Hydrogen will be a crucial pillar in the clean-energy foundation, and therefore, the development of safe and cost-effective storage and transportation methods is essential to its success. One of the key challenges in the development of such storage and transportation methods is related to the interaction of hydrogen with structural materials. Despite extensive work, there are significant questions related to the hydrogen embrittlement of ferritic steels due to challenges associated with these steels, coupled with the difficulties with gauging the hydrogen content in all materials. Recent advancements in experimental tools and multi-scale modeling are starting to provide insight into the embrittlement process. This review focuses on a subset of the recent developments, with an emphasis on how new methods have improved our understanding of the structure–property–performance relationships of ferritic steels subjected to mechanical loading in a hydrogen environment. The structure of ferritic steels in the presence of hydrogen is described in terms of the sorption and dissociation processes, the diffusion through the lattice and grain boundaries, and the hydrogen–steel interactions. The properties of ferritic steels subjected to mechanical loading in hydrogen are also investigated; the effects of test conditions and hydrogen pressure on the tensile, fracture, and fatigue properties of base metal and welds are highlighted. The performance of steels in hydrogen is then explored via a comprehensive analysis of the various embrittlement mechanisms. Finally, recent insights from in situ and high-resolution experiments are presented and future studies are proposed to address challenges related to embrittlement in ferritic steels.
References
1.
B.
Obama
, Science
355
(6321
), 126
(2017
).2.
3.
4.
U. S. Energy Information Administration,
“Monthly Energy Review
,” Report No. DOE/EIA-0035(2020/8)
, May 2019
.5.
T. E.
Mallouk
, Nat. Chem.
5
(5
), 362
(2013
).6.
W. H.
Johnson
, Proc. R. Soc. London
23
(156–163
), 168
(1875
).7.
I. M.
Robertson
, J.
Fenske
, M.
Martin
, M.
Briceno
, M.
Dadfarnia
, P.
Novak
, D. C.
Ahn
, P.
Sofronis
, J. B.
Liu
, and D. D.
Johnson
, in Proceedings of the 2nd International Symposium of Steel Science
, edited by K.
Higashida
and N.
Tsuji
(The Iron and Steel Institute of Japan
, Kyoto, Japan
, 2009
), p. 63
.8.
T.
Michler
, M.
Lindner
, U.
Eberle
, and J.
Meusinger
, in Gaseous Hydrogen Embrittlement of Materials in Energy Technologies
, Vol. 1
: The Problem, its Characterisation and Effects on Particular Alloy Classes, edited by R. P.
Gangloff
and B. P.
Somerday
(Woodhead Publishing
, 2012
), Vol. 1, p. 94
.9.
J.
Volkl
and G.
Alefeld
, in Diffusion in Solids: Recent Developments
, edited by A. S.
Nowick
(Academic Press
, New York
, 1975
), p. 231
.10.
E. S.
Drexler
, J. D.
McColskey
, M.
Dvorak
, N.
Rustagi
, D. S.
Lauria
, and A. J.
Slifka
, Exp. Tech.
40
(1
), 429
(2016
).11.
M.
Connolly
, P.
Bradley
, A.
Slifka
, and E.
Drexler
, Rev. Sci. Instrum.
88
(6
), 063901
(2017
).12.
M.
Connolly
, J.-S.
Park
, P.
Bradley
, D.
Lauria
, A.
Slifka
, and E.
Drexler
, Rev. Sci. Instrum.
89
(6
), 063701
(2018
).13.
G.
McMahon
, B. D.
Miller
, and M. G.
Burke
, npj Mater. Degrad.
2
(1
), 2
(2018
).14.
M. L.
Martin
, J. A.
Fenske
, G. S.
Liu
, P.
Sofronis
, and I. M.
Robertson
, Acta Mater.
59
(4
), 1601
(2011
).15.
M. L.
Martin
, I. M.
Robertson
, and P.
Sofronis
, Acta Mater.
59
(9
), 3680
(2011
).16.
R.
Gemma
, T.
Al-Kassab
, R.
Kirchheim
, and A.
Pundt
, Ultramicroscopy
109
(5
), 631
(2009
).17.
J.
Takahashi
, K.
Kawakami
, Y.
Kobayashi
, and T.
Tarui
, Scr. Mater.
63
(3
), 261
(2010
).18.
American Society of Mechanical Engineers
, Standard: Hydrogen Piping and Pipelines B31.12-2019, 2020
.19.
National Fire Protection Association
, Standard: Hydrogen Technologies Code—NFPA 2, 2020
.20.
M.
Elboujdaini
, in Uhlig's Corrosion Handbook
, edited by R. W.
Revie
(John Wiley and Sons, Inc
., Hoboken, NJ
, 2011
), Vol. 3
, p. 183
.21.
M.
Kermani
, in Hydrogen Transport and Cracking in Metals
(Institute of Materials
, 1995
), p. 1
.22.
E. M.
Moore
and D. R.
Mcintyre
, Mater. Perform.
37
(10
), 77
(1998
).23.
24.
M.
Prager
, Am. Soc. Mech. Eng. Press. Vessels Pip. Div. (Publ.)
411
, 65
(2000
).25.
API Recommended Practice 941: Steels for Hydrogen Service at Elevated Temperatures and Pressures in Petroleum Refineries and Petrochemical Plants (
American-Petroleum-Institute
, 2016
), Vol. 941
, p. 45
.26.
W. L.
Williams
, Corrosion
17
(7
), 340t
(1961
).27.
U. K.
Chatterjee
and R. K.
Singh Raman
, in Stress Corrosion Cracking
, edited by V. S.
Raja
and T.
Shoji
(Woodhead Publishing
, 2011
), p. 169
.28.
W.
Zheng
, M.
Elboujdaini
, and R. W.
Revie
, in Stress Corrosion Cracking
, edited by V. S.
Raja
and T.
Shoji
(Woodhead Publishing
, 2011
), p. 749
.29.
J.
Song
and W. A.
Curtin
, Nat. Mater.
12
(2
), 145
(2013
).30.
M.
Dadfarnia
, P.
Sofronis
, and T.
Neeraj
, Int. J. Hydrogen Energy
36
(16
), 10141
(2011
).31.
R.
Kirchheim
and A.
Pundt
, in Physical Metallurgy
(Elsevier
, 2014
), p. 2597
.32.
C. M.
Ransom
and P. J.
Ficalora
, Metall. Trans. A
11
(5
), 801
(1980
).33.
T.
Wang
, S.
Wang
, Q.
Luo
, Y.-W.
Li
, J.
Wang
, M.
Beller
, and J.
Haijun
, J. Phys. Chem. C
118
(8
), 4181
(2014
).34.
Q.
Liu
, E.
Gray
, J.
Venezuela
, Q.
Zhou
, C.
Tapia‐Bastidas
, M.
Zhang
, and A.
Atrens
, Adv. Eng. Mater.
20
(1
), 1700469
(2017
).35.
J.
Venezuela
, C.
Tapia-Bastidas
, Q.
Zhou
, T.
Depover
, K.
Verbeken
, E.
Gray
, Q.
Liu
, Q.
Liu
, M.
Zhang
, and A.
Atrens
, Corros. Sci.
132
, 90
(2018
).36.
M. R.
Shanabarger
, Surf. Sci.
150
(2
), 451
(1985
).37.
M.
Connolly
, M.
Martin
, R.
Amaro
, A.
Slifka
, and E.
Drexler
, Mater. Sci. Eng., A
753
, 331
(2019
).38.
G.
Ertl
, M.
Huber
, S. B.
Lee
, Z.
Paal
, and M.
Weiss
, Appl. Surf. Sci.
8
(4
), 373
(1981
).39.
G.
Ertl
, S. B.
Lee
, and M.
Weiss
, Surf. Sci.
111
(2
), L711
(1981
).40.
A.
Staykov
, J.
Yamabe
, and B. P.
Somerday
, Int. J. Quantum Chem.
114
(10
), 626
(2014
).41.
R.
Komoda
, M.
Kubota
, A.
Staykov
, P.
Ginet
, F.
Barbier
, and J.
Furtado
, Fatigue Fract. Eng. Mater. Struct.
42
(6
), 1387
(2019
).42.
R.
Komoda
, K.
Yamada
, M.
Kubota
, P.
Ginet
, F.
Barbier
, J.
Furtado
, and L.
Prost
, Int. J. Hydrogen Energy
44
(54
), 29007
(2019
).43.
J. D.
Frandsen
and H. L.
Marcus
, Metall. Trans. A
8
(2
), 265
(1977
).44.
H. G.
Nelson
and J. E.
Stein
, “Gas-phase hydrogen permeation through alpha iron, 4130 steel, and 304 strainless steel from less than 100 C to near 600 C
,” Report No. NASA TN D-7265 (NASA, 1973
).45.
A.
Sieverts
and K.
Brüning
, Arch. Eisenhuttenw.
7
, 641
(1934
).46.
47.
S. X.
Mao
and M.
Li
, J. Mech. Phys. Solids
46
(6
), 1125
(1998
).48.
S.
Taketomi
, R.
Matsumoto
, and N.
Miyazaki
, Acta Mater.
56
(15
), 3761
(2008
).49.
N.
Yazdipour
, A. J.
Haq
, K.
Muzaka
, and E. V.
Pereloma
, Comput. Mater. Sci.
56
, 49
(2012
).50.
J. Q.
Wang
, A.
Atrens
, D. R.
Cousens
, and N.
Kinaev
, J. Mater. Sci.
34
(8
), 1721
(1999
).51.
M. C.
Zhao
, K.
Yang
, F. R.
Xiao
, and Y. Y.
Shan
, Mater. Sci. Eng., A
355
(1–2
), 126
(2003
).52.
I.
Moro
, L.
Briottet
, P.
Lemoine
, E.
Andrieu
, C.
Blanc
, and G.
Odemer
, Mater. Sci. Eng., A
527
(27–28
), 7252
(2010
).53.
J.
Song
and W. A.
Curtin
, Acta Mater.
59
, 1557
(2011
).54.
G. M.
Pressouyre
, Metall. Trans. A
10
(10
), 1571
(1979
).55.
G. M.
Pressouyre
, Acta Metall.
28
(7
), 895
(1980
).56.
G. T.
Park
, S. U.
Koh
, and H. G.
Jung
, Corros. Sci.
50
(7
), 1865
(2008
).57.
W.
Counts
, C.
Wolverton
, and R.
Gibala
, Acta Mater.
58
(14
), 4730
(2010
).58.
A.
Pundt
and R.
Kirchheim
, Annu. Rev. Mater. Res.
36
, 555
(2006
).59.
Y. A.
Du
, L.
Ismer
, J.
Rogal
, T.
Hickel
, J.
Neugebauer
, and R.
Drautz
, Phys. Rev. B
84
(14
), 144121
(2011
).60.
A.
Kimura
and H. K.
Birnbaum
, Acta Metall.
36
(3
), 757
(1988
).61.
T. M.
Harris
and M.
Latanision
, Metall. Trans. A
22
(2
), 351
(1991
).62.
J.
Yao
and J. R.
Cahoon
, Acta Metall. Mater.
39
(1
), 119
(1991
).63.
A.
Oudriss
, J.
Creus
, J.
Bouhattate
, C.
Savall
, B.
Peraudeau
, and X.
Feaugas
, Scr. Mater.
66
(1
), 37
(2012
).64.
M. R.
Louthan
, Jr., J. A.
Donovan
, and G. P.
Caskey
, Jr., Acta Metall.
23
(6
), 745
(1975
).65.
A.
Turnbull
, D. H.
Ferriss
, and H.
Anzai
, Mater. Sci. Eng., A
206
(1
), 1
(1996
).66.
M.
Dadfarnia
, M. L.
Martin
, A.
Nagao
, P.
Sofronis
, and I. M.
Robertson
, J. Mech. Phys. Solids
78
, 511
(2015
).67.
E.
Hayward
and C.-C.
Fu
, Phys. Rev. B
87
(17
), 174103
(2013
).68.
Y.
Tateyama
and T.
Ohno
, Phys. Rev. B
67
(17
), 174105
(2003
).69.
D.
Li
, R. P.
Gangloff
, and J. R.
Scully
, Metall. Mater. Trans. A
35
(3
), 849
(2004
).70.
R.
Walter
and W. T.
Chandler
, “Influence of gaseous hydrogen on metal
,” Final Report No. NASA-CR-124410, 1973
.71.
R. P.
Jewett
, R. J.
Walter
, W. T.
Chandler
, and R. P.
Frohmberg
, “Hydrogen environment embrittlement of metals
,” Report No. CR-2163
, 1973
.72.
H. H.
Chialone
and J. H.
Holbrook
, Sensitivity of Steels to Degradation in Gaseous Hydrogen
(American Society for Testing and Materials
, Philadelphia, PA
, 1988
).73.
M.
Dadfarnia
, P.
Sofronis
, J.
Brouwer
, and S.
Sosa
, Int. J. Hydrogen Energy
44
, 10808
(2019
).74.
C.
San Marchi
and B. P.
Somerday
, “Technical reference on hydrogen compatibility of materials: Plain carbon ferritic steels: C-Mn alloys (code 1100)
,” Report No. SAND2012-7321, 2012
, see http://www.sandia.gov/matlsTechRef/.75.
H.
Barthelemy
, Int. J. Hydrogen Energy
36
, 2750
(2011
).76.
T.
Michler
and J.
Naumann
, Int. J. Hydrogen Energy
35
(2
), 821
(2010
).77.
T.
Doshida
and K.
Takai
, Acta Mater.
79
, 93
(2014
).78.
P. S.
Lam
, R. L.
Sindelar
, and T. M.
Adams
, Proceedings of the ASME Pressure Vessels and Piping Division Conference
(ASME
, 2008
), p. 1
.79.
W.
Hofmann
and W.
Rauls
, Weld. J.
44
(Res. Suppl.
), 225
(1965
).80.
N. E.
Nanninga
, Y. S.
Levy
, E. S.
Drexler
, R. T.
Condon
, A. E.
Stevenson
, and A. J.
Slifka
, Corros. Sci.
59
, 1
(2012
).81.
M.
Wang
, E.
Akiyama
, and K.
Tsukaki
, Mater. Sci. Eng., A
398
, 37
(2005
).82.
R. J.
Walter
and W. T.
Chandler
, Mater. Sci. Eng.
8
, 90
(1971
).83.
P. S.
Lam
, R. L.
Sindelar
, A. J.
Duncan
, and T. M.
Adams
, J. Pressure Vessel Technol.
131
(4
), 0414081
(2009
).84.
ASTM International
, Standard: Standard Test Method for Determining Threshold Stress Intensity Factor for Environment-Assisted Cracking of Metallic Materials, 2013
.85.
K. A.
Nibur
and B. P.
Somerday
, in Gaseous Hydrogen Embrittlement of Materials in Energy Technologies
, Vol. 1
: The Problem, Its Characterisation and Effects on Particular Alloy Classes, edited by R. P.
Gangloff
and B. P.
Somerday
(Woodhead Publishing
, 2012
), Vol. 1, p. 195
.86.
American Society of Mechanical Engineers
, Standard: Boiler and Pressure Vessel Code, 2010
.87.
A. W.
Loginow
and E. H.
Phelps
, J. Eng. Ind.
97
(1
), 274
(1975
).88.
W. W.
Gerberich
and Y.
Chen
, Metall. Trans. A
6
(2
), 271
(1975
).89.
K.
Nibur
, B. P.
Somerday
, D. K.
Balch
, and C.
San Marchi
, Effects of Hydrogen on Materials
(ASM International, 2008
), p. 341
.90.
K.
Nibur
, B.
Somerday
, D.
Balch
, and C.
San Marchi
, in Proceedings of the International Hydrogen Conference on Effects of Hydrogen on Materials
, edited by B.
Somerday
, P.
Sofronis
, and R.
Jones
(ASM International
, 2009
), p. 341
.91.
K. A.
Nibur
, B. P.
Somerday
, C.
San Marchi
, and D. K.
Balch
, in Proceedings of the ASME Pressure Vessels and Piping Conference
(ASME
, 2008
), p. 201
.92.
D.
Stalheim
, T.
Boggess
, D.
Bromley
, S.
Jansto
, and S.
Ningileri
, in Proceedings of the 9th International Pipeline Conference
, edited by (American Society of Mechanical Engineers Digital Collection
, 2012
), p. 275
.93.
Y.
Ogawa
, H.
Matsunaga
, J.
Yamabe
, M.
Yoshikawa
, and S.
Matsuoka
, Int. J. Fatigue
103
, 223
(2017
).94.
D. G.
Stalheim
, T.
Boggess
, C.
San Marchi
, S.
Jansto
, B. P.
Somerday
, G.
Muralidharan
, and P.
Sofronis
, in Proceedings of the International Pipeline Conference
, Calgary, Canada, 27 September–1 October 2010, Paper No. IPC2010-31301.95.
C.
San Marchi
, D. G.
Stalheim
, B. P.
Somerday
, T.
Boggess
, K. A.
Nibur
, and S.
Jansto
, in Proceedings of the ASME Pressure Vessels and Piping Division/K-PVP 2010 Conference
(ASME
, Bellevue, Washington, USA
, 2010
), p. 10
.96.
C.
San Marchi
, D. G.
Stalheim
, B. P.
Somerday
, T.
Boggess
, K. A.
Nibur
, and S.
Jansto
, in Proceedings of the ASME Pressure Vessels and Piping Division/K-PVP 2011 Conference
(ASME
, Baltimore, Maryland, USA
, 2011
), p. 9
.97.
C.
San Marchi
, B. P.
Somerday
, and S. L.
Robinson
, Int. J. Hydrogen Energy
32
(1
), 100
(2007
).98.
G.
Álvarez
, L.
Peral
, C.
Rodríguez
, T.
García
, and F.
Belzunce
, Int. J. Hydrogen Energy
44
(29
), 15634
(2019
).99.
L.
Peral
, A.
Zafra
, C.
Rodríguez
, and J.
Belzunce
, Procedia Struct. Integrity
5
, 1275
(2017
).100.
American Society of Mechanical Engineers
, Standard: ASME B31.12-2019: Hydrogen Piping and Pipelines, 2019
.101.
N.
Nanninga
, A.
Slifka
, Y.
Levy
, and C.
White
, J. Res. Nat. Inst. Stand. Technol.
115
(6
), 437
(2010
).102.
H.
Cialone
and J.
Holbrook
, Metall. Mater. Trans. A
16
(1
), 115
(1985
).103.
R. P.
Wei
and G. W.
Simmons
, in Stress Corrosion Cracking and Hydrogen Embrittlement of Iron Based Alloys
(Unieux-Firminy
, France
, 1973
), p. 751
.104.
S.
Suresh
and R. O.
Ritchie
, Met. Sci.
16
(11
), 529
(1982
).105.
A.
Slifka
, E. S.
Drexler
, R. L.
Amaro
, D. S.
Lauria
, L. E.
Hayden
, D. G.
Stalheim
, and Y.
Chen
, in Proceedings of the ASME Pressure Vessels and Piping Conference
(ASME
, 2014
), Paper No. PVP2014-28938.106.
A. J.
Slifka
, E. S.
Drexler
, R. L.
Amaro
, L. E.
Hayden
, D. G.
Stalheim
, D. S.
Lauria
, and N. W.
Hrabe
, J. Pressure Vessel Technol.
140
, 011407
(2018
).107.
R.
Krishnamurthy
, C.
Marzinsky
, and R.
Gangloff
, in Proceedings of the International Hydrogen Conference
, edited by N. R.
Moody
and A.
Thompson
(TMS-AIME
, 1990
), p. 891
.108.
M.
Carroll
and J.
King
, in Fracture of Engineering Materials and Structures
(Springer
, 1991
), p. 735
.109.
H. J.
Cialone
and J. H.
Holbrook
, in Welding, Failure Analysis, and Metallography
(ASM
, 1985
), p. 407
.110.
J. H.
Holbrook
, “Hydrogen degradation of pipeline steels
,” Report No. BNL 52049 (Battelle Columbus Laboratories
, 1986
).111.
R. L.
Amaro
, R. M.
White
, C. P.
Looney
, E. S.
Drexler
, and A. J.
Slifka
, J. Pressure Vessel Technol.
140
(2
), 021403
(2018
).112.
A. J.
Slifka
, E. S.
Drexler
, N. E.
Nanninga
, Y. S.
Levy
, J. D.
McColskey
, R. L.
Amaro
, and A. E.
Stevenson
, Corros. Sci.
78
, 313
(2014
).113.
J. R.
Ronevich
, C. R.
D'Elia
, and M. R.
Hill
, Eng. Fract. Mech.
194
, 42
(2018
).114.
R. J.
Walter
and W. T.
Chandler
, in Proceedings of the International Conference on Effect of Hydrogen Behavior of Materials
(Metallurgical Society of AIME
, New York
, 1976
), p. 273
.115.
E. S.
Drexler
, A. J.
Slifka
, R. L.
Amaro
, and D. S.
Lauria
, Steely Hydrogen
, edited by L.
Duprez
(OCAS
, 2014
), p. 403
.116.
L.
Peral
, A.
Zafra
, S.
Blasón
, C.
Rodríguez
, and J.
Belzunce
, Int. J. Fatigue
120
, 201
(2019
).117.
J. A.
Ronevich
, B. P.
Somerday
, and C. W.
San Marchi
, Int. J. Fatigue
82
, 497
(2016
).118.
J. J.-A.
Wang
, F.
Ren
, T.
Tan
, and K.
Liu
, Int. J. Hydrogen Energy
40
(4
), 2013
(2015
).119.
E. S.
Drexler
, A. J.
Slifka
, R. L.
Amaro
, J. W.
Sowards
, M. J.
Connolly
, M. L.
Martin
, and D. S.
Lauria
, J. Res. Nat. Inst. Stand.
124
, 124008
(2019
).120.
J. A.
Ronevich
, B. P.
Somerday
, and Z.
Feng
, Int. J. Hydrogen Energy
42
(7
), 4259
(2017
).121.
V.
Olden
, A.
Alvaro
, and O. M.
Akselsen
, Int. J. Hydrogen Energy
37
(15
), 11474
(2012
).122.
E. V.
Chatzidouros
, V. J.
Papazoglou
, T. E.
Tsiourva
, and D. I.
Pantelis
, Int. J. Hydrogen Energy
36
(19
), 12626
(2011
).123.
H. H.
Johnson
, J. G.
Morlet
, and A. R.
Troiano
, Metall. Soc. Am. Inst. Min. Metall. Pet. Eng. Trans.
212
(4
), 528
(1958
).124.
125.
J.
Takahashi
, K.
Kawakami
, and T.
Tarui
, Scr. Mater.
67
(2
), 213
(2012
).126.
M.
Kaneko
, T.
Doshida
, and K.
Takai
, Mater. Sci. Eng., A
674
, 375
(2016
).127.
N.
Abe
, H.
Suzuki
, K.
Takai
, N.
Ishikawa
, and H.
Sueyoshi
, in Proceedings of the Materials Science and Technology Conference and Exhibition
, 16–20 October 2011 (Association for Iron and Steel Technology
, 2011
), p. 1277
.128.
J.-Y.
Lee
and S. M.
Lee
, Surf. Coat. Technol.
28
(3
), 301
(1986
).129.
C. J. J.
McMahon
, in Gaseous Hydrogen Embrittlement of Materials in Energy Technologies
, Vol. 2
: Mechanisms, Modelling and Future Developments, edited by R. P.
Gangloff
and B. P.
Somerday
(Woodhead Publishing
, 2012
), Vol. 2, p. 154
.130.
D. H.
Lassila
and H. K.
Birnbaum
, Acta Metall.
34
(7
), 1237
(1986
).131.
J. A.
Fenske
, I. M.
Robertson
, R.
Ayer
, M.
Hukle
, D.
Lillig
, and B.
Newbury
, Metall. Mater. Trans. A
43
(9
), 3011
(2012
).132.
C. J.
McMahon
, Jr., Eng. Fract. Mech.
68
(6
), 773
(2001
).133.
S.
Wang
, M. L.
Martin
, P.
Sofronis
, S.
Ohnuki
, N.
Hashimoto
, and I. M.
Robertson
, Acta Mater.
69
, 275
(2014
).134.
Y.
Ogawa
, D.
Birenis
, H.
Matsunaga
, O.
Takakuwa
, J.
Yamabe
, Ø.
Prytz
, and A.
Thøgersen
, Mater. Sci. Eng., A
733
, 316
(2018
).135.
S.
Wang
, M. L.
Martin
, I. M.
Robertson
, and P.
Sofronis
, Acta Mater.
107
, 279
(2016
).136.
T.
Neeraj
, R.
Srinivasan
, and J.
Li
, Acta Mater.
60
(13
), 5160
(2012
).137.
E.
Merson
, A. V.
Kudrya
, V. A.
Trachenko
, D.
Merson
, V.
Danilov
, and A.
Vinogradov
, Mater. Sci. Eng., A
665
, 35
(2016
).138.
T. S.
Sudarshan
, D. P.
Harvey
, and T. A.
Place
, Metall. Trans. A
19
(6
), 1547
(1988
).139.
R.
Smith
, G.
Moore
, and R.
Brick
, Mechanical Properties of Metals at Low Temperatures
(U.S. National Bureau of Standards
, 1952
), p. 153
.140.
D. E.
Jiang
and E. A.
Carter
, Acta Mater.
52
(16
), 4801
(2004
).141.
A.
Van der Ven
and G.
Ceder
, Acta Mater.
52
(5
), 1223
(2004
).142.
R. A.
Oriani
and P. H.
Josephic
, Acta Metall.
22
(9
), 1065
(1974
).143.
U.
Komaragiri
, S. R.
Agnew
, R. P.
Gangloff
, and M. R.
Begley
, J. Mech. Phys. Solids
56
(12
), 3527
(2008
).144.
E.
Martínez-Pañeda
, C. F.
Niordson
, and R. P.
Gangloff
, Acta Mater.
117
, 321
(2016
).145.
W. W.
Gerberich
, R. A.
Oriani
, M. J.
Lii
, X.
Chen
, and T.
Foecke
, Philos. Mag. A
63
(2
), 363
(1991
).146.
R. P.
Gangloff
, in Proceedings of the International Hydrogen Conference-Effects of Hydrogen on Materials
, 7–10 September 2008 (ASM International
, 2008
), p. 1
.147.
A.
Tehranchi
and W. A.
Curtin
, Eng. Fract. Mech.
216
, 106502
(2019
).148.
M. L.
Martin
, M.
Dadfarnia
, A.
Nagao
, S.
Wang
, and P.
Sofronis
, Acta Mater.
165
, 734
(2019
).149.
I. M.
Robertson
, P.
Sofronis
, A.
Nagao
, M. L.
Martin
, S.
Wang
, D. W.
Gross
, and K. E.
Nygren
, Metall. Mater. Trans. A
46
(6
), 2323
(2015
).150.
T.
Tabata
and H. K.
Birnbaum
, Scr. Metall.
18
(3
), 231
(1984
).151.
P. J.
Ferreira
, I. M.
Robertson
, and H. K.
Birnbaum
, Acta Mater.
46
(5
), 1749
(1998
).152.
P. J.
Ferreira
, I. M.
Robertson
, and H. K.
Birnbaum
, in Proceedings of the 7th International Conference on Intergranular and Interphase Boundaries in Materials
, 26–29 June 1995 (Trans Tech Publications
, 1985
), p. 93
.153.
H. K.
Birnbaum
and P.
Sofronis
, Mater. Sci. Eng., A
176
(1–2
), 191
(1994
).154.
H.
Matsui
, H.
Kimura
, and S.
Moriya
, Mater. Sci. Eng.
40
(2
), 207
(1979
).155.
A.
Kimura
and H. K.
Birnbaum
, Acta Metall. Mater.
38
(7
), 1343
(1990
).156.
D. J.
Quesnel
, A.
Sato
, and M.
Meshii
, Mater. Sci. Eng.
18
(2
), 199
(1975
).157.
S.
Wang
, N.
Hashimoto
, Y.
Wang
, and S.
Ohnuki
, Acta Mater.
61
(13
), 4734
(2013
).158.
D. P.
Abraham
and C. J.
Altstetter
, Metall. Mater. Trans. A
26
(11
), 2859
(1995
).159.
E.
Sirois
and H. K.
Birnbaum
, Acta Metall. Mater.
40
(6
), 1377
(1992
).160.
161.
M. L.
Martin
, B. P.
Somerday
, R. O.
Ritchie
, P.
Sofronis
, and I. M.
Robertson
, Acta Mater.
60
(6
), 2739
(2012
).162.
M.
Wagih
, Y.
Tang
, T.
Hatem
, and J. A.
El-Awady
, Mater. Res. Lett.
3
(4
), 184
(2015
).163.
M.
Deutges
, H. P.
Barth
, C.
Yuzeng
, C.
Borchers
, and R.
Kirchheim
, Acta Mater.
82
, 266
(2015
).164.
D.
Delafosse
, in Gaseous Hydrogen Embrittlement of Materials in Energy Technologies
, Vol. 2
: Mechanisms, Modelling and Future Developments, edited by R. P.
Gangloff
and B. P.
Somerday
(Woodhead Publishing
, 2012
), Vol. 2, p. 247
.165.
D.
Delafosse
, X.
Feaugas
, I.
Aubert
, N.
Saintier
, and J.
Olive
, Proceedings of the International Hydrogen Conference on Effects of Hydrogen on Materials
, 2008
.166.
K. M.
Bertsch
, S.
Wang
, A.
Nagao
, and I. M.
Robertson
, Mater. Sci. Eng., A
760
, 58
(2019
).167.
C.
Hwang
and I. M.
Bernstein
, Scr. Metall.
17
(11
), 1299
(1983
).168.
G. S.
Frankel
and R. M.
Latanision
, Metall. Trans. A
17
(5
), 869
(1986
).169.
G. S.
Frankel
and R. M.
Latanision
, Metall. Trans. A
17
(5
), 861
(1986
).170.
B.
Ladna
and H. K.
Birnbaum
, Acta Metall.
35
, 1775
(1987
).171.
Y.
Jagodzinski
, H.
Hanninen
, O.
Tarasenko
, and S.
Smuk
, Scr. Mater.
43
(3
), 245
(2000
).172.
R.
Kirchheim
and J. P.
Hirth
, Scr. Metall.
16
(4
), 475
(1982
).173.
J.
Von Pezold
, L.
Lymperakis
, and J.
Neugebeauer
, Acta Mater.
59
, 2969
(2011
).174.
M.
Nagumo
and K.
Takai
, Acta Mater.
165
, 722
(2019
).175.
M.
Nagumo
, K.
Ohta
, and H.
Saitoh
, Scr. Mater.
40
, 313
(1999
).176.
A.
Oudriss
, J.
Creus
, J.
Bouhattate
, E.
Conforto
, C.
Berziou
, C.
Savall
, and X.
Feaugas
, Acta Mater.
60
(19
), 6814
(2012
).177.
T.
Doshida
, M.
Nakamura
, H.
Saito
, T.
Sawada
, and K.
Takai
, Acta Mater.
61
(20
), 7755
(2013
).178.
R.
Kirchheim
, Acta Mater.
55
(15
), 5129
(2007
).179.
K.
Saito
, T.
Hirade
, and K.
Takai
, Metall. Mater. Trans. A
50
(11
), 5091
(2019
).180.
K.
Sakaki
, T.
Kawase
, M.
Hirato
, M.
Mizuno
, H.
Araki
, Y.
Shirai
, and M.
Nagumo
, Scr. Mater.
55
(11
), 1031
(2006
).181.
S.
Li
, Y.
Li
, Y.-C.
Lo
, T.
Neeraj
, R.
Srinivasan
, X.
Ding
, J.
Sun
, L.
Qi
, P.
Gumbsch
, and J.
Li
, Int. J. Plast.
74
, 175
(2015
).182.
A.
Tehranchi
, X.
Zhang
, G.
Lu
, and W. A.
Curtin
, Modell. Simul. Mater. Sci. Eng.
25
(2
), 025001
(2016
).183.
S.
Gahr
, B. J.
Makenas
, and H. K.
Birnbaum
, Acta Metall.
28
(9
), 1207
(1980
).184.
S.
Takano
and T.
Suzuki
, Acta Metall.
22
(3
), 265
(1974
).185.
G.
Bertolino
, G.
Meyer
, and J. P.
Ipina
, in Proceedings of the International Symposium on Metal-Hydrogen Systems, Fundamentals and Applications (MH)
, 1–6 October 2000 (Elsevier
, 2000
), p. 408
.186.
R.
Dutton
, K.
Nuttall
, M. P.
Puls
, and L. A.
Simpson
, Metall. Trans. A
8
(10
), 1553
(1977
).187.
D. S.
Shih
, I. M.
Robertson
, and H. K.
Birnbaum
, Acta Metall.
36
(1
), 111
(1988
).188.
K. S.
Chan
, Acta Metall. Mater.
43
(12
), 4325
(1995
).189.
M. L.
Wayman
and G. C.
Smith
, J. Phys. Chem. Solids
32
(1
), 103
(1971
).190.
M. L.
Wayman
and G. C.
Smith
, Acta Metall.
19
(3
), 227
(1971
).191.
S.
Bechtle
, M.
Kumar
, B. P.
Somerday
, M. E.
Launey
, and R. O.
Ritchie
, Acta Mater.
57
(14
), 4148
(2009
).192.
J. V.
Badding
, R. J.
Hemley
, and H. K.
Mao
, Science
253
(5018
), 421
(1991
).193.
P.
Rozenak
and D.
Eliezer
, Acta Metall.
35
(9
), 2329
(1987
).194.
D. P.
Abraham
and C. J.
Altstetter
, Metall. Mater. Trans. A
26
(11
), 2849
(1995
).195.
H.
Matsunaga
and H.
Noda
, Metall. Mater. Trans. A
42
(9
), 2696
(2011
).196.
B.
An
, H.
Itouga
, T.
Iijima
, C.
San Marchi
, and B.
Somerday
, in Proceedings of the Pressure Vessels and Piping Conference
(ASME
, 2013
).197.
M.
Koyama
, S.
Okazaki
, T.
Sawaguchi
, and K.
Tsuzaki
, Metall. Mater. Trans. A
47
(6
), 2656
(2016
).198.
R.
Kirchheim
, Int. J. Mater. Res.
100
(4
), 483
(2009
).199.
R.
Kirchheim
, Scr. Mater.
62
(2
), 67
(2010
).200.
E.
Tal-Gutelmacher
, R.
Gemma
, C. A.
Volkert
, and R.
Kirchheim
, Scr. Mater.
63
(10
), 1032
(2010
).201.
R.
Kirchheim
, Acta Mater.
55
(15
), 5139
(2007
).202.
W.
Gerberich
, D.
Stauffer
, and P.
Sofronis
, Effects of Hydrogen on Materials
(ASM International
, Materials Park, OH
, 2009
), p. 38
.203.
M. B.
Djukic
, G. M.
Bakic
, V.
Sijacki Zeravcic
, A.
Sedmak
, and B.
Rajicic
, Eng. Fract. Mech.
216
, 106528
(2019
).204.
P.
Novak
, R.
Yuan
, B. P.
Somerday
, P.
Sofronis
, and R. O.
Ritchie
, J. Mech. Phys. Solids
58
(2
), 206
(2010
).205.
J.
Kacher
and I. M.
Robertson
, Acta Mater.
60
(19
), 6657
(2012
).206.
L.
Wan
, W. T.
Geng
, A.
Ishii
, J.-P.
Du
, Q.
Mei
, N.
Ishikawa
, H.
Kimizuka
, and S.
Ogata
, Int. J. Plast.
112
, 206
(2019
).207.
A.
Nagao
, C. D.
Smith
, M.
Dadfarnia
, P.
Sofronis
, and I. M.
Robertson
, Acta Mater.
60
(13
), 5182
(2012
).208.
A.
Nagao
, M. L.
Martin
, M.
Dadfarnia
, P.
Sofronis
, and I. M.
Robertson
, Acta Mater.
74
, 244
(2014
).209.
A.
Nagao
, M.
Dadfarnia
, B. P.
Somerday
, P.
Sofronis
, and R. O.
Ritchie
, J. Mech. Phys. Solids
112
, 403
(2018
).210.
P. P.
Darcis
, J.
McColskey
, A.
Lasseigne
, and T.
Siewert
, in Proceedings of the International Hydrogen Conference–Effects of Hydrogen on Materials
, 7–10 September 2008 (ASM International Jackson
, WY
, 2008
), p. 381
.211.
M.
Koyama
, M.
Rohwerder
, C. C.
Tasan
, A.
Bashir
, E.
Akiyama
, K.
Takai
, D.
Raabe
, and K.
Tsuzaki
, Mater. Sci. Technol.
33
(13
), 1481
(2017
).212.
G.
Sundell
, M.
Thuvander
, and H. O.
Andrén
, Ultramicroscopy
132
, 285
(2013
).213.
W. Y.
Choo
and J. Y.
Lee
, Metall. Trans. A
13
(1
), 135
(1982
).214.
J.
Yao
and J. R.
Cahoon
, Metall. Trans. A
21
(2
), 603
(1990
).215.
J.
Ovejero-García
, J. Mater. Sci.
20
(7
), 2623
(1985
).216.
K.
Beyer
, T.
Kannengiesser
, A.
Griesche
, and B.
Schillinger
, J. Mater. Sci.
46
(15
), 5171
(2011
).217.
P.
Withers
, Philos. Trans. R. Soc. A
373
(2036
), 20130157
(2015
).218.
B. J.
Heuser
, D. R.
Trinkle
, N.
Jalarvo
, J.
Serio
, E. J.
Schiavone
, E.
Mamontov
, and M.
Tyagi
, Phys. Rev. Lett.
113
(2
), 025504
(2014
).219.
A.
Griesche
, E.
Dabah
, and T.
Kannengießer
, Can. Metall. Q.
54
(1
), 38
(2015
).220.
M. L.
Martin
, P.
Sofronis
, I. M.
Robertson
, T.
Awane
, and Y.
Murakami
, Int. J. Fatigue
57
, 28
(2013
).221.
S.
Wang
, K. E.
Nygren
, A.
Nagao
, P.
Sofronis
, and I. M.
Robertson
, Scr. Mater.
166
, 102
(2019
).222.
N.
Kheradmand
, H.
Vehoff
, and A.
Barnoush
, Acta Mater.
61
(19
), 7454
(2013
).223.
Y.
Deng
, B. R. S.
Rogne
, and A.
Barnoush
, Eng. Fract. Mech.
217
, 106551
(2019
).224.
M.
Asadipoor
, A.
Pourkamali Anaraki
, J.
Kadkhodapour
, S. M. H.
Sharifi
, and A.
Barnoush
, Mater. Sci. Eng., A
772
, 138762
(2020
).225.
C.
Senöz
, S.
Evers
, M.
Stratmann
, and M.
Rohwerder
, Electrochem. Commun.
13
(12
), 1542
(2011
).226.
M. A. V.
Devanathan
, Z.
Stachurski
, and F. C.
Tompkins
, Proc. R. Soc. London, Ser. A
270
(1340
), 90
(1962
).227.
M. A. V.
Devanathan
, Z.
Stachurski
, and W.
Beck
, J. Electrochem. Soc.
110
(8
), 886
(1963
).228.
S.
Evers
, C.
Senöz
, and M.
Rohwerder
, Sci. Technol. Adv. Mater.
14
(1
), 014201
(2013
).229.
W.
Krieger
, S. V.
Merzlikin
, A.
Bashir
, A.
Szczepaniak
, H.
Springer
, and M.
Rohwerder
, Acta Mater.
144
, 235
(2018
).230.
K.
Takai
, J.
Seki
, and Y.
Homma
, Mater. Trans., JIM
36
(9
), 1134
(1995
).231.
G. B.
Wood
, J. Electrochem. Soc.
110
(8
), 867
(1963
).232.
K.
Takai
, Y.
Chiba
, K.
Noguchi
, and A.
Nozue
, Metall. Mater. Trans. A
33
(8
), 2659
(2002
).233.
A.
Nishimoto
, M.
Koyama
, S.
Yamato
, Y.
Oda
, T.
Awane
, and H.
Noguchi
, ISIJ Int.
55
(1
), 335
(2015
).234.
O.
Sobol
, G.
Holzlechner
, G.
Nolze
, T.
Wirth
, D.
Eliezer
, T.
Boellinghaus
, and W. E. S.
Unger
, Mater. Sci. Eng., A
676
, 271
(2016
).235.
G.
McMahon
, B. D.
Miller
, and M. G.
Burke
, Int. J. Hydrogen Energy
45
, 20042
(2020
).236.
M.
Miller
and R.
Forbes
, Atom Probe Tomography: The Local Electrode Atom Probe
(Springer
, 2014
).237.
F.
Kurosawa
and T.
Akimoto
, J. Jpn. Inst. Met.
71
(8
), 641
(2007
).238.
J.
Takahashi
, K.
Kawakami
, and Y.
Kobayashi
, Acta Mater.
153
, 193
(2018
).239.
K.
Kawakami
and T.
Matsumiya
, ISIJ Int.
52
(9
), 1693
(2012
).240.
Y.-S.
Chen
, D.
Haley
, S. S. A.
Gerstl
, A. J.
London
, F.
Sweeney
, R. A.
Wepf
, W. M.
Rainforth
, P. A. J.
Bagot
, and M. P.
Moody
, Science
355
(6330
), 1196
(2017
).241.
B.
Malard
, B.
Remy
, C.
Scott
, A.
Deschamps
, J.
Chêne
, T.
Dieudonné
, and M. H.
Mathon
, Mater. Sci. Eng., A
536
, 110
(2012
).242.
M.
Ohnuma
, J.-I.
Suzuki
, F.-G.
Wei
, and K.
Tsuzaki
, Scr. Mater.
58
(2
), 142
(2008
).243.
Y.-S.
Chen
, H.
Lu
, J.
Liang
, A.
Rosenthal
, H.
Liu
, G.
Sneddon
, I.
McCarroll
, Z.
Zhao
, W.
Li
, A.
Guo
, and J. M.
Cairney
, Science
367
(6474
), 171
(2020
).244.
M. G.
Burke
and J. J. H.
Lim
, Microsc. Microanal.
25
(S2
), 2264
(2019
).245.
M.
Herbig
, D.
Raabe
, Y. J.
Li
, P.
Choi
, S.
Zaefferer
, and S.
Goto
, Phys. Rev. Lett.
112
(12
), 126103
(2014
).2020
U.S. Government
You do not currently have access to this content.