A key step toward implementing quantitative ultrasound techniques in a clinical setting is demonstrating that parameters such as the ultrasonic backscatter coefficient (BSC) can be accurately estimated independent of the clinical imaging system used. In previous studies, agreement in BSC estimates for well characterized phantoms was demonstrated across different laboratory systems. The goal of this study was to compare the BSC estimates of a tissue mimicking sample measured using four clinical scanners, each providing RF echo data in the 1-15 MHz frequency range. The sample was previously described and characterized with single-element transducer systems. Using a reference phantom for analysis, excellent quantitative agreement was observed across the four array-based imaging systems for BSC estimates. Additionally, the estimates from data acquired with the clinical systems agreed with theoretical predictions and with estimates from laboratory measurements using single-element transducers.
REFERENCES
1.
T.
Liu
, F. L.
Lizzi
, R. H.
Silverman
, and G. J.
Kutcher
, “Ultrasonic tissue characterization using 2-D spectrum analysis and its application in ocular tumor diagnosis
,” Med. Phys.
31
, 1032
–1039
(2004
).2.
E. J.
Feleppa
, J.
Machi
, T.
Noritomi
, T.
Tateishi
, R.
Oishi
, E.
Yanagihara
, and J.
Jucha
, “Differentiation of metastatic from benign lymph nodes by spectrum analysis invitro
,” Proc.—IEEE Ultrason. Symp.
2
, 1137
–1142
(1997
).3.
J.
Mamou
, A.
Coron
, M.
Hata
, J.
Machi
, E.
Yanagihara
, P.
Laugier
, and E. J.
Feleppa
, “Three-dimensional high-frequency characterization of excised human lymph nodes
,” Proc.—IEEE Ultrason. Symp.
45
–48
(2009
).4.
F. G.
Sommer
, R. A.
Stern
, P. J.
Howes
, and H.
Young
, “Envelope amplitude analysis following narrow-band filtering: a technique for ultrasonic tissue characterization
,” Med. Phys.
14
, 627
–632
(1987
).5.
M. F.
Insana
, T. J.
Hall
, J. G.
Wood
, and Z. Y.
Yan
, “Renal ultrasound using parametric imaging techniques to detect changes in microstructure and function
,” Invest. Radiol.
28
, 720
–725
(1993
).6.
M. L.
Oelze
, W. D.
O’Brien
, Jr., J. P.
Blue
, and J. F.
Zachary
, “Differentiation and characterization of rat mammary fibroadenomas and 4T1 mouse carcinomas using quantitative ultrasound imaging
,” IEEE Trans. Med. Imaging
23
, 764
–771
(2004
).7.
K. A.
Wear
, T. A.
Stiles
, G. R.
Frank
, E. L.
Madsen
, F.
Cheng
, E. J.
Feleppa
, C. S.
Hall
, B. S.
Kim
, P.
Lee
, W. D.
O’Brien
, Jr., M. L.
Oelze
, B. I.
Raju
, K. K.
Shung
, T. A.
Wilson
, and J. R.
Yuan
, “Interlaboratory comparison of ultrasonic backscatter coefficient measurements from 2 to 9 MHz
,” J. Ultrasound Med.
24
, 1235
–1250
(2005
).8.
J. J.
Anderson
, M. T.
Herd
, M. R.
King
, A.
Haak
, Z. T.
Hafez
, J.
Song
, M. L.
Oelze
, E. L.
Madsen
, J. A.
Zagzebski
, W. D.
O’Brien
, Jr., and T. J.
Hall
, “Interlaboratory comparison of backscatter coefficient estimates for tissue-mimicking phantoms
,” Ultrason. Imaging
32
, 48
–64
(2010
).9.
M. R.
King
, J. J.
Anderson
, M. T.
Herd
, D.
Ma
, A.
Haak
, E. L.
Madsen
, J. A.
Zagzebski
, M. L.
Oelze
, T. J.
Hall
, and W. D.
O’Brien
, Jr., “Ultrasonic backscatter coefficients for weakly scattering, agar spheres in agar phantoms
,” J. Acoust. Soc. Am.
128
, 903
–908
(2010
).10.
L. X.
Yao
, J. A.
Zagzebski
, and E. L.
Madsen
, “Backscatter coefficient measurements using a reference phantom to extract depth-dependent instrumentation factors
,” Ultrason. Imaging
12
, 58
–70
(1990
).11.
E. L.
Madsen
, M. F.
Insana
, and J. A.
Zagzebski
, “Method of data reduction for accurate determination of acoustic backscatter coefficients
,” J. Acoust. Soc. Am.
76
, 913
–923
(1984
).12.
J. F.
Chen
, J. A.
Zagzebski
, and E. L.
Madsen
, “Tests of backscatter coefficient measurement using broadband pulses
,” IEEE Trans. Ultrason. Ferroelectr. Freq. Control
40
, 603
–607
(1993
).13.
J. J.
Faran
, “Sound scattering by solid cylinders and spheres
,” J. Acoust. Soc. Am.
23
, 405
–418
(1951
).14.
R.
Hickling
, “Analysis of echoes from a solid elastic sphere in water
,” J. Acoust. Soc. Am.
34
, 1582
–1592
(1962
).15.
E. L.
Madsen
, M. A.
Hobson
, H.
Shi
, T.
Varghese
, and G. R.
Frank
, “Stability of heterogeneous elastography phantoms made from oil dispersions in aqueous gels
,” Ultrasound Med. Biol.
32
, 261
–270
(2006
).16.
M. F.
Insana
, R. F.
Wagner
, D. G.
Brown
, and T. J.
Hall
, “Describing small-scale structure in random media using pulse-echo ultrasound
,” J. Acoust. Soc. Am.
87
, 179
–192
(1990
).17.
A. L.
Gerig
, J. A.
Zagzebski
, and T.
Varghese
, “Statistics of ultrasonic scatterer size estimation with a reference phantom
,” J. Acoust. Soc. Am.
113
, 3430
–3437
(2003
).18.
K.
Nam
, I. M.
Rosado-Mendez
, N. C.
Rupert
, E. L.
Madsen
, J. A.
Zagzebski
, and T. J.
Hall
, “Effects of sound speed mismatch on ultrasound attenuation measurements using reference phantoms.
” Ultrason. Imaging
33
, 251
–263
(2011
).19.
M. F.
Insana
, and T. J.
Hall
, “Parametric ultrasound imaging from backscatter coefficient measurements: image formation and interpretation
,” Ultrason. Imaging
12
, 245
–267
(1990
).© 2012 Acoustical Society of America.
2012
Acoustical Society of America
You do not currently have access to this content.