Understanding the permeation of molecules through lipid membranes is fundamental for predicting the cellular uptake of solutes and drug delivery mechanisms. In molecular simulations, the usual approach is to compute the free energy (FE) profile of a molecule across a model lipid bilayer, which can then be used to estimate the permeability of the molecule. Umbrella Sampling (US), which involves carrying out a series of biased simulations along a defined reaction coordinate (usually the bilayer normal direction), is a popular method for the computation of such FE profiles. However, US can be challenging to implement because the results are dependent on the strength of the biasing potential and the spacing of windows along the reaction coordinate, which, in practice, are usually optimized by an inefficient trial and error approach. The Steered Molecular Dynamics implementation of the Jarzynski Equality (JE-SMD) has been identified as an alternative to equilibrium sampling methods for measuring the FE change across a reaction coordinate. In the JE-SMD approach, equilibrium FE values are evaluated from the average of rapid non-equilibrium trajectories, thus avoiding the practical issues that come with US. Here, we use three different corrections of the JE-SMD method to calculate the FE change for the translocation of two aromatic substrates, phenylalanine and toluene, across a lipid bilayer and compare the accuracy and computational efficiency of these approaches to the results obtained using US. We show evidence that when computing the free energy profile, the JE-SMD approach suffers from insufficient sampling convergence of the bilayer environment and is dependent on the characteristic of the aromatic substrate itself. We deduce that, despite its drawbacks, US remains the more viable approach of the two for computing the FE profile.
REFERENCES
1.
M.
Edidin
, “Lipids on the Frontier: A century of cell-membrane bilayers
,” Nat. Rev. Mol. Cell Biol.
4
, 414
–418
(2003
).2.
D. M.
Engelman
, “Membranes are more mosaic than fluid
,” Nature
438
, 578
–580
(2005
).3.
E.
Awoonor-Williams
and C. N.
Rowley
, “Molecular simulation of nonfacilitated membrane permeation
,” Biochim. Biophys. Acta, Biomembr.
1858
, 1672
–1687
(2016
).4.
M.
Kang
and S. M.
Loverde
, “Molecular simulation of the concentration-dependent interaction of hydrophobic drugs with model cellular membranes
,” J. Phys. Chem. B
118
, 11965
–11972
(2014
).5.
N. J.
Yang
and M. J.
Hinner
, “Getting across the cell membrane: An overview for small molecules, peptides, and proteins
,” Methods Mol. Biol.
1266
, 29
–53
(2015
).6.
S. J.
Marrink
and H. J. C.
Berendsen
, “Permeation process of small molecules across lipid membranes studied by molecular dynamics simulations
,” J. Phys. Chem.
100
, 16729
–16738
(1996
).7.
W.
Shinoda
, “Permeability across lipid membranes
,” Biochim. Biophys. Acta, Biomembr.
1858
, 2254
–2265
(2016
).8.
C.
Neale
and R.
Pomès
, “Sampling errors in free energy simulations of small molecules in lipid bilayers
,” Biochim. Biophys. Acta, Biomembr.
1858
, 2539
–2548
(2016
).9.
R. M.
Venable
, A.
Krämer
, and R. W.
Pastor
, “Molecular dynamics simulations of membrane permeability
,” Chem. Rev.
119
, 5954
–5997
(2019
).10.
T.
Pieńko
and J.
Trylska
, “Computational methods used to explore transport events in biological systems
,” J. Chem. Inf. Model.
59
, 1772
–1781
(2019
).11.
S.-J.
Marrink
and H. J. C.
Berendsen
, “Simulation of water transport through a lipid membrane
,” J. Phys. Chem.
98
, 4155
–4168
(1994
).12.
G. M.
Torrie
and J. P.
Valleau
, “Monte Carlo free energy estimates using non-Boltzmann sampling: Application to the sub-critical Lennard-Jones fluid
,” Chem. Phys. Lett.
28
, 578
–581
(1974
).13.
J.
Shankar
, J. M.
Rosenberg
, D.
Bouzida
, R. H.
Swendson
, and P. A.
Kollman
, “The weighted histogram analysis method for free-energy calculations on biomolecules. I. The method
,” J. Comput. Chem.
13
, 1011
–1021
(1992
).14.
J.
Kästner
, “Umbrella sampling
,” Wiley Interdiscip. Rev.: Comput. Mol. Sci.
1
, 932
–942
(2011
).15.
C.
Jarzynski
, “Nonequilibrium equality for free energy differences
,” Phys. Rev. Lett.
78
, 2690
–2693
(1997
).16.
S.
Park
and K.
Schulten
, “Calculating potentials of mean force from steered molecular dynamics simulations
,” J. Chem. Phys.
120
, 5946
(2004
).17.
R. C.
Lua
and A. Y.
Grosberg
, “Practical applicability of the Jarzynski relation in statistical mechanics: A pedagogical example
,” J. Phys. Chem. B
109
, 6805
–6811
(2005
).18.
T.
Bastug
, P.
Chen
, S. M.
Patra
, and S.
Kuyucak
, “Potential of mean force calculations of ligand binding to ion channels from Jarzynski’s equality and umbrella sampling
,” J. Chem. Phys.
128
, 155104
(2008
).19.
T.
Bastug
and S.
Kuyucak
, “Application of Jarzynski’s equality in simple versus complex systems
,” Chem. Phys. Lett.
436
, 383
–387
(2007
).20.
D.
Collin
, F.
Ritort
, C.
Jarzynski
, S. B.
Smith
, I.
Tinoco
, Jr., and C.
Busamante
, “Verification of the Crooks fluctuation theorem and recovery of RNA folding free energies
,” Nat. Lett.
90
, 231
–234
(1998
).21.
M.
Orsi
and J. W.
Essex
, “Physical properties of mixed bilayers containing lamellar and nonlamellar lipids: Insights from coarse-grain molecular dynamics simulations
,” Faraday Discuss.
161
, 249
–272
(2013
).22.
M.
Orsi
and J. W.
Essex
, “The ELBA force field for coarse-grain modeling of lipid membranes
,” PLoS One
6
, e28637
(2011
).23.
J.
Wang
, R. M.
Wolf
, J. W.
Caldwell
, P. A.
Kollman
, and D. A.
Case
, “Development and testing of a general AMBER force field
,” J. Comput. Chem.
25
, 1157
–1174
(2004
).24.
G.
Landrum
, “RDKit: Open-source cheminformatics
,” Release 2015.09.1: 1105, available at http://www.rdkit.org.25.
N. M.
O’Boyle
, M.
Banck
, C. A.
James
, C.
Morley
, T.
Vandermeersch
, and G. R.
Hutchinson
, “Open Babel: An open chemical toolbox
,” J. Cheminf.
3
, 33
(2011
).26.
S.
Plimpton
, “Fast parallel algorithms for short-range molecular dynamics
,” J. Comput. Phys.
117
, 1
–19
(1995
).27.
M.
Tuckerman
, B. J.
Berne
, and G. J.
Martyna
, “Reversible multiple time scale molecular dynamics
,” J. Chem. Phys.
97
, 1990
(1992
).28.
S.
Genheden
and J. W.
Essex
, “A simple and transferable all-atom/coarse-grained hybrid model to study membrane processes
,” J. Chem. Theory Comput.
11
, 4749
–4759
(2015
).29.
See http://membrane.urmc.rochester.edu/content/wham for WHAM: The weighted histogram analysis method.
30.
J.
Domanski
, G.
Hedger
, R. B.
Best
, P. J.
Stanfield
, and M. S. P.
Sansom
, “Convergence and sampling in determining free energy landscapes for membrane protein association
,” J. Phys. Chem. B
121
, 3364
–3375
(2017
).31.
J.
Gore
, F.
Ritort
, and C.
Bustamante
, “Bias and error in estimates of equilibrium free-energy differences from nonequilibrium measurements
,” Proc. Natl. Acad. Sci. U. S. A.
100
, 12564
–12569
(2003
).32.
X.
Daura
, R.
Affentranger
, and A. E.
Mark
, “On the relative merits of equilibrium and non-equilibrium simulations for the estimation of free-energy differences
,” ChemPhysChem
11
, 3734
–3743
(2010
).33.
W.
Humphrey
, A.
Dalke
, and K.
Schulten
, “VMD—Visual molecular dynamics
,” J. Mol. Graphics
14
, 33
–38
(1996
).34.
Y.
Wang
, P.
Gkeka
, J. E.
Fuchs
, K. R.
Liedl
, and Z.
Cournia
, “DPPC-cholesterol phase diagram using coarse-grained molecular dynamics simulation
,” Biochim. Biophys. Acta, Biomembr.
1858
, 2846
–2857
(2016
).35.
D. P.
Tieleman
, L. R.
Forrest
, M. S. P.
Sansom
, and H. J. C.
Berendsen
, “Lipid properties and the orientation of aromatic residues in OmpF, Influenza M2, Alamethicin systems: Molecular dynamics simulations
,” Biochemistry
37
, 17554
–17561
(1998
).36.
R. J.
Gowers
, M.
Linke
, J.
Barnoud
, T. J. E.
Reddy
, M. N.
Melo
, S. L.
Seyler
, D. L.
Dotson
, J.
Domanski
, S.
Buchoux
, I. M.
Kenney
, and O.
Beckstein
, “MDAnalysis: A Python package for the rapid analysis of molecular dynamics simulations
,” in Proceedings of the 15th Python in Science Conference, edited by S. Benthall and S. Rostrup
(2016
), pp. 98
–105
.37.
N.
Michaud-Agrawal
, E. J.
Denning
, T. B.
Woolf
, and O.
Beckstein
, “MDAnalysis: A toolkit for the analysis of molecular dynamics simulations
,” J. Comput. Chem.
32
, 2319
–2327
(2011
).38.
O.
Berger
, O.
Edholm
, and F.
Jähnig
, “Molecular dynamics simulations of a fluid bilayer of dipalmitoylphosphatidylcholine at full hydration, constant pressure,and constant temperature
,” Biophys. J.
72
, 2002
–2013
(1997
).39.
T. V.
Pogorelov
, J. V.
Vermaas
, M. J.
Arcario
, and E.
Tajkhorshid
, “Partitioning of amino acids into model membrane: Capturing the interface
,” J. Phys. Chem. B
118
, 1481
–1492
(2014
).40.
J. L.
MacCallum
, W. F. D.
Bennett
, and D. P.
Tieleman
, “Distribution of amino acids in a lipid bilayer from computer simulations
,” Biophys. J.
94
, 3393
–3404
(2008
).41.
L.
Monticelli
, S. K.
Kandasamy
, X.
Periole
, R. G.
Larson
, D. P.
Tieleman
, and S.-J.
Marrink
, “The MARTINI coarse-grained force field: Extension to proteins
,” J. Chem. Theory Comput.
4
, 819
–834
(2008
).42.
W.-M.
Yau
, W. C.
Wimley
, K.
Gawrisch
, and S. H.
White
, “The preference of tryptophan for membrane interfaces
,” Biochemistry
37
, 14713
–14718
(1998
).43.
K. E.
Norman
and H.
Nymeyer
, “Indole localization in lipid membranes revealed by molecular simulation
,” Biophys. J.
91
, 2046
–2054
(2006
).44.
Z.
Cao
, Y.
Bian
, G.
Hu
, L.
Zhao
, Z.
Kong
, Y.
Yang
, J.
Wang
, and Y.
Zhou
, “Bias-exchange metadynamics simulation of membrane permeation of 20 amino acids
,” Int. J. Mol. Sci.
19
, 885
(2018
).45.
A.
Kukol
, “Lipid models for united-atom molecular dynamics simulations of proteins
,” J. Chem. Theory Comput.
5
, 615
–626
(2009
).46.
B. L.
Lee
, K.
Kuczera
, C. R.
Middaugh
, and G. S.
Jas
, “Permeation of the three aromatic dipeptides through lipid bilayers: Experimental and computational study
,” J. Chem. Phys.
144
, 245103
(2016
).47.
A. E.
Cardenas
, G. S.
Jas
, K. Y.
DeLeon
, W. A.
Hegefeld
, K.
Kuczera
, and R.
Elber
, “Unassisted transport of N-acetyl-l-tryptophanamide through membrane: Experiment and simulation of kinetics
,” J. Phys. Chem. B
116
, 2739
–2750
(2012
).48.
A.
Warshel
, P. K.
Sharma
, M.
Kato
, and W. W.
Parson
, “Modeling electrostatic effects in proteins
,” Biochim. Biophys. Acta
1764
, 1647
–1676
(2006
).49.
O.
Perisic
and H.
Lu
, “On the improvement of free-energy calculation from steered molecular dynamics simulations using adaptive stochastic perturbation protocols
,” PLoS One
9
, e101810
(2014
).50.
I.
Echeverria
and L. M.
Amzel
, “Estimation of free-energy differences from computed work distributions: An application of Jarzynski’s equality
,” J. Phys. Chem. B
116
, 10986
–10995
(2012
).© 2020 Author(s).
2020
Author(s)
You do not currently have access to this content.
