In the recent work,1 an inaccuracy has been found in the charge-state averaged heat fluxes within the heat-flux-dependent part of the viscous-stress tensor. Specifically, the h¯α* should be used instead of the h¯α in Eq. (A10) in Ref. 1 as
(A10)
where the charge-state averaged heat fluxes are defined as
(A3)
More details can be found in Sec. 4.3.4.2 in Ref. 2. Consequently, the divergences of the parallel components of the viscous-stress tensor [Eqs. (B7) and (44)] in Ref. 1 need to be rewritten as
(B7)
and
(44)
The heat-flux-dependent part of Eq. (44) in Ref. 1 is used in the SOLPS-ITER code when the Zhdanov–Grad module is enabled in the form of Eq. (5.17) from Ref. 2. The corresponding corrections to the heat flux are applied in the 3.0.9 “develop” branch of the SOLPS-ITER code. For details, see the git pull requests: https://git.iter.org/projects/BND/repos/solps-iter/pull-requests/381/overview and https://git.iter.org/projects/BND/repos/b2.5/pull-requests/347/overview.

In the SOLPS-ITER code, the same temperature is assumed for all ion species (Ti). Therefore, the ion heat flux h¯α can be written as follows: h¯α=ZZ2hαZ/Zα2¯. For the single charge state ions, h¯α=h¯α*. Thus, for plasmas with single charge state main ions and multi-charge state impurity ions, the total plasma heat-dependent part of the viscous-stress tensor πih=α,ZπαZh is mainly defined by the heat fluxes of the single charge state main ion species, for which h¯α=h¯α*. For impurities, the friction and thermal forces dominate the parallel momentum balance, and the changes due to (·παZ(par)) for impurities due to h¯αh¯α* do not lead to substantial changes in the impurity transport. As a result, no substantial changes are expected for the most common plasma mixtures used in magnetic fusion device simulations, such as hydrogen isotope plasma with impurities.

To confirm this, tests were performed using a D+T+N mixture in the ASDEX-Upgrade H-mode with the SOLPS-ITER code, including the Zhdanov–Grad module, drifts, and currents. As expected, correcting h¯αh¯α* in Eq. (44) in Ref. 1 led to only minor changes in the solution. Despite the minor impact on the SOLPS-ITER solution, it is important to consider this correction for implementing the multi-species heat flux-dependent part of the viscous-stress tensor in future fluid models.

1.
S. O.
Makarov
,
D. P.
Coster
,
V. A.
Rozhansky
,
A. A.
Stepanenko
,
V. M.
Zhdanov
,
E. G.
Kaveeva
,
I. Y.
Senichenkov
, and
X.
Bonnin
,
Phys. Plasmas
28
,
062308
(
2021
).
2.
S. O.
Makarov
, “
Development and implementation of a generalized multi-ion transport model in plasma edge fluid codes
,” Ph.D. thesis (
Technische Universität München
,
2024
).