. M.
, and Assmann
, P. F.
(2007
). “Probabilistic ‘sliding template’ models for indirect vowel normalization
,” in Experimental Approaches to Phonology
, edited by M. J.
Solé
, P. S.
Beddor
, and M.
Ohala
(Oxford University Press
, Oxford
), pp. 246
–269
.25.
Nycz
, J.
, and Hall-Lew
, L.
(2015
). “Best practices in measuring vowel merger
,” Proc. Meet. Acoust.
20
, 060008
.26.
Perry
, S. J.
, and Tucker
, B. V.
(2019
). “L2 production of American English vowels in function words by Spanish L1 speakers
,” in Acoustics Week in Canada 2019 Conference Proceedings
, Edmonton, Alberta, Canada.27.
Pillai
, K. C. S.
(1954
). “On some distribution problems in multivariate analysis
,” Technical Report 88
(Institute of Statistics, University of North Carolina
, Chapel Hill, NC
).28.
R Core Team
(2017
). R: A Language and Environment for Statistical Computing
(R Foundation for Statistical Computing
, Vienna, Austria
), available at https://www.R-project.org/ (Last viewed January 6, 2020).29.
Sandoval
, S.
, Berisha
, V.
, Utianski
, R. L.
, Liss
, J. M.
, and Spanias
, A.
(2013
). “Automatic assessment of vowel space area
,” J. Acoust. Soc. Am.
134
(5
), EL477
–EL483
.30.
Schmid
, F.
, and Schmidt
, A.
(2006
). “Nonparametric estimation of the coefficient of overlapping–theory and empirical application
,” Comput. Stat. Data Anal.
50
(6
), 1583
–1596
.31.
Shirai
, S.
(2005
). “Lexical effects in Japanese vowel reduction
,” Ph.D. dissertation, University of Washington, available at https://digital.lib.washington.edu:443/researchworks/handle/1773/8381 (Last viewed January 6, 2020).32.
Story
, B. H.
, and Bunton
, K.
(2017
). “Vowel space density as an indicator of speech performance
,” J. Acoust. Soc. Am.
141
(5
), EL458
–EL464
.33.
Venables
, W. N.
, and Ripley
, B. D.
(2002
). Modern Applied Statistics with S
, fourth ed. (Springer
, New York
).34.
Wang
, B.
, Shi
, W.
, and Miao
, Z.
(2015
). “Confidence analysis of standard deviational ellipse and its extension into higher dimensional Euclidean space
,” PLoS One
10
(3
), e0118537
.35.
Wanrooij
, K.
, Boersma
, P.
, and Zuijen
, T. L. v.
(2014
). “Distributional vowel training is less effective for adults than for infants. A study using the mismatch response
,” PLoS One
9
(10
), e109806
.36.
Wassink
, A. B.
(2006
). “A geometric representation of spectral and temporal vowel features: Quantification of vowel overlap in three linguistic varieties
,” J. Acoust. Soc. Am.
119
(4
), 2334
–2350
.37.
Whalen
, D. H.
, and Chen
, W.-R.
(2019
). “Variability and central tendencies in speech production
,” Front. Commun.
4
, 1
–9
.38.
Wong
, A. W.-M.
, and Hall-Lew
, L.
(2014
). “Regional variability and ethnic identity: Chinese Americans in New York City and San Francisco
,” Lang. Commun.
35
, 27
–42
.© 2020 Acoustical Society of America.
2020
Acoustical Society of America
You do not currently have access to this content.
