The goal of this study is to investigate the effect of various design parameters on the performance of a Vertical Axis Wind Turbine (VAWT) subjected to realistic unsteady wind conditions. Thirteen turbine design configurations are examined to determine if an optimal VAWT has applications in an urban/suburban environment. The four design parameters of interest include the height-to-diameter aspect ratio (0.83H/D1.34), blade airfoil shape (NACA 0012, 0015, 0018), turbine solidity (12S25%), and turbine moment of inertia. The height and diameter of the turbine varied between 1.89 and 2.54 m, depending on the aspect ratio. The turbine moment of inertia was calculated using a computer-aided design drawing of the turbine, along with the realistic material properties of blades, shafts, and supports. The energy generated by each VAWT design configuration is simulated using a full year of actual wind speed data collected in 2009 at 9 different locations around Oklahoma City spanning an area of approximately 500 km2. The wind data were acquired from the top of traffic light posts at a height of about 9 m above the ground. In all cases, an active control strategy is used that allows the turbine to continuously adjust its rotational speed in response to the fluctuating wind. The results suggest that, for the case of operation in unsteady winds, the optimal power coefficient (Cp) versus tip speed ratio curve is not necessarily the one exhibiting the highest peak Cp value but rather the broadest shape. Of the thirteen configurations examined, the optimal wind turbine design capable of harvesting the most energy from the gusty winds was found to have an aspect ratio of H/D=1.2, a solidity of S=12%, and a blade shape using the NACA 0015 airfoil. This design also displayed the lowest moment of inertia. However, when the effects of mass were removed, this design still performed the best. The site-to-site variation in terms of energy captured relative to the available energy in the gusty winds was only about 5% on average and increased slightly with turbine moment of inertia. Four of the suburban sites studied were deemed to be economically viable locations for a small-scale VAWT. The results further indicate that, at one of these sites, the levelized cost of energy associated with the top performing turbine designs examined in the study was about 10% less than the national electricity price, meaning that wind energy provides a cheaper alternative to fossil fuel at this location. It is surmised that VAWTs could economically harvest wind energy in the urban center as well if the turbines were located higher than 9 m, such as on the rooftops of commercial/residential buildings.

1.
T.
Ackermann
and
L.
Söder
, “
An overview of wind energy-status 2002
,”
Renewable Sustainable Energy Rev.
6
(
1
),
67
127
(
2002
).
2.
A.
Alaimo
,
A.
Esposito
,
A.
Messineo
,
C.
Orlando
, and
D.
Tumino
, “
3d CFD analysis of a vertical axis wind turbine
,”
Energies
8
(
4
),
3013
3033
(
2015
).
3.
S.
Armstrong
,
A.
Fiedler
, and
S.
Tullis
, “
Flow separation on a high Reynolds number, high solidity vertical axis wind turbine with straight and canted blades and canted blades with fences
,”
Renewable Energy
41
,
13
22
(
2012
).
4.
A.W.E.A.
, http://www.awea.org/production-tax-credit for Production tax credit,
2017
.
5.
S.
Azau
, “
A breath of fresh air the European wind energy association annual report 2009
,”
Technical Report No. ISSN 2032-9024
, EWEA,
2010
.
6.
K. S.
Babu
,
N. S.
Raju
,
M. S.
Reddy
, and
D. N.
Rao
, “
The material selection for typical wind turbine blades using a MADM approach & analysis of blades
,” in
Proceedings of 18th International Conference on Multiple Criteria Decision Making (MCDM 2006)
, Chania, Greece, 19–23 June
2006
.
7.
J. B.
Basara
,
B. G.
Illston
,
C. A.
Fiebrich
,
P. D.
Browder
,
C. R.
Morgan
,
A.
McCombs
,
J. P.
Bostic
,
R. A.
McPherson
,
A. J.
Schroeder
, and
K. C.
Crawford
, “
The Oklahoma City micronet
,”
Meteorol. Appl.
18
(
3
),
252
261
(
2011
).
8.
G.
Bedon
,
M. R.
Castelli
, and
E.
Benini
, “
Optimization of a Darrieus vertical-axis wind turbine using blade element–momentum theory and evolutionary algorithm
,”
Renewable Energy
59
,
184
192
(
2013
).
9.
D. E.
Berg
, “
Improved double-multiple streamtube model for the Darrieus-type vertical-axis wind turbine
,”
Technical Report No. SAND-82-2479C
, Sandia National Laboratories, Albuquerque, NM, USA,
1983
.
10.
H.
Beri
,
Y.
Yao
 et al, “
Double multiple streamtube model and numerical analysis of vertical axis wind turbine
,”
Energy Power Eng.
3
(03),
262
(
2011
).
11.
T.
Bertényi
,
C.
Wickins
, and
S.
McIntosh
, “
Enhanced energy capture through gust-tracking in the urban wind environment
,” in
48th AIAA Aerospace Sciences Meeting
, Orlando, Florida, USA (
2010
).
12.
B. F.
Blackwell
,
R. E.
Sheldahl
, and
L. V.
Feltz
, “
Wind tunnel performance data for the Darrieus wind turbine with NACA 0012 blades
,”
Technical Report No. SAND76-0130
, Sandia Laboratories, Albuquerque, NM, USA,
1976
.
13.
S.
Brusca
,
R.
Lanzafame
, and
M.
Messina
, “
Design of a vertical-axis wind turbine: How the aspect ratio affects the turbines performance
,”
Int. J. Energy Environ. Eng.
5
(4),
333
340
(
2014
).
14.
M. R.
Castelli
,
S.
De Betta
, and
E.
Benini
, “
Effect of blade number on a straight-bladed vertical-axis Darreius wind turbine
,”
World Acad. Sci., Eng. Technol.
6
(1),
68
74
(
2012
), available online at http://waset.org/publications/12820/effect-of-blade-number-on-a-straight-bladed-vertical-axis-darreius-wind-turbine.
15.
W.
Chong
,
K.
Pan
,
S.
Poh
,
A.
Fazlizan
,
C.
Oon
,
A.
Badarudin
, and
N.
Nik-Ghazali
, “
Performance investigation of a power augmented vertical axis wind turbine for urban high-rise application
,”
Renewable Energy
51
,
388
397
(
2013
).
16.
A.
Fiedler
and
S.
Tullis
, “
Blade offset and pitch effects on a high solidity vertical axis wind turbine
,”
Wind Eng.
33
(
3
),
237
246
(
2009
).
17.
R. E.
Gormont
, “
A mathematical model of unsteady aerodynamics and radial flow for application to helicopter rotors
,”
Technical Report No. D210-10492-1
, DTIC Document,
1973
.
18.
IRENA Working Paper, Renewable Energy Technologies: Cost Analysis Series, Volume 1: Power Sector, Issue 5/5, Wind Power
(International Renewable Energy Agency, 2012), available online at https://www.irena.org/DocumentDownloads/Publications/RE_Technologies_Cost_Analysis-WIND_POWER.pdf.
19.
M.
Islam
,
D. S.-K.
Ting
, and
A.
Fartaj
, “
Aerodynamic models for Darrieus-type straight-bladed vertical axis wind turbines
,”
Renewable Sustainable Energy Rev.
12
(
4
),
1087
1109
(
2008
).
20.
E. N.
Jacobs
and
A.
Sherman
, “
Airfoil section characteristics as affected by variations of the Reynolds number
,”
Technical Report No. 586
, National Advisory Committee for Aeronautics,
1937
.
21.
M.
Jureczko
,
M.
Pawlak
, and
A.
Mezyk
, “
Optimisation of wind turbine blades
,”
J. Mater. Process. Technol.
167
(
2
),
463
471
(
2005
).
22.
J.
Kaldellis
, “
Optimum autonomous wind–power system sizing for remote consumers, using long-term wind speed data
,”
Appl. Energy
71
(
3
),
215
233
(
2002
).
23.
K.-J.
Lavappa
, “
Energy price indices and discount factors for life-cycle cost analysis
,”
Technical Report No. NISTR 85-3273-30
, National Institute of Standards and Technology - US Department of Commerce,
2015
.
24.
D. Y.
Leung
and
Y.
Yang
, “
Wind energy development and its environmental impact: A review
,”
Renewable Sustainable Energy Rev.
16
(
1
),
1031
1039
(
2012
).
25.
S.
Lindenberg
,
20% Wind Energy by 2030: Increasing Wind Energy‘s Contribution to US Electricity Supply
(
Diane Publishing
,
2009
).
26.
N.
Mahmoud
,
A.
El-Haroun
,
E.
Wahba
, and
M.
Nasef
, “
An experimental study on improvement of Savonius rotor performance
,”
Alexandria Eng. J.
51
(
1
),
19
25
(
2012
).
27.
C.
Masson
,
C.
Leclerc
, and
I.
Paraschivoiu
, “
Appropriate dynamic-stall models for performance predictions of Vawts with NLF blades
,”
Int. J. Rotating Mach.
4
(
2
),
129
139
(
1998
).
28.
S.
McIntosh
,
H.
Babinsky
, and
T.
Bertenyi
, “
Optimizing the energy output of vertical axis wind turbines for fluctuating wind conditions
,” in
45th AIAA Aerospace Sciences Meeting and Exhibit
, Reno, Nevada (
2007
).
29.
S.
McIntosh
,
H.
Babinsky
, and
T.
Bertenyi
, “
Unsteady power output of vertical axis wind turbines operating within a fluctuating free-stream
,” in
46th AIAA Aerospace Sciences Meeting and Exhibit
, Reno, Nevada (
2008
).
30.
S. C.
McIntosh
, “
Wind energy for the built environment
,” Ph.D. thesis (
University of Cambridge
,
2009
).
31.
M.
Mohamed
, “
Performance investigation of H-rotor Darrieus turbine with new airfoil shapes
,”
Energy
47
(
1
),
522
530
(
2012
).
32.
L.
Nguyen
and
M.
Metzger
, “
Enhanced energy capture by a vertical axis wind turbine during gusty winds in an urban/suburban environment
,”
J. Renewable Sustainable Energy
7
(
5
),
053118
(
2015
).
33.
L.
Nguyen
and
M.
Metzger
, “
Comparison of forecasting methods for vertical axis wind turbine applications in an urban/suburban area
,”
J. Renewable Sustainable Energy
9
(
2
),
023302
(
2017
).
34.
I.
Paraschivoiu
,
Wind Turbine Design: With Emphasis on Darrieus Concept
(
Presses Inter Polytechnique
,
2002
).
35.
I.
Paraschivoiu
and
F.
Delclaux
, “
Double multiple streamtube model with recent improvements (for predicting aerodynamic loads and performance of Darrieus vertical axis wind turbines)
,”
J. Energy
7
(
3
),
250
255
(
1983
).
36.
I.
Paraschivoiu
,
F.
Delclaux
,
P.
Fraunie
, and
C.
Beguier
, “
Aerodynamic analysis of the Darrieus rotor including secondary effects
,”
J. Energy
7
(
5
),
416
422
(
1983
).
37.
S.-C.
Roh
and
S.-H.
Kang
, “
Effects of a blade profile, the Reynolds number, and the solidity on the performance of a straight bladed vertical axis wind turbine
,”
J. Mech. Sci. Technol.
27
(
11
),
3299
3307
(
2013
).
38.
P. J.
Schubel
and
R. J.
Crossley
, “
Wind turbine blade design
,”
Energies
5
(
9
),
3425
3449
(
2012
).
39.
R. E.
Sheldahl
and
P. C.
Klimas
, “
Aerodynamic characteristics of seven symmetrical airfoil sections through 180-degree angle of attack for use in aerodynamic analysis of vertical axis wind turbines
,”
Technical Report No. SAND80-2114
, Sandia National Laboratories, Albuquerque, NM, USA,
1981
.
40.
I.
Staffell
and
R.
Green
, “
How does wind farm performance decline with age?
,”
Renewable Energy
66
,
775
786
(
2014
).
41.
J. D.-P.
Stefan Gsnger
, “
2015 small wind world report summary
,”
Technical Report WWEA March 2015
.
42.
J. H.
Strickland
, “
Darrieus turbine: A performance prediction model using multiple streamtubes
,”
Technical Report No. SAND74-0431
, Sandia Laboratories, Albuquerque, NM, USA,
1975
.
43.
J. H.
Strickland
,
B.
Webster
, and
T.
Nguyen
, “
Vortex model of the Darrieus turbine: An analytical and experimental study
,”
Technical Report No. SAND-79-7058
, Texas Tech University, Lubbock, USA,
1980
.
44.
R.
Templin
, “
Aerodynamic performance theory for the NRC vertical-axis wind turbine
,” NASA STI/Recon,
Technical Report No. 16618
(
1974
), Vol.
76
.
45.
A.
Tirkey
,
Y.
Sarthi
,
K.
Patel
,
R.
Sharma
, and
P. K.
Sen
, “
Study on the effect of blade profile, number of blade, Reynolds number, aspect ratio on the performance of vertical axis wind turbine
,”
Int. J. Sci., Eng. Technol. Res. (IJSETR)
3
(
12
),
3183
3187
(
2014
).
You do not currently have access to this content.