The Saffman-Delbrück hydrodynamic model for lipid-bilayer membranes is modified to account for the periodic boundary conditions commonly imposed in molecular simulations. Predicted lateral diffusion coefficients for membrane-embedded solid bodies are sensitive to box shape and converge slowly to the limit of infinite box size, raising serious doubts for the prospects of using detailed simulations to accurately predict membrane-protein diffusivities and related transport properties. Estimates for the relative error associated with periodic boundary artifacts are 50% and higher for fully atomistic models in currently feasible simulation boxes. MARTINI simulations of LacY membrane protein diffusion and LacY dimer diffusion in DPPC membranes and lipid diffusion in pure DPPC bilayers support the underlying hydrodynamic model.
REFERENCES
1.
R. B.
Gennis
, Biomembranes: Molecular Structure and Function
(Springer-Verlag
, Berlin
, 1989
).2.
J. B.
Klauda
, R. M.
Venable
, J. A.
Freites
, J. W.
O’Connor
, D. J.
Tobias
, C.
Mondragon-Ramirez
, I.
Vorobyov
, A. D.
MacKerell
, Jr., and R. W.
Pastor
, J. Phys. Chem. B
114
, 7830
(2010
).3.
L.
Rosso
and I. R.
Gould
, J. Comput. Chem.
29
, 24
(2008
).4.
O.
Berger
, O.
Edholm
, and F.
Jähnig
, Biophys. J.
72
, 2002
(1997
).5.
S.
Marrink
, H.
Risselada
, S.
Yefimov
, D.
Tieleman
, and A.
De Vries
, J. Phys. Chem. B
111
, 7812
(2007
).6.
I. R.
Cooke
, K.
Kremer
, and M.
Deserno
, Phys. Rev. E
72
, 011506
(2005
).7.
G.
Brannigan
, L. C.-L.
Lin
, and F. L.
Brown
, Eur. Biophys. J.
35
, 104
(2006
).8.
G.
Guigas
and M.
Weiss
, Biophys. J.
91
, 2393
(2006
).9.
W.
den Otter
and S.
Shkulipa
, Biophys. J.
93
, 423
(2007
).10.
J.
Knight
, M.
Lerner
, J.
Marcano-Velázquez
, R.
Pastor
, and J.
Falke
, Biophys. J.
99
, 2879
(2010
).11.
M.
Chavent
, T.
Reddy
, J.
Goose
, A. C. E.
Dahl
, J. E.
Stone
, B.
Jobard
, and M. S.
Sansom
, Faraday Discuss.
169
, 455
(2014
).12.
J. B.
Klauda
, B. R.
Brooks
, and R. W.
Pastor
, J. Chem. Phys.
125
, 144710
(2006
).13.
E.
Flenner
, J.
Das
, M. C.
Rheinstädter
, and I.
Kosztin
, Phys. Rev. E
79
, 011907
(2009
).14.
T.
Apajalahti
, P.
Niemelä
, P. N.
Govindan
, M. S.
Miettinen
, E.
Salonen
, S.-J.
Marrink
, and I.
Vattulainen
, Faraday Discuss.
144
, 411
(2010
).15.
B.
Dünweg
and K.
Kremer
, J. Chem. Phys.
99
, 6983
(1993
).16.
I.-C.
Yeh
and G.
Hummer
, J. Phys. Chem. B
108
, 15873
(2004
).17.
S.
Kim
and S. J.
Karrila
, Microhydrodynamics: Principles and Selected Applications
(Dover Publications
, 2005
).18.
P. G.
Saffman
and M.
Delbrück
, Proc. Natl. Acad. Sci. U. S. A.
72
, 3111
(1975
).19.
P.
Saffman
, J. Fluid Mech.
73
, 593
(1976
).20.
B. D.
Hughes
, B. A.
Pailthorpe
, and L. R.
White
, J. Fluid Mech.
110
, 349
(1981
).21.
N.
Oppenheimer
and H.
Diamant
, Biophys. J.
96
, 3041
(2009
).22.
D. K.
Lubensky
and R. E.
Goldstein
, Phys. Fluids
8
, 843
(1996
).23.
A. J.
Levine
and F. C.
MacKintosh
, Phys. Rev. E
66
, 061606
(2002
).24.
E. P.
Petrov
and P.
Schwille
, Biophys. J.
94
, L41
(2008
).25.
E. P.
Petrov
, R.
Petrosyan
, and P.
Schwille
, Soft Matter
8
, 7552
(2012
).26.
C.
Peskin
, Acta Numer.
11
, 1
(2002
).27.
P. J.
Atzberger
, Phys. Lett. A
351
, 225
(2006
).28.
B. A.
Camley
and F. L. H.
Brown
, Phys. Rev. E
84
, 021904
(2011
).29.
B.
Dünweg
, J. Chem. Phys.
99
, 6977
(1993
).30.
A. J.
Levine
and T. C.
Lubensky
, Phys. Rev. E
63
, 041510
(2001
).31.
32.
R.
Cortez
, SIAM J. Sci. Comput.
23
, 1204
(2001
).33.
A. J.
Levine
, T. B.
Liverpool
, and F. C.
MacKintosh
, Phys. Rev. E
69
, 021503
(2004
).34.
B. A.
Camley
and F. L.
Brown
, Soft Matter
9
, 4767
(2013
).35.
E.
Noruzifar
, B. A.
Camley
, and F. L.
Brown
, J. Chem. Phys.
141
, 124711
(2014
).37.
J.
Veysey
II and N.
Goldenfeld
, Rev. Mod. Phys.
79
, 883
(2007
).38.
B. A.
Camley
, C.
Esposito
, T.
Baumgart
, and F. L. H.
Brown
, Biophys. J.
99
, L44
(2010
).39.
A. R.
Honerkamp-Smith
, F. G.
Woodhouse
, V.
Kantsler
, and R. E.
Goldstein
, Phys. Rev. Lett.
111
, 038103
(2013
).40.
K.
Weiß
, A.
Neef
, Q.
Van
, S.
Kramer
, I.
Gregor
, and J.
Enderlein
, Biophys. J.
105
, 455
(2013
).41.
W. L.
Vaz
, F.
Goodsaid-Zalduondo
, and K.
Jacobson
, FEBS Lett.
174
, 199
(1984
).42.
Y. A.
Domanov
, S.
Aimon
, G. E.
Toombes
, M.
Renner
, F.
Quemeneur
, A.
Triller
, M. S.
Turner
, and P.
Bassereau
, Proc. Natl. Acad. Sci. U. S. A.
108
, 12605
(2011
).43.
T. J.
Müller
and F.
Müller-Plathe
, ChemPhysChem
10
, 2305
(2009
).44.
S.
Ramadurai
, A.
Holt
, V.
Krasnikov
, G.
Van Den Bogaart
, J.
Killian
, and B.
Poolman
, J. Am. Chem. Soc.
131
, 12650
(2009
).45.
T. T.
Hormel
, S. Q.
Kurihara
, M. K.
Brennan
, M. C.
Wozniak
, and R.
Parthasarathy
, Phys. Rev. Lett.
112
, 188101
(2014
).46.
This brief derivation provides the correct result, but has ignored the forces of constraint associated with the dimer. A rigorous derivation may be found in Section V of Ref. 35.
47.
Y.
Han
, A.
Alsayed
, M.
Nobili
, J.
Zhang
, T.
Lubensky
, and A.
Yodh
, Science
314
, 626
(2006
).48.
L.
Monticelli
, S.
Kandasamy
, X.
Periole
, R.
Larson
, D.
Tieleman
, and S.
Marrink
, J. Chem. Theory Comput.
4
, 819
(2008
).49.
M.
Sansom
, K.
Scott
, and P.
Bond
, Biochem. Soc. Trans.
36
, 27
(2008
).50.
B.
Hess
, C.
Kutzner
, D.
Van Der Spoel
, and E.
Lindahl
, J. Chem. Theory Comput.
4
, 435
(2008
).51.
S.
Nosé
, J. Chem. Phys.
81
, 511
(1984
).52.
W. G.
Hoover
, Phys. Rev. A
31
, 1695
(1985
).53.
M.
Parrinello
and A.
Rahman
, J. Appl. Phys.
52
, 7182
(1981
).54.
D.
Frenkel
and B.
Smit
, Understanding Molecular Simulation: From Algorithms to Applications
(Academic Press
, 2001
), Vol. 1
.55.
S. D.
Stoyanov
and R. D.
Groot
, J. Chem. Phys.
122
, 114112
(2005
).56.
Schroedinger, LLC, The PyMOL Molecular Graphics System, Version 1.4.1, 2011.
57.
In computing these diffusion coefficients, bilayer center of mass motion was removed. Trajectories were converted from GROMACS to CHARMM format, and CHARMM’s correl command was used to calculate MSD curves. Diffusion coefficients were obtained by fitting to the linear portion of the MSD curve.
58.
G. S.
Grest
and K.
Kremer
, Phys. Rev. A
33
, 3628
(1986
).59.
R. D.
Groot
and P. B.
Warren
, J. Chem. Phys.
107
, 4423
(1997
).60.
T.
Soddemann
, B.
Dünweg
, and K.
Kremer
, Phys. Rev. E
68
, 046702
(2003
).61.
W. L.
Vaz
, R. M.
Clegg
, and D.
Hallmann
, Biochemistry
24
, 781
(1985
).62.
F.
Ould-Kaddour
and D.
Levesque
, Phys. Rev. E
63
, 011205
(2000
).63.
J.
Schmidt
and J.
Skinner
, J. Phys. Chem. B
108
, 6767
(2004
).64.
J.
Schmidt
and J.
Skinner
, J. Chem. Phys.
119
, 8062
(2003
).65.
A.
Naji
and F. L.
Brown
, J. Chem. Phys.
126
, 235103
(2007
).66.
A.
Naji
, P.
Atzberger
, and F. L. H.
Brown
, Phys. Rev. Lett.
102
, 138102
(2009
).67.
A.
Naji
, A. J.
Levine
, and P.
Pincus
, Biophys. J.
93
, L49
(2007
).68.
B. A.
Camley
and F. L.
Brown
, Phys. Rev. E
85
, 061921
(2012
).69.
V.
Démery
and D. S.
Dean
, Phys. Rev. E
84
, 011148
(2011
).70.
B. A.
Camley
and F. L.
Brown
, J. Chem. Phys.
141
, 075103
(2014
).71.
Y.
Gambin
, R.
Lopez-Esparza
, M.
Reffay
, E.
Sierecki
, N. S.
Gov
, M.
Genest
, R. S.
Hodes
, and W.
Urbach
, Proc. Natl. Acad. Sci. U. S. A.
103
, 2098
(2006
).72.
Y.
Gambin
, M.
Reffay
, E.
Sierecki
, F.
Homblé
, R. S.
Hodges
, N. S.
Gov
, N.
Taulier
, and W.
Urbach
, J. Phys. Chem. B
114
, 3559
(2010
).73.
A. J.
Levine
and T. C.
Lubensky
, Phys. Rev. E
65
, 011501
(2001
).74.
V.
Prasad
, S.
Koehler
, and E.
Weeks
, Phys. Rev. Lett.
97
, 176001
(2006
).75.
R.
Zwanzig
and M.
Bixon
, Phys. Rev. A
2
, 2005
(1970
).76.
B.
Alder
and T.
Wainwright
, Phys. Rev. A
1
, 18
(1970
).77.
D.
Brune
and S.
Kim
, Proc. Natl. Acad. Sci. U. S. A.
91
, 2930
(1994
).78.
J.
Antosiewicz
and J. A.
McCammon
, Biophys. J.
69
, 57
(1995
).79.
V.
Prasad
and E. R.
Weeks
, Phys. Rev. Lett.
102
, 178302
(2009
).80.
K.
Seki
, S.
Mogre
, and S.
Komura
, Phys. Rev. E
89
, 022713
(2014
).81.
T.
Han
, T. P.
Bailey
, and M.
Haataja
, Phys. Rev. E
89
, 032717
(2014
).82.
R. J.
Hill
and C.-Y.
Wang
, Proc. R. Soc. A
470
, 20130843
(2014
).83.
B. R.
Brooks
, C. L.
Brooks
, A. D.
MacKerell
, L.
Nilsson
, R. J.
Petrella
, B.
Roux
, Y.
Won
, G.
Archontis
, C.
Bartels
, S.
Boresch
et al., J. Comput. Chem.
30
, 1545
(2009
).84.
A.-P.
Hynninen
and M. F.
Crowley
, J. Comput. Chem.
35
, 406
(2014
).85.
P. J.
Atzberger
, P. R.
Kramer
, and C. S.
Peskin
, J. Comput. Phys.
224
, 1255
(2007
).© 2015 AIP Publishing LLC.
2015
AIP Publishing LLC
You do not currently have access to this content.
