In order to examine the role of noise sensitivity in response to environmental noise, this paper presents detailed comparisons of socio-acoustic studies conducted around international airports in Amsterdam, Sydney, and London. Earlier findings that noise sensitivity moderates the effect of noise on annoyance were examined to see if they could be replicated in each of the datasets, independent of the technique of measuring noise sensitivity. The relation between exposure to aircraft noise and noise annoyance was studied separately for groups of individuals with low, medium, and high noise sensitivity, with statistical adjustment for relevant confounders. Results support the previous findings that noise sensitivity is an independent predictor of annoyance and adds to the prediction of noise annoyance afforded by noise exposure level by up to 26% of explained variance. There is no evidence of a moderating effect, whereby the covariation between noise exposure level and annoyance is weak for people who score at the extreme high or low end of the sensitivity scale, and strong for people who score in the middle of the sensitivity scale. Generally, noise sensitivity appears to increase annoyance independently of the level of noise exposure after adjustment for relevant confounders. These findings were consistent across the three datasets.
REFERENCES
1.
R. F. S.
Job
, “Community response to noise: A review of factors influencing the relation between noise exposure and reaction
,” J. Acoust. Soc. Am.
83
, 991
–1001
(1988
).2.
R. F. S.
Job
, “Noise sensitivity as a factor influencing human reactions to noise
,” Noise and Health
3
, 57
–68
(1999
).3.
R.
Guski
, “Personal and social variables as co-determinants of noise-annoyance
,” Noise and Health
3
, 45
–56
(1999
).4.
J. M.
Fields
, “The effect of numbers of noise events on people’s reactions to noise. An analysis of existing survey data
,” J. Acoust. Soc. Am.
75
, 447
–467
(1994
).5.
J. M.
Fields
and J. G.
Walker
, “Comparing the relation between noise level and annoyance in different surveys
,” J. Sound Vib.
81
, 51
–80
(1982
).6.
S. A.
Stansfeld
, M. M.
Haines
, and B.
Brown
, “Noise and health in the urban environment
,” Noise and Health
2
, 43
–82
(2000
).7.
A. C. McKennell, “Aircraft noise annoyance around London (Heathrow) Airport,” Central Office of Information: London, S.S 337 (1963).
8.
S. A.
Stansfeld
, “Noise, noise sensitivity and psychiatric disorder: Epidemiological and psychophysiological studies
,” Psychol. Med. Monogr. Suppl.
22
, 1
–44
(1992
).9.
J. M. Fields, “Effects of personal and situational variables on noise annoyance with special reference to implications for en Route Noise,” Washington DC: Federal Aviation Administration and NASA Report No: FAA-AEE-92-03 (1992).
10.
E.
Ohrstrom
, “Effects of low levels of road traffic noise during the night: A laboratory study on number of events, maximum noise levels, and noise sensitivity
,” J. Sound Vib.
179
, 603
–615
(1995
).11.
M. E.
Nivison
and I. M.
Endresen
, “An analysis of relations among environmentalnoise, annoyance and sensitivity to noise, and the consequences for health and sleep
,” J. Behav. Med.
16
, 257
–276
(1993
).12.
J.
di Nisi
, A.
Muzet
, J.
Ehrhart
, and J. P.
Libert
, “Comparison of cardiovascular responses to noise during waking and sleeping in humans
,” Sleep
13
, 108
–120
(1990
).13.
S. A.
Stansfeld
, C. R.
Clark
, and L. M.
Jenkins
, “Sensitivity to noise a community sample: I. Measurement of psychiatric disorder and personality
,” Psychol. Med.
15
, 243
–254
(1985
).14.
S. A.
Stansfeld
, C. R.
Clark
, G.
Turpin
, L. M.
Jenkins
, and A.
Tarnopolsky
, “Sensitivity to noise in a community sample. II. Measurement of psychophysiological indices
,” Psychol. Med.
15
, 255
–263
(1985
).15.
S. A.
Stansfeld
, D.
Sharp
, J.
Gallacher
, and W.
Babisch
, “Road traffic noise, noise sensitivity and psychological disorder
,” Psychol. Med.
23
, 977
–985
(1993
).16.
S. A.
Stansfeld
, J.
Gallacher
, W.
Babisch
, and M.
Shipley
, “Road traffic noise and psychiatric disorder: Prospective findings from the Caerphilly Study
,” Br. Med. J.
313
, 266
–267
(1996
).17.
A.
Smith
and S. A.
Stansfeld
, “Aircraft noise exposure, noise sensitivity and everyday errors
,” Environ. Behav.
18
, 214
–226
(1986
).18.
J.
Gallacher
and W.
Babisch
, “Road traffic noise, noise sensitivity, and psychological disorder
,” Psychol. Med.
23
, 977
–985
(1993
).19.
P.
Bathia
, I. S.
Muhar
, K. K
Mahajan
, and K.
Chawia
, “Noise sensitivity as related to anxiety, intelligence and introversion–extraversion
,” J. Pers. Clin. Stud.
12
, 55
–60
(1996
).20.
E.
Ohrstrom
, M.
Bjorkman
, and R.
Rylander
, “Effects of noise during sleep with reference to noise sensitivity and habituation
,” Environ. Int.
16
, 477
–482
(1990
).21.
K. S.
Ann
, “Effects of aircraft noise and noise sensitivity on the physical and mental well-being of older adults
,” Health Sci. Nursing.
47
(3
), 991
-B
(1986
).22.
E. P. Sarafino, Health Psychology, Biopsychosocial Interactions, 2nd ed. (Wiley, New York, 1994).
23.
R. F. S.
Job
, J.
Hatfield
, P.
Peploe
, N. L.
Carter
, R.
Taylor
, and S.
Morrell
, “General scales of community reaction to noise (dissatisfaction and perceived affectedness) are more reliable than scales of annoyance
,” J. Acoust. Soc. Am.
110
, 939
–946
(2001
).24.
J.
Hatfield
, R. F. S.
Job
, P.
Peploe
, N. L.
Carter
, R.
Taylor
, and S.
Morrell
, “The influence of psychological factors on the physiological and health effects of noise
,” Noise and Health
10
, 1
–14
(2001
).25.
K.
Zimmer
and W.
Ellermeier
, “Psychometric properties of four measures of noise sensitivity: A comparison
,” J Environ. Psychol.
19
, 295
(1999
).26.
G.
Belojevic
, E.
Öhrström
, and R.
Rylander
, “Effects of noise on mental performance with regard to subjective noise sensitivity
,” Int. Arch. Occup. Environ. Health
64
, 293
–301
(1992
).27.
G.
Belojevic
, B.
Jakovljevic
, and O.
Oleksic
, “Subjective reactions to traffic noise with regard to some personality traits
,” Environ. Int.
23
, 221
–226
(1997
).28.
B.
Ekehammar
and S.
Dornic
, “Weinstein’s noise-sensitivity scale: Reliability and construct validity
,” Percept. Mot. Skills
70
, 129
–130
(1990
).29.
N.
Moreira
and M.
Bryan
, “Noise annoyance susceptibility
,” J. Sound Vib.
21
, 449
–462
(1972
).30.
S. M.
Taylor
, “A path model of aircraft noise annoyance
,” J. Sound Vib.
96
, 243
–260
(1984
).31.
N. D.
Weinstein
, “Individual differences in reactions to noise: A longitudinal study in a college dormitory
,” J. Appl. Psychol.
63
, 458
–566
(1978
).32.
N. D.
Weinstein
, “Individual differences in critical tendencies and noise annoyance
,” J. Sound Vib.
68
, 241
–248
(1980
).33.
J. M.
Fields
, “The effect of numbers of noise events on people’s reactions to noise: An analysis of existing survey data
,” J. Acoust. Soc. Am.
75
, 447
–467
(1984
).34.
R. B.
Bullen
, A. J.
Hede
, and R. F. S.
Job
, “Community reaction to noise from an artillery range
,” Noise Control Eng.
37
, 115
–128
(1991
).35.
C. Levy-Leboyer and G. Moser, “Individual differences in noise annoyance: Four explanations,” in Environmental Annoyance Characterisation, Measurement and Control, edited by H.S. Koelega (Elsevier, Woudschoten, 1989).
36.
C. M. B. Anderson, “The measurement of attitude to noise and noises,” Acoustic report Ac. 52, National Physical Laboratory, Teddington (1971).
37.
F. J.
Langdon
, “Noise nuisance caused by road traffic in residential areas
,” J. Sound Vib.
111
, 243
–263
(1976
).38.
An intervening variable can be described (see Ref. 3) as a feature/attribute of a person that depends on the stimulus and also influences the response to this stimulus. In such a model each step adds to the prediction.
39.
An effect modifier is a feature/attribute of a person that changes the effect of a stimulus (e.g., noise) on the response (e.g., annoyance). The relation between noise and reaction is only valid for some values of noise sensitivity, but not for others.
40.
H. M. E.
Miedema
and H.
Vos
, “Noise sensitivity and reactions to noise and other environmental conditions
,” J. Acoust. Soc. Am.
113
, 1492
–1504
(2003
).41.
J.
Hatfield
, R. F. S.
Job
, A. J.
Hede
, P.
Peploe
, N. L.
Carter
, R.
Taylor
, and S.
Morrell
, “The role of learned helplessness in human response to noise
,” Int. J. Behav. Med.
9
, 341
–359
(2002
).42.
E. A. M.
Franssen
, C. M. A. G.
van Wiechen
, N. J. D.
Nagelkerke
, and E.
Lebret
, “Aircraft noise around a large international airport and its impact on general health and medication use
,” Occup. Environ. Med.
61
, 405
–413
(2004
).43.
M. M.
Haines
, S. A.
Stansfeld
, R. F. S.
Job
, B.
Berglund
, and J.
Head
, “Chronic aircraft noise exposure, stress responses, mental health, and cognitive performance in school children
,” Psychol. Med.
31
, 265
–277
(2001
).44.
A. J.
Hede
and R. B.
Bullen
, “Human perception and reaction to noise
,” Architect. Sci. Rev.
3
, 58
–64
(1981
).45.
R. B.
Bullen
, A. J.
Hede
, and E.
Kyriacos
, “Reaction to aircraft noise in residential areas around Australian airports
,” J. Sound Vib.
108
, 199
–225
(1986
).46.
A. L.
Brown
, “Traffic noise annoyance along urban roadways: report on a survey in Brisbane, Sydney and Melbourne,” Australian Road Research, Internal Report
AIR 206-06 1978
.47.
G. J.
Raw
and I. D.
Griffith
, “Individual differences in response to road traffic noise
,” J. Sound Vib.
121
, 463
–471
(1988
).
This content is only available via PDF.
© 2004 Acoustical Society of America.
2004
Acoustical Society of America
You do not currently have access to this content.