Breast ultrasound tomography has the potential to improve the cost, safety, and reliability of breast cancer screening and diagnosis over the gold-standard of mammography. Vital to achieving this potential is the development of imaging algorithms to unravel the complex anatomy of the breast and its mechanical properties. The solution most commonly relied upon is time-of-flight tomography, but this exhibits low resolution due to the presence of diffraction effects. Iterative full-wave inversion methods present one solution to achieve higher resolution, but these are slow and are not guaranteed to converge to the correct solution. Presented here is HARBUT, the hybrid algorithm for robust breast ultrasound tomography, which utilizes the complementary strengths of time-of-flight and diffraction tomography resulting in a direct, fast, robust and accurate high resolution method of reconstructing the sound speed through the breast. The algorithm is shown to produce accurate reconstructions with realistic data from a complex three-dimensional simulation, with masses as small as 4 mm being clearly visible.

1.
F.
Kamangar
,
G.
Dores
, and
W.
Anderson
, “
Patterns of cancer incidence, mortality, and prevalence across five continents: defining priorities to reduce cancer disparities in different geographic regions of the world
,”
J. Clin. Oncol.
24
,
2137
(
2006
).
2.
P.
Autier
,
M.
Boniol
,
C.
LaVecchia
,
L.
Vatten
,
A.
Gavin
,
C.
Hery
, and
M.
Heanue
, “
Disparities in breast cancer mortality trends between 30 European countries: retrospective trend analysis of who mortality database
,”
Br. Med. J.
341
,
3620
(
2010
).
3.
M. J.
Silverstein
,
M. D.
Lagios
,
A.
Recht
,
D. C.
Allred
,
S. E.
Harms
,
R.
Holland
,
D. R.
Holmes
,
L. L.
Hughes
,
R. J.
Jackman
,
T. B.
Julian
,
H. M.
Kuerer
,
H. C.
Mabry
,
D. R.
McCready
,
K. M.
Masters
,
D. L.
Page
,
S. H.
Parker
,
H. A.
Pass
,
M.
Pegram
,
E.
Rubin
,
A. T.
Stavros
,
D.
Tripathy
,
F.
Vicini
, and
P. W.
Whitworth
, “
Image-detected breast cancer: State of the art diagnosis and treatment.”
J. Am. Coll. Surg.
201
,
586
597
(
2005
).
4.
T. M.
Kolb
,
J.
Lichy
, and
J. H.
Newhouse
, “
Comparison of the performance of screening mammography, physical examination, and breast US and evaluation of factors that influence them: An analysis of 27,825 patient evaluation
,”
Radiology
225
,
165
175
(
2002
).
5.
P. C.
Stomper
,
D. J.
D’Souza
,
P. A.
Dinitto
, and
M. A.
Arredondo
, “
Analysis of parenchymal density on mammograms in 1353 women 25–79 years old
,”
Am. J. Roentgenol.
167
,
1261
1265
(
1996
).
6.
D.
Saslow
,
C.
Boetes
,
W.
Burke
,
S.
Harms
,
M. O.
Leach
,
C. D.
Lehman
,
E.
Morris
,
E.
Pisano
,
M.
Schnall
,
S.
Sener
,
R. A.
Smith
,
E.
Warner
,
M.
Yaffe
,
K. S.
Andrews
, and
C. A.
Russell
, “
American Cancer Society guidelines for breast screening with MRI as an adjunct to mammography
,”
Ca—Cancer J. Clin.
57
,
75
(
2007
).
7.
M.
Kriege
,
C. T. M.
Brekelmans
,
C.
Boetes
,
P. E.
Besnard
,
H. M.
Zonderland
,
I. M.
Obdeijn
,
R. A.
Manoliu
,
T.
Kok
,
H.
Peterse
,
M. M. A.
Tilanus-Linthorst
,
S. H.
Muller
,
S.
Meijer
,
J. C.
Oosterwijk
,
L. V. A. M.
Beex
,
R. A. E. M.
Tollenaar
,
H. J.
de Koning
,
E. J. T.
Rutgers
, and
J. G. M.
Klijn
, “
Efficacy of MRI and mammography for breast-cancer screening in women with a familial or genetic predisposition
,”
N. Engl. J. Med.
351
,
427
(
2004
).
8.
J. F.
Greenleaf
,
S. A.
Johnson
,
S. L.
Lee
,
G. T.
Herman
, and
E. H.
Wood
, “
Algebraic reconstruction of spatial distributions of acoustic absorption within tissue from their two- dimensional acoustic projections
,”
Int. Symp. Acoust. Hologr. Imag., 5th, Palo Alto, Calif
5
,
591
603
(
1973
).
9.
P.
Carson
,
C.
Meyer
,
A.
Scherzinger
, and
T.
Oughton
, “
Breast imaging in coronal planes with simultaneous pulse echo and transmission ultrasound
,”
Science
214
,
1141
(
1981
).
10.
J.
Schreiman
,
J.
Gisvold
,
J.
Greenleaf
, and
R.
Bahn
, “
Ultrasound transmission computed tomography of the breast
,”
Radiology
150
,
523
(
1984
).
11.
M. P.
Andre
,
H. S.
Janee
,
P.
Martin
,
G. P.
Otto
,
B. A.
Spivey
, and
D. A.
Palmer
, “
Highspeed data acquisition in a diffraction tomography system employing large-scale toroidal arrays
,”
Int. J. Imag. Syst. Tech.
8
,
137
147
(
1997
).
12.
N.
Duric
,
P.
Littrup
,
L.
Poulo
,
A.
Babkin
,
R.
Pevzner
,
E.
Holsapple
,
O.
Rama
, and
C.
Glide
, “
Detection of breast cancer with ultrasound tomography: First results with the computed ultrasound risk evaluation (cure) prototype
,”
Med. Phys.
34
,
773
(
2007
).
13.
H.
Gemmeke
and
N.
Ruiter
, “
3d ultrasound computer tomography for medical imaging
,”
Nucl. Instrum. Methods Phys. Res. A
580
,
1057
1065
(
2007
).
14.
S.
Mensah
and
E.
Franceschini
, “
Near-field ultrasound tomography
,”
J. Acoust. Soc. Am.
121
,
1423
1433
(
2007
).
15.
C.
Hansen
,
N.
Huttebrauker
,
H.
Ermert
,
M.
Hollenhorst
,
L.
Heuser
, and
G.
Schulte-Altedorneburg
, “
Determination of a mean sound velocity in the female breast for artifact reduction in full angle spatial compounding
,”
Proc.-IEEE Ultrason. Symp.
1
,
538
541
(
2009
).
16.
J. F.
Greenleaf
,
S. A.
Johnson
,
W. F.
Samayoa
, and
F. A.
Duck
, “
Algebraic reconstruction of spatial distributions of acoustic velocities in tissue from their time-of-flight profiles
,” in
Acoustical Holography
, edited by
P. S.
Green
(
Plenum
,
New York
,
1975
), Vol.
6
, pp.
71
90
.
17.
J.
Greenleaf
,
S.
Johnson
, and
R.
Bahn
, “
Quantitative cross-sectional imaging of ultrasound parameters
,” in
Ultrasonics Symposium 1977
(
1977
), pp.
989
995
.
18.
H.
Schomberg
, “
An improved approach to reconstructive ultrasound tomography
,”
J. Phys. D
11
,
L181
(
1978
).
19.
M.
Krueger
,
A.
Pesavento
, and
H.
Ermert
, “
A modified time-of-flight tomography concept for ultrasonic breast imaging
,”
Proc.-IEE Ultrason. Symp.
2
,
1381
1385
(
1996
).
20.
Y.
Quan
and
L.
Huang
, “
Sound-speed tomography using first-arrival transmission ultrasound for a ring array
,”
Proc. SPIE
6513
,
651306
(
2007
).
21.
S.
Li
,
M.
Jackowski
,
D.
Dione
,
T.
Varslot
,
L.
Staib
, and
K.
Mueller
, “
Refraction corrected transmission ultrasound computed tomography for application in breast imaging
,”
Med. Phys.
37
,
2233
(
2010
).
22.
A.
Hormati
,
I.
Jovanovic
,
O.
Roy
, and
M.
Vetterli
, “
Robust ultrasound travel-time tomography using the bent ray model
,”
Proc. SPIE
7629
,
76290I
(
2010
).
23.
K.
Tanabe
, “
Projection method for solving a singular system of linear equations and its applications
,”
Num. Math.
17
,
203
214
(
1971
).
24.
A.
Louis
and
F.
Natterer
, “
Mathematical problems of computerized tomography
,”
Proc. IEEE
71
,
379
389
(
1983
).
25.
P.
Williamson
, “
A guide to the limits of resolution imposed by scattering in ray tomography
,”
Geophysics
56
,
202
207
(
1991
).
26.
R.
Snieder
and
A.
Lomax
, “
Wavefield smoothing and the effect of rough velocity perturbations on arrival times and amplitudes
,”
Geophys. J. Int.
125
,
796
812
(
1996
).
27.
G.
Schuster
, “
Resolution limits for crosswell migration and traveltime tomography
,”
Geophys. J. Int.
127
,
427
440
(
1996
).
28.
R.
Pratt
, “
Seismic waveform inversion in the frequency domain. I. Theory and verification in a physical scale model
,”
Geophysics
64
,
888
901
(
1999
).
29.
P.
Thore
and
C.
Juliard
, “
Fresnel zone effect on seismic velocity resolution
,”
Geophysics
64
,
593
603
(
1999
).
30.
S.
Hung
,
F.
Dahlen
, and
G.
Nolet
, “
Wavefront healing: a banana-doughnut perspective
,”
Geophys. J. Int.
146
,
289
312
(
2001
).
31.
J.
Spetzler
,
C.
Sivaji
,
O.
Nishizawa
, and
Y.
Fukushima
, “
A test of ray theory and scattering theory based on a laboratory experiment using ultrasonic waves and numerical simulation by finite-difference method
,”
Geophys. J. Int.
148
,
165
178
(
2002
).
32.
A.
Devaney
, “
A filtered backpropagation algorithm for diffraction tomography
,”
Ultrason. Imag.
4
,
336
350
(
1982
).
33.
M.
Born
and
E.
Wolf
,
Principles of Optics
(
Cambridge University Press
,
Cambridge, UK
,
1999
), pp.
695
703
.
34.
A. C.
Kak
and
M.
Slaney
,
Principles of Computerized Tomographic Reconstruction
(
IEEE Press
,
New York
,
1998
), pp.
203
218
.
35.
F.
Simonetti
,
L.
Huang
,
N.
Duric
, and
P.
Littrup
, “
Diffraction and coherence in breast ultrasound tomography: A study with a toroidal array
,”
Med. Phys.
36
,
2955
(
2009
).
36.
F.
Natterer
and
F.
Wubbeling
,
Mathematical Methods in Image Reconstruction
(
Society for Industrial Mathematics
,
Philadelphia
,
2001
).
37.
A.
Tarantola
,
Inverse Problem Theory and Methods for Model Parameter Estimation
(
Society for Industrial Mathematics
,
Philadelphia
,
2005
).
38.
J.
Wiskin
,
D.
Borup
,
S.
Johnson
,
M.
Berggren
,
T.
Abbott
, and
R.
Hanover
, “
Full-wave, non-linear, inverse scattering
,”
Acoust. Imag.
28
,
183
193
(
2007
).
39.
T. D.
Mast
, “
Aberration correction for time-domain ultrasound diffraction tomography
,”
J. Acoust. Soc. Am.
112
,
55
(
2002
).
40.
P. M.
Morse
and
K. U.
Ingard
,
Theoretical Acoustics
(
McGraw-Hill
,
New York
,
1968
), pp.
227
305
.
41.
S.
Pourjavid
and
O.
Tretiak
, “
Numerical solution of the direct scattering problem through the transformed acoustical wave equation
,”
J. Acoust. Soc. Am.
91
,
639
(
1992
).
42.
W.
Chew
and
Y.
Wang
, “
Reconstruction of two-dimensional permittivity distribution using the distorted born iterative method
,”
IEEE Trans. Med. Imag.
9
,
218
225
(
1990
).
43.
F.
Simonetti
and
L.
Huang
, “
From beamforming to diffraction tomography
,”
J. Appl. Phys.
103
,
103110
(
2008
).
44.
S.
Norton
and
M.
Linzer
, “
Ultrasonic reflectivity imaging in three dimensions: exact inverse scattering solutions for plane, cylindrical, and spherical apertures
,”
IEEE Trans. Biomed. Eng.
28
,
202
(
1981
).
45.
F.
Anderson
and
F.
Morgan
, “
Active imaging analysis via ellipsoidal projections
,”
Acoust. Imag.
21
,
171
182
(
1995
).
46.
J.
Jensen
,
S.
Nikolov
,
K.
Gammelmark
, and
M.
Pedersen
, “
Synthetic aperture ultrasound imaging
,”
Ultrasonics
44
,
e5
e15
(
2006
).
47.
S.
Li
,
K.
Mueller
,
M.
Jackowski
,
D.
Dione
, and
L.
Staib
, “
Fast marching method to correct for refraction in ultrasound computed tomography
,” in
3rd IEEE International Symposium on Biomedical Imaging: Nano to Macro 2006
, pp.
896
899
.
48.
J.
Sethian
, “
A fast marching level set method for monotonically advancing fronts
,”
Proc. Natl. Acad. Sci. U.S.A.
93
,
1591
(
1996
).
49.
W.
Schneider
, “
Integral formulation for migration in two and three dimensions
,”
Geophysics
43
,
49
(
1978
).
50.
M.
Haynes
and
M.
Moghaddam
, “
Large-domain, low-contrast acoustic inverse scattering for ultrasound breast imaging
,”
IEEE Trans. Biomed. Eng.
57
,
2712
2722
(
2010
).
51.
T. D.
Mast
, “
Wideband quantitative ultrasonic imaging by time-domain diffraction tomography
,”
J. Acoust. Soc. Am.
106
,
3061
(
1999
).
52.
C.
Li
,
N.
Duric
,
P.
Littrup
, and
L.
Huang
, “
In vivo breast sound-speed imaging with ultrasound tomography
,”
Ultrasound Med. Biol.
35
,
1615
1628
(
2009
).
53.
S.
Goss
,
R.
Johnston
, and
F.
Dunn
, “
Comprehensive compilation of empirical ultrasonic properties of mammalian tissues
,”
J. Acoust. Soc. Am.
64
,
423
(
1978
).
54.
E.
Franceschini
,
S.
Mensah
,
D.
Amy
, and
J.
Lefebvre
, “
A 2-d anatomic breast ductal computer phantom for ultrasonic imaging
,”
IEEE Trans. Ultrason. Ferroelectr. Freq. Cont.
53
,
1281
(
2006
).
55.
L.
Foldy
, “
The multiple scattering of waves. I. General theory of isotropic scattering by randomly distributed scatterers
,”
Phys. Rev.
67
,
107
119
(
1945
).
56.
M.
Cowan
,
K.
Beaty
,
J.
Page
,
Z.
Liu
, and
P.
Sheng
, “
Group velocity of acoustic waves in strongly scattering media: Dependence on the volume fraction of scatterers
,”
Phys. Rev. E
58
,
6626
6636
(
1998
).
57.
T. D.
Mast
, “
Empirical relationships between acoustic parameters in human soft tissues
,”
Acoust. Res. Lett. Online
1
,
37
(
2000
).
58.
F.
Simonetti
,
L.
Huang
, and
N.
Duric
, “
On the sampling of the far-field operator with a circular ring array
,”
J. Appl. Phys.
101
,
083103
(
2007
).
59.
K.
Yee
, “
Numerical solution of inital boundary value problems involving maxwell’s equations in isotropic media
,”
IEEE Trans. Antennas Propag.
14
,
302
307
(
1966
).
60.
D.
Komatitsch
and
R.
Martin
, “
An unsplit convolutional perfectly matched layer improved at grazing incidence for the seismic wave equation
,”
Geophysics
72
,
155
167
(
2007
).
61.
N.
Wiener
,
Extrapolation, Interpolation, and Smoothing of Stationary Time Series
(
The MIT Press
,
Cambridge, MA
,
1964
), pp.
1
116
.
62.
C.
Li
,
L.
Huang
,
N.
Duric
,
H.
Zhang
, and
C.
Rowe
, “
An improved automatic time-of-flight picker for medical ultrasound tomography
,”
Ultrasonics
49
,
61
72
(
2009
).
63.
A.
Goldstein
and
B.
Madrazo
, “
Slice-thickness artifacts in gray-scale ultrasound
,”
J. Clin. Ultrasound
9
,
365
375
(
1981
).
64.
J. W.
Goodman
,
Introduction to Fourier Optics
(
McGraw-Hill
,
New York
,
1996
), pp.
73
75
.
65.
F.
Simonetti
and
L.
Huang
, “
Synthetic aperture diffraction tomography for three-dimensional imaging,” Proc. R. Soc. London
,
Ser. A
465
,
2877
(
2009
).
66.
R.
Lavarello
and
M.
Oelze
, “
Density imaging using inverse scattering
,”
J. Acoust. Soc. Am.
125
,
793
(
2009
).
67.
F.
Simonetti
,
L.
Huang
, and
N.
Duric
, “
A multiscale approach to diffraction tomography of complex three-dimensional objects
,”
Appl. Phys. Lett.
95
,
061904
(
2009
).
You do not currently have access to this content.