The classical psychophysical paradigm of narrow-band tone-in-noise (TiN) detection has been under investigation for more than 70 years, yet no conclusive answer has been given as to which auditory stimulus features listeners rely on. Here, individual observer models were fit to a large trial-by-trial behavioral data set using a modern statistical analysis procedure. Relative perceptual weights were estimated for a set of auditory features including sound energy, representations of the spectra as well as summary statistics of both fine structure and envelope. The fitted models captured the behavior of all listeners on a single-trial level. The estimated perceptual weights were stable across signal levels. They suggest that responses of observers depended on stimulus energy, though that cue was not always dominant, as well as on band-pass detectors applied to the fine structure spectrum. A subset of the observers exhibited an additional dependence on sound envelope which was best captured by two envelope descriptors: average slope and extrema count. For some listeners, a concurrent analysis of sequential dependencies showed interactions between the current and several preceding decisions. There was no unique answer regarding the strategy individual listeners employ during TiN detection, and implications thereof are discussed.
REFERENCES
1.
Berg
, B. G.
(2004
). “A temporal model of level-invariant, tone-in-noise detection
,” Psychol. Rev.
111
, 914
–930
.2.
Berg
, B. G.
, Nguyen
, Q. T.
, and Green
, D. M.
(1992
). “Discrimination of narrow-band spectra. I: Spectral weights and pitch cues
,” J. Acoust. Soc. Am.
92
, 1911
–1918
.3.
Busse
, L.
, Ayaz
, A.
, Dhruv
, N. T.
, Katzner
, S.
, Saleem
, A. B.
, Schölvinck
, M. L.
, Zaharia
, A. D.
, and Carandini
, M.
(2011
). “The detection of visual contrast in the behaving mouse
,” J. Neurosci.
31
, 11351
–11361
.4.
Carney
, L. H.
, Heinz
, M.
, Evilsizer
, M. E.
, Gilkey
, R. H.
, and Colburn
, H. S.
(2002
). “Auditory phase opponency: A temporal model for masked detection at low frequencies
,” Acta Acust. Acust.
88
, 334
–347
.5.
Chopin
, A.
, and Mamassian
, P.
(2012
). “Predictive properties of visual adaptation
,” Curr. Biol.
22
, 622
–626
.6.
Collett
, D.
(2002
). Modelling Binary Data
, 2nd ed. (Chapman & Hall/CRC
, Boca Raton, FL
).7.
Dau
, T.
, Püschel
, D.
, and Kohlrausch
, A.
(1996a
). “A quantitative model of the ‘effective’ signal processing in the auditory system. I. Model structure
,” J. Acoust. Soc. Am.
99
, 3615
–3622
.8.
Dau
, T.
, Püschel
, D.
, and Kohlrausch
, A.
(1996b
). “A quantitative model of the ‘effective’ signal processing in the auditory system. II. Simulations and measurements
,” J. Acoust. Soc. Am.
99
, 3623
–3631
.9.
Davidson
, S. A.
, Gilkey
, R. H.
, Colburn
, H. S.
, and Carney
, L. H.
(2009a
). “An evaluation of models for diotic and dichotic detection in reproducible noises
,” J. Acoust. Soc. Am.
126
, 1906
–1925
.10.
Davidson
, S. A.
, Gilkey
, R. H.
, Colburn
, H. S.
, and Carney
, L. H.
(2009b
). “Diotic and dichotic detection with reproducible chimeric stimuli
,” J. Acoust. Soc. Am.
126
, 1889
–1905
.11.
Evilsizer
, M. E.
, Gilkey
, R. H.
, Mason
, C. R.
, Colburn
, H. S.
, and Carney
, L. H.
(2002
). “Binaural detection with narrowband and wideband reproducible noise maskers: I. Results for human
,” J. Acoust. Soc. Am.
111
, 336
–345
.12.
Fan
, R.-E.
, Chang
, K.-W.
, Hsieh
, C.-J.
, Wang
, X.-R.
, and Lin.
, C.-J.
(2008
). “Liblinear: A library for large linear classification
,” J. Mach. Learn. Res.
9
, 1871
–1874
.13.
Felsen
, G.
, and Dan
, Y.
(2005
). “A natural approach to studying vision
,” Nature
8
, 1643
–1646
.14.
Fletcher
, H.
(1938
). “Loudness, masking and their relation to the hearing process and the problem of noise measurement
,” J. Acoust. Soc. Am.
9
, 275
–293
.15.
Fletcher
, H.
(1940
). “Auditory patterns
,” Rev. Mod. Phys.
12
, 47
–65
.16.
Fründ
, I.
, Wichmann
, F. A.
, and Macke
, J. H.
(2012
). “Dealing with sequential dependencies in psychophysical data
,” in Cosyne Abstracts 2013
(Salt Lake City
, UT
), p. 97
.17.
Gilkey
, R. H.
, and Robinson
, D. E.
(1986
). “Models of auditory masking: A molecular psychophysical approach
,” J. Acoust. Soc. Am.
79
, 1499
–1510
.18.
Goris
, R. L. T.
, Wagemans
, J.
, and Wichmann
, F. A.
(2008
). “Modelling contrast discrimination data suggest both the pedestal effect and stochastic resonance to be caused by the same mechanism
,” J. Vision
8
, 17
.1
–21
.19.
Green
, D. M.
(1964
). “Consistency of auditory detection judgments
,” Psychol. Rev.
71
, 392
–407
.20.
Green
, D. M.
, Berg
, B. G.
, Dai
, H.
, Eddins
, D. A.
, Onsan
, Z.
, and Nguyen
, Q.
(1992
). “Spectral shape discrimination of narrow-band sounds
,” J. Acoust. Soc. Am.
92
, 2586
–2597
.21.
Green
, D. M.
, Luce
, R. D.
, and Duncan
, J. E.
(1977
). “Variability and sequential effects in magnitude production and estimation of auditory intensity
,” Percept. Psychophys.
22
, 450
–456
.22.
Green
, D. M.
, and Swets
, J. A.
(1966
). Signal Detection Theory and Psychophysics
(Wiley
, New York
).23.
Hartmann
, W. M.
(1998
). Signals, Sound, and Sensation (Modern Acoustics and Signal Processing)
(Springer Science+Business Media
, New York)
, Chap. 10.24.
Hastie
, T.
, Tibshirani
, R.
, and Friedman
, J.
(2009
). The Elements of Statistical Learning
, 2nd ed. (Springer Science+Business Media
, New York
).25.
Heinz
, M. G.
, Zhang
, X.
, Bruce
, I. C.
, and Carney
, L. H.
(2001
). “Auditory nerve model for predicting performance limits of normal and impaired listeners
,” ARLO
2
, 91
–96
.26.
Howarth
, C. I.
, and Bulmer
, M. G.
(1956
). “Non-random sequences in visual threshold experiments
,” Q. J. Exp. Psychol.
8
, 163
–171
.27.
Kidd
, G.
, Mason
, C. R.
, Brantley
, M. A.
, and Owen
, G. A.
(1989
). “Roving-level tone-in-noise detection
,” J. Acoust. Soc. Am.
86
, 1310
–1317
.28.
Kleiner
, M.
, Brainard
, D.
, and Pelli
, D.
(2007
). “What's new in psychtoolbox-3?
,” in Perception 36 ECVP Abstract Supplement
, p. 14
.29.
Lages
, M.
, and Treisman
, M.
(1998
). “Spatial frequency discrimination: visual long-term memory or criterion setting?
,” Vision Res.
38
, 557
–572
.30.
Li
, Xiangrui
(2008
). “response time box [experimental apparatus],” http://lobes.usc.edu/RTbox, Department of Psychology, University of Southern California (Last viewed 09/12/12).31.
Neri
, P.
, and Levi
, D. M.
(2006
). “Receptive versus perceptive fields from the reverse-correlation viewpoint
,” Vision Res.
46
, 2465
–2474
.32.
Peterson
, W. W.
, and Birdsall
, T. G.
(1953
). “The theory of signal detectability
,” Technical Report No. 13, Electronic Defense Group, Department of Electrical Engineering, University of Michigan, Ann Arbor, MI.33.
Pièron
, H.
(1914
). “Recherches sur les lois de variation des temps de latence sensorielle en fonction des intensités excitatrices” (“Research on the laws of variation in sensory latency as a function of excitatory intensities”)
, Année Psychol.
20
, 17
–96
.34.
Richards
, V. M.
(1992
). “The detectability of a tone added to narrow bands of equal-energy noise
,” J. Acoust. Soc. Am.
91
, 3424
–3435
.35.
Richards
, V. M.
, and Buss
, E.
(1996
). “Frequency correlation functions for the detection of a tone added to modulated noise maskers
,” J. Acoust. Soc. Am.
99
, 1645
–1652
.36.
Richards
, V. M.
, Heller
, L. M.
, and Green
, D. M.
(1991
). “The detection of a tone added to a narrow band of noise: The energy model revisited
,” Q. J. Exp. Psychol. A
43
, 481
–501
.37.
Richards
, V. M.
, and Nekrich
, R. D.
(1993
). “The incorporation of level and level-invariant cues for the detection of a tone added to noise
,” J. Acoust. Soc. Am.
94
, 2560
–2574
.38.
Rosas
, P.
, and Wichmann
, F. A.
(2011
). “Cue Combination: Beyond Optimality
,” in Sensory Cue Integration
, edited by J.
Trommershäuser
, K.
Körding
, and M. S.
Landy
(Oxford University Press
, Oxford
), pp. 144
–152
.39.
Rust
, N. C.
, and Movshon
, J. A.
(2005
). “In praise of artifice
,” Nature Neurosci.
8
, 1647
–1650
.40.
Schönfelder
, V. H.
, and Wichmann
, F. A.
(2012
). “Sparse regularized regression identifies behaviorally relevant stimulus features from psychophysical data
,” J. Acoust. Soc. Am.
131
, 3953
–3969
.41.
Sherwin
, C. W.
, Kodman
, F. J.
, Kovaly
, J. J.
, Prothe
, W. C.
, and Melrose
, J.
(1956
). “Detection of Signals in Noise: A Comparison between the Human Detector and an Electronic Detector
,” J. Acoust. Soc. Am.
28
, 617
–622
.42.
Treisman
, M.
, and Williams
, T. C.
(1984
). “A theory of criterion setting with an application to sequential dependencies
,” Psychol. Rev.
91
, 68
–111
.43.
Wagenmakers
, E.-J.
, Wetzels
, R.
, Borsboom
, D.
, and van der Maas
, H. L. J.
(2011
). “Why psychologists must change the way they analyze their data: The case of psi: Comment on Bem (2011)
.” J. Pers. Soc. Psychol.
100
, 426
–432
.44.
Wichmann
, F. A.
, and Hill
, N. J.
(2001
). “The psychometric function: I. Fitting, sampling, and goodness of fit
,” Percept. Psychophys.
63
, 1293
–1313
.© 2013 Acoustical Society of America.
2013
Acoustical Society of America
You do not currently have access to this content.