As a prerequisite to quantitative psychophysical models of sensory processing it is necessary to learn to what extent decisions in behavioral tasks depend on specific stimulus features, the perceptual cues. Based on relative linear combination weights, this study demonstrates how stimulus-response data can be analyzed in this regard relying on an L1-regularized multiple logistic regression, a modern statistical procedure developed in machine learning. This method prevents complex models from over-fitting to noisy data. In addition, it enforces “sparse” solutions, a computational approximation to the postulate that a good model should contain the minimal set of predictors necessary to explain the data. In simulations, behavioral data from a classical auditory tone-in-noise detection task were generated. The proposed method is shown to precisely identify observer cues from a large set of covarying, interdependent stimulus features—a setting where standard correlational and regression methods fail. The proposed method succeeds for a wide range of signal-to-noise ratios and for deterministic as well as probabilistic observers. Furthermore, the detailed decision rules of the simulated observers were reconstructed from the estimated linear model weights allowing predictions of responses on the basis of individual stimuli.
REFERENCES
1.
Ahumada
, A.
(1996
). “Perceptual classification images from Vernier acuity masked by noise
,” Perception
25
.2.
Ahumada
, A.
(2002
). “Classification image weights and internal noise level estimation
,” J. Vision
2
, 121
–131
.3.
Ahumada
, A.
, and Lovell
, J.
(1971
). “Stimulus features in signal detection
,” J. Acoust. Soc. Am.
49
, 1751
–1756
.4.
Ahumada
, A. J.
(1967
). “Detection of tones masked by noise: A comparison of human observers with digital-computer-simulated energy detectors of varying bandwidths
,” doctoral dissertation, Tech. Rep. No. 29, University of California
, Los Angeles, CA.5.
Alexander
, J. M.
, and Lutfi
, R. A.
(2004
). “Informational masking in hearing-impaired and normal-hearing listeners: Sensation level and decision weights
,” J. Acoust. Soc. Am.
116
, 2234
–2247
.6.
Berg
, B. G.
(1989
). “Analysis of weights in multiple observation tasks
,” J. Acoust. Soc. Am.
86
, 1743
–1746
.7.
Bishop
, C. M.
(2006
). Pattern Recognition and Machine Learning
(Springer
, New York)
, 738
pp.8.
Claerbout
, J. F.
, and Muir
, F.
(1973
). “Robust modeling with erratic data
,” Geophysics
38
, 826
–844
.9.
Dau
, T.
, Püschel
, D.
, and Kohlrausch
, A.
(1996
). “A quantitative model of the ‘effective’ signal processing in the auditory system. I. Model structure
,” J. Acoust. Soc. Am.
99
, 3615
–3622
.10.
Davidson
, S. A.
, Gilkey
, R. H.
, Colburn
, H. S.
, and Carney
, L. H.
(2006
). “Binaural detection with narrowband and wideband reproducible noise maskers. III. Monaural and diotic detection and model results
,” J. Acoust. Soc. Am.
119
, 2258
–2275
.11.
Davidson
, S. A.
, Gilkey
, R. H.
, Colburn
, H. S.
, and Carney
, L. H.
(2009a
). “An evaluation of models for diotic and dichotic detection in reproducible noises
,” J. Acoust. Soc. Am.
126
, 1906
–1925
.12.
Davidson
, S. A.
, Gilkey
, R. H.
, Colburn
, H. S.
, and Carney
, L. H.
(2009b
). “Diotic and dichotic detection with reproducible chimeric stimuli
,” J. Acoust. Soc. Am.
126
, 1889
–1905
.13.
Donoho
, D. L.
(2004
). “For most large underdetermined systems of linear equations the minimal l1-norm solution is also the sparsest solution
,” Commun. Pure Appl. Math.
59
, 797
–829
.14.
Donoho
, D. L.
, Elad
, M.
, and Temlyakov
, V.
(2006
). “Stable recovery of sparse overcomplete representations in the presence of noise
,” IEEE Trans. Inf. Theory
52
, 6
–18
.15.
Duda
, R. O.
, Hart
, P. E.
, and Stork
, D. G.
(2001
). Pattern Classification
, 2nd edition (John Wiley
, New York
), Chap. 6.11.16.
Dye
, R. H.
, Stellmack
, M. A.
, and Jurcin
, N. F.
(2005
). “Observer weighting strategies in interaural time-difference discrimination and monaural level discrimination for a multi-tone complex
,” J. Acoust. Soc. Am.
117
, 3079
–3090
.17.
Evilsizer
, M. E.
, Gilkey
, R. H.
, Mason
, C. R.
, Colburn
, H. S.
, and Carney
, L. H.
(2002
). “Binaural detection with narrowband and wideband reproducible noise maskers: I. Results for human
,” J. Acoust. Soc. Am.
111
, 336
–345
.18.
Fan
, R.-E.
, Chang
, K.-W.
, Hsieh
, C.-J.
, Wang
, X.-R.
, and Lin.
, C.-J.
(2008
). “Liblinear: A library for large linear classification
,” J. Mach. Learn. Res.
9
, 1871
–1874
, http://www.csie.ntu.edu.tw/̃cjlin/liblinear (Last viewed August 8, 2011).19.
Fletcher
, H.
(1938
). “Loudness, masking and their relation to the hearing process and the problem of noise measurement
,” J. Acoust. Soc. Am.
9
, 275
–293
.20.
Fletcher
, H.
(1940
). “Auditory patterns
,” Rev. Mod. Phys.
12
, 47
–65
.21.
Forster
, M.
(2000
). “Key concepts in model selection: Performance and generalizability
,” J. Math. Psychol.
44
, 205
–231
.22.
Gilkey
, R. H.
, and Robinson
, D. E.
(1986
). “Models of auditory masking: A molecular psychophysical approach
,” J. Acoust. Soc. Am.
79
, 1499
–1510
.23.
Green
, D. M.
(1964
). “Consistency of auditory detection judgments
,” Psychol. Rev.
71
, 392
–407
.24.
Green
, D. M.
, Berg
, B. G.
, Dai
, H.
, Eddins
, D. A.
, Onsan
, Z.
, and Nguyen
, Q.
(1992
). “Spectral shape discrimination of narrow-band sounds
,” J. Acoust. Soc. Am.
92
, 2586
–2597
.25.
Green
, D. M.
, and Swets
, J. A.
(1966
). Signal Detection Theory and Psychophysics
(John Wiley
, New York
), 455
pp.26.
Hall
, J. W.
, and Grose
, J. H.
(1988
). “Comodulation masking release: Evidence for multiple cues
,” J. Acoust. Soc. Am.
84
, 1669
–1675
.27.
Hartmann
, W. M.
(1998
). Signals, Sound, and Sensation (Modern Acoustics and Signal Processing)
(Springer
, New York
), Chap. 23.28.
Hastie
, T.
, Tibshirani
, R.
, and Friedman
, J.
(2009
). The Elements of Statistical Learning
, 2nd edition (Springer
, New York
), 745
pp.29.
Kidd
, G.
, Mason
, C. R.
, Brantley
, M. A.
, and Owen
, G. A.
(1989
). “Roving-level tone-in-noise detection
,” J. Acoust. Soc. Am.
86
, 1310
–1317
.30.
Kienzle
, W.
, Franz
, M. O.
, Schölkopf
, B.
, and Wichmann
, F. A.
(2009
). “Center-surround patterns emerge as optimal predictors for human saccade targets
,” J. Vision
9
, 7
–1
.31.
Koh
, K.
, Kim
, S.
, and Boyd
, S.
(2007
). “An interior-point method for large-scale l1-regularized logistic regression
,” J. Mach. Learn. Res.
8
, 1519
–1555
.32.
Lutfi
, R. A.
(1995
). “Correlation coefficients and correlation ratios as estimates of observer weights in multiple-observation tasks
,” J. Acoust. Soc. Am.
97
, 1333
–1334
.33.
Macke
, J. H.
, and Wichmann
, F. A.
(2010
). “Estimating predictive stimulus features from psychophysical data: The decision image technique applied to human faces
,” J. Vision
10
, 22
–1
.34.
Matthew
, R.
, Banjevic
, M.
, Chan
, A. S.
, Myers
, L.
, Wolkowicz
, R.
, Haberer
, J.
, and Singer
, J.
(2005
). “Use of the l1-norm for selection of sparse parameter sets that accurately predict drug response phenotype from viral genetic sequences
,” in AMIA Annual Symposium Proceedings
, pp. 505
–509
.35.
Neri
, P.
, and Levi
, D. M.
(2006
). “Receptive versus perceptive fields from the reverse-correlation viewpoint
,” Vision Res.
46
, 2465
–2474
.36.
Noble
, W. S.
(2006
). “What is a support vector machine?
,” Nat. Biotechnol.
24
, 1565
–1567
.37.
Patterson
, R.
, Nimmo-Smith
, I.
, Holdsworth
, J.
, and Rice
, P.
(1988
). “Spiral VOS final report, Part A: The auditory filter bank
,” Report No. 2341, MRC Applied Psychology Unit, University of Cambridge Medical School, Cambridge, UK.38.
Pedersen
, B.
, and Ellermeier
, W.
(2008
). “Temporal weights in the level discrimination of time-varying sounds
,” J. Acoust. Soc. Am.
123
, 963
–972
.39.
Richards
, V. M.
, Heller
, L. M.
, and Green
, D. M.
(1991
). “The detection of a tone added to a narrow band of noise: The energy model revisited
,” Quart. J. Exp. Psychol. A
43
, 481
–501
.40.
Richards
, V. M.
, and Nekrich
, R. D.
(1993
). “The incorporation of level and level-invariant cues for the detection of a tone added to noise
,” J. Acoust. Soc. Am.
94
, 2560
–2574
.41.
Richards
, V. M.
, and Tang
, Z.
(2006
). “Estimates of effective frequency selectivity based on the detection of a tone added to complex maskers
,” J. Acoust. Soc. Am.
119
, 1574
–1584
.42.
Richards
, V. M.
, and Zhu
, S.
(1994
). “Relative estimates of combination weights, decision criteria, and internal noise based on correlation coefficients
,” J. Acoust. Soc. Am.
95
, 423
–434
.43.
Ryali
, S.
, Supekar
, K.
, Abrams
, D. A.
, and Menon
, V.
(2010
). “Sparse logistic regression for whole-brain classification of fMRI data
,” NeuroImage
51
, 752
–764
.44.
Schölkopf
, B.
, and Smola
, A. J.
(2001
). Learning with Kernels: Support Vector Machines, Regularization, Optimization, and Beyond
(MIT Press
, Cambridge, MA
), 626
pp.45.
Tibshirani
, R.
(1996
). “Regression shrinkage and selection via the lasso
,” J. R. Stat. Soc. Ser. B
58
, 267
–288
.46.
Tikhonov
, A. N.
(1963
). “On solving ill-posed problems and the method of regularization
,” Dokl. Akad. Nauk USSR
153
, 501
–504
.47.
Tropp
, J. A.
(2006
). “Just relax: Convex programming methods for identifying sparse signals in noise
,” IEEE Trans. Inf. Theory
52
, 1030
–1051
.48.
Vapnik
, V. N.
(2000
). The Nature of Statistical Learning Theory
, 2nd edition (Springer Verlag
, New York
).49.
Wichmann
, F. A.
, Graf
, A.
, Simoncelli
, E. P.
, and Bülthoff
, H.
(2005
). “Machine learning applied to perception: Decision-images for gender classification
,” Adv. Neural Inf. Process. Syst.
17
, 1489
–1496
.50.
Wichmann
, F. A.
, and Hill
, N. J.
(2001
). “The psychometric function: I. Fitting, sampling, and goodness of fit
,” Percept. Psychophys.
63
, 1293
–1313
.51.
Yovel
, Y.
, Franz
, M. O.
, Stilz
, P.
, and Schnitzler
, H.-U.
(2008
). “Plant classification from bat-like echolocation signals
,” PLoS Comput. Biol.
4
, e1000032
.52.
Yovel
, Y.
, Melcon
, M.
, Franz
, M. O.
, Denzinger
, A.
, and Schnitzler
, H.-U.
(2009
). “The voice of bats: How greater mouse-eared bats recognize individuals based on their echolocation calls
” PLoS Comput. Biol.
5
, e1000400
.© 2012 Acoustical Society of America.
2012
Acoustical Society of America
You do not currently have access to this content.