By comparing femtosecond laser-pulse-induced spin dynamics in the surface state of the rare earth metals Gd and Tb, we show that the spin polarization of valence states in both materials decays with significantly different time constants of 15 ps and 400 fs, respectively. The distinct spin polarization dynamics in Gd and Tb are opposed by similar exchange splitting dynamics in the two materials. The different time scales observed in our experiment can be attributed to weak and strong 4f spin to lattice coupling in Gd and Tb, suggesting an intimate coupling of spin polarization and 4f magnetic moment. While in Gd the lattice mainly acts as a heat sink, it contributes significantly to ultrafast demagnetization of Tb. This helps explain why all optical switching is observed in FeGd—but rarely in FeTb-based compounds.
References
1.
A.
Kirilyuk
, A. V.
Kimel
, and T.
Rasing
, “Ultrafast optical manipulation of magnetic order
,” Rev. Mod. Phys.
82
, 2731
–2764
(2010
).2.
A. V.
Kimel
and M.
Li
, “Writing magnetic memory with ultrashort light pulses
,” Nat. Rev. Mater.
4
, 189
(2019
).3.
C. D.
Stanciu
, F.
Hansteen
, A. V.
Kimel
, A.
Kirilyuk
, A.
Tsukamoto
, A.
Itoh
, and T.
Rasing
, “All-optical magnetic recording with circularly polarized light
,” Phys. Rev. Lett.
99
, 047601
(2007
).4.
M. L. M.
Lalieu
, M. J. G.
Peeters
, S. R. R.
Haenen
, R.
Lavrijsen
, and B.
Koopmans
, “Deterministic all-optical switching of synthetic ferrimagnets using single femtosecond laser pulses
,” Phys. Rev. B
96
, 220411
(2017
).5.
S.
Mangin
, M.
Gottwald
, C.-H.
Lambert
, D.
Steil
, V.
Uhlír
, L.
Pang
, M.
Hehn
, S.
Alebrand
, M.
Cinchetti
, G.
Malinowski
, Y.
Fainman
, M.
Aeschlimann
, and E. E.
Fullerton
, “Engineered materials for all-optical helicity-dependent magnetic switching
,” Nat. Mater.
13
, 286
(2014
).6.
M. S.
El Hadri
, P.
Pirro
, C.-H.
Lambert
, S.
Petit-Watelot
, Y.
Quessab
, M.
Hehn
, F.
Montaigne
, G.
Malinowski
, and S.
Mangin
, “Two types of all-optical magnetization switching mechanisms using femtosecond laser pulses
,” Phys. Rev. B
94
, 064412
(2016
).7.
T. A.
Ostler
, J.
Barker
, R. F. L.
Evans
, R. W.
Chantrell
, U.
Atxitia
, O.
Chubykalo-Fesenko
, S. E.
Moussaoui
, L. L.
Guyader
, E.
Mengotti
, L. J.
Heyderman
, F.
Nolting
, A.
Tsukamoto
, A.
Itoh
, D.
Afanasiev
, B. A.
Ivanov
, A. M.
Kalashnikova
, K.
Vahaplar
, J.
Mentink
, A.
Kirilyuk
, T.
Rasing
, and A. V.
Kimel
, “Ultrafast heating as a sufficient stimulus for magnetization reversal in a ferrimagnet
,” Nat. Commun.
3
, 666
(2012
).8.
M.
Beens
, M. L. M.
Lalieu
, A. J. M.
Deenen
, R. A.
Duine
, and B.
Koopmans
, “Comparing all-optical switching in synthetic-ferrimagnetic multilayers and alloys
,” Phys. Rev. B
100
, 220409
(2019
).9.
T. M.
Liu
, T.
Wang
, A. H.
Reid
, M.
Savoini
, X.
Wu
, B.
Koene
, P.
Granitzka
, C. E.
Graves
, D. J.
Higley
, Z.
Chen
, G.
Razinskas
, M.
Hantschmann
, A.
Scherz
, J.
Stöhr
, A.
Tsukamoto
, B.
Hecht
, A. V.
Kimel
, A.
Kirilyuk
, T.
Rasing
, and H. A.
Dürr
, “Nanoscale confinement of all-optical magnetic switching in TbFeCo–competition with nanoscale heterogeneity
,” Nano Lett.
15
, 6862
–6868
(2015
).10.
L.
Avilés-Félix
, A.
Olivier
, L.
Álvaro-Gómez
, M.
Rubio-Roy
, S.
Auffret
, A.
Kirilyuk
, A. V.
Kimel
, T.
Rasing
, R. C.
Sousa
, B.
Dieny
, and I. L.
Prejbeanu
, “Single-shot all-optical switching of magnetization in Tb/Co multilayer-based electrodes
,” Sci. Rep.
10
, 5211
(2020
).11.
A. R.
Khorsand
, M.
Savoini
, A.
Kirilyuk
, A. V.
Kimel
, A.
Tsukamoto
, A.
Itoh
, and T.
Rasing
, “Element-specific probing of ultrafast spin dynamics in multisublattice magnets with visible light
,” Phys. Rev. Lett.
110
, 107205
(2013
).12.
J. H.
Mentink
, J.
Hellsvik
, D. V.
Afanasiev
, B. A.
Ivanov
, A.
Kirilyuk
, A. V.
Kimel
, O.
Eriksson
, M. I.
Katsnelson
, and T.
Rasing
, “Ultrafast spin dynamics in multisublattice magnets
,” Phys. Rev. Lett.
108
, 057202
(2012
).13.
S.
Wienholdt
, D.
Hinzke
, K.
Carva
, P. M.
Oppeneer
, and U.
Nowak
, “Orbital-resolved spin model for thermal magnetization switching in rare-earth-based ferrimagnets
,” Phys. Rev. B
88
, 020406
(2013
).14.
C.
Davies
, T.
Janssen
, J.
Mentink
, A.
Tsukamoto
, A.
Kimel
, A.
van der Meer
, A.
Stupakiewicz
, and A.
Kirilyuk
, “Pathways for single-shot all-optical switching of magnetization in ferrimagnets
,” Phys. Rev. Appl.
13
, 024064
(2020
).15.
B.
Frietsch
, J.
Bowlan
, R.
Carley
, M.
Teichmann
, S.
Wienholdt
, D.
Hinzke
, U.
Nowak
, K.
Carva
, P. M.
Oppeneer
, and M.
Weinelt
, “Disparate ultrafast dynamics of itinerant and localized magnetic moments in gadolinium metal
,” Nat. Commun.
6
, 8262
(2015
).16.
B.
Andres
, M.
Christ
, C.
Gahl
, M.
Wietstruk
, M.
Weinelt
, and J.
Kirschner
, “Separating exchange splitting from spin mixing in gadolinium by femtosecond laser excitation
,” Phys. Rev. Lett.
115
, 207404
(2015
).17.
B.
Frietsch
, A.
Donges
, R.
Carley
, M.
Teichmann
, J.
Bowlan
, K.
Döbrich
, K.
Carva
, D.
Legut
, P. M.
Oppeneer
, U.
Nowak
, and M.
Weinelt
, “The role of ultrafast magnon generation in the magnetization dynamics of rare-earth metals
,” Sci. Adv.
6
, eabb1601
(2020
).18.
A.
Winkelmann
, D.
Hartung
, H.
Engelhard
, C.-T.
Chiang
, and J.
Kirschner
, “High efficiency electron spin polarization analyzer based on exchange scattering at Fe/W(001)
,” Rev. Sci. Instrum.
79
, 083303
(2008
).19.
K.
Zakeri
, T.
Peixoto
, Y.
Zhanga
, J.
Prokopa
, and J.
Kirschner
, “On the preparation of clean tungsten single crystals
,” Surf. Sci.
604
, L1
–L3
(2010
).20.
(), it is generally possible to populate the unoccupied minority-spin component of the surface state with the pump pulse and ionize it with a second laser pulse in two-photon photoemission. Nevertheless, such a two-photon photoemission measurement yields count rates at least a factor of thousand lower compared to direct photoemission. Thus, we can assume that our data analysis of the occupied majority-spin surface state measured in direct photoemission is not compromised by any two-photon photoemission contribution of the unoccupied minority-spin surface state component.
21.
B.
Liu
, H.
Xiao
, G.
Siemann
, J.
Weber
, B.
Andres
, W.
Bronsch
, P. M.
Oppeneer
, and M.
Weinelt
, “Signature of magnon polarons in electron relaxation on terbium revealed by comparison with gadolinium
,” Phys. Rev. B
104
, 024434
(2021
).22.
A.
Eschenlohr
, M.
Sultan
, A.
Melnikov
, N.
Bergeard
, J.
Wieczorek
, T.
Kachel
, C.
Stamm
, and U.
Bovensiepen
, “Role of spin-lattice coupling in the ultrafast demagnetization of Gd1−xTbx alloys
,” Phys. Rev. B
89
, 214423
(2014
).23.
U.
Bovensiepen
, “Coherent and incoherent excitations of the Gd(0001) surface on ultrafast timescales
,” J. Phys.: Condens. Matter
19
, 083201
(2007
).24.
M.
Lisowski
, P. A.
Loukakos
, A.
Melnikov
, I.
Radu
, L.
Ungureanu
, M.
Wolf
, and U.
Bovensiepen
, “Femtosecond electron and spin dynamics in Gd(0001) studied by time-resolved photoemission and magneto-optics
,” Phys. Rev. Lett.
95
, 137402
(2005
).25.
M.
Bode
, M.
Getzlaff
, A.
Kubetzka
, R.
Pascal
, O.
Pietzsch
, and R.
Wiesendanger
, “Temperature-dependent exchange splitting of a surface state on a local-moment magnet: Tb(0001)
,” Phys. Rev. Lett.
83
, 3017
–3020
(1999
).26.
(), we assume that electronic diffusion processes are happening within the timescale of our laser pulses and are thus not distinguishable from the excitation process in our experiment.
27.
S. I.
Anisimov
, B. L.
Kapeliovich
, and T. L.
Perel'man
, “Electron emission from metal surfaces exposed to ultrashort laser pulses
,” Zh. Éksp. Teor. Fiz.
66
, 776
(1974
).28.
A.
Melnikov
, A.
Povolotskiy
, and U.
Bovensiepen
, “Magnon-enhanced phonon damping at Gd(0001) and Tb(0001) surfaces using femtosecond time-resolved optical second-harmonic generation
,” Phys. Rev. Lett.
100
, 247401
(2008
).29.
R.
Carley
, K.
Döbrich
, B.
Frietsch
, C.
Gahl
, M.
Teichmann
, O.
Schwarzkopf
, P.
Wernet
, and M.
Weinelt
, “Femtosecond laser excitation drives ferromagnetic gadolinium out of magnetic equilibrium
,” Phys. Rev. Lett.
109
, 057401
(2012
).30.
M.
Teichmann
, B.
Frietsch
, K.
Döbrich
, R.
Carley
, and M.
Weinelt
, “Transient band structures in the ultrafast demagnetization of ferromagnetic gadolinium and terbium
,” Phys. Rev. B
91
, 014425
(2015
).31.
M.
Wietstruk
, A.
Melnikov
, C.
Stamm
, T.
Kachel
, N.
Pontius
, M.
Sultan
, C.
Gahl
, M.
Weinelt
, H. A.
Dürr
, and U.
Bovensiepen
, “Hot-electron-driven enhancement of spin-lattice coupling in Gd and Tb 4f ferromagnets observed by femtosecond X-ray magnetic circular dichroism
,” Phys. Rev. Lett.
106
, 127401
(2011
).32.
J.
Jensen
, “Magneto-elastic interaction in terbium
,” Intern. J. Magn.
1
, 271
–275
(1971
).33.
S.
Rex
, V.
Eyert
, and W.
Nolting
, “Temperature-dependent quasiparticle bandstructure of ferromagnetic gadolinium
,” J. Magn. Magn. Mater.
192
, 529
–542
(1999
).34.
L. M.
Sandratskii
, “Exchange splitting of surface and bulk electronic states in excited magnetic states of Gd: First-principles study
,” Phys. Rev. B
90
, 184406
(2014
).35.
C. E.
Graves
, A. H.
Reid
, T.
Wang
, B.
Wu
, S.
de Jong
, K.
Vahaplar
, I.
Radu
, D. P.
Bernstein
, M.
Messerschmidt
, L.
Müller
, R.
Coffee
, M.
Bionta
, S. W.
Epp
, R.
Hartmann
, N.
Kimmel
, G.
Hauser
, A.
Hartmann
, P.
Holl
, H.
Gorke
, J. H.
Mentink
, A.
Tsukamoto
, A.
Fognini
, J. J.
Turner
, W. F.
Schlotter
, D.
Rolles
, H.
Soltau
, L.
Strüder
, Y.
Acremann
, A. V.
Kimel
, A.
Kirilyuk
, T.
Rasing
, J.
Stöhr
, A. O.
Scherz
, and H. A.
Dürr
, “Nanoscale spin reversal by non-local angular momentum transfer following ultrafast laser excitation in ferrimagnetic GdFeCo
,” Nat. Mater.
12
, 293
–297
(2013
).36.
N.
Thielemann-Kühn
, D.
Schick
, N.
Pontius
, C.
Trabant
, R.
Mitzner
, K.
Holldack
, H.
Zabel
, A.
Föhlisch
, and C.
Schüßler-Langeheine
, “Ultrafast and energy-efficient quenching of spin order: Antiferromagnetism beats ferromagnetism
,” Phys. Rev. Lett.
119
, 197202
(2017
).37.
C.
Dornes
, Y.
Acremann
, M.
Savoini
, M.
Kubli
, M. J.
Neugebauer
, E.
Abreu
, L.
Huber
, G.
Lantz
, C. A. F.
Vaz
, H.
Lemke
, E. M.
Bothschafter
, M.
Porer
, V.
Esposito
, L.
Rettig
, M.
Buzzi
, A.
Alberca
, Y. W.
Windsor
, P.
Beaud
, U.
Staub
, D.
Zhu
, S.
Song
, J. M.
Glownia
, and S. L.
Johnson
, “The ultrafast Einstein-De Haas effect
,” Nature
565
, 209
–212
(2019
).38.
J.
Gorchon
, C.-H.
Lambert
, Y.
Yang
, A.
Pattabi
, R. B.
Wilson
, S.
Salahuddin
, and J.
Bokor
, “Single shot ultrafast all optical magnetization switching of ferromagnetic Co/Pt multilayers
,” Appl. Phys. Lett.
111
, 042401
(2017
).39.
J.
Igarashi
, Q.
Remy
, S.
Iihama
, G.
Malinowski
, M.
Hehn
, J.
Gorchon
, J.
Hohlfeld
, S.
Fukami
, H.
Ohno
, and S.
Mangin
, “Engineering single-shot all-optical switching of ferromagnetic materials
,” Nano Lett.
20
, 8654
–8660
(2020
).40.
C.
Banerjee
, N.
Teichert
, K. E.
Siewierska
, Z.
Gercsi
, G. Y. P.
Atcheson
, P.
Stamenov
, K.
Rode
, J. M. D.
Coey
, and J.
Besbas
, “Single pulse all-optical toggle switching of magnetization without gadolinium in the ferrimagnet Mn2RuxGa
,” Nat. Commun.
11
, 4444
(2020
).© 2021 Author(s). Published under an exclusive license by AIP Publishing.
2021
Author(s)
You do not currently have access to this content.
