Quantitative measures of acoustic similarity can reveal patterns of shared vocal behavior in social species. Many methods for computing similarity have been developed, but their performance has not been extensively characterized in noisy environments and with vocalizations characterized by complex frequency modulations. This paper describes methods of bioacoustic comparison based on dynamic time warping (DTW) of the fundamental frequency or spectrogram. Fundamental frequency is estimated using a Bayesian particle filter adaptation of harmonic template matching. The methods were tested on field recordings of flight calls from superb starlings, Lamprotornis superbus, for how well they could separate distinct categories of call elements (motifs). The fundamental-frequency-based method performed best, but the spectrogram-based method was less sensitive to noise. Both DTW methods provided better separation of categories than spectrographic cross correlation, likely due to substantial variability in the duration of superb starling flight call motifs.
REFERENCES
1.
Anderson
, S. E.
, Dave
, A. S.
, and Margoliash
, D.
(1996
). “Template-based automatic recognition of birdsong syllables from continuous recordings
,” J. Acoust. Soc. Am.
100
, 1209
–1219
.2.
Auger
, F.
, and Flandrin
, P.
(1995
). “Improving the readability of time-frequency and time-scale representations by the reassignment method
,” IEEE Trans. Signal Process.
43
, 1068
–1089
.3.
Baker
, M. C.
, and Logue
, D. M.
(2003
). “Population differentiation in a complex bird sound: A comparison of three bioacoustical analysis procedures
,” Ethology
109
, 223
–242
.4.
Beecher
, M. D.
, and Burt
, J. M.
(2004
). “The role of social interaction in bird song learning
,” Curr. Dir. Psychol. Sci.
13
, 224
–228
.5.
Beecher
, M. D.
, Stoddard
, P. K.
, Campbell
, E. S.
, and Horning
, C. L.
(1996
). “Repertoire matching between neighbouring song sparrows
,” Anim. Behav.
51
, 917
–923
.6.
Boersma
, P.
(1993
). “Accurate short-term analysis of the fundamental frequency and the harmonics-to-noise ratio of a sampled sound
,” Proc. Inst. Phonetic Sci.
17
, 97
–110
.7.
Boughman
, J. W.
(1997
). “Greater spear-nosed bats give group-distinctive calls
,” Behav. Ecol. Sociobiol.
40
, 61
–70
.8.
Brunton
, D. H.
, and Li
, X.
(2006
). “The song structure and seasonal patterns of vocal behavior of male and female bellbirds (Anthornis melanura)
,” J. Ethol.
24
, 17
–25
.9.
Charif
, R. A.
, Waack
, A. M.
, and Strickman
, L. M.
(2010
). Raven 1.4 User's Manual
(Cornell Lab of Ornithology
, Ithaca, NY
), Chap. 9, pp. 221
–236
.10.
Chen
, Z.
, and Maher
, R. C.
(2006
). “Semi-automatic classification of bird vocalizations using spectral peak tracks
,” J. Acoust. Soc. Am.
120
, 2974
–2984
.11.
Christie
, P. J.
, Mennill
, D. J.
, and Ratcliffe
, L. M.
(2004
). “Pitch shifts and song structure indicate male quality in the dawn chorus of black-capped chickadees
,” Behav. Ecol. Sociobiol.
55
, 341
–348
.12.
Clark
, C. W.
, Marler
, P.
, and Beeman
, K.
(1987
). “Quantitative analysis of animal vocal phonology: An application to swamp sparrow song
,” Ethology
76
, 101
–115
.13.
Curry
, R.
(1937
). “The mechanism of pitch change in the voice
,” J. Physiol.
91
, 254
–258
.14.
Deecke
, V. B.
, Ford
, J. K. B.
, and Spong
, P.
(1999
). “Quantifying complex patterns of bioacoustic variation: Use of a neural network to compare killer whale (Orcinus orca) dialects
,” J. Acoust. Soc. Am.
105
, 2499
–2507
.15.
Farabaugh
, S. M.
, Linzenbold
, A.
, and Dooling
, R. J.
(1994
). “Vocal plasticity in budgerigars (Melopsittacus undulatus): Evidence for social factors in the learning of contact calls
,” J. Comp. Psychol.
108
, 81
–92
.16.
Feare
, C. J.
, and Craig
, A.
(1999
). Starlings and Mynas
(Princeton University Press
, Princeton, NJ
), pp. 218
–219
.17.
Freeberg
, T. M.
, Lucas
, J. R.
, and Clucas
, B.
(2003
). “Variation in chick-a-dee calls of a Carolina chickadee population, Poecile carolinensis: Identity and redundancy within note types
,” J. Acoust. Soc. Am.
113
, 2127
–2136
.18.
Gardner
, T. J.
, and Magnasco
, M. O.
(2006
). “Sparse time-frequency representations
,” Proc. Natl. Acad. Sci. U.S.A.
103
, 6094
–6099
.19.
Godsill
, S.
, Doucet
, A.
, and West
, M.
(2001
). “Maximum a posteriori sequence estimation using Monte Carlo particle filters
,” Ann. Inst. Stat. Math.
53
, 82
–96
.20.
Gold
, B.
, Morgan
, N.
, and Ellis
, D.
(2011
). Speech and Audio Signal Processing: Processing and Perception of Speech and Music
(Wiley and Sons
, New York
), Chap. 31, pp. 455
–472
.21.
Goller
, F.
, and Suthers
, R. A.
(1996
). “Role of syringeal muscles in controlling the phonology of bird song
,” J. Neurophysiol.
76
, 287
–300
.22.
Irwin
, D. E.
, Thimgan
, M. P.
, and Irwin
, J. H.
(2008
). “Call divergence is correlated with geographic and genetic distance in greenish warblers (Phylloscopus trochiloides): A strong role for stochasticity in signal evolution?
” J. Evol. Biol.
21
, 435
–448
.23.
Itakura
, F.
(1975
). “Minimum prediction residual principle applied to speech recognition
,” IEEE Trans. Acoust. Speech
23
, 67
–72
.24.
Janik
, V. M.
, and Slater
, P. J. B.
(1997
). “Vocal learning in mammals
,” Adv. Study Behav.
26
, 59
–99
.25.
Johansson
, A. T.
, and White
, P. R.
(2011
). “An adaptive filter-based method for robust, automatic detection and frequency estimation of whistles
,” J. Acoust. Soc. Am.
130
, 893
–903
.26.
Lachlan
, R. F.
, and Slater
, P. J. B.
(2003
). “Song learning by chaffinches: How accurate, and from where?
” Anim. Behav.
65
, 957
–969
.27.
Liu
, J. S.
, and Chen
, R.
(1998
). “Sequential Monte Carlo methods for dynamic systems
,” J. Am. Stat. Assoc.
93
, 1032
–1044
.28.
Mallawaarachchi
, A.
, Ong
, S. H.
, Chitre
, M.
, and Taylor
, E.
(2008
). “Spectrogram denoising and automated extraction of the fundamental frequency variation of dolphin whistles
,” J. Acoust. Soc. Am.
124
, 1159
–1170
.29.
Mammen
, D. L.
, and Nowicki
, S.
(1981
). “Individual differences and within-flock convergence in chickadee calls
,” Behav. Ecol. Sociobiol.
9
, 179
–186
.30.
McComb
, K.
, Reby
, D.
, Baker
, L.
, Moss
, C.
, and Sayialel
, S.
(2003
). “Long-distance communication of acoustic cues to social identity in African elephants
,” Anim. Behav.
65
, 317
–329
.31.
McCowan
, B.
(1995
). “A new quantitative technique for categorizing whistles using simulated signals and whistles from captive bottlenose dolphins (Delphinidae, Tursiops truncatus)
,” Ethology
100
, 177
–193
.32.
McDonald
, P. G.
, and Wright
, J.
(2011
). “Bell miner provisioning calls are more similar among relatives and are used by helpers at the nest to bias their effort towards kin
,” Proc. R. Soc. B.
278
, 3403
–3411
.33.
Mundinger
, P. C.
(1970
). “Vocal imitation and individual recognition of finch calls
,” Science
168
, 480
–482
.34.
Nelson
, D. A.
, and Marler
, P.
(1989
). “Categorical perception of a natural stimulus continuum: Birdsong
,” Science
244
, 976
–978
.35.
Pilowsky
, J. A.
, and Rubenstein
, D. R.
(2013
). “Social context and the lack of sexual dimorphism in song in an avian cooperative breeder
,” Anim. Behav.
85
, 709
–714
.36.
Ranjard
, L.
, Anderson
, M. G.
, Rayner
, M. J.
, Payne
, R. B.
, McLean
, I.
, Briskie
, J. V.
, Ross
, H. A.
, Brunton
, D. H.
, Woolley
, S. M. N.
, and Hauber
, M. E.
(2010
). “Bioacoustic distances between the begging calls of brood parasites and their host species: A comparison of metrics and techniques
,” Behav. Ecol. Sociobiol.
64
, 1915
–1926
.37.
Rousseeuw
, P. J.
(1987
). “Silhouettes: A graphical aid to the interpretation and validation of cluster analysis
,” J. Comput. Appl. Math.
20
, 53
–65
.38.
Rubenstein
, D. R.
(2007a
). “Female extrapair mate choice in a cooperative breeder: Trading sex for help and increasing offspring heterozygosity
,” Proc. R. Soc. B.
274
, 1895
–1903
.39.
Rubenstein
, D. R.
(2007b
). “Territory quality drives intraspecific patterns of extrapair paternity
,” Behav. Ecol.
18
, 1058
–1064
.40.
Runciman
, D.
, Zann
, R. A.
, and Murray
, N. D.
(2005
). “Geographic and temporal variation of the male zebra finch distance call
,” Ethology
111
, 367
–379
.41.
Schrader
, L.
, and Hammerschmidt
, K.
(1997
). “Computer-aided analysis of acoustic parameters in animal vocalisations: A multi-parametric approach
,” Bioacoustics
7
, 247
–265
.42.
Searcy
, W. A.
, and Yasukawa
, K.
(1996
). “Song and female choice
,” in Ecology and Evolution of Acoustic Communication in Birds
, edited by D.
Kroodsma
and E.
Miller
(Comstock/Cornell
, Ithaca, NY
), pp. 454
–473
.43.
Sewall
, K. B.
(2009
). “Limited adult vocal learning maintains call dialects but permits pair-distinctive calls in red crossbills
,” Anim. Behav.
77
, 1303
–1311
.44.
Shapiro
, A. D.
, and Wang
, C.
(2009
). “A versatile pitch tracking algorithm: From human speech to killer whale vocalizations
,” J. Acoust. Soc. Am.
126
, 451
–459
.45.
Shofner
, W. P.
(2005
). “Comparative aspects of pitch perception
,” in Springer Handbook of Auditory Research. Pitch
, edited by C.
Plack
, R.
Fay
, A.
Oxenham
, and A.
Popper
(Springer
, New York
), Vol. 24
, pp. 56
–98
.46.
Smolker
, R.
, and Pepper
, J.
(1999
). “Whistle convergence among allied male bottlenose dolphins (Delphinidae, Tursiops sp.)
,” Ethology
105
, 595
–617
.47.
Tchernichovski
, O.
, Nottebohm
, F.
, Ho
, C. E.
, Pesaran
, B.
, and Mitra
, P. P.
(2000
). “A procedure for an automated measurement of song similarity
,” Anim. Behav.
59
, 1167
–1176
.48.
Townsend
, S. W.
, Hollén
, L. I.
, and Manser
, M. B.
(2010
). “Meerkat close calls encode group-specific signatures, but receivers fail to discriminate
,” Anim. Behav.
80
, 133
–138
.49.
Vintsyuk
, T. K.
(1971
). “Element-wise recognition of continuous speech composed of words from a specified dictionary
,” Cybernetics
7
, 361
–372
.50.
Wang
, C.
, and Seneff
, S.
(2000
). “Robust pitch tracking for prosodic modeling in telephone speech
,” in Proceedings of the IEEE International Conference on Acoustics, Speech, and Signal Processing
, Vol. 3
, pp. 1343
–1346
.51.
Williams
, H.
(2004
). “Birdsong and singing behavior
,” Ann. N. Y. Acad. Sci.
1016
, 1
–30
.52.
Xiao
, J.
, and Flandrin
, P.
(2007
). “Multitaper time-frequency reassignment for nonstationary spectrum estimation and chirp enhancement
,” IEEE Trans. Signal Process.
55
, 2851
–2860
.© 2013 Acoustical Society of America.
2013
Acoustical Society of America
You do not currently have access to this content.