Dynamic-range compression (DRC) is used in the music industry to maximize loudness. The amount of compression applied to commercial recordings has increased over time due to a motivating perspective that louder music is always preferred. In contrast to this viewpoint, artists and consumers have argued that using large amounts of DRC negatively affects the quality of music. However, little research evidence has supported the claims of either position. The present study investigated how DRC affects the perceived loudness and sound quality of recorded music. Rock and classical music samples were peak-normalized and then processed using different amounts of DRC. Normal-hearing listeners rated the processed and unprocessed samples on overall loudness, dynamic range, pleasantness, and preference, using a scaled paired-comparison procedure in two conditions: un-equalized, in which the loudness of the music samples varied, and loudness-equalized, in which loudness differences were minimized. Results indicated that a small amount of compression was preferred in the un-equalized condition, but the highest levels of compression were generally detrimental to quality, whether loudness was equalized or varied. These findings are contrary to the “louder is better” mentality in the music industry and suggest that more conservative use of DRC may be preferred for commercial music.
REFERENCES
1.
Arehart
, K. H.
, Kates
, J. M.
, and Anderson
, M. C.
(2011
). “Effects of noise, nonlinear processing, and linear filtering on perceived music quality
,” Int. J. Audiol.
50
, 177
–190
.2.
Balfour
, P. B.
, and Hawkins
, D. B.
(1992
). “A comparison of sound quality judgments for monaural and binaural hearing-aid processed stimuli
,” Ear Hear.
13
, 331
–339
.3.
Bhatara
, A.
, Tirovolas
, A. K.
, Duan
, L. M.
, Levy
, B.
, and Levitin
, D. J.
(2011
). “Perception of emotional expression in musical performance
,” J. Exp. Psychol. Hum. Percept. Perform.
37
, 921
–934
.4.
Bregitzer
, L
. (2009
). Secrets of Recording: Professional Tips, Tools & Techniques
(Elsevier
, Amsterdam
), Chap. 7–8, pp. 155
–209
.5.
Dahlquist
, M.
, and Leijon
, A.
(2003
). “Paired-comparison rating of sound quality using MAP parameter estimation for data analysis
,” in First ISCA Tutorial and Research Workshop on Auditory Quality of Systems
, Akademie Mont-Cenis, Germany (April 23–25, 2003), ISCA Archive http://www.isca-speech.org/archive_open/aqs2003 (Last viewed April 6, 2012), pp. 79
–84
.6.
Davies-Venn
, E.
, Souza
, P.
, and Fabry
, D.
(2007
). “Speech and music quality ratings for linear and nonlinear hearing aid circuitry
,” J. Am. Acad. Audiol.
18
, 688
–699
.7.
Dillon
, H.
(1984
). “A procedure for subjective quality rating of hearing aids
,” NAL Report No. 100, Canberra, Australian Government Publishing Service.8.
Gabrielsson
, A.
, and Sjogren
, H.
(1979
). “Perceived sound quality of sound-reproducing systems
,” J. Acoust. Soc. Am.
65
, 1019
–1033
.9.
Geringer
, J. M
. (1995
). “Continuous loudness judgments of dynamics in recorded music excerpts
,” J. Res. Mus. Ed
. 43
, 22
–35
.10.
Glasberg
, B. R.
, and Moore
, B. C. J.
(2002
). “A model of loudness applicable to time-varying sounds
,” J. Audio Eng. Soc.
50
, 331
–342
.11.
Jenstad
, L. M.
, and Souza
, P. E.
(2005
). “Quantifying the effect of compression hearing aid release time on speech acoustics and intelligibility
,” J. Speech Lang. Hear. Res.
48
, 651
–667
.12.
Kates
, J. M.
(2010
). “Understanding compression: Modeling the effects of dynamic-range compression in hearing aids
,” Int. J. Audiol.
49
, 395
–409
.13.
Kates
, J. M.
, and Arehart
, K. H.
(2010
). “The hearing-aid speech quality index (HASQI)
,” J. Audio Eng. Soc.
58
, 363
–381
.14.
Katz
, B
. (2007
). Mastering Audio: The Art and the Science
(Focal Press
, Amsterdam
), pp. 121, 167
–173
.15.
Kefauver
, A. P
. (2001
). The Audio Recording Handbook
(A-R Editions, Inc.
, Middleton
), Chap. 8, pp. 222
–223
.16.
Koelsch
, S.
, Schroger
, E.
, and Tervaniemi
, M.
(1999
). “Superior pre-attentive auditory processing in musicians
,” NeuroReport
10
, 1309
–1313
.17.
Maempel
, H.-J.
, and Gawlik
, F.
(2009
). “The influence of sound processing on listeners’ program choice in radio broadcasting
,” in 126th Convention of the Audio Engineering Society
, Munich, Germany (May 7–9, 2009), Paper #7785.18.
Moore
, B. C. J.
(2012
). “The perception of loudness
,” in An Introduction to the Psychology of Hearing
, 6th ed. (Emerald Group Publishing Limited
, United Kingdon
), pp. 133
–167
.19.
Moore
, B. C. J.
, Fullgrabe
, C.
, and Stone
, M. A.
(2011
). “Determination of preferred parameters for multichannel compression using individually fitted simulated hearing aids and paired comparisons
,” Ear Hear.
32
, 556
–568
.20.
Moore
, B. C. J.
, and Glasberg
, B. R.
(1997
). “A model of loudness perception applied to cochlear hearing loss
,” Aud. Neurosci.
3
, 289
–311
.21.
Moore
, B. C. J.
, Glasberg
, B. R.
, and Stone
, M. A.
(2003
). “Why are commercials so loud? Perception and modeling of the loudness of amplitude-compressed speech
,” J. Audio Eng. Soc.
51
, 1123
–1132
.22.
Muchnik
, C.
, Amir
, N.
, Shabtai
, E.
, and Kaplan-Neeman
, R.
(2012
). “Preferred listening levels of personal listening devices in young teenagers: Self reports and physical measurements
,” Int. J. Audiol.
51
, 287
–293
.23.
Munro
, K. J.
, and Lutman
, M. E.
(2005
). “Sound quality judgments of new hearing instrument users over a 24-week post-fitting period
,” Int. J. Audiol.
44
, 92
–101
.24.
Neuhoff
, J. G.
(2001
). “An adaptive bias in the perception of looming auditory motion
,” Ecol. Psychol.
13
, 87
–110
.25.
Neuman
, A. C.
, Bakke
, M. H.
, Mackersie
, C.
, Hellman
, S.
, and Levitt
, H.
(1998
). “The effect of compression ratio and release time on the categorical rating of sound quality
,” J. Acoust. Soc. Am.
103
, 2273
–2281
.26.
Olive
, S. E
. (2003
). “Differences in performance and preference of trained versus untrained listeners in loudspeaker tests: A case study
,” J. Audio Eng. Soc
. 51
, 806
–825
.27.
Olsen
, K. N.
, Stevens
, C. J.
, and Tardieu
, J.
(2010
). “Loudness change in response to dynamic acoustic intensity
,” J. Exp. Psychol. Hum. Percept. Perform.
36
, 1631
–1644
.28.
Oxenham
, A. J.
, Fligor
, B. J.
, Mason
, C. R.
, and Kidd
, G.
(2003
). “Informational masking and musical training
,” J. Acoust. Soc. Am.
114
, 1543
–1549
.29.
Parbery-Clark
, A.
, Skoe
, E.
, Lam
, C.
, and Kraus
, N.
(2009
). “Musician enhancement for speech-in-noise
,” Ear Hear.
30
, 653
–661
.30.
Parbery-Clark
, A.
, Strait
, D. L.
, Anderson
, S.
, Hittner
, E.
, and Kraus
, N
. (2011
). “Musical experience and the aging auditory system: Implications for cognitive abilities and hearing speech in noise
,” PLoS ONE
6
(1-8
), e18082
.31.
Patterson
, R. D.
, Allerhand
, M. H.
, and Giguère
, C.
(1995
). “Time-domain modeling of peripheral auditory processing: A modular architecture and a software platform
,” J. Acoust. Soc. Am.
98
, 1890
–1894
.32.
Pras
, A.
, Zimmerman
, R.
, Levitin
, D.
, and Guastavino
, C
. (2009
). “Subjective evaluation of mp3 compression for different musical genres
,” in 127th Convention of the Audio Engineering Society
, New York, NY (October 9–12, 2009), Paper #7879.33.
Rammsayer
, T.
, and Altenmuller
, E.
(2006
). “Temporal information processing in musicians and nonmusicians
,” Music Percept.
24
, 37
–47
.34.
Schmidt
, J. C.
, and Rutledge
, J. C.
(1996
). “Multichannel dynamic range compression for music signals
,” in Proceedings of the IEEE International Conference on Acoustics, Speech, and Signal Processing
, Atlanta, GA (May 7–10, 1996), Vol. 2, pp. 1013
–1016
.35.
Smeds
, K.
(2004
). “Is normal or less than normal overall loudness preferred by first-time hearing aids users?
,” Ear Hear.
25
, 159
–172
.36.
Souza
, P. E.
(2002
). “Effects of compression on speech acoustics, intelligibility, and sound quality
,” Trends Amplif.
6
, 131
–165
.37.
Souza
, P. E.
, and Gallun
, F.
(2010
). “Amplification and consonant modulation spectra
,” Ear Hear.
31
, 268
–276
.38.
Souza
, P. E.
, and Turner
, C. W.
(1998
). “Multichannel compression, temporal cues, and audibility
,” J. Speech Lang. Hear. Res.
41
, 315
–326
.39.
Stone
, M. A.
, Moore
, B. C. J.
, Füllgrabe
, C.
, and Hinton
, A. C.
(2009
). “Multichannel fast-acting dynamic range compression hinders performance by young normal-hearing listeners in a two-talker separation task
,” J. Audio Eng. Soc.
57
, 532
–546
.40.
Strait
, D. L.
, and Kraus
, N.
(2011
). “Can you hear me now? Musical training shapes functional brain networks for selective auditory attention and hearing speech in noise
,” Front. Psychol.
2
, 1
–10
.41.
Tervaniemi
, M.
, Just
, V.
, Koelsch
, S.
, Widmann
, A.
, and Schroger
, E.
(2005
). “Pitch discrimination accuracy in musicians vs nonmusicians: an event-related potential and behavioral study
,” Exp. Brain Res.
161
, 1
–10
.42.
van Buuren
, R. A.
, Festen
, J. M.
, and Houtgast
, T.
(1999
). “Compression and expansion of the temporal envelope: Evaluation of speech intelligibility and sound quality
,” J. Acoust. Soc. Am.
105
, 2903
–2913
.43.
Vickers
, E.
(2011
). “The loudness war: Do louder, hypercompressed recordings sell better?
,” J. Audio Eng. Soc.
59
, 346
–351
.© 2012 Acoustical Society of America.
2012
Acoustical Society of America
You do not currently have access to this content.