A crucial step in the understanding of vocal behavior of birds is to be able to classify calls in the repertoire into meaningful types. Methods developed to this aim are limited either because of human subjectivity or because of methodological issues. The present study investigated whether a feature generation system could categorize vocalizations of a bird species automatically and effectively. This procedure was applied to vocalizations of African gray parrots, known for their capacity to reproduce almost any sound of their environment. Outcomes of the feature generation approach agreed well with a much more labor-intensive process of a human expert classifying based on spectrographic representation, while clearly out-performing other automated methods. The method brings significant improvements in precision over commonly used bioacoustical analyses. As such, the method enlarges the scope of automated, acoustics-based sound classification.
REFERENCES
1.
Al Aïn
, S.
, Giret
, N.
, Grand
, M.
, Kreutzer
, M.
, and Bovet
, D.
(2009
). “The discrimination of discrete and continuous quantities in African grey parrots (Psittacus erithacus)
,” Anim. Cogn
. 12
, 145
–154
. 2.
Anderson
, S. E.
, Dave
, A. S.
, and Margoliash
, D.
(1996
). “Template-based automatic recognition of birdsong syllables from continuous recordings
,” J. Acoust. Soc. Am
. 100
, 1209
–1219
. 4.
Baker
, M. C.
(2003
). “Local similarity and geographic differences in a contact call of the Galah (Cacatua roseicapilla assimilis) in Western Australia
,” EMU
103
, 233
–237
. 5.
Bloomfield
, L. L.
, Charrier
, I.
, and Sturdy
, C. B.
(2004
). “Note types and coding in parid vocalizations. II: The chick-a-dee call of the mountain chickadee (Poecile gambeli)
,” Can. J. Zool
. 82
, 780
–793
. 51.
Boerma
, P.
, and Weenink
, D.
(1996
). “PRAAT: a system for doing phonetics by computer
,” Glot Int
. 5
, 341
–345
. 6.
Budney
, G. F.
, and Grotke
, R. W.
(1997
). “Techniques for audio recordings vocalizations of tropical birds
,” Ornithol. Monogr
. 48
, 147
–163
. 7.
Charrier
, I.
, Bloomfield
, L. L.
, and Sturdy
, C. B.
(2004
). “Note types and coding in parid vocalizations. I: The chick-a-dee call of the black-capped chickadee (Poecile atricapillus)
,” Can. J. Zool
. 82
, 769
–779
. 8.
Chang-Hsing
, L.
, Chih-Hsun
, C.
, Chin-Chuan
, H.
, and Ren-Zhuang
, H.
(2006
). “Automatic recognition of animal vocalizations using averaged MFCC and linear discriminant analysis
,” Pattern Recogn. Lett
. 27
, 93
–101
. 9.
Clark
, C. W.
, Marler
, P.
, and Beaman
, K.
(1987
). “Quantitative analysis of animal vocal phonology: An application to swamp sparrow song
,” Ethology
76
, 101
–115
. 10.
Clemins
, P. J.
, and Johnson
, M. T.
(2006
). “Generalized perceptual linear prediction features for animal vocalization analysis
,” J. Acoust. Soc. Am
. 120
, 527
–534
. 11.
Clemins
, P. J.
, Johnson
, M. T.
, Leong
, K. M.
, and Savage
, A.
(2005
). “Automatic classification and speaker identification of African elephant (Loxodonta africana) vocalizations
,” J. Acoust. Soc. Am
. 117
, 956
–963
. 12.
Cortopassi
, K. A.
, and Bradbury
, J. W.
(2000
). “The comparison of harmonically rich sounds using spectrographic cross-correlation and principal coordinates analysis
,” Bioacoustics
11
, 89
–127
. 13.
Cruickshank
, A. J.
, Gautier
, J. P.
, and Chappuis
, C.
(1993
). “Vocal mimicry in wild African grey parrots (Psittacus erithacus)
,” Ibis
135
, 293
–299
. 14.
Davis
, S. B.
, and Mermelstein
, P.
(1980
). “Comparison of parametric representations for monosyllabic word recognition in continuously spoken sentences
,” IEEE Trans. Acoust., Speech, Signal Process
. 28
, 357
–366
. 16.
Draganoiu
, T. I.
, Nagle
, L.
, Musseau
, R.
, and Kreutzer
, M.
(2006
). “In a songbird, the black redstart, parents use acoustic cues to discriminate between their different fledglings
,” Anim. Behav
. 71
, 1039
–1046
. 17.
Eronen
, A.
, and Klapuri
, A.
(2000
) “Musical instrument recognition using cepstral coefficients and temporal features
,” in Proceedings of the IEEE International Conference on Acoustics, Speech, and Signal Processing (ICASSP)
, 2
, pp. II753
–II756
. 18.
Farabaugh
, S. M.
, and Dooling
, R. J.
(1996
). “Acoustic communication in parrots: Laboratory and field studies of budgerigars (Melopsittacus undulatus)
,” in Ecology and Evolution of Acoustic Communication in Birds
, edited by D. E.
Kroodsma
and E. H.
Miller
(Cornell University Press
, Ithaca, NY
), pp. 97
–117
. 19.
Farabaugh
, S. M.
, Linzenbold
, A.
, and Dooling
, R. J.
(1994
). “Vocal plasticity in budgerigars (Melopsittacus undulatus): Evidence for social factors in the learning of contact calls
,” J. Comp. Psychol
. 108
, 81
–92
. 20.
Fernández-Juricic
, E.
, Martella
, M. B.
, and Alvarez
, E. V.
(1998
). “Vocalizations of the blue-fronted Amazon (Amazona aestiva) in the Chancaní Reserve
,” Wilson Bull
. 110
, 352
–361
. 21.
Foote
, J. T.
(1997
) “Content-based retrieval of music and audio
,” Proc. SPIE
, 3229
, 138
–147
. 22.
Giret
, N.
, Miklósi
, Á
., Kreutzer
, M.
, and Bovet
, D.
(2009
). “Use of experimenter given cues by African gray parrots (Psittacus erithacus)
,” Anim. Cogn
. 12
, 1
–10
. 23.
Giret
, N.
, Péron
, F.
, Lindová
, J.
, Tichotová
, L.
, Nagle
, L.
, Kreutzer
, M.
, Tymr
, F.
, and Bovet
, D.
(2010
). “Referential learning of French and Czech labels in African grey parrots (Psittacus erithacus): Different methods yield contrasting results
,” Behav. Processes
85
, 90
–98
. 24.
Guyon
, I.
, and Elisseeff
, A.
(2003
). “An introduction to variable and feature selection
,” J. Mach. Learn. Res
. 3
, 1157
–1182
. 52.
Hall
, M. A.
(2000
). “Correlation-based feature selection for discrete and numeric class machine learning
” (Working paper 00/08), (Department of Computer Science, University of Waikato
, Hamilton, New Zealand)
. 25.
Härmä
, A.
(2003
). “Automatic identification of bird species based on sinusoidal modeling of syllables
,” in Proceedings of the IEEE International Conference on Acoustics, Speech, and Signal Processing (ICASSP)
, Hong Kong
, pp. 545
–548
. 26.
Härmä
, A.
, and Somervuo
, P.
(2004
). “Classification of the harmonic structure in bird vocalization
,” in Proceedings of the IEEE International Conference on Acoustics, Speech, and Signal Processing
, Montreal
, Canada
, pp. 701
–704
. 27.
Janik
, V. M.
(1999
). “Pitfalls in the categorization of behavior: A comparison of dolphin whistle classification methods
,” Anim. Behav
. 57
, 133
–143
. 28.
Jones
, A. E.
, Ten Cate
, C.
, and Bijleveld
, C. C. J. H.
(2001
). “The interobserver reliability of scoring sonagrams by eye: A study on methods, illustrated on zebra finch songs
,” Anim. Behav
. 62
, 791
–801
. 29.
Khanna
, H.
, Gaunt
, S. L. L.
, and Mccallum
, D. A.
(1997
). “Digital spectrographic cross-correlation, tests of sensitivity
,” Bioacoustics
7
, 209
–234
. 30.
Kogan
, J. A.
, and Margoliash
, D.
(1998
). “Automated recognition of bird song elements from continuous recordings using dynamic time warping and hidden Markov models: A comparative study
,” J. Acoust. Soc. Am
. 103
, 2185
–2196
. 31.
Koza
, J. R.
(1992
). Genetic Programming: On the Programming of Computers by Means of Natural Selection
(The MIT Press
, Cambridge, MA
), p. 840
. 32.
Marler
, P.
(2004
). “Science and birdsong: The good and old days
,” in Nature’s Music
, edited by P.
Marler
and H.
Slabbekoorn
(Elsevier Academic Press
, San Diego, CA
), pp. 1
–38
. 33.
Mccowan
, B.
(1995
). “A new quantitative technique for categorizing whistles using simulated signals and whistles from captive bottlenose dolphins (Delphinidae, Tursiops truncatus)
,” Ethology
100
, 177
–193
. 34.
Milinski
, M.
(1997
). “How to avoid seven deadly sins in the study of behavior
,” Adv. Study Behav
. 26
, 160
–180
. 35.
Mjolsness
, E.
, and Decoste
, D.
(2001
). “Machine learning for science: State of the art and future prospects
,” Science
293
, 2051
–2055
. 36.
Molnár
, C.
, Kaplan
, F.
, Roy
, P.
, Pachet
, F.
, Pongrácz
, P.
, Dóka
, A.
, and Miklósi
, Á
. (2008
). “Classification of dog barks: A machine learning approach
,” Anim. Cogn
. 11
, 389
–400
. 37.
Nowicki
, S.
, and Nelson
, D. A.
(1990
). “Defining natural categories in acoustic signals: Comparison of three methods applied to “chick-a-dee” call notes
,” Ethology
86
, 89
–101
. 38.
Pachet
, F.
, and Roy
, P.
(2009
). “Analytical features: A knowledge-based approach to audio feature generation
,” EURASIP J. Audio Speech Music Process
, pp. 1
–39
. 39.
Pepperberg
, I. M.
(1999
). The Alex Studies: Cognitive and Communicative Abilities of Grey Parrots
(Harvard University Press
, Cambridge, MA
), p. 448
. 40.
Pepperberg
, I. M.
(2006
). “Cognitive and communicative abilities of grey parrots
,” Appl. Anim. Behav. Sci
. 100
, 77
–86
. 41.
Pepperberg
, I. M.
(2007
). “Grey parrots do not always ‘parrot’: The roles of imitation and phonological awareness in the creation of new labels from existing vocalizations
,” Lang. Sci
. 29
, 1
–13
. 42.
Quinlan
, J. R.
(1993
). C4.5: Programs for Machine Learning
(Morgan Kaufmann Publishers
, San Francisco, CA
), p. 302
. 45.
Schrader
, L.
, and Hammerschmidt
, K.
(1997
) “Computer-aided analysis of acoustic parameters in animal vocalizations: A multi-parametric approach
,” Bioacoustics
7
, 247
–265
. 46.
Stockwell
, D. R. B.
(2006
). “Improving ecological niche models by data mining large environmental datasets for surrogate models
,” Ecol. Modell
. 192
, 188
–196
. 47.
Tchernichovski
, O.
, Nottebohm
, F.
, Ho
, C. E.
, Pesaran
, B.
, and Mitra
, P. P.
(2000
). “A procedure for an automated measurement of song similarity
,” Anim. Behav
. 59
, 1167
–1176
. 48.
Thorpe
, W. H.
(1954
). “The process of song-learning in the chaffinch as studied by means of the sound spectrograph
,” Nature
173
, 465
–469
. 49.
Tyagi
, H.
, Hegde
, R. M.
, Murthy
, H. A.
, and Prabhakar
, A.
(2006
). “Automatic identification of bird calls using spectral ensemble average voice prints
,” in Proceedings of the European Signal Processing Conference
(EUSIPCO
), Italy
, p. 5
. 50.
Vallet
, E.
, and Kreutzer
, M.
(1995
). “Female canaries are sexually responsive to special song phrases
,” Anim. Behav
. 49
, 1603
–1610
. © 2011 Acoustical Society of America.
2011
Acoustical Society of America
You do not currently have access to this content.