Using recent developments in music theory, which are generalizations of the well-known properties of the familiar 12-tone, equal-tempered musical scale, an approach is described for constructing equal-tempered musical scales (with “diatonic” scales and the associated chord structure) based on good-fitting intervals and a generalization of the modulation properties of the circle of fifths. An analysis of the usual 12-tone equal-tempered system is provided as a vehicle to introduce the mathematical details of these recent music-theoretic developments and to articulate the approach for constructing musical scales. The formalism is extended to describe equal-tempered musical scales with nonoctave closure. Application of the formalism to a system with closure at an octave plus a perfect fifth generates the Bohlen–Pierce scale originally developed for harmonic properties similar to traditional chords but without the perceptual biases of these familiar chords. Subsequently, the formalism is applied to the group-theory-based 20-fold microtonal system of Balzano. It is shown that with an appropriate choice of nonoctave closure (6:1 in this case), determined by the formalism combined with continued fraction analysis, that this group-theoretic-generated system may be interpreted in terms of the frequency ratios 21:56:88:126. Although contrary to the spirit of the group-theoretic approach to generating scales, this analysis may be applicable for discovering the ratio basis of unusual tunings common in non-Western music.

1.
J. M.
Barbour
, “
The Persistence of Pythagorean Tuning Systems
,”
Scr. Math.
1
,
286
(
1933
).
2.
J. M.
Barbour
, “
Musical Logarithms
,”
Scr. Math.
3
,
21
(
1940
).
3.
H. Helmholtz, in On Sensation of Tone (Dover, New York, 1954), Chaps. I and XVI (originally published in 1885).
4.
“Modulation,” in The New Harvard Dictionary of Music, edited by D. M. Randell (Belknap, Cambridge, MA, 1986), p. 503.
5.
“Temperaments,” in The New Harvard Dictionary of Music (Ref. 4), p. 837.
6.
R. J.
Krantz
and
J.
Douthett
, “
A Measurement of the Reasonableness of Equal-Tempered Musical Scale
,”
J. Acoust. Soc. Am.
95
,
3642
3650
(
1994
).
7.
D. E.
Hall
, “
The Objective Measure of Goodness-of-Fit for Tunings and Temperaments
,”
J. Music Theory
17
,
274
(
1973
).
8.
D. E.
Hall
, “
Quantitative Evaluation of Musical Scale Tunings
,”
Am. J. Phys.
42
(
7
),
543
(
1974
).
9.
D. E.
Hall
, “
Acoustical Numerology and Lucky Temperaments
,”
Am. J. Phys.
56
(
4
),
329
(
1988
).
10.
D. E.
Hall
, “
A Systematic Evaluation of Equal Temperaments Through N=612,
Interface (USA)
14
,
61
73
(
1985
).
11.
G. C.
Hartmann
, “
A Numerical Exercise in Musical Scales
,”
Am. J. Phys.
55
(
3
),
223
(
1987
).
12.
J. Mandelbaum, “Multiple Division of the Octave and Tonal Resources of 19-Tone Temperament,” Ph.D. dissertation (Indiana University, Bloomington, IN, 1961).
13.
W. Stoney, “Theoretical Possibilities for Equally Tempered Musical Systems,” in The Computer and Music, edited by H. B. Lincoln (Cornell University Press, Ithaca, NY, 1970), pp. 163–171.
14.
D.
De Klerk
, “
Equal Temperament
,”
Acta Musicol.
51
,
140
(
1979
).
15.
M.
Yunik
and
G.
Swift
, “
Tempered Music Scales for Sound Synthesis
,”
Comput. Music J.
4
(
4
),
60
(
1980
).
16.
D. Clampitt, “Pair-Wise, Well-Formed Scales: Structured and Transformational Properties,” Ph.D. dissertation (SUNY at Buffalo, Buffalo, NY, April 1997).
17.
J.
Clough
and
J.
Douthett
, “
Maximally Even Sets
,”
J. Music Theory
35
,
93
173
(
1991
).
18.
In July of 1993 Clough (SUNY at Buffalo) assembled a group—known as the “SUNY Buffalo Working Group”—of music theorists, music psychologists, and mathematicians to investigate and expand on the ideas put forth by Richard Cohn (University of Chicago) on late 19th century voice leading. The term P-cycles was introduced by Cohn and was among the topics explored at the meeting. This group met again in July of 1997 to explore a related topic, neo-Riemannian Transformations. For more information on the above, including a bibliography of related topics, see the special topics edition of the Journal of Music Theory 42(2) (1998).
19.
J. Yasser, The Theory of Evolving Tonality (American Library of Musicology, New York, 1932).
20.
J.
Chalmers
, “
Cycle Scales
,”
Xenharmonikon
4
,
69
78
(
1975
).
21.
J.
Chalmers
, “
Polychordal Matrices and MOS Scales
,”
Xenharmonikon
7–8
,
156
167
(
1979
).
22.
J. Chalmers, “Construction and Harmonization of Microtonal Scales in Non-Twelve-Tone Equal Temperaments,” Proceedings of the 8th International Computer Music Conference, Venice, Italy, pp. 534–555, 1982 (unpublished).
23.
E. Wilson, Private communication to J. Douthett (1996).
24.
C.
Gamer
, “
Some Combinatorial Resources of Equal-Tempered Systems
,”
J. Music Theory
11
(
1
),
32
59
(
1967
).
25.
G.
Balzano
, “
The Group-Theoretic Description of 12-Fold Pitch Systems
,”
Comput. Music J.
4
,
66
84
(
1980
).
26.
J.
Clough
and
G.
Myerson
, “
Musical Scales and the Generalized Circle of Fifths
,”
Am. Math. Monthly
93
(
9
),
695
701
(
1986
).
27.
J.
Clough
and
G.
Myerson
, “
Variety and Multiplicity in Diatonic Systems
,”
J. Music Theory
29
,
249
270
(
1985
).
28.
M. V.
Mathews
,
J. R.
Pierce
,
A.
Reeves
, and
L. A.
Roberts
, “
Theoretical and Experimental Explorations of the Bohlen–Pierce Scale
,”
J. Acoust. Soc. Am.
84
,
1214
1222
(
1988
).
29.
E.
Agmon
, “
A Mathematical Model of the Diatonic System
,”
J. Music Theory
33
,
1
25
(
1989
).
30.
J.
Clough
,
J.
Cuciurean
, and
Douthett
, “
Hyperscales and the Generalized Tetrachord
,”
J. Music Theory
41
(
2
),
67
100
(
1997
).
31.
P.
Zweifel
, “
Generalized Diatonic and Pentatonic Scales: A Group Theoretic Approach
,”
Perspect. New Music
34
(
1
),
140
161
(
1996
).
32.
To get a sense of why these sets are called maximally even,
S.
Block
and
J.
Douthett
,
J. Music Theory
38
,
21
(
1994
) constructed a measure of the eveness of subsets in the same cardinal family (e.g., same chromatic cardinality or same diatonic cardinality). This measure is consistent with the ME algorithm.
33.
J. Douthett, “The Theory of Maximally and Minimally Even Sets, the One-Dimensional Antiferromagnetic Ising Model, and the Continued Fraction Compromise of Musical Scales,” Ph.D. dissertation (University of New Mexico, Albuquerque, NM, May 1999).
34.
When c is a denominator of a continued fraction convergent of the logb of a ratio, then the ratio’s desirability at c is better than at any smaller chromatic cardinality (Ref. 6). Remarkably, for the sequence of ratios 3:5:7:9, c=13 is a denominator of continued fraction convergents to log3 of all three ratios: log3(5/3)≈6/13,log3(7/5)≈4/13, and log3(9/7)≈3/13. This coincidence explains why this small chromatic cardinality has such an extraordinarily good desirability.
35.
H.
Bohlen
, “
13 Tonstufen in der Doudezeme
,”
Acustica
39
,
76
86
(
1978
).
36.
L.
Roberts
and
M.
Mathews
, “
Intonation Sensitivity for Traditional and Nontraditional Chords
,”
J. Acoust. Soc. Am.
75
,
954
959
(
1984
).
37.
M.
Schechter
, “
Tempered Scales and Continued Fractions
,”
Am. Math. Monthly
87
,
40
42
(
1980
).
38.
J.
Douthett
,
R.
Entringer
, and
A.
Mullhaupt
, “
Musical Scale Construction: The Continued Fraction Compromise
,”
Util. Mathemat.
42
,
97
113
(
1992
).
39.
A. Ya Khinchin, Continued Fractions (The University of Chicago Press, Chicago, 1992).
This content is only available via PDF.
You do not currently have access to this content.