Dr. Staples’ lengthy comments [J. Acoust. Soc. Am. 104, 1726–1728 (1998)] deal less with the matters of research design or data analysis described by Fidell et al. [J. Acoust. Soc. Am. 100, 2909–2918 (1996)] than with her beliefs about the proper study and interpretation of aircraft noise effects in outdoor recreational settings. Her comments nonetheless raise several interesting issues related to the role of technical expertise in noise-related policy analyses. This response therefore concentrates on those of Staples’ comments and arguments that are of general interest, while only secondarily addressing certain inaccuracies and oversimplifications in them.
REFERENCES
1.
Christensen, H. H., and Davis, N. J. (1984). “Evaluating user impacts and management controls: Implications for recreation choice behavior,” in Proceedings—Symposium on Recreation Choice Behavior, Gen. Tech. Rep. INT-1 84, Ogden, UT: USDA Forest Service Intermountain Research Station, compiled by G. H. Stankey and S. F. McCool, pp. 71–78.
2.
Fidell
, S.
, Schultz
, T. J.
, and Green
, D. M.
(1988
). “A theoretical interpretation of the prevalence rate of noise-induced annoyance in residential populations
,” J. Acoust. Soc. Am.
84
, 2109
–2113
. 3.
Fidell
, S.
, Silvati
, L.
, Howe
, R.
, Pearsons
, K. S.
, Tabachnick
, B.
, Knopf
, R. C.
, Gramann
, J.
, and Buchanan
, T.
(1996
). “Effects of aircraft overflights on wilderness recreationists
,” J. Acoust. Soc. Am.
100
, 2009
–2918
. 4.
Garrison
, L. A.
(1939
). “Camper activities in Yosemite Valley, study of 1937–1938
,” Yosemite Nature Notes
18(6). 5.
Gramann, J. H. (1992). Visitors, Alternative Futures, and Recreational Displacement at Yosemite National Park (National Park Service Western Regional Office, San Francisco, CA).
6.
HBRS, Inc. (1994a). “Survey of National Park Service Managers Related to Aircraft Overflying National Parks,” NPOA Report No. 93-7.
7.
HBRS, Inc. (1994b). “Air Tow Passengers Survey,” NPOA Report No. 94-1.
8.
Kuentzel
, W. F.
, and Heberlein
, T. A.
(1992
). “Cognitive and behavioral adaptations to perceived crowding: A panel study of coping and displacement
,” J. Leisure Res.
24
, 377
–393
. 9.
Leopold, A. (1949). “Conservation esthetic,” in A Sand Country Almanac (Oxford U.P., London), pp. 165–177.
10.
Manning
, R. E.
, and Ciali
, C. P.
(1980
). “Recreation density and user satisfaction: A further exploration of the satisfaction model
,” J. Leisure Res.
12
, 329
–345
.11.
National Park Service (1994). “Report to Congress: Report on effects of aircraft overflights on the National Park System,” U.S. Department of Interior, Washington, DC.
12.
Shindler
, B.
, and Shelby
, B.
(1995
). “Product shift in recreation setting: Findings and implications for panel research
,” Leisure Sci.
17
, 91
–107
. 13.
Staples
, S.
(1998
). “Comment on ‘Effects of aircraft overflights on wilderness recreationists’ [J. Acoust. Soc. Am. 100, 2909–2918 (1996)]
,” J. Acoust. Soc. Am.
104
, 1726
–1728
. 14.
Weilman
, J. D.
, Dawson
, M. S.
, and Roggenbuck
, J. W.
(1982
). “Park managers’ predictions of the motivations of visitors to two National Park Service areas
,” J. Leisure Res.
14
, 1
–15
.
This content is only available via PDF.
© 1998 Acoustical Society of America.
1998
Acoustical Society of America
You do not currently have access to this content.