Soiling, the accumulation of dust, is a detrimental influencing factor for solar energy generation in desert climates, as it blocks the sun light and therefore reduces the energy yield of photovoltaic (PV) modules. Accordingly, soiling requires mitigation by frequent cleaning. However, regular cleaning of PV modules can damage glass surfaces and commonly used anti-reflective coatings (ARCs), which typically enable 2–3% or even higher increases in the power output. Within this study, the damage potential of dry manual cleaning on uncoated solar glass and two different commercial ARCs is examined. For this, a cleaning test apparatus and methodology applicable to full size PV modules were developed. The changes in the optical behavior of coated and uncoated glass samples were investigated both theoretically and experimentally, including the analysis of spectroscopic reflectance and microstructural damage patterns. It is found that dry brushing on dusty surfaces causes only minor damage to uncoated glass surfaces with no changes in hemispherical reflectance, even at high numbers of brush cycles. In contrast, both the tested coatings indicate significant reductions of the AR performance, already after 100 brush cycles with increasing reflectance up to 2.3% at 600 nm. Furthermore, the coatings indicated different stabilities during extended abrasion testing, but still retained the AR properties after 500 cycles of testing, reflecting harsh and bi-weekly cleaning over 20 years of operation. Localized coating removal and—to a less extent—coating thinning were identified as ARC degradation mechanisms, which were supported by spectroscopy experimental and simulation results for microstructural analysis of the samples.

1.
K. K.
Ilse
,
B. W.
Figgis
,
V.
Naumann
,
C.
Hagendorf
, and
J.
Bagdahn
, “
Fundamentals of soiling processes on photovoltaic modules
,”
Renewable Sustainable Energy Rev.
98
,
239
254
(
2018
).
2.
K.
Ilse
,
L.
Micheli
,
B. W.
Figgis
,
K.
Lange
,
D.
Daßler
,
H.
Hanifi
,
F.
Wolfertstetter
,
V.
Naumann
,
C.
Hagendorf
,
R.
Gottschalg
, and
J.
Bagdahn
, “
Techno-economic assessment of soiling losses and mitigation strategies for solar power generation
,”
Joule
3
,
2303
2321
(
2019
).
3.
L.
Micheli
,
M. G.
Deceglie
, and
M.
Muller
, “
Predicting photovoltaic soiling losses using environmental parameters: An update
,”
Prog. Photovoltaics: Res. Appl.
27
,
210
(
2019
).
4.
L.
Micheli
and
M.
Muller
, “
An investigation of the key parameters for predicting PV soiling losses
,”
Prog. Photovoltaics: Res. Appl.
25
,
291
307
(
2017
).
5.
S.
Toth
,
M.
Muller
,
D. C.
Miller
,
H.
Moutinho
,
B.
To
,
L.
Micheli
,
J.
Linger
,
C.
Engtrakul
,
A.
Einhorn
, and
L.
Simpson
, “
Soiling and cleaning: Initial observations from 5-year photovoltaic glass coating durability study
,”
Sol. Energy Mater. Sol. Cells
185
,
375
384
(
2018
).
6.
B.
Gallagher
, https://www.vox.com/energy-and-environment/2018/8/29/17783114/solar-pv-panels-market-tech for “
Rise of the machines: Solar module-washing robots
,” GTM Report,
2018
.
7.
J.
Kurz
, “
PV cleaning: Choosing the optimal method and frequency
,” Webinar,
2017
.
8.
M.
Mesbahi
, White Paper///Soiling: The Science & Solutions,
2018
.
9.
N.
Ferretti
, White Paper///PV Module Cleaning: Market Overview and Basics,
2018
.
10.
MnGN.
Grando
,
E. R.
Maletz
,
D.
Martins
,
H.
Simas
, and
R.
Simoni
, “
Robots for cleaning photovoltaic panels: State of the art and future prospects
,”
Rev. Tecnol. Ciencia
35
,
137
150
(
2019
).
11.
Photonics for Solar Energy Systems VI
, edited by
R. B.
Wehrspohn
,
A.
Gombert
, and
A. N.
Sprafke
(
SPIE
,
2016
).
12.
M. M.
Braun
and
L.
Pilon
, “
Effective optical properties of non-absorbing nanoporous thin films
,”
Thin Solid Films
496
,
505
514
(
2006
).
13.
P.-Z.
Yang
,
L.-M.
Liu
,
J.-H.
Mo
, and
W.
Yang
, “
Characterization of PECVD grown porous SiO2 thin films with potential application in an uncooled infrared detector
,”
Semicond. Sci. Technol.
25
,
045017
(
2010
).
14.
M.
Rubin
, “
Optical properties of soda lime silica glasses
,”
Sol. Energy Mater.
12
,
275
288
(
1985
).
15.
S. C.
Pop
,
V.
Abbaraju
,
B.
Brophy
,
Y. S.
Yang
,
S.
Maghsoodi
, and
P.
Gonsalves
, “
A highly abrasive-resistant, long-lasting anti-reflective coating for PV module glass
,” in
IEEE 40th Photovoltaic Specialists Conference (PVSC), Denver, CO
(
IEEE
, Piscataway, NJ,
2014
), pp.
2715
2719
.
16.
T.
Weber
,
M.
Hanusch
,
S.
Koch
,
M.
Trawny
,
A.
Janker
,
A.
Böttcher
,
J.
Berghold
, and
P.
Grunow
, “
From the impact of harsh climates and environmental conditions on PV-modules—development of a soiling and abrasion test
,” in
Proceedings of the 29th European Photovoltaic Solar Energy Conference and Exhibition
, Amsterdam (Holland) (
2014
).
17.
N.
Ferretti
,
A.
Sönmez
,
F.
Schneider
,
B.
Litzenburger
,
S.
Janke
,
T.
Weber
,
J.
Berghold
, and
P.
Grunow
, “
Reflectance measurements for testing the effect of module cleaning on the glass surface
,” in
EU PVSEC
(
2015
).
18.
E.
Klimm
,
T.
Kaltenbach
,
D.
Philipp
,
M.
Masche
,
K.-A.
Weiss
, and
M.
Koehl
, “
Soiling and abrasion testing of surfaces for solar energy systems adapted to extreme climatic conditions
,” in
31st EU-PVSEC
(
2015
).
19.
N.
Ferretti
,
K.
Ilse
,
A.
Sönmez
,
C.
Hagendorf
, and
J.
Berghold
, “
Investigation on the impact of module cleaning on the antireflection coating
,” in
32nd EU-PVSEC
(
2016
), pp.
1697
1700
.
20.
D. C.
Miller
,
M. T.
Muller
, and
L. J.
Simpson
, “
Review of artificial abrasion test methods for pv module technology
,”
Technical Report No. NREL/TP-5J00-66334
,
2016
.
21.
A.
Al Shehri
,
B.
Parrott
,
P.
Carrasco
,
H.
Al Saiari
, and
I.
Taie
, “
Accelerated testbed for studying the wear, optical and electrical characteristics of dry cleaned PV solar panels
,”
Sol. Energy
146
,
8
19
(
2017
).
22.
G.
Womack
,
P. M.
Kaminski
,
A.
Abbas
,
K.
Isbilir
,
R.
Gottschalg
, and
J. M.
Walls
, “
Performance and durability of broadband antireflection coatings for thin film CdTe solar cells
,”
J. Vac. Sci. Technol., A
35
,
021201
(
2017
).
23.
B.
Parrott
,
P.
Carrasco Zanini
,
A.
Shehri
,
K.
Kotsovos
, and
I.
Gereige
, “
Automated, robotic dry-cleaning of solar panels in Thuwal, Saudi Arabia using a silicone rubber brush
,”
Sol. Energy
171
,
526
533
(
2018
).
24.
D. C.
Miller
,
A.
Einhorn
,
C.
Engtrakul
,
C. L.
Lanaghan
,
L.
Micheli
,
H. R.
Moutinho
,
M.
Muller
,
B.
To
,
S.
Toth
, and
L. J.
Simpson
, “
Soiling related abrasion and the development of a PV abrasion standard
,”
Report No. NREL/PR-5K00-72850
,
2018
.
25.
C. A.
Mohamed
,
L. N.
Mamadou
,
M.
Amy
,
S.
Mamadou
,
A. N.
Pape
, and
N.
Amadou
, “
Study of the performance of a system for dry cleaning dust deposited on the surface of solar photovoltaic panels
,”
Int. J. Phys. Sci.
13
,
16
23
(
2018
).
26.
K.
Isbilir
,
F.
Lisco
,
G.
Womack
,
A.
Abbas
, and
J. M.
Walls
, “
Testing of an anti-soiling coating for PV module cover glass
,” in
2018 IEEE 7th World Conference on Photovoltaic Energy Conversion (WCPEC)
(
2018
).
27.
J.
Bengoechea
,
M. J.
Rodríguez
,
E.
Zugasti
, and
A. R.
Lagunas
, “
Susceptibility of CPV optical materials to abrasion
,” in
15th International Conference on Concentrator Photovoltaic Systems (CPV-15)
, Fes, Morocco (
AIP Publishing
,
2019
), p.
70002
.
28.
A.
Einhorn
,
L.
Micheli
,
D. C.
Miller
,
L. J.
Simpson
,
H. R.
Moutinho
,
B.
To
,
C. L.
Lanaghan
,
M. T.
Muller
,
S.
Toth
,
J. J.
John
,
S.
Warade
,
A.
Kottantharayil
, and
C.
Engtrakul
, “
Evaluation of soiling and potential mitigation approaches on photovoltaic glass
,”
IEEE J. Photovoltaics
9
,
233
239
(
2019
).
29.
K.
Ilse
,
C.
Pfau
,
P.-T.
Miclea
,
S.
Krause
, and
C.
Hagendorf
, “
Quantification of abrasion-induced ARC transmission losses from reflection spectroscopy
,” in
2019 IEEE 46th Photovoltaic Specialists Conference (PVSC)
, pp.
2883
2888
.
30.
N.
Ferretti
,
A.
El-Issa
, and
L.
Podlowski
, “
Standardized Test Procedure for PV Module Cleaning Equipment
,” in
36
th
European Photovoltaic Solar Energy Conference and Exhibition
(
2019
), pp.
805
809
.
31.
D. C.
Miller
,
A.
Alnuaimi
,
J. J.
John
,
L. J.
Simpson
,
C.
Engtrakul
,
A.
Einhorn
,
C. L.
Lanaghan
,
J. M.
Newkirk
,
B.
To
,
D.
Holsapple
,
J.
Morse
,
P. F.
Ndione
, and
H. R.
Moutinho
, “
The abrasion of photovoltaic glass: A comparison of the effects of natural and artificial aging
,”
IEEE J. Photovoltaics
10
,
173
180
(
2020
).
32.
K.
Lange
,
M. A.
Bahattab
,
S. H.
Alqahtani
,
M.
Mirza
,
W.
Glaubitt
,
V.
Naumann
,
C.
Hagendorf
, and
K. K.
Ilse
, “
Combined soiling and abrasion testing of antisoiling coatings
,”
IEEE J. Photovoltaics
10
,
1
7
(
2019
).
33.
J. M.
Newkirk
,
I.
Nayshevsky
,
V. A.
Sinclair
,
A.
Law
,
Q.
Xu
,
B.
To
,
P. F.
Ndione
,
L. T.
Schelhas
,
J. M.
Walls
,
A.
Lyons
, and
D. C.
Miller
, “
Artificial linear brush abrasion of coatings for photovoltaic module first surfaces
,”
Report No. NREL-PR-5K00-75028
,
2019
.
34.
K.
Ilse
,
P.-T.
Miclea
,
V.
Naumann
, and
C.
Hagendorf
, “
Cleaning resistance of glass coatings
,” Test Report No. V403/2018,
2018
.
35.
M.
Born
and
E.
Wolf
,
Principles of Optics: Electromagnetic Theory of Propagation, Interference and Diffraction of Light
, 7th (expanded) ed. (
Cambridge University Press
,
Cambridge
,
2009
).
You do not currently have access to this content.