Recent use of very small photon beams (down to 4 mm) in stereotactic radiotherapy requires new detectors to accurately determine the delivered dose. Diamond detectors have been presented in the literature as an attractive candidate for this application, due to their small detection volume and the diamond atomic number (Z = 6) which is close to water effective atomic number (Zeff ∼ 7.42). However, diamond exhibits a density 3.51 times greater than that of water and recent studies using Monte Carlo simulations have demonstrated the drawback of a high-density detector on small beam output factors. The current study focuses on geometrical parameters of diamond detector, namely, the diamond dimensions and the electrode geometry, in order to solve the dosimetric issues still observed in small photon beams with diamond detectors. To give better insights to these open questions, we have used both computational method and experimental analysis. This study highlighted that reducing diamond dimensions is crucial for small beam output factor measurements and to limit the influence of its high density. Furthermore, electrodes covering the whole diamond surface were essential for a dose rate independence of the diamond detector. The optimal dosimeter derived from this work presented small diamond dimensions of approximately 1 × 1 × 0.15 mm3, with diamond-like-carbon electrodes covering the whole diamond surface. A dose rate independence of this diamond detector (better than 0.5% over a wide range of dose rates available on a stereotactic dedicated facility) was obtained due to the electrode geometry. Concerning the output factor measurements, a good agreement (better than 1.1%) was observed between this carbon material detector and two types of passive dosimeters (LiF microcubes and EBT2 radiochromic films) for all beam sizes except the smallest field of 0.6 × 0.6 cm2 with a deviation of 2.6%. This new study showed the high performance of this diamond detector in small photon beams, in comparison with various commercially available passive and active dosimeters.
References
1.
Almaviva
, S.
, Cancaglioni
, I.
, Consorti
, R.
, De Notaristefani
, F.
, Manfredotti
, C.
, Marinelli
, M.
, Milani
, E.
, Petrucci
, A.
, Prestopino
, G.
, Verona
, C.
, and Verona-Rinati
, G.
, “Synthetic single crystal diamond dosimeters for intensity modulated radiation therapy applications
,” Nucl. Instrum. Methods Phys. Res., Sect. A
608
, 191
–194
(2009
).2.
Bassinet
, C.
, Huet
, C.
, Derreumaux
, S.
, Brunet
, G.
, Chea
, M.
, Baumann
, M.
, Lacornerie
, T.
, Gaudaire-Josset
, S.
, Trompier
, F.
, Roch
, P.
, Boisserie
, G.
, and Clairand
, I.
, “Small fields output factors measurements and correction factors determination for several detectors for a CyberKnife and linear accelerators equipped with microMLC and circular cones
,” Med. Phys.
40
, 071725
(2013
).3.
Bassinet
, C.
, Robbes
, I.
, Barbier
, L.
, Baumann
, M.
, Kernisant
, B.
, and Trompier
, F.
, “Characterization of 7LiF:Mg,Ti TLD micro-cubes
,” Radiat. Meas.
45
, 646
–648
(2010
).4.
Bergonzo
, P.
, Tromson
, D.
, Descamps
, C.
, Hamrita
, H.
, Mer
, C.
, Tranchant
, N.
, and Nesladek
, M.
, “Improving diamond detectors: A device case
,” Diamond Relat. Mater.
16
, 1038
–1043
(2007
).5.
Betzel
, G. T.
, Lansley
, S. P.
, Baluti
, F.
, Reinisch
, L.
, and Meyer
, J.
, “Clinical investigations of a CVD diamond detector for radiotherapy dosimetry
,” Phys. Med.
28
, 144
–152
(2012
).7.
Bouchard
, H.
, Kamio
, Y.
, Palmans
, H.
, Seuntjens
, J.
, and Duane
, S.
, “Detector dose response in megavoltage small photon beams. II. Pencil beam perturbation effects
,” Med. Phys.
42
, 6048
–6061
(2015b
).6.
Bouchard
, H.
, Seuntjens
, J.
, Duane
, S.
, Kamio
, Y.
, and Palmans
, H.
, “Detector response in megavoltage small photon beams. I. Theoretical concepts
,” Med. Phys.
42
, 6033
–6047
(2015a
).8.
BrainLAB Physics
, Technical Reference Guide Rev 1.0, 2008
.9.
Ciancaglioni
, I.
, Marinelli
, M.
, Milani
, E.
, Prestopino
, G.
, Verona
, C.
, Verona-Rinati
, G.
, Consorti
, R.
, Petrucci
, A.
, and De Notaristefani
, F.
, “Dosimetric characterization of a synthetic single crystal diamond detector in clinical radiation therapy small photon beams
,” Med. Phys.
39
, 4493
–4501
(2012
).10.
Cranmer-Sargison
, G.
, Weston
, S.
, Evans
, J. A.
, Sidhu
, N. P.
, and Thwaites
, D. I.
, “Implementing a newly proposed Monte Carlo based small field dosimetry formalism for a comprehensive set of diode detectors
,” Med. Phys.
38
, 6592
–6
602
(2011
).11.
Das
, I. J.
, Ding
, G. X.
, and Ahnesjö
, A.
, “Small fields: Nonequilibrium radiation dosimetry
,” Med. Phys.
35
, 206
–215
(2008
).12.
De Angelis
, C.
, Onori
, S.
, Pacilio
, M.
, Cirrone
, G. A. P.
, Cuttone
, G.
, Raffaele
, L.
, Bucciolini
, M.
, and Mazzocchi
, S.
, “An investigation of the operating characteristics of two PTW diamond detectors in photon and electron beams
,” Med. Phys.
29
, 248
–254
(2002
).13.
Dzierma
, Y.
, Licht
, N.
, Nuesken
, F.
, and Ruebe
, C.
, “Beam properties and stability of a flattening-filter free 7 MV beam—An overview
,” Med. Phys.
39
, 2595
–2602
(2012
).14.
Eklund
, K.
and Ahnesjö
, A.
, “Spectral perturbations from silicon diode detector encapsulation and shielding in photon fields
,” Med. Phys.
37
, 6055
–6060
(2010
).15.
Fenwick
, J. D.
, Kumar
, S.
, Scott
, A. J.
, and Nahum
, A. E.
, “Using cavity theory to describe the dependence on detector density of dosimeter response in non-equilibrium small fields
,” Phys. Med. Biol.
58
, 2901
–2923
(2013
).16.
Fidanzio
, A.
, Azario
, L.
, Miceli
, R.
, Russo
, A.
, and Piermattei
, A.
, “PTW-diamond detector: dose rate and particle type dependence
,” Med. Phys.
27
, 2589
–2593
(2000
).17.
Fowler
, J. F.
, Radiation Dosimetry
, edited by Attix
, F. H.
and Roesch
, W. C.
(Academic Press
, New York
, 1966
).18.
Francescon
, P.
, Kilby
, W.
, Satariano
, N.
, and Cora
, S.
, “Monte Carlo simulated correction factors for machine specific reference field dose calibration and output factor measurement using fixed and iris collimators on the CyberKnife system
,” Phys. Med. Biol.
57
, 3741
–3758
(2012
).19.
Gagnon
, J. C.
, Thériault
, D.
, Guillot
, M.
, Archambault
, L.
, Beddar
, S.
, Gingras
, L.
, and Beaulieu
, L.
, “Dosimetric performance and array assessment of plastic scintillation detectors for stereotactic radiosurgery quality assurance
,” Med. Phys.
39
, 429
–436
(2012
).20.
Garino
, Y.
, Lo Giudice
, A.
, Manfredotti
, C.
, Marinelli
, M.
, Milani
, E.
, Tucciarone
, A.
, and Verona-Rinati.
, G.
, “Performances of homoepitaxial single crystal diamond in diagnostic x-ray dosimetry
,” Appl. Phys. Lett.
88
, 151901
(2006
).21.
Górka
, G.
, Nilsson
, B.
, Fernández-Varea
, J. M.
, Svensson
, R.
, and Brahme
, A.
, “Influence of electrodes on the photon energy deposition in CVD-diamond dosimeters studied with the Monte Carlo code PENELOPE
,” Phys. Med. Biol.
51
, 3607
–3623
(2006
).22.
Griessbach
, I.
, Lapp
, M.
, Bohsung
, J.
, Gademann
, G.
, and Harder
, D.
, “Dosimetric characteristics of a new unshielded silicon diode and its application in clinical photon and electron beams
,” Med. Phys.
32
, 3750
–3754
(2005
).23.
Hoban
, P. W.
, Heydarian
, M.
, Beckham
, W. A.
, and Beddoe
, A. H.
, “Dose rate dependence of a PTW diamond detector in the dosimetry of a 6 MV photon beam
,” Phys. Med. Biol.
39
, 1219
–1229
(1994
).24.
Huet
, C.
, Dagois
, S.
, Derreumaux
, S.
, Trompier
, F.
, Chenaf
, C.
, and Robbes
, I.
, “Characterization and optimization of EBT2 radiochromic films dosimetry system for precise measurements of output factors in small fields used in radiotherapy
,” Radiat. Meas.
47
, 40
–49
(2012
).25.
Lárraga-Gutiérrez
, J. M.
, Ballesteros-Zebadúa
, P.
, Rodríguez-Ponce
, M.
, García-Garduño
, O. A.
, and de la Cruz
, O. O.
, “Properties of a commercial PTW-60019 synthetic diamond detector for the dosimetry of small radiotherapy beams
,” Phys. Med. Biol.
60
, 905
–924
(2015
).26.
Laub
, W. U.
and Crilly
, R.
, “Clinical radiation therapy measurements with a new commercial synthetic single crystal diamond detector
,” J. Appl. Clin. Med. Phys.
15
, 4890
(2014
).27.
Laub
, W. U.
and Wong
, T.
, “The volume effect of detectors in the dosimetry of small fields used in IMRT
,” Med. Phys.
30
, 341
–347
(2003
).28.
Marsolat
, F.
, Tromson
, D.
, Tranchant
, N.
, Pomorski
, M.
, Lazaro-Ponthus
, D.
, Bassinet
, C.
, Huet
, C.
, Derreumaux
, S.
, Chea
, M.
, Boisserie
, G.
, Alvarez
, J.
, and Bergonzo
, P.
, “Diamond dosimeter for small beam stereotactic radiotherapy
,” Diamond Relat. Mater.
33
, 63
–70
(2013a
).29.
Marsolat
, F.
, Tromson
, D.
, Tranchant
, N.
, Pomorski
, M.
, Le Roy
, M.
, Donois
, M.
, Moignau
, F.
, Ostrowsky
, A.
, De Carlan
, L.
, Bassinet
, C.
, Huet
, C.
, Derreumaux
, S.
, Chea
, M.
, Cristina
, K.
, Boisserie
, G.
, and Bergonzo
, P.
, “A new single crystal diamond dosimeter for small beam: comparison with different commercial active detectors
,” Phys. Med. Biol.
58
, 7647
–7660
(2013b
).30.
Martens
, C.
, De Wagter
, C.
, and De Neve
, W.
, “The value of the PinPoint ion chamber for characterization of small field segments used in intensity-modulated radiotherapy
,” Phys. Med. Biol.
45
, 2519
–2530
(2000
).31.
Mazurier
, J.
, Salvat
, F.
, Chauvenet
, B.
, and Barthe
, J.
, “Simulation of photon beams from a Saturne 43 accelerator using the code PENELOPE
,” Phys. Med.
15
, 101
–110
(1999
).32.
Moignier
, C.
, Huet
, C.
, and Makovicka
, L.
, “Determination of the k((fclin,fmsr)(Qclin,Qmsr)) correction factors for detectors used with an 800 MU/min CyberKnife system equipped with fixed collimators and a study of detector response to small photon beams using a Monte Carlo method
,” Med. Phys.
41
, 071702
(2014
).33.
Morales
, J. E.
, Crowe
, S. B.
, Hill
, R.
, Freeman
, N.
, and Trapp
, J. V.
, “Dosimetry of cone-defined stereotactic radiosurgery fields with commercial synthetic diamond detector
,” Med. Phys.
41
, 111702
(2014
).34.
Pantelis
, E.
, Moutsatsos
, A.
, Zourari
, K.
, Kilby
, W.
, Antypas
, C.
, Papagiannis
, P.
, Karaiskos
, P.
, Georgiou
, E.
, and Sakelliou
, L.
, “On the implementation of a recently proposed dosimetric formalism to a robotic radiosurgery system
,” Med. Phys.
37
, 2369
–2379
(2010
).35.
Pantelis
, E.
, Moutsatsos
, A.
, Zourari
, K.
, Petrokokkinos
, L.
, Sakelliou
, L.
, Kilby
, W.
, Antypas
, C.
, Papagiannis
, P.
, Karaiskos
, P.
, Georgiou
, E.
, and Seimenis
, I.
, “On the output factor measurements of the CyberKnife iris collimator small fields: Experimental determination of the correction factors for microchamber and diode detectors
,” Med. Phys.
39
, 4875
–4885
(2012
).36.
Ralston
, A.
, Liu
, P.
, Warrener
, K.
, McKenzie
, D.
, and Suchowerska
, N.
, “Small field diode correction factors derived using an air core fibre optic scintillation dosimeter and EBT2 film
,” Phys. Med. Biol.
57
, 2587
–2602
(2012
).37.
Ralston
, A.
, Tyler
, M.
, Liu
, P.
, McKenzie
, D.
, and Suchowerska
, N.
, “Over-response of synthetic microdiamond detectors in small radiation fields
,” Phys. Med. Biol.
59
, 5873
–5881
(2014
).38.
Salvat
, F.
, Fernandez-Varea
, J. M.
, and Sempau
, J.
, PENELOPE-2006: A code System for Monte Carlo Simulation of Electron and Photon Transport
(OECD Nuclear Energy Agency
, 2006
).39.
Scherf
, C.
, Peter
, C.
, Moog
, J.
, Licher
, J.
, Kara
, E.
, Zink
, K.
, Rödel
, C.
, and Ramm
, U.
, “Silicon diodes as an alternative to diamond detectors for depth dose curves and profile measurements of photon and electron radiation
,” Strahlenther Onkol.
185
, 530
–536
(2009
).40.
Schirru
, F.
, Kisielewicz
, K.
, Nowak
, T.
, and Marczewska
, B.
, “Single crystal diamond detector for radiotherapy
,” J. Phys. D: Appl. Phys.
43
, 265101
(2010
).41.
Scott
, A. J. D.
, Kumar
, S.
, Nahum
, A. E.
, and Fenwick
, J. D.
, “Characterizing the influence of detector density on dosimeter response in non-equilibrium small photon fields
,” Phys. Med. Biol.
57
, 4461
–4476
(2012
).42.
Scott
, A. J. D.
, Nahum
, A. E.
, and Fenwick
, J. D.
, “Using a Monte Carlo model to predict dosimetric properties of small radiotherapy photon fields
,” Med. Phys.
35
, 4671
–4684
(2008
).43.
Spadaro
, S.
, Conte
, A.
, Pimpinella
, M.
, and Guerra
, A. S.
, “Electrical and dosimetric characterization of a CVD diamond detector with high sensitivity
,” Radiat. Meas.
48
, 1
–6
(2013
).44.
Tranchant
, N.
, Tromson
, D.
, Descamps
, C.
, Isambert
, A.
, Hamrita
, H.
, Bergonzo
, P.
, and Nesladek
, M.
, “High mobility single crystal diamond detectors for dosimetry: Application to radiotherapy
,” Diamond Relat. Mater.
17
, 1297
–1301
(2008
).45.
Tromson
, D.
, Rebisz-Pomorska
, M.
, Tranchant
, N.
, Isambert
, A.
, Moignau
, F.
, Moussier
, A.
, Marczewska
, B.
, and Bergonzo
, P.
, “Single crystal CVD diamond detector for high resolution dose measurement for IMRT and novel radiation therapy needs
,” Diamond Relat. Mater.
19
, 1012
–1016
(2010
).47.
Underwood
, T. S.
, Winter
, H. C.
, Hill
, M. A.
, and Fenwick
, J. D.
, “Detector density and small field dosimetry: Integral versus point dose measurement schemes
,” Med. Phys.
40
, 082102
(2013
).46.
Underwood
, T. S. A.
, Rowland
, B. C.
, Ferrand
, R.
, and Vieillevigne
, L.
, “Application of the Exradin W1 scintillator to determine Ediode 60017 and microDiamond 60019 correction factors for relative dosimetry within small MV and FFF fields
,” Phys. Med. Biol.
60
, 6669
–6683
(2015
).© 2015 AIP Publishing LLC.
2015
AIP Publishing LLC
You do not currently have access to this content.
