This study investigated whether clear speech reduces the cognitive demands of lexical competition by crossing speaking style with lexical difficulty. Younger and older adults identified more words in clear versus conversational speech and more easy words than hard words. An initial analysis suggested that the effect of lexical difficulty was reduced in clear speech, but more detailed analyses within each age group showed this interaction was significant only for older adults. The results also showed that both groups improved over the course of the task and that clear speech was particularly helpful for individuals with poorer hearing: for younger adults, clear speech eliminated hearing-related differences that affected performance on conversational speech. For older adults, clear speech was generally more helpful to listeners with poorer hearing. These results suggest that clear speech affords perceptual benefits to all listeners and, for older adults, mitigates the cognitive challenge associated with identifying words with many phonological neighbors.
References
1.
Andruski
, J. E.
, Blumstein
, S. E.
, and Burton
, M.
(1994
). “The effect of subphonetic differences on lexical access
,” Cognition
52
(3
), 163
–187
.2.
Banks
, B.
, Gowen
, E.
, Munro
, K. J.
, and Adank
, P.
(2015
). “Cognitive predictors of perceptual adaptation to accented speech
,” J. Acoust. Soc. Am.
137
(4
), 2015
–2024
.3.
Barr
, D. J.
, Levy
, R.
, Scheepers
, C.
, and Tily
, H. J.
(2013
). “Random effects structure for confirmatory hypothesis testing: Keep it maximal
,” J. Mem. Lang.
68
(3
), 255
–278
.4.
Bartón
, K.
(2016
). “Package ‘MuMIn’
” for R 1.15.6. https://cran.r-project.org/web/packages/MuMIn/MuMIn.pdf (Last viewed August 14, 2017).5.
Bates
, D.
, Maechler
, M.
, Bolker
, B.
, and Walker
, S.
(2015
). “Fitting linear mixed-effects models using lme4,”
J. Stat. Softw.
67
(1
), 1
–48
.6.
Bilger
, R. C.
, Nuetzel
, J. M.
, Rabinowitz
, W. M.
, and Rzeczkowski
, C.
(1984
). “Standardization of a Test of Speech Perception in Noise
,” J. Speech Lang. Hear. Res.
27
(1
), 32
–48
.7.
Bradlow
, A. R.
, and Bent
, T.
(2002
). “The clear speech effect for non-native listeners
,” J. Acoust. Soc. Am.
112
(1
), 272
–313
.8.
Bradlow
, A. R.
, Kraus
, N.
, and Hayes
, E.
(2003
). “Speaking clearly for children with learning disabilities,”
J. Speech Lang. Hear. Res.
46
(1
), 80
–97
.9.
Dahan
, D.
, Magnuson
, J. S.
, and Tanenhaus
, M. K.
(2001
). “Time course of frequency effects in spoken-word recognition: Evidence from eye movements
,” Cogn. Psychol.
42
(4
), 317
–367
.10.
Dey
, A.
, and Sommers
, M. S.
(2015
). “Age-related differences in inhibitory control predict audiovisual speech perception
,” Psychol. Aging
30
(3
), 634
–646
.11.
Erb
, J.
, Henry
, M. J.
, Eisner
, F.
, and Obleser
, J.
(2013
). “The brain dynamics of rapid perceptual adaptation to adverse listening conditions
,” J. Neuro.
33
(26
), 10688
–10697
.12.
Ferguson
, S. H.
(2012
). “Talker differences in clear and conversational speech: Vowel intelligibility for older adults with hearing loss
,” J. Speech Lang. Hear. Res.
55
(3
), 779
–790
.13.
Ferguson
, S. H.
, and Kewley-Port
, D.
(2002
). “Vowel intelligibility in clear and conversational speech for normal-hearing and hearing-impaired listeners
,” J. Acoust. Soc. Am.
112
(1
), 259
–271
.14.
Ferguson
, S. H.
, and Kewley-Port
, D.
(2007
). “Talker differences in clear and conversational speech: Acoustic characteristics of vowels
,” J. Speech Lang. Hear. Res.
50
(5
), 1241
–1255
.15.
Gaskell
, M. G.
, and Marslen-Wilson
, W. D.
(2002
). “Representation and competition in the perception of spoken words
,” Cogn. Psychol.
45
(2
), 220
–266
.16.
Gilbert
, R. C.
, Chandrasekaran
, B.
, and Smiljanic
, R.
(2014
). “Recognition memory in noise for speech of varying intelligibility
,” J. Acoust. Soc. Am.
135
(1
), 389
–399
.17.
Halling
, D. C.
, and Humes
, L. E.
(2000
). “Factors affecting the recognition of reverberant speech by elderly listeners
,” J. Speech Lang. Hear. Res.
43
(2
), 414
–431
.18.
Hasher
, L.
, and Zacks
, R. T.
(1988
). “Working memory, comprehension, and aging: A review and a new view
,” Psychol. Learn. Motiv.
22
, 193
–225
.19.
Heinrich
, A.
, Gagne
, J.-P.
, Viljanen
, A.
, Levy
, D.
, Ben-David
, B. M.
, and Schneider
, B. A.
(2016
). “Effective communication as a fundamental aspect of active aging and well-being: Paying attention to the challenges older adults face in noisy environments
,” Soc. Inq. Well-Being
2
(1
), 51
–69
.20.
Heinrich
, A.
, Henshaw
, H.
, and Ferguson
, M. A.
(2015
). “The relationship of speech intelligibility with hearing sensitivity, cognition, and perceived hearing difficulties varies for different speech perception tests
,” Front. Psychol.
6
, 782
.21.
Helfer
, K. S.
(1998
). “Auditory and auditory-visual perception of clear and conversational speech by older adults
,” J. Am. Acad. Aud.
9
, 234
–242
.22.
Helfer
, K. S.
, and Staub
, A.
(2014
). “Competing speech perception in older and younger adults
,” Ear Hear.
35
(2
), 161
–170
.23.
Humes
, L. E.
(2013
). “Understanding the speech-understanding problems of older adults
,” Am. J. Aud.
22
(2
), 303
–305
.24.
Humes
, L. E.
, Watson
, B. U.
, Christensen
, L. A.
, Cokely
, C. G.
, Halling
, D. C.
, and Lee
, L.
(1994
). “Factors associated with individual differences in clinical measures of speech recognition among the elderly
,” J. Speech Lang. Hear. Res.
37
(2
), 465
–474
.25.
Huyck
, J. J.
, and Johnsrude
, I. S.
(2012
). “Rapid perceptual learning of noise-vocoded speech requires attention
,” J. Acoust. Soc. Am.
131
(3
), EL236
–EL242
.26.
Krause
, J. C.
, and Braida
, L. D.
(2002
). “Investigating alternative forms of clear speech: The effects of speaking rate and speaking mode on intelligibility
,” J. Acoust. Soc. Am.
112
(5
), 2165
–2172
.27.
Krause
, J. C.
, and Braida
, L. D.
(2004
). “Acoustic properties of naturally produced clear speech at normal speaking rates
,” J. Acoust. Soc. Am.
115
(1
), 362
–378
.28.
Lash
, A.
, and Wingfield
, A.
(2014
). “A Bruner-Potter effect in audition? Spoken word recognition in adult aging
,” Psychol. Aging
29
(4
), 907
–912
.29.
Levy
, R.
(2014
). “Using R formulae to test for main effects in the presence of higher-order interactions
,” arXiv:stat.ME/1405.2094v1.30.
Luce
, P. A.
, and Pisoni
, D. B.
(1998
). “Recognizing spoken words: The neighborhood activation model
,” Ear Hear.
19
(1
), 1
–36
.31.
Marslen-Wilson
, W.
(1989
). “Access and integration: Projecting sound onto meaning,”
in Lexical Representation and Process
, edited by W.
Marslen-Wilson
(The MIT Press
, Cambridge, MA
), pp. 3
–24
.32.
Marslen-Wilson
, W.
, and Warren
, P.
(1994
). “Levels of perceptual representation and process in lexical access: Words, phonemes, and features
,” Psychol. Rev.
101
(4
), 653
–675
.33.
McClelland
, J. L.
, and Elman
, J. L.
(1986
). “The TRACE model of speech perception
,” Cogn. Psychol.
18
(1
), 1
–86
.34.
McCloy
, D. R.
(2016
). “phonr: Tools for phoneticians and phonologists
,” R package version 1.0-7.35.
McDowd
, J. M.
, and Oseas-kreger
, D. M.
(1991
). “Aging, inhibitory processes, and negative priming,”
J. Gerontol.
46
(6
), 340
–345
.36.
McMurray
, B.
, Tanenhaus
, M. K.
, and Aslin
, R. N.
(2002
). “Gradient effects of within-category phonetic variation on lexical access
,” Cognition
86
, B33
–B42
.37.
Moon
, S. J.
, and Lindblom
, B.
(1994
). “Interaction between duration, context, and speaking style in English stressed vowels
,” J. Acoust. Soc. Am.
96
(1
), 40
–55
.38.
Munson
, B.
, and Solomon
, N. P.
(2004
). “The effect of phonological neighborhood density on vowel articulation
,” J. Speech Lang. Hear. Res.
47
, 1048
–1058
.39.
Nakagawa
, S.
, and Schielzeth
, H.
(2013
). “A general and simple method for obtaining R2 from generalized linear mixed-effects models
,” Methods Ecol. Evol.
4
, 133
–142
.40.
Norris
, D.
(1994
). “Shortlist: A connectionist model of continuous speech recognition
,” Cognition
52
(3
), 189
–234
.41.
Nusbaum
, H. C.
, Pisoni
, D. B.
, and Davis
, C. K.
(1984
). “Sizing up the Hoosier mental lexicon: Measuring the familiarity of 20,000 words
,” Research on Speech Perception Progress Report #10 (Indiana University, Bloomington, IN).42.
Payton
, K. L.
, Uchanski
, R. M.
, and Braida
, L. D.
(1994
). “Intelligibility of conversational and clear speech in noise and reverberation for listeners with normal and impaired hearing
,” J. Acoust. Soc. Am.
95
(3
), 1581
–1592
.43.
Picheny
, M. A.
, Durlach
, N. I.
, and Braida
, L. D.
(1986
). “Speaking clearly for the hard of hearing II: Acoustic characteristics of clear and conversational speech
,” J. Speech Hear. Res.
29
, 434
–446
.44.
Pichora-Fuller
, M. K.
, and Souza
, P. E.
(2003
). “Effects of aging on auditory processing of speech
,” Int. J. Aud.
42
, 11
–16
.45.
R Core Team
(2016
). “R: A language and environment for statistical computing
,” R Foundation for Statistical Computing, Vienna, Austria, https://www.R-project.org/ (Last viewed August 14, 2017).46.
Scarborough
, R.
(2004
). “Coarticulation and the lexicon
,” Ph.D. thesis, University of California
, Los Angeles, CA
.47.
Scarborough
, R.
(2010
). “Lexical and contextual predictability: Confluent effects on the production of vowels
,” in Laboratory Phonology 10
, edited by C.
Fougeron
, B.
Kühnert
, M.
D'Imperio
, and N.
Vallée
(Mouton de Gruyter
, Berlin
), pp. 557
–586
.48.
Scarborough
, R.
, and Zellou
, G.
(2013
). “Clarity in communication: ‘Clear’ speech authenticity and lexical neighborhood density effects in speech production and perception
,” J. Acoust. Soc. Am.
134
(5
), 3793
–3807
.49.
Schneider
, B. A.
, Avivi-Reich
, M.
, and Daneman
, M.
(2015
). “How spoken language comprehension is achieved by older listeners in difficult listening situations
,” Exp. Aging Res.
42
(1
), 31
–49
.50.
Schneider
, B. A.
, Parker
, S.
, and Murphy
, D.
(2011
). “A model of top-down gain control in the auditory system
,” Atten. Percept. Psychophys.
73
(5
), 1562
–1578
.51.
Schneider
, B. A.
, Pichora-Fuller
, K.
, and Daneman
, M.
(2010
). “Effects of senescent changes in audition and cognition on spoken language comprehension,”
in The Aging Auditory System
(Springer
, New York
), Vol. 34, pp. 167
–210
.52.
Schum
, D. J.
(1996
). “Intelligibility of clear and conversational speech of young and elderly talkers
,” J. Am. Acad. Aud.
7
, 212
–218
.53.
Sommers
, M. S.
, and Danielson
, S. M.
(1999
). “Inhibitory processes and spoken word recognition in young and older adults: The interaction of lexical competition and semantic context
,” Psychol. Aging
14
(3
), 458
–472
.54.
Smiljanic
, R.
, and Bradlow
, A. R.
(2005
). “Production and perception of clear speech in Croatian and English
,” J. Acoust. Soc. Am.
118
(3
), 1677
–1688
.55.
Smiljanic
, R.
, and Bradlow
, A. R.
(2009
). “Speaking and hearing clearly: Talker and listener factors in speaking style changes
,” Lang. Linguist. Comp.
3
(1
), 236
–264
.56.
Taler
, V.
, Aaron
, G. P.
, Steinmetz
, L. G.
, and Pisoni
, D. B.
(2010
). “Lexical neighborhood density effects on spoken word recognition and production in healthy aging
,” J. Gerontol. B-Psychol.
65B
(5
), 551
–560
.57.
Van Engen
, K. J.
, Chandrasekaran
, B.
, and Smiljanic
, R.
(2012
). “Effects of speech clarity on recognition memory for spoken sentences
,” PloS One
7
(9
), e43753
.58.
Van Engen
, K. J.
, and Peelle
, J. E.
(2014
). “Listening effort and accented speech
,” Front. Hum. Neurosci.
8
, 577
.59.
Wild
, C. J.
, Yusuf
, A.
, Wilson
, D. E.
, Peelle
, J. E.
, Davis
, M. H.
, and Johnsrude
, I. S.
(2012
). “Effortful listening: The processing of degraded speech depends critically on attention
,” J. Neuro.
32
(40
), 14010
–14021
.60.
Wright
, R.
(2004
). “Factors of lexical competition in vowel articulation,”
in Papers in Laboratory Phonology VI
, edited by J.
Local
, R.
Ogden
, and R.
Temple
(Cambridge University Press
, Cambridge, UK
), pp. 26
–50
.© 2017 Acoustical Society of America.
2017
Acoustical Society of America
You do not currently have access to this content.
