This study examined variability of lip movements across repetitions of the same utterance as a function of age in Swedish speakers. The specific purpose was to extend earlier findings by examining variability in both phase and amplitude. Subjects were 50 typically developed native Swedish children and adults (28 females, 22 males, aged 5 to 31 yr). Lip movements were recorded during 15 to 20 repetitions of a short Swedish phrase using three-dimensional articulography. After correction for head movements, the kinematic records were expressed in a maxilla-based coordinate system. Movement onset and offset of the utterance were identified using kinematic landmarks. The Euclidean distance between receivers on the upper and lower lips was calculated and subjected to functional data analysis to assess both phase and amplitude variability. Results show a decrease in both indices as a function of age, with a greater reduction of amplitude variability. There was no difference between males and females for either index. The two indices were moderately correlated with each other, suggesting that they capture different aspects of speech production. Utterance duration also decreased with age, but variability was unrelated to duration. The standard deviation of utterance duration also decreased with age. The present results thus suggest that age related changes in speech motor control continue up until 30 years of age.
REFERENCES
1.
Bernstein
, N.
(1967
). The Co-Ordination and Regulation of Movement
(Pergamon Press
, Oxford
), pp. 1
–196
.2.
Blakemore
, S.
, and Choudbury
, S.
(2006
). “Development of the adolescent brain: Implications for executive function and social cognition
,” J. Child Psychol. Psychiatry
47
, 296
–312
.3.
Byrd
, D.
, Lee
, S.
, and Campos-Astorkiza
, R.
(2008
). “Phrase boundary effects on the temporal kinematics of sequential tongue tip consonants
,” J. Acoust. Soc. Am.
123
, 4456
–4465
.4.
Christou
, E.
, and Tracy
, B.
(2006
). “Aging and variability in motor output
,” in Movement System Variability
, edited by K.
Davids
, S.
Bennett
, and K.
Newell
(Human Kinetics
, Champaign, IL
), pp. 201
–215
.5.
Churchland
, M.
, Afshar
, A.
, and Shenoy
, K.
(2006
). “A central source of movement variability
,” Neuron
52
, 1085
–1096
.6.
Dominici
, N.
, Ivanenko
, Y.
, Cappellini
, G.
, d'Avdella
, A.
, Mondi
, V.
, Cicchese
, M.
, Fabiano
, A.
, Silei
, T.
, Di Paolo
, A.
, Giannini
, C.
, Poppele
, R.
, and Lacquaniti
, F.
(2011
). “Locomotor primitives in newborn babies and their development
,” Science
334
, 997
–999
.7.
Fant
, G.
(1961
). “The acoustics of speech
,” in Proceedings of the 3rd International Congress of Acoustics
, edited by L.
Cremer
(Elsevier, Amsterdam), pp. 188
–201
. [Reprinted in Fant, G. (1983). Speech Sounds and Features (MIT Press, Cambridge, MA), pp. 4–16].8.
Fitch
, T.
, and Giedd
, J.
(1999
). “Morphology and development of the human vocal tract: A study using magnetic resonance imaging
,” J. Acoust. Soc. Am.
106
, 1511
–1522
.9.
Giedd
, J.
, Lalonde
, F.
, Celano
, M.
, White
, S.
, Wallace
, G.
, Lee
, N.
, and Lenroot
, R.
(2009
). “Anatomical brain magnetic resonance imaging of typically developing children and adolescents
,” J. Am. Acad. Child Adolesc. Psychiatry
48
, 465
–470
.10.
Goffman
, L.
, and Smith
, A.
(1999
). “Development and phonetic differentiation of speech movement patterns
,” J. Exp. Psychol. Hum. Percept. Perform.
25
, 649
–660
.11.
Grigos
, M.
(2009
). “Changes in articulator movement variability during phonemic development: A longitudinal study
,” J. Speech Lang. Hear. Res.
52
, 164
–177
.12.
Harris
, C.
, and Wolpert
, D.
(1998
). “Signal-dependent noise determines motor planning
,” Nature
394
, 780
–784
.13.
Howell
, P.
, Anderson
, A.
, Nartrip
, J.
, and Bailey
, E.
(2009
). “Comparison of acoustic and kinematic approaches to measuring utterance level speech variability
,” J. Speech Lang. Hear. Res.
52
, 1088
–1096
.14.
Kent
, R.
(1976
). “Anatomical and neuromuscular maturation of the speech mechanism: Evidence from acoustic studies
,” J. Speech Lang. Hear. Res.
19
, 421
–445
.15.
Kent
, R.
, and Forner
, L.
(1980
). “Speech segment duration in sentence recitation by children and adults
,” J. Phonetics
8
, 157
–168
.16.
Kleinow
, J.
, and Smith
, A.
(2006
). “Potential interactions among linguistic, autonomic, and motor factors in speech
,” Dev. Psychobiol.
48
, 275
–287
.17.
Koenig
, L.
, Lucero
, J.
, and Perlman
, E.
(2008
). “Speech production variability in fricatives of children and adults: Results of functional data analysis
,” J. Acoust. Soc. Am.
124
, 3158
–3170
.18.
Latash
, M.
, and Anson
, J.
(2006
). “Synergies in health and disease: Relations to adaptive changes in motor coordination
,” Phys. Ther.
86
, 1151
–1160
.19.
Latash
, M.
, Scholz
, J.
, and Schöner
, G.
(2007
). “Toward a new theory of motor synergies
,” Motor Control
11
, 276
–308
.20.
Lee
, S.
, Byrd
, D.
, and Krivokapic
, J.
(2006
). “Functional data analysis of prosodic effects on articulatory timing
,” J. Acoust. Soc. Am.
119
, 1666
–1671
.21.
Lee
, S.
, Potamianos
, A.
, and Narayanan
, S.
(1999
). “Acoustics of children's speech: Developmental changes of temporal and spectral parameters
,” J. Acoust. Soc. Am.
105
, 1455
–1468
.22.
Lenroot
, R.
, and Giedd
, J.
(2006
). “Brain development in children and adolescents: Insights from anatomical magnetic resonance imaging
,” Neurosci. Biobehav Rev.
30
, 718
–729
.23.
Lindblom
, B.
, and Sundberg
, J.
(1971
). “Acoustic consequences of lip, tongue, jaw, and larynx movement
,” J. Acoust. Soc. Am.
50
, 1166
–1179
.24.
Löfqvist
, A.
(1990
). “Speech as audible movements
,” in Speech Production and Speech Modeling
, edited by W.
Hardcastle
and A.
Marchal
(Klüwer
, Dordrecht
), pp. 289
–322
.25.
Löfqvist
, A.
(2005
). “Lip kinematics in long and short stop and fricative consonants
,” J. Acoust. Soc. Am.
117
, 858
–878
.26.
Löfqvist
, A.
, and Gracco
, V. L.
(1997
). “Lip and jaw kinematics in bilabial stop consonant production
,” J. Speech Lang. Hear. Res.
40
, 877
–893
.27.
Lucero
, J.
(2005
). “Comparison of measures of variability of speech movement trajectories using synthetic records
,” J. Speech Lang. Hear. Res.
48
, 336
–344
.28.
Lucero
, J.
, and Koenig
, L.
(2000
). “Time normalization of voice signals using functional data analysis
,” J. Acoust. Soc. Am.
108
, 1408
–1420
.29.
Lucero
, J.
, and Löfqvist
, A.
(2005
). “Measures of articulatory variability in VCV sequences
,” ARLO
6
, 80
–84
.30.
Lucero
, J.
, Munhall
, K.
, Gracco
, V.
, and Ramsay
, J.
(1997
). “On the registration of time and the patterning of speech movements
,” J. Speech Lang. Hear. Res.
40
, 1111
–1117
.31.
Maner
, K.
, Smith
, A.
, and Grayson
, L.
(2000
). “Influence of utterance length and complexity on speech motor performance in children and adults
,” J. Speech Lang. Hear. Res.
43
, 560
–573
.32.
Murdoch
, B.
, Cheng
, H.-Y.
, and Goozée
, J.
(2012
). “Developmental changes in the variability of tongue and lip movements during speech from childhood to adulthood: An EMA study
,” Clin. Linguist. Phonetics
26
, 216
–231
.33.
Ostry
, D.
Feltham
, R.
, and Munhall
, K.
(1984
). “Characteristics of speech motor development in children
,” Dev. Psychol.
20
, 859
–871
.34.
Ramsay
, J. O.
, Munhall
, K.
, Gracco
, V.
, and Ostry
D.
(1996
). “Functional data analysis of lip motion
,” J. Acoust. Soc. Am.
99
, 3718
–3727
.35.
Ramsay
, J. O.
, and Silverman
, B. W.
(2005
). Functional Data Analysis
, Vol. 2 (Springer
, New York
), pp. 1
–426
.36.
Riley
, R.
, and Smith
, A.
(2003
). “Speech movements do not scale by orofacial structure size
,” J. Appl. Physiol.
94
, 2119
–2126
.37.
Sadagopan
, N.
, and Smith
, A.
(2008
). “Developmental changes in the effects of utterance length and complexity on speech movement variability
,” J. Speech Lang. Hear. Res.
51
, 1138
–1151
.38.
Sasisekaran
, J.
, Smith
, A.
Sadagopan
, N.
, and Weber-Fox
, C.
(2010
). “Nonword repetition in children and adults: Effects on movement coordination
,” Dev. Sci.
13
, 521
–532
.39.
Scholz
, J.
, and Schöner
, G.
(1999
). “The uncontrolled manifold concept: Identifying control variables for a functional task
,” Exp. Brain Res.
126
, 289
–306
.40.
Sharkey
, S. G.
, and Folkins
, J. W.
(1985
). “Variability in lip and jaw movements in children and adults: Implications for the development of speech motor control
,” J. Speech Lang. Hear. Res.
28
, 8
–15
.41.
Smith
, A.
(2010
). “Development of neural control of orofacial movements for speech
,” in The Handbook of Phonetic Sciences
, 2nd ed., edited by W.
Hardcastle
, J.
Laver
, and F.
Gibbon
(Blackwell
, Oxford
), pp. 251
–296
.42.
Smith
, A.
, and Goffman
, L.
(1998
). “Stability and patterning of speech movement sequences in children and adults
,” J. Speech Lang. Hear. Res.
41
, 18
–30
.43.
Smith
, A.
, Goffman
, L.
, Zelaznik
, H. N.
, Ying
, G.
, and McGillem
, C.
(1995
). “Spatiotemporal stability and patterning of speech movement sequences
,” Exp. Brain Res.
104
, 439
–501
.45.
Smith
, A.
, Johnson
, M.
, McGillem
, C.
, and Goffman
, L.
(2000
). “On the assessment of stability and patterning of speech movements
,” J. Speech Lang. Hear. Res.
43
, 277
–286
.44.
Smith
, A.
, and Zelaznik
, H.
(2004
). “Development of functional synergies for speech motor coordination in childhood and adolescence
,” Dev. Psychobiol.
45
, 22
–33
.46.
Smith
, B.
(1978
). “Temporal aspects of English speech production: A developmental perspective
,” J. Phonetics
6
, 37
–67
.47.
Smith
, B.
(1995
). “Variability of lip and jaw movements in the speech of children and adults
,” Phonetica
52
, 307
–316
.48.
Smith
, B.
, and Gartenberg
, T.
(1984
). “Initial observations concerning developmental characteristics of labiomandibular kinematics
,” J. Acoust. Soc. Am.
75
, 1599
–1605
.49.
Smith
, B.
, and McLean-Muse
, A.
(1986
). “Articulatory movement characteristics of labial consonant productions by children and adults
,” J. Acoust. Soc. Am.
80
, 1321
–1328
.50.
Smith
, L.
, and Thelen
, E.
(2003
). “Development as a dynamical system
,” Trends Cogn. Sci.
7
, 343
–348
.51.
Sowell
, E.
, Peterson
, B.
, Thompson
, P.
, Welcome
, S.
, Henkenius
, A.
, and Toga
, A.
(2003
). “Mapping cortical change across the human life span
,” Nat. Neurosci.
6
, 309
–315
.52.
Stergiou
, B.
, Harbourne
, R.
, and Cavanaugh
, J.
(2006
). “Optimal movement variability: A new theoretical perspective for neurological physical therapy
,” J. Neurol. Phys. Therapy
30
, 120
–129
.53.
van Beers
, R.
, Haggard
, P.
, and Wolpert
, D.
(2004
). “The role of execution noise in movement variability
,” J. Neurophysiol.
91
, 1050
–1083
.54.
Vereijken
, B.
(2010
). “The complexity of childhood development: Variability in perspective
,” Phys. Ther.
90
, 1850
–1859
.55.
Vorperian
, H.
, Kent
, R.
, Lindstrom
, M.
, Kalina
, C.
, Gentry
, L.
, and Yandell
, B.
(2005
). “Development of vocal tract length during early childhood: A magnetic resonance imaging study
,” J. Acoust. Soc. Am.
117
, 338
–350
.56.
Vorperian
, H.
, Wang
, S.
, Chung
, M.
, Schimek
, M.
, Durtschi
, R.
, Kent
, R.
, Ziegert
, A.
, and Gentry
, L.
(2009
). “Anatomic development of the oral and pharyngeal portions of the vocal tract: An imaging study
,” J. Acoust. Soc. Am.
125
, 1666
–1678
.57.
Walsh
, B.
, and Smith
, A.
(2002
). “Articulatory movements in adolescence: Evidence for a protracted development of speech motor control processes
,” J. Speech Lang. Hear. Res.
45
, 1119
–1133
.58.
Walsh
, B.
, Smith
, A.
, and Weber-Fox
, C.
(2006
). “Short-term plasticity in children's speech motor systems
,” Dev. Psychobiol.
48
, 660
–674
.59.
Ward
, D.
, and Arnfield
, S.
(2001
). “Linear and nonlinear analysis of the stability of gestural organization of speech movement sequences
,” J. Speech Lang. Hear. Res.
44
, 108
–117
.60.
Westbury
, J.
, Lindstrom
, M.
, and McClean
, M.
(2002
). “Tongues and lips without jaws: A comparison of methods for decoupling speech movements
,” J. Speech Lang. Hear. Res.
45
, 651
–662
.61.
Wohlert
, A.
, and Smith
, A.
(1998
). “Spatiotemporal stability of lip movements in older adult speakers
,” J. Speech Lang. Hear. Res.
41
, 41
–50
.62.
Wohlert
, A. B.
, and Smith
, A.
(2002
). “Developmental change in variability of lip muscle activity during speech
,” J. Speech Lang. Hear. Res.
45
, 1077
–1087
.63.
Yan
, J.
, Stelmach
, G.
, Thomas
, J.
, and Thomas
, K.
(2000
). “Developmental features of rapid aiming arm movements across the lifespan
,” J. Motor Behav.
32
, 121
–140
.© 2013 Acoustical Society of America.
2013
Acoustical Society of America
You do not currently have access to this content.