Acoustic imaging methods often ignore multiple scattering. This leads to false images in cases where multiple scattering is strong. Marchenko imaging has recently been introduced as a data-driven way to deal with internal multiple scattering. Given the increasing interest in non-reciprocal materials, both for acoustic and electromagnetic applications, a modification to the Marchenko method is proposed for imaging such materials. A unified wave equation is formulated for non-reciprocal materials, exploiting the similarity between acoustic and electromagnetic wave phenomena. This unified wave equation forms the basis for deriving reciprocity theorems that interrelate wave fields in a non-reciprocal medium and its complementary version. Next, these theorems are reformulated for downgoing and upgoing wave fields. From these decomposed reciprocity theorems, representations of the Green's function inside the non-reciprocal medium are derived in terms of the reflection response at the surface and focusing functions inside the medium and its complementary version. These representations form the basis for deriving a modified version of the Marchenko method to retrieve the wave field inside a non-reciprocal medium and to form an image, free from artefacts related to multiple scattering. The proposed method is illustrated at the hand of the numerically modeled reflection response of a horizontally layered medium.
References
1.
J. F.
Claerbout
, “Toward a unified theory of reflector mapping
,” Geophysics
36
, 467
–481
(1971
).2.
R. H.
Stolt
, “Migration by Fourier transform
,” Geophysics
43
, 23
–48
(1978
).3.
A. J.
Berkhout
and D. W.
van Wulfften Palthe
, “Migration in terms of spatial deconvolution
,” Geophys. Prosp.
27
, 261
–291
(1979
).4.
E. G.
Williams
and J. D.
Maynard
, “Holographic imaging without the wavelength resolution limit
,” Phys. Rev. Lett.
45
, 554
–557
(1980
).5.
A. J.
Devaney
, “A filtered backpropagation algorithm for diffraction tomography
,” Ultrasonic Imag.
4
, 336
–350
(1982
).6.
N.
Bleistein
and J. K.
Cohen
, “Velocity inversion—Present status, new directions
,” Geophysics
47
, 1497
–1511
(1982
).7.
J. D.
Maynard
, E. G.
Williams
, and Y.
Lee
, “Nearfield acoustic holography: I. Theory of generalized holography and the development of NAH
,” J. Acoust. Soc. Am.
78
, 1395
–1413
(1985
).8.
K. J.
Langenberg
, M.
Berger
, T.
Kreutter
, K.
Mayer
, and V.
Schmitz
, “Synthetic aperture focusing technique signal processing
,” NDT Int.
19
, 177
–189
(1986
).9.
G. A.
McMechan
, “Migration by extrapolation of time-dependent boundary values
,” Geophys. Prosp.
31
, 413
–420
(1983
).10.
C.
Esmersoy
and M.
Oristaglio
, “Reverse-time wave-field extrapolation, imaging, and inversion
,” Geophysics
53
, 920
–931
(1988
).11.
M. L.
Oristaglio
, “An inverse scattering formula that uses all the data
,” Inverse Probl.
5
, 1097
–1105
(1989
).12.
S. J.
Norton
, “Annular array imaging with full-aperture resolution
,” J. Acoust. Soc. Am.
92
, 3202
–3206
(1992
).13.
S. F.
Wu
, “Hybrid near-field acoustic holography
,” J. Acoust. Soc. Am.
115
, 207
–217
(2004
).14.
C.
Lindsey
and D. C.
Braun
, “Principles of seismic holography for diagnostics of the shallow subphotosphere
,” Astrophys. J. Suppl. Series
155
, 209
–225
(2004
).15.
J.
Etgen
, S. H.
Gray
, and Y.
Zhang
, “An overview of depth imaging in exploration geophysics
,” Geophysics
74
, WCA5
–WCA17
(2009
).16.
D. J.
Verschuur
, A. J.
Berkhout
, and C. P. A.
Wapenaar
, “Adaptive surface-related multiple elimination
,” Geophysics
57
, 1166
–1177
(1992
).17.
P. M.
Carvalho
, A. B.
Weglein
, and R. H.
Stolt
, “Nonlinear inverse scattering for multiple suppression: Application to real data, Part 1
,” in SEG, Expanded Abstracts
(1992
), pp. 1093
–1095
.18.
R. G.
van Borselen
, J. T.
Fokkema
, and P. M.
van den Berg
, “Removal of surface-related wave phenomena—The marine case
,” Geophysics
61
, 202
–210
(1996
).19.
J.
Biersteker
, “MAGIC: Shell's surface multiple attenuation technique
,” in SEG, Expanded Abstracts
(2001
), 1301
–1304
.20.
A.
Pica
, G.
Poulain
, B.
David
, M.
Magesan
, S.
Baldock
, T.
Weisser
, P.
Hugonnet
, and P.
Herrmann
, “3D surface-related multiple modeling
,” Leading Edge
24
, 292
–296
(2005
).21.
B.
Dragoset
, E.
Verschuur
, I.
Moore
, and R.
Bisley
, “A perspective on 3D surface-related multiple elimination
,” Geophysics
75
, 75A245
–75A261
(2010
).22.
A. B.
Weglein
, F. A.
Gasparotto
, P. M.
Carvalho
, and R. H.
Stolt
, “An inverse-scattering series method for attenuating multiples in seismic reflection data
,” Geophysics
62
, 1975
–1989
(1997
).23.
F.
Ten Kroode
, “Prediction of internal multiples
,” Wave Motion
35
, 315
–338
(2002
).24.
A. B.
Weglein
, F. V.
Araújo
, P. M.
Carvalho
, R. H.
Stolt
, K. H.
Matson
, R. T.
Coates
, D.
Corrigan
, D. J.
Foster
, S. A.
Shaw
, and H.
Zhang
, “Inverse scattering series and seismic exploration
,” Inverse Probl.
19
, R27
–R83
(2003
).25.
A. J.
Berkhout
, “Review paper: An outlook on the future of seismic imaging, Part II: Full-Wavefield Migration
,” Geophys. Prosp.
62
, 931
–949
(2014
).26.
M.
Davydenko
and D. J.
Verschuur
, “Full-wavefield migration: Using surface and internal multiples in imaging
,” Geophys. Prosp.
65
, 7
–21
(2017
).27.
J. H.
Rose
, “ ‘Single-sided’ focusing of the time-dependent Schrödinger equation
,” Phys. Rev. A
65
, 012707
(2001
).28.
J. H.
Rose
, “ ‘Single-sided’ autofocusing of sound in layered materials
,” Inverse Probl.
18
, 1923
–1934
(2002
).29.
F.
Broggini
and R.
Snieder
, “Connection of scattering principles: A visual and mathematical tour
,” Eur. J. Phys.
33
, 593
–613
(2012
).30.
K.
Wapenaar
, F.
Broggini
, and R.
Snieder
, “Creating a virtual source inside a medium from reflection data: Heuristic derivation and stationary-phase analysis
,” Geophys. J. Int.
190
, 1020
–1024
(2012
).31.
K.
Wapenaar
, J.
Thorbecke
, J.
van der Neut
, F.
Broggini
, E.
Slob
, and R.
Snieder
, “Green's function retrieval from reflection data, in absence of a receiver at the virtual source position
,” J. Acoust. Soc. Am.
135
, 2847
–2861
(2014
).32.
F.
Broggini
, R.
Snieder
, and K.
Wapenaar
, “Data-driven wavefield focusing and imaging with multidimensional deconvolution: Numerical examples for reflection data with internal multiples
,” Geophysics
79
, WA107
–WA115
(2014
).33.
J.
Behura
, K.
Wapenaar
, and R.
Snieder
, “Autofocus imaging: Image reconstruction based on inverse scattering theory
,” Geophysics
79
, A19
–A26
(2014
).34.
G. A.
Meles
, K.
Löer
, M.
Ravasi
, A.
Curtis
, and C. A.
da Costa Filho
, “Internal multiple prediction and removal using Marchenko autofocusing and seismic interferometry
,” Geophysics
80
, A7
–A11
(2015
).35.
J.
van der Neut
, I.
Vasconcelos
, and K.
Wapenaar
, “On Green's function retrieval by iterative substitution of the coupled Marchenko equations
,” Geophys. J. Int.
203
, 792
–813
(2015
).36.
J.
van der Neut
and K.
Wapenaar
, “Adaptive overburden elimination with the multidimensional Marchenko equation
,” Geophysics
81
, T265
–T284
(2016
).37.
J.
Thorbecke
, E.
Slob
, J.
Brackenhoff
, J.
van der Neut
, and K.
Wapenaar
, “Implementation of the Marchenko method
,” Geophysics
82
, WB29
–WB45
(2017
).38.
J.
Van der Neut
, M.
Ravasi
, Y.
Liu
, and I.
Vasconcelos
, “Target-enclosed seismic imaging
,” Geophysics
82
, Q53
–Q66
(2017
).39.
S.
Singh
, R.
Snieder
, J.
van der Neut
, J.
Thorbecke
, E.
Slob
, and K.
Wapenaar
, “Accounting for free-surface multiples in Marchenko imaging
,” Geophysics
82
, R19
–R30
(2017
).40.
C.
Mildner
, F.
Broggini
, J. O. A.
Robertsson
, D. J.
van Manen
, and S.
Greenhalgh
, “Target-oriented velocity analysis using Marchenko-redatumed data
,” Geophysics
82
, R75
–R86
(2017
).41.
P.
Elison
, D. J.
van Manen
, J. O. A.
Robertsson
, M. S.
Dukalski
, and K.
de Vos
, “Marchenko-based immersive wave simulation
,” Geophys. J. Int.
215
, 1118
–1131
(2018
).42.
M.
Ravasi
, I.
Vasconcelos
, A.
Kritski
, A.
Curtis
, C. A.
da Costa Filho
, and G. A.
Meles
, “Target-oriented Marchenko imaging of a North Sea field
,” Geophys. J. Int.
205
, 99
–104
(2016
).43.
M.
Ravasi
, “Rayleigh-Marchenko redatuming for target-oriented, true-amplitude imaging
,” Geophysics
82
, S439
–S452
(2017
).44.
M.
Staring
, R.
Pereira
, H.
Douma
, J.
van der Neut
, and K.
Wapenaar
, “Source-receiver Marchenko redatuming on field data using an adaptive double-focusing method
,” Geophysics
83
, S579
–S590
(2018
).45.
J.
Brackenhoff
, J.
Thorbecke
, and K.
Wapenaar
, “Monitoring induced distributed double-couple sources using Marchenko-based virtual receivers
,” Solid Earth
10
, in press (2019
).46.
K.
Wapenaar
, J.
Brackenhoff
, J.
Thorbecke
, J.
van der Neut
, E.
Slob
, and E.
Verschuur
, “Virtual acoustics in inhomogeneous media with single-sided access
,” Sci. Rep.
8
, 2497
(2018
).47.
T.
Cui
, T. S.
Becker
, D.-J.
van Manen
, J. E.
Rickett
, and I.
Vasconcelos
, “Marchenko redatuming in a dissipative medium: Numerical and experimental implementation
,” Phys. Rev. Appl.
10
, 044022
(2018
).48.
J. R.
Willis
, “Effective constitutive relations for waves in composites and metamaterials
,” Proc. R. Soc. A
467
, 1865
–1879
(2011
).49.
C.
He
, M. H.
Lu
, X.
Heng
, L.
Feng
, and Y. F.
Chen
, “Parity-time electromagnetic diodes in a two-dimensional nonreciprocal photonic crystal
,” Phys. Rev. B
83
, 075117
(2011
).50.
A. G.
Ardakani
, “Nonreciprocal electromagnetic wave propagation in one-dimensional ternary magnetized plasma photonic crystals
,” J. Opt. Soc. Am. B
31
, 332
–339
(2014
).51.
J. R.
Willis
, “The construction of effective relations for waves in a composite
,” C. R. Mecan.
340
, 181
–192
(2012
).52.
A. N.
Norris
, A. L.
Shuvalov
, and A. A.
Kutsenko
, “Analytical formulation of three-dimensional dynamic homogenization for periodic elastic systems
,” Proc. R. Soc. A
468
, 1629
–1651
(2012
).53.
Z.
Gu
, J.
Hu
, B.
Liang
, X.
Zou
, and J.
Cheng
, “Broadband non-reciprocal transmission of sound with invariant frequency
,” Sci. Rep.
6
, 19824
(2016
).54.
G.
Trainiti
and M.
Ruzzene
, “Non-reciprocal elastic wave propagation in spatiotemporal periodic structures
,” New J. Phys.
18
, 083047
(2016
).55.
H.
Nassar
, H.
Chen
, A. N.
Norris
, M. R.
Haberman
, and G. L.
Huang
, “Non-reciprocal wave propagation in modulated elastic metamaterials
,” Proc. R. Soc. A
473
, 20170188
(2017
).56.
H.
Nassar
, X. C.
Xu
, A. N.
Norris
, and G. L.
Huang
, “Modulated phononic crystals: Non-reciprocal wave propagation and Willis materials
,” J. Mech. Phys. Solids
101
, 10
–29
(2017
).57.
M. A.
Attarzadeh
and M.
Nouh
, “Non-reciprocal elastic wave propagation in 2D phononic membranes with spatiotemporally varying material properties
,” J. Sound Vib.
422
, 264
–277
(2018
).58.
J. T.
Fokkema
and P. M.
van den Berg
, Seismic Applications of Acoustic Reciprocity
(Elsevier
, Amsterdam
, 1993
), Chap. 5.59.
A. T.
de Hoop
, Handbook of Radiation and Scattering of Waves
(Academic Press
, London
, 1995
), Chaps. 7, 15, and 28.60.
J. D.
Achenbach
, Reciprocity in Elastodynamics
(Cambridge University Press
, Cambridge
, 2003
), Chaps. 4 and 6.61.
J. A.
Kong
, “Theorems of bianisotropic media
,” Proc. IEEE
60
, 1036
–1046
(1972
).62.
R. R.
Birss
and R. G.
Shrubsall
, “The propagation of EM waves in magnetoelectric crystals
,” Philos. Mag.
15
, 687
–700
(1967
).63.
I. V.
Lindell
, A. H.
Sihvola
, and K.
Suchy
, “Six-vector formalism in electromagnetics of bi-anisotropic media
,” J. Electron. Waves Appl.
9
, 887
–903
(1995
).64.
C.
Altman
and K.
Suchy
, Reciprocity, Spatial Mapping and Time Reversal in Electromagnetics
(Kluwer
, Dordrecht
, 1991
), Chap. 3.65.
E.
Slob
and K.
Wapenaar
, “Retrieving the Green's function from cross correlation in a bianisotropic medium
,” Prog. Electromagn. Res.
93
, 255
–274
(2009
).66.
L. M.
Lyamshev
, “On certain integral relations in the acoustics of a moving medium
,” Dokl. Akad. Nauk
138
, 575
–578
(1961
), available at http://mi.mathnet.ru/eng/dan/v138/i3/p575.67.
O. A.
Godin
, “Reciprocity and energy theorems for waves in a compressible inhomogeneous moving fluid
,” Wave Motion
25
, 143
–167
(1997
).68.
K.
Wapenaar
and J.
Fokkema
, “Reciprocity theorems for diffusion, flow and waves
,” J. Appl. Mech.
71
, 145
–150
(2004
).69.
C. P. A.
Wapenaar
and A. J.
Berkhout
, Elastic Wave Field Extrapolation
(Elsevier
, Amsterdam
, 1989
), Chap. 3 and Appendix B.70.
J. P.
Corones
, M. E.
Davison
, and R. J.
Krueger
, “Direct and inverse scattering in the time domain via invariant imbedding equations
,” J. Acoust. Soc. Am.
74
, 1535
–1541
(1983
).71.
L.
Fishman
, J. J.
McCoy
, and S. C.
Wales
, “Factorization and path integration of the Helmholtz equation: Numerical algorithms
,” J. Acoust. Soc. Am.
81
, 1355
–1376
(1987
).72.
L.
Fishman
, “One-way propagation methods in direct and inverse scalar wave propagation modeling
,” Radio Sci.
28
, 865
–876
, (1993
).73.
M. V.
de Hoop
, “Directional decomposition of transient acoustic wave fields
,” Ph.D. thesis, Delft University of Technology
, Delft, The Netherlands
(1992
).74.
M. V.
de Hoop
, “Generalization of the Bremmer coupling series
,” J. Math. Phys.
37
, 3246
–3282
(1996
).75.
C. P. A.
Wapenaar
, “Reciprocity theorems for two-way and one-way wave vectors: A comparison
,” J. Acoust. Soc. Am.
100
, 3508
–3518
(1996
).76.
A. J.
Haines
and M. V.
de Hoop
, “An invariant imbedding analysis of general wave scattering problems
,” J. Math. Phys.
37
, 3854
–3881
(1996
).77.
L.
Fishman
, M. V.
de Hoop
, and M. J. N.
van Stralen
, “Exact constructions of square-root Helmholtz operator symbols: The focusing quadratic profile
,” J. Math. Phys.
41
, 4881
–4938
(2000
).78.
E.
Slob
, K.
Wapenaar
, F.
Broggini
, and R.
Snieder
, “Seismic reflector imaging using internal multiples with Marchenko-type equations
,” Geophysics
79
, S63
–S76
(2014
).79.
K.
Wapenaar
, J.
Fokkema
, M.
Dillen
, and P.
Scherpenhuijsen
, “One-way acoustic reciprocity and its applications in multiple elimination and time-lapse seismics
,” in SEG, Expanded Abstracts
(2000
), pp. 2377
–2380
.80.
L.
Amundsen
, “Elimination of free-surface related multiples without need of the source wavelet
,” Geophysics
66
, 327
–341
(2001
).81.
E.
Holvik
and L.
Amundsen
, “Elimination of the overburden response from multicomponent source and receiver seismic data, with source designature and decomposition into PP-, PS-, SP-, and SS-wave responses
,” Geophysics
70
, S43
–S59
(2005
).82.
K.
Wapenaar
and J.
van der Neut
, “A representation for Green's function retrieval by multidimensional deconvolution
,” J. Acoust. Soc. Am.
128
, EL366
–EL371
(2010
).83.
J.
van der Neut
, J.
Thorbecke
, K.
Mehta
, E.
Slob
, and K.
Wapenaar
, “Controlled-source interferometric redatuming by crosscorrelation and multidimensional deconvolution in elastic media
,” Geophysics
76
, SA63
–SA76
(2011
).84.
M.
Ravasi
, G.
Meles
, A.
Curtis
, Z.
Rawlinson
, and L.
Yikuo
, “Seismic interferometry by multidimensional deconvolution without wavefield separation
,” Geophys. J. Int.
202
, 1
–16
(2015
).85.
B. L. N.
Kennett
and N. J.
Kerry
, “Seismic waves in a stratified half-space
,” Geophys. J. R. Astron. Soc.
57
, 557
–584
(1979
).86.
R. M.
Kiehn
, G. P.
Kiehn
, and J. B.
Roberds
, “Parity and time-reversal symmetry breaking, singular solutions, and Fresnel surfaces
,” Phys. Rev. A
43
, 5665
–5671
(1991
).87.
E.
Slob
and K.
Wapenaar
, “Green's function extraction for interfaces with impedance boundary conditions
,” IEEE Trans. Ant. Prop.
60
, 351
–359
(2012
).88.
B. D. H.
Tellegen
, “The gyrator, a new electric network element
,” Philips Res. Rep.
3
, 81
–101
(1948
), available at http://web.archive.org/web/20140423045739/http://techpreservation.dyndns.org/beitman/abpr/newfiles/The%20Gyrator.pdf.© 2019 Acoustical Society of America.
2019
Acoustical Society of America
You do not currently have access to this content.