Musicians can sometimes achieve better speech recognition in noisy backgrounds than non-musicians, a phenomenon referred to as the “musician advantage effect.” In addition, musicians are known to possess a finer sense of pitch than non-musicians. The present study examined the hypothesis that the latter fact could explain the former. Four experiments measured speech reception threshold for a target voice against speech or non-speech maskers. Although differences in fundamental frequency (ΔF0s) were shown to be beneficial even when presented to opposite ears (experiment 1), the authors' attempt to maximize their use by directing the listener's attention to the target F0 led to unexpected impairments (experiment 2) and the authors' attempt to hinder their use by generating uncertainty about the competing F0s led to practically negligible effects (experiments 3 and 4). The benefits drawn from ΔF0s showed surprisingly little malleability for a cue that can be used in the complete absence of energetic masking. In half of the experiments, musicians obtained better thresholds than non-musicians, particularly in speech-on-speech conditions, but they did not reliably obtain larger ΔF0 benefits. Thus, the data do not support the hypothesis that the musician advantage effect is based on greater ability to exploit ΔF0s.
References
1.
Allen
, K.
, Alais
, D.
, Shinn-Cunningham
, B.
, and Carlile
, S.
(2011
). “Masker location uncertainty reveals evidence for suppression of maskers in two-talker contexts
,” J. Acoust. Soc. Am.
130
, 2043
–2053
.2.
Assmann
, P. F.
(1999
). “Fundamental frequency and the intelligibility of competing voices
,” in Proceedings of the 14th International Congress of Phonetic Sciences
, San Francisco, CA
(August 1–7
), pp. 179
–182
.3.
Assmann
, P. F.
, and Summerfield
, Q.
(1990
). “Modeling the perception of concurrent vowels: Vowels with different fundamental frequencies
,” J. Acoust. Soc. Am.
88
, 680
–697
.4.
Assmann
, P. F.
, and Summerfield
, Q.
(1994
). “The contribution of waveform interactions to the perception of concurrent vowels
,” J. Acoust. Soc. Am.
95
, 471
–484
.5.
Baskent
, D.
, and Gaudrain
, E.
(2016
). “Musician advantage for speech-on-speech perception
,” J. Acoust. Soc. Am.
139
, EL51
–EL56
.6.
Besson
, M.
, Chobert
, J.
, and Marie
, C.
(2011
). “Transfer of training between music and speech: Common processing, attention, and memory
,” Front. Psychol.
2
, 94
.7.
Bialystok
, E.
, and DePape
, A. M.
(2009
). “Musical expertise, bilingualism, and executive functioning
,” J. Exp. Psychol. Hum. Percept. Perform.
35
, 565
–574
.8.
Bidelman
, G. M.
, Krishnan
, A.
, and Gandour
, J. T.
(2011
). “Enhanced brainstem encoding predicts musicians' perceptual advantages with pitch
,” Eur. J. Neurosci.
33
, 530
–538
.9.
Bilsen
, F. A.
(1976
). “Pronounced binaural pitch phenomenon
,” J. Acoust. Soc. Am.
59
, 467
–468
.10.
Binns
, C.
, and Culling
, J. F.
(2007
). “The role of fundamental frequency contours in the perception of speech against interfering speech
,” J. Acoust. Soc. Am.
122
, 1765
–1776
.11.
Bird
, J.
, and Darwin
, C. J.
(1998
). “Effects of a difference in fundamental frequency in separating two sentences
,” in Psychophysical and Physiological Advances in Hearing
, edited by A. R.
Palmer
, A.
Rees
, A. Q.
Summerfield
, and R.
Meddis
(Whurr
, London
), pp. 263
–269
.12.
Boebinger
, D.
, Evans
, S.
, Rosen
, S.
, Lima
, C. F.
, Manly
, T.
, and Scott
, S. K.
(2015
). “Musicians and nonmusicians are equally adept at perceiving masked speech
,” J. Acoust. Soc. Am.
137
, 378
–387
.13.
Boersma
, P.
, and Weenink
, D.
(2013
). Praat: Doing phonetics by computer [computer program]. Version 5.3.85, http://www.praat.org/ (Last viewed September 8, 2014).14.
Brattico
, E.
, Naatanen
, R.
, and Tervaniemi
, M.
(2002
). “Context effects on pitch perception in musicians and nonmusicians: Evidence from event-related-potential recordings
,” Music Percept.
19
, 199
–222
.15.
Brattico
, E.
, Pallesen
, K. J.
, Varyagina
, O.
, Bailey
, C.
, Anourova
, I.
, Jarvenpaa
, M.
, Eerola
, T.
, and Tervaniemi
, M.
(2009
). “Neural discrimination of nonprototypical chords in music experts and laymen: An MEG study
,” J. Cogn. Neurosci.
21
, 2230
–2244
.16.
Brokx
, J.
, and Nooteboom
, S.
(1982
). “Intonation and the perceptual separation of simultaneous voices
,” J. Phonetics
10
, 23
–36
.17.
Carcagno
, S.
, and Plack
, C. J.
(2011
). “Subcortical plasticity following perceptual learning in a pitch discrimination task
,” J. Assoc. Res. Otolaryngol.
12
, 89
–100
.18.
Cherry
, E. C.
(1953
). “Some experiments on the recognition of speech with one and two ears
,” J. Acoust. Soc. Am.
25
, 975
–979 (1953)
.19.
Collin
, B.
, and Lavandier
, M.
(2013
). “Binaural speech intelligibility in rooms with variations in spatial location of sources and modulation depth of noise interferers
,” J. Acoust. Soc. Am.
134
, 1146
–1159
.20.
Corrigall
, K. A.
, Schellenberg
, E. G.
, and Misura
, N. M.
(2013
). “Music training, cognition, and personality
,” Front. Psychol.
4
, 222
.21.
Cramer
, E. M.
, and Huggins
, W. H.
(1958
). “Creation of pitch through binaural interaction
,” J. Acoust. Soc. Am.
30
, 413
–417
.22.
Culling
, J. F.
, and Colburn
, H. S.
(2000
). “Binaural sluggishness in the perception of tone sequences and speech in noise
,” J. Acoust. Soc. Am.
107
, 517
–527
.23.
Culling
, J. F.
, and Darwin
, C. J.
(1993
). “Perceptual separation of simultaneous vowels: Within and across-formant grouping by f0
,” J. Acoust. Soc. Am.
93
, 3454
–3467
.24.
Culling
, J. F.
, and Darwin
, C. J.
(1994
). “Perceptual and computational separation of simultaneous vowels: Cues arising from low frequency beating
,” J. Acoust. Soc. Am.
95
, 1559
–1569
.25.
Darwin
, C. J.
, Brungart
, D. S.
, and Simpson
, B. D.
(2003
). “Effects of fundamental frequency and vocal-tract length changes on attention to one of two simultaneous talkers
,” J. Acoust. Soc. Am.
114
, 2913
–2922
.26.
de Cheveigné
, A.
(1993
). “Separation of concurrent harmonic sounds: Fundamental frequency estimation and a time-domain cancellation model of auditory processing
,” J. Acoust. Soc. Am.
93
, 3271
–3290
.27.
de Cheveigné
, A.
(1999
). “Waveform interactions and the segregation of concurrent vowels
,” J. Acoust. Soc. Am.
106
, 2959
–2972
.28.
de Cheveigné
, A.
, Kawahara
, H.
, Tsuzaki
, M.
, and Aikawa
, K.
(1997a
). “Concurrent vowel segregation. I. Effects of relative amplitude and F0 difference
,” J. Acoust. Soc. Am.
101
, 2839
–2847
.29.
de Cheveigné
, A.
, McAdams
, S.
, Laroche
, J.
, and Rosenberg
, M.
(1995
). “Identification of concurrent harmonic and inharmonic vowels: A test of the theory of harmonic cancellation and enhancement
,” J. Acoust. Soc. Am.
97
, 3736
–3748
.30.
de Cheveigné
, A.
, McAdams
, S.
, and Marin
, C.
(1997b
). “Concurrent vowel segregation. II. Effects of phase, harmonicity and task
,” J. Acoust. Soc. Am.
101
, 2848
–2856
.31.
Deroche
, M. L. D.
, and Culling
, J. F.
(2013
). “Voice segregation by difference in fundamental frequency: Effect of masker type
,” J. Acoust. Soc. Am.
134
, EL465
–EL470
.32.
Deroche
, M. L. D.
, Culling
, J. F.
, Chatterjee
, M.
, and Limb
, C. J.
(2014a
). “Speech recognition against harmonic and inharmonic complexes: Spectral dips and periodicity
,” J. Acoust. Soc. Am.
135
, 2873
–2884
.33.
Deroche
, M. L. D.
, Culling
, J. F.
, Chatterjee
, M.
, and Limb
, C. J.
(2014b
). “Roles of target and masker fundamental frequency in voice segregation
,” J. Acoust. Soc. Am.
136
, 1225
–1236
.34.
Deroche
, M. L. D.
, Culling
, J. F.
, Lavandier
, M.
, and Gracco
, V. L.
(2017
). “Reverberation limits the release from informational masking obtained in the harmonic and binaural domains
,” Attn., Percept., Psychophys.
79
, 363
–379
.35.
Durlach
, N.
, Mason
, C. R.
, Shinn-Cunningham
, B. G.
, Arbogast
, T. L.
, Colburn
, H. S.
, and Kidd
, G.
, Jr. (2003
). “Informational masking: Counteracting the effects of stimulus uncertainty by decreasing target-masker similarity
,” J. Acoust. Soc. Am.
114
, 368
–379
.36.
Ericsson
, K. A.
, Krampe
, R. T.
, and Tesch-Römer
, C.
(1993
). “The role of deliberate practice in the acquisition of expert performance
,” Psychol. Rev.
100
, 363
–406
.37.
Freyman
, R. L.
, Balakrishnan
, U.
, and Helfer
, K. S.
(2004
). “Effect of number of masking talkers and auditory priming on informational masking in speech recognition
,” J. Acoust. Soc. Am.
115
, 2246
–2256
.38.
Johnsrude
, I. S.
, Mackey
, A.
, Hakyemez
, H.
, Alexander
, E.
, Trang
, H. P.
, and Carlyon
, R. P.
(2013
). “Swinging at a cocktail party: Voice familiarity aids speech perception in the presence of a competing voice
,” Psychol. Sci.
24
(10), 1995
–2004
.39.
Kidd
, G.
, Mason
, C. R.
, Deliwala
, P. S.
, Woods
, W. S.
, and Colburn
, H. S.
(1994
). “Reducing informational masking by sound segregation
,” J. Acoust. Soc. Am.
95
, 3475
–3480
.40.
Kidd
, G.
, Jr., Mason
, C. R.
, and Gallun
, F. J.
(2005
). “Combining energetic and informational masking for speech identification
,” J. Acoust. Soc. Am.
118
, 982
–992
.41.
Kishon-Rabin
, L.
, Amir
, O.
, Vexler
, Y.
, and Zaltz
, Y.
(2001
). “Pitch discrimination: Are professional musicians better than non-musicians?
,” J. Basic Clin. Physiol. Pharmacol.
12
, 125
–144
.42.
Koelsch
, S.
, Schroger
, E.
, and Tervaniemi
, M.
(1999
). “Superior pre-attentive auditory processing in musicians
,” Neuroreport
10
, 1309
–1313
.43.
Leclère
, T.
, Lavandier
, M.
, and Deroche
, M. L. D.
(2017
). “The intelligibility of speech in a harmonic masker varying in fundamental frequency contour, broadband temporal envelope, and spatial location
,” Hear. Res.
350
, 1
–10
.44.
Lutfi
, R. A.
, Kistler
, D. J.
, Oh
, E. L.
, Wightman
, F. L.
, and Callahan
, M. R.
(2003
). “One factor underlies individual differences in auditory informational masking within and across age groups
,” Percept. Psychophys.
65
, 396
–406
.45.
Micheyl
, C.
, Delhommeau
, K.
, Perrot
, X.
, and Oxenham
, A. J.
(2006
). “Influence of musical and psychoacoustical training on pitch discrimination
,” Hear. Res.
219
, 36
–47
.46.
Miller
, S. E.
, Schlauch
, R. S.
, and Watson
P. J.
(2010
). “The effects of fundamental frequency contour manipulations on speech intelligibility in background noise
,” J. Acoust. Soc. Am.
128
, 435
–443
.47.
Musacchia
, G.
, Sams
, M.
, Skoe
, E.
, and Kraus
, N.
(2007
). “Musicians have enhanced subcortical auditory and audiovisual processing of speech and music
,” Proc. Natl. Acad. Sci. U.S.A.
104
, 15894
–15898
.48.
Neff
, D. L.
, and Dethlefs
, T. M.
(1995
). “Individual differences in simultaneous masking with random-frequency, multicomponent maskers
,” J. Acoust. Soc. Am.
98
, 125
–134
.49.
Oh
, E. L.
, and Lufti
, R. A.
(1998
). “Nonmonotonicity of informational masking
,” J. Acoust. Soc. Am.
104
, 3489
–3499
.50.
Oxenham
, A. J.
, Fligor
, B. J.
, Mason
, C. R.
, and Kidd
, G.
(2003
). “Informational masking and musical training
,” J. Acoust. Soc. Am.
114
, 1543
–1549
.51.
Pantev
, C.
, Elbert
, T.
, Ross
, B.
, Eulitz
, C.
, and Terhardt
, E.
(1996
). “Binaural fusion and the representation of virtual pitch in the human auditory cortex
,” Hear. Res.
100
, 164
–170
.52.
Parbery-Clark
, A.
, Skoe
, E.
, and Kraus
, N.
(2009a
). “Musical experience limits the degradative effects of background noise on the neural processing of sound
,” J. Neurosci.
29
, 14100
–14107
.53.
Parbery-Clark
, A.
, Skoe
, E.
, Lam
, C.
, and Kraus
, N.
(2009b
). “Musician enhancement for speech-in-noise
,” Ear. Hear.
30
, 653
–661
.54.
Plomp
, R.
, and Mimpen
, A. M.
(1979
). “Improving the reliability of testing the speech-reception threshold for sentences
,” Audiology
18
, 43
–52
.55.
Rothauser
, E. H.
, Chapman
, W. D.
, Guttman
, N.
, Nordby
, K. S.
, Silbiger
, H. R.
, Urbanek
, G. E.
, and Weinstock
, M.
(1969
). “IEEE recommended practice for speech quality measurements
,” IEEE Trans. Audio Electroacoust.
17
, 225
–246
.56.
Ruggles
, D. R.
, Freyman
, R. L.
, and Oxenham
, A. J.
(2014
). “Influence of musical training on understanding voiced and whispered speech in noise
,” PLoS One
9
, e86980
.57.
Shaw
, W. A.
, Newman
, E. B.
, and Hirsh
, I. J.
(1947
). “The difference between monaural and binaural thresholds
,” J. Exp. Psychol.
37
, 229
–242
.58.
Spiegel
, M. F.
, and Watson
, C. S.
(1984
). “Performance on frequency-discrimination tasks by musicians and nonmusicians
,” J. Acoust. Soc. Am.
76
, 1690
–1695
.59.
Strait
, D. L.
, Kraus
, N.
, Parbery-Clark
, A.
, and Ashley
, R.
(2010
). “Musical experience shapes top-down auditory mechanisms: Evidence from masking and auditory attention performance
,” Hear. Res.
261
, 22
–29
.60.
Wightman
, F. L.
, Kistler
, D. J.
, and O'Bryan
, A.
(2010
). “Individual differences and age effects in a dichotic informational masking paradigm
,” J. Acoust. Soc. Am.
128
, 270
–279
.61.
Zendel
, B. R.
, and Alain
, C.
(2012
). “Musicians experience less age-related decline in central auditory processing
,” Psychol. Aging
27
, 410
–417
.62.
Zuk
, J.
, Benjamin
, C.
, Kenyon
, A.
, and Gaab
, N.
(2014
). “Behavioral and neural correlates of executive functioning in musicians and non-musicians
,” PLoS One
9
(6
), e99868
.© 2017 Acoustical Society of America.
2017
Acoustical Society of America
You do not currently have access to this content.