Inertial confinement fusion (ICF) experiments at the National Ignition Facility suffer from asymmetries in the x-ray drive, which degrade capsule performance compared to expectations for a symmetric one-dimensional implosion. Mode 1, or pole-to-pole, drive asymmetry can reduce confinement and implosion efficiency, driving a bulk motion of the hot spot that is detectable by neutron diagnostics. Understanding and removing sources of mode 1 asymmetry in ICF implosions is important for improving performance, and the three-dimensional nature of the problem makes high-resolution radiation-hydrodynamic modeling extremely computationally expensive. This work describes a reduced order view factor model that calculates the drive asymmetry induced by beam-to-beam variations in laser delivery and Hohlraum diagnostic windows along the equator. The capsule response is estimated by coupling to a Green's function that relates final hot spot velocity to the applied time-varying mode 1 asymmetry. The model makes several predictions about the impact of mode 1 drivers such as laser delivery and target misalignment and achieves good agreement in both the magnitude and the vector direction for several shots in three families of high-performance platforms. However, notable discrepancies suggest that other potential sources of mode 1 asymmetry not captured by the model are also at play.

1.
J. D.
Lindl
,
P.
Amendt
,
R. L.
Berger
,
S. G.
Glendinning
,
S. H.
Glenzer
,
S. W.
Haan
,
R. L.
Kauffman
,
O. L.
Landen
, and
L. J.
Suter
, “
The physics basis for ignition using indirect-drive targets on the national ignition facility
,”
Phys. Plasmas
11
,
339
491
(
2004
).
2.
E.
Moses
,
R.
Boyd
,
B.
Remington
,
C.
Keane
, and
R.
Al-Ayat
, “
The national ignition facility: Ushering in a new age for high energy density science
,”
Phys. Plasmas
16
,
041006
(
2009
).
3.
Y.
Saillard
, “
Acceleration and deceleration model of indirect drive icf capsules
,”
Nucl. Fusion
46
,
1017
(
2006
).
4.
R.
Town
,
D.
Bradley
,
A.
Kritcher
,
O.
Jones
,
J.
Rygg
,
R.
Tommasini
,
M.
Barrios
,
L.
Benedetti
,
L.
Berzak Hopkins
,
P.
Celliers
,
T.
Doppner
,
E.
Dewald
,
D.
Eder
,
J.
Field
,
S.
Glenn
,
N.
Izumi
,
S.
Haan
,
S.
Khan
,
J.
Kline
,
G.
Kyrala
,
T.
Ma
,
J.
Milovich
,
J.
Moody
,
S.
Nagel
,
A.
Pak
,
J.
Peterson
,
H.
Robey
,
J.
Ross
,
R.
Scott
,
B.
Spears
,
M.
Edwards
,
J.
Kilkenny
, and
O.
Landen
, “
Dynamic symmetry of indirectly driven inertial confinement fusion capsules on the national ignition facility
,”
Phys. Plasmas
21
,
056313
(
2014
).
5.
D.
Clark
,
S.
Haan
,
A.
Cook
,
M.
Edwards
,
B.
Hammel
,
J.
Koning
, and
M.
Marinak
, “
Short-wavelength and three-dimensional instability evolution in national ignition facility ignition capsule designs
,”
Phys. Plasmas
18
,
082701
(
2011
).
6.
A.
Kritcher
,
R.
Town
,
D.
Bradley
,
D.
Clark
,
B.
Spears
,
O.
Jones
,
S.
Haan
,
P.
Springer
,
J.
Lindl
,
R.
Scott
,
D.
Callahan
,
M.
Edwards
, and
O.
Landen
, “
Metrics for long wavelength asymmetries in inertial confinement fusion implosions on the national ignition facility
,”
Phys. Plasmas
21
,
042708
(
2014
).
7.
B.
MacGowan
,
O.
Landen
,
D.
Casey
,
C.
Young
,
D.
Callahan
,
E.
Hartouni
,
R.
Hatarik
,
M.
Hohenberger
,
T.
Ma
,
D.
Mariscal
,
A.
Moore
,
R.
Nora
,
H.
Rinderknecht
,
D.
Schlossberg
, and
B.
Van Wonterghem
, “
Trending low mode asymmetries in NIF capsule drive using a simple view factor metric
,”
High Energy Density Phys.
(submitted) (
2020
).
8.
J.
Peterson
,
P.
Michel
,
C.
Thomas
, and
R.
Town
, “
The impact of laser plasma interactions on three-dimensional drive symmetry in inertial confinement fusion implosions
,”
Phys. Plasmas
21
,
072712
(
2014
).
9.
B. K.
Spears
,
M.
Edwards
,
S.
Hatchett
,
J.
Kilkenny
,
J.
Knauer
,
A.
Kritcher
,
J.
Lindl
,
D.
Munro
,
P.
Patel
,
H.
Robey
, and
R.
Town
, “
Mode 1 drive asymmetry in inertial confinement fusion implosions on the national ignition facility
,”
Phys. Plasmas
21
,
042702
(
2014
).
10.
J.
Lindl
, “
Development of the indirect-drive approach to inertial confinement fusion and the target physics basis for ignition and gain
,”
Phys. Plasmas
2
,
3933
4024
(
1995
).
11.
S.
Pollaine
, “
Radiation transport between two concentric spheres
,”
Nucl. Fusion
40
,
2061
(
2000
).
12.
V. Y.
Glebov
,
T.
Sangster
,
C.
Stoeckl
,
J.
Knauer
,
W.
Theobald
,
K.
Marshall
,
M.
Shoup
 III
,
T.
Buczek
,
M.
Cruz
,
T.
Duffy
,
M.
Romanofsky
,
M.
Fox
,
A.
Pruyne
,
M.
Moran
,
R.
Lerche
,
J.
McNaney
,
J.
Kilkenny
,
M.
Eckart
,
D.
Schneider
,
D.
Munro
,
W.
Stoeffl
,
R.
Zacharias
,
J.
Haslam
,
T.
Clancy
,
M.
Yeoman
,
D.
Warwas
,
C.
Horsfield
,
J.-L.
Bourgade
,
O.
Landoas
,
L.
Disdier
,
G.
Chandler
, and
R.
Leeper
, “
The national ignition facility neutron time-of-flight system and its initial performance
,”
Rev. Sci. Instrum.
81
,
10D325
(
2010
).
13.
V. Y.
Glebov
,
C.
Forrest
,
J.
Knauer
,
A.
Pruyne
,
M.
Romanofsky
,
T.
Sangster
,
M.
Shoup
 III
,
C.
Stoeckl
,
J.
Caggiano
,
M.
Carman
,
T.
Clancy
,
R.
Hatarik
,
J.
McNaney
, and
N.
Zaitseva
, “
Testing a new nif neutron time-of-flight detector with a bibenzyl scintillator on omega
,”
Rev. Sci. Instrum.
83
,
10D309
(
2012
).
14.
H. G.
Rinderknecht
,
R.
Bionta
,
G.
Grim
,
R.
Hatarik
,
H.
Khater
,
D.
Schlossberg
, and
C.
Yeamans
, “
Velocity correction for neutron activation diagnostics at the nif
,”
Rev. Sci. Instrum.
89
,
10I125
(
2018
).
15.
R.
Hatarik
,
R.
Nora
,
B.
Spears
,
M.
Eckart
,
G.
Grim
,
E.
Hartouni
,
A.
Moore
, and
D.
Schlossberg
, “
Using multiple neutron time of flight detectors to determine the hot spot velocity
,”
Rev. Sci. Instrum.
89
,
10I138
(
2018
).
16.
M.
Marinak
,
G.
Kerbel
,
N.
Gentile
,
O.
Jones
,
D.
Munro
,
S.
Pollaine
,
T.
Dittrich
, and
S.
Haan
, “
Three-dimensional hydra simulations of national ignition facility targets
,”
Phys. Plasmas
8
,
2275
2280
(
2001
).
17.
J.
Milovich
,
D.
Casey
,
O.
Jones
, and
O.
Landen
, “
Integrated simulations of capsule implosions in low gas-fill hohlraums at the National Ignition Facility
,” APS Meeting Abstracts, available at https://ui.adsabs.harvard.edu/abs/2019APS..DPPJO7005M/abstract.
18.
D. S.
Clark
,
C. R.
Weber
,
J. L.
Milovich
,
A. E.
Pak
,
D. T.
Casey
,
B. A.
Hammel
,
D. D.
Ho
,
O. S.
Jones
,
J. M.
Koning
,
A. L.
Kritcher
,
M. M.
Marinak
,
L. P.
Masse
,
D. H.
Munro
,
M. V.
Patel
,
P. K.
Patel
,
H. F.
Robey
,
C. R.
Schroeder
,
S. M.
Sepke
, and
M. J.
Edwards
, “
Three-dimensional modeling and hydrodynamic scaling of national ignition facility implosions
,”
Phys. Plasmas
26
,
050601
(
2019
).
19.
L.
Masse
,
D.
Clark
,
S.
MacLaren
,
L.
Berzak Hopkins
,
S.
Haan
,
S.
Khan
,
A.
Kritcher
,
G.
Kyrala
,
O.
Landen
,
J.
Lindl
,
T.
Ma
,
P.
Patel
,
J.
Ralph
,
J.
Salmonson
,
R.
Tipton
, and
C.
Weber
, “
A simulation-based model for understanding the time dependent x-ray drive asymmetries and error bars in indirectly driven implosions on the national ignition facility
,”
Phys. Plasmas
26
,
062703
(
2019
).
20.
J.
MacFarlane
, “
Visrad—A 3-d view factor code and design tool for high-energy density physics experiments
,”
J. Quant. Spectrosc. Radiat. Transfer
81
,
287
300
(
2003
).
21.
J. R.
Howell
,
R.
Siegel
, and
M. P.
Menguc
,
Thermal Radiation Heat Transfer
, 5th ed. (
CRC Press
,
2015
).
22.
S.
Le Pape
,
L. B.
Hopkins
,
L.
Divol
,
A.
Pak
,
E.
Dewald
,
S.
Bhandarkar
,
L.
Bennedetti
,
T.
Bunn
,
J.
Biener
,
J.
Crippen
,
D.
Casey
,
D.
Edgell
,
D.
Fittinghoff
,
M.
Gatu-Johnson
,
C.
Goyon
,
S.
Haan
,
R.
Hatarik
,
M.
Havre
,
D. D.-M.
Ho
,
N.
Izumi
,
J.
Jaquez
,
S.
Khan
,
G.
Kyrala
,
T.
Ma
,
A.
Mackinnon
,
A.
MacPhee
,
B.
MacGowan
,
N.
Meezan
,
J.
Milovich
,
M.
Millot
,
P.
Michel
,
S.
Nagel
,
A.
Nikroo
,
P.
Patel
,
J.
Ralph
,
J.
Ross
,
N.
Rice
,
D.
Strozzi
,
M.
Stadermann
,
P.
Volegov
,
C.
Yeamans
,
C.
Weber
,
C.
Wild
,
D.
Callahan
, and
O.
Hurricane
, “
Fusion energy output greater than the kinetic energy of an imploding shell at the national ignition facility
,”
Phys. Rev. Lett.
120
,
245003
(
2018
).
23.
K. L.
Baker
,
C. A.
Thomas
,
D. T.
Casey
,
M.
Hohenberger
,
S.
Khan
,
B. K.
Spears
,
O. L.
Landen
,
R.
Nora
,
T.
Woods
,
J. L.
Milovich
,
R. L.
Berger
,
D.
Strozzi
,
C.
Weber
,
D.
Clark
,
O. A.
Hurricane
,
D. A.
Callahan
,
A.
Kritcher
,
B.
Backmann
,
R.
Benedetti
,
R.
Bionta
,
P. M.
Celliers
,
D.
Fittinghoff
,
C.
Goyon
,
R.
Hatarik
,
N.
Izumi
,
M.
Gatu-Johnson
,
G.
Kyrala
,
T.
Ma
,
K.
Meany
,
M.
Millot
,
S. R.
Nagel
,
P. K.
Patel
,
D.
Turnbull
,
P. L.
Volegov
,
C.
Yeamans
, and
C.
Wilde
, “
Hotspot parameter scaling with velocity and yield for high adiabat layered implosions on the national ignition facility
,”
Phys. Rev. E
(in press) (
2020
).
24.
J.
Ralph
,
O.
Landen
,
L.
Divol
,
A.
Pak
,
T.
Ma
,
D.
Callahan
,
A.
Kritcher
,
T.
Döppner
,
D.
Hinkel
,
C.
Jarrott
,
J.
Moody
,
B.
Pollock
,
O.
Hurricane
, and
M.
Edwards
, “
The influence of hohlraum dynamics on implosion symmetry in indirect drive inertial confinement fusion experiments
,”
Phys. Plasmas
25
,
082701
(
2018
).
25.
N.
Izumi
,
N.
Meezan
,
S.
Johnson
,
B.
Woodworth
,
T.
Woods
,
O.
Jones
,
O.
Landen
,
J.
Kroll
,
S.
Vonhof
,
A.
Nikroo
,
J.
Jaquez
,
K.
Kangas
,
C.
Bailey
,
M.
Hardy
,
R.
Ehrlich
,
J.
Ralph
,
R. P.
Town
,
D.
Bradley
,
D.
Hinkel
,
A.
Moore
,
L.
Divol
,
C.
Young
, and
J.
Moody
, “
Simultaneous visualization of wall motion, beam propagation, and implosion symmetry on the national ignition facility
,”
Rev. Sci. Instrum.
89
,
10K111
(
2018
).
26.
R.
Nora
,
J. E.
Field
,
B.
Spears
,
D.
Casey
,
M. K. G.
Kruse
,
D.
Mariscal
, and
P.
Patel
, “
Modeling the 3-d structure of ignition experiments at the nif
,”
Phys. Plasmas
27
,
032706
(
2020
).
27.
D.
Munro
,
J.
Field
,
R.
Hatarik
,
J.
Peterson
,
E.
Hartouni
,
B.
Spears
, and
J.
Kilkenny
, “
Impact of temperature-velocity distribution on fusion neutron peak shape
,”
Phys. Plasmas
24
,
056301
(
2017
).
28.
L.
Ballabio
,
J.
Källne
, and
G.
Gorini
, “
Relativistic calculation of fusion product spectra for thermonuclear plasmas
,”
Nucl. Fusion
38
,
1723
(
1998
).
29.
O.
Hurricane
,
D.
Casey
,
O.
Landen
,
A. L.
Kritcher
,
R.
Nora
,
P. K.
Patel
,
J. A.
Gaffney
,
K. D.
Humbird
,
J. E.
Field
,
M. K. G.
Kruse
,
J. L.
Peterson
, and
B.
Spears
, “
An analytic asymmetric-piston model for the impact of mode-1 shell asymmetry on icf implosions
,”
Phys. Plasmas
27
,
062704
(
2020
).
30.
Lawrence Livermore National Laboratory,
Laser indirect drive input to NNSA 2020 report
,”
Report No. LLNL-TR-810573
(
2020
).
You do not currently have access to this content.