We describe a multi-messenger interpretation of GW170817, which yields a robust lower limit on NS radii. This excludes NSs with radii smaller than about 10.7 km and thus rules out very soft nuclear matter. We stress the potential of this type of constraints when future detections become available. For instance, a very similar argumentation may yield an upper bound on the maximum mass of nonrotating NSs. We also discuss simulations of NS mergers, which undergo a first-order phase transition to quark matter. We point out a different dynamical behavior. Considering the gravitational-wave signal, we identify an unambiguous signature of the QCD phase transition in NS mergers. We show that the occurrence of quark matter through a strong first-order phase transition during merging leads to a characteristic shift of the dominant postmerger frequency. The frequency shift is indicative for a phase transition if it is compared to the postmerger frequency which is expected for purely hadronic EoS models. A very strong deviation of several 100 Hz is observed for hybrid EoSs in an otherwise tight relation between the tidal deformability and the postmerger frequency. In future events the tidal deformability will be inferred with sufficient precision from the premerger phase, while the dominant postmerger frequency can be obtained when current detectors reach a higher sensitivity in the high-frequency range within the next years. Finally, we address the potential impact of a first-order phase transition on the electromagnetic counter-part of NS mergers. Our simulations suggest that there would be no significant qualitative differences between a system undergoing a phase transition to quark matter and purely hadronic mergers. The quantitative differences are within the spread which is found between different hadronic EoS models. This implies on the one hand that GW170817 is compatible with a possible transition to quark matter. On the other hand these considerations show that it may not be easy to identify quantitative differences between purely hadronic mergers and events in which quark matter occurs considering solely their electromagnetic counterpart or their nucleosynthesis products.

1.
B. P.
Abbott
 et al (
LIGO Scientific Collaboration and Virgo Collaboration
),
Phys. Rev. Lett.
119
,
161101
(
2017
).
2.
The LIGO Scientific Collaboration, the Virgo Collaboration
,
B. P.
Abbott
,
R.
Abbott
,
T. D.
Abbott
,
S.
Abraham
,
F.
Acernese
,
K.
Ackley
,
C.
Adams
,
R. X.
Adhikari
, et al, arXiv e-prints arXiv:1811.12940 (
2018
), 1811.12940.
3.
B. P.
Abbott
 et al (
LIGO Scientific Collaboration and Virgo Collaboration
),
Astrophys. J. Lett.
848
,
L12
(
2017
), 1710.05833.
4.
F.
Özel
and
P.
Freire
,
An. Rev. Astron. Astrophys.
54
,
401
(
2016
), 1603.02698.
5.
B. P.
Abbott
,
R.
Abbott
,
T. D.
Abbott
,
F.
Acernese
,
K.
Ackley
,
C.
Adams
,
T.
Adams
,
P.
Addesso
,
R. X.
Adhikari
,
V. B.
Adya
, et al,
Physical Review X
9
,
011001
(
2019
), 1805.11579.
6.
B. P.
Abbott
 et al (
The LIGO Scientific Collaboration and the Virgo Collaboration
),
Phys. Rev. Lett.
121
,
161101
(
2018
), URL .
7.
K.
Chatziioannou
,
C.-J.
Haster
, and
A.
Zimmerman
,
Phys. Rev. D
97
,
104036
(
2018
), 1804.03221.
8.
S.
De
,
D.
Finstad
,
J. M.
Lattimer
,
D. A.
Brown
,
E.
Berger
, and
C. M.
Biwer
,
Phys. Rev. Lett.
121
,
091102
(
2018
), 1804.08583.
9.
M. F.
Carney
,
L. E.
Wade
, and
B. S.
Irwin
,
Phys. Rev. D
98
,
063004
(
2018
), 1805.11217.
10.
Y.
Lim
and
J. W.
Holt
,
Phys. Rev. Lett.
121
,
062701
(
2018
), 1803.02803.
11.
I.
Tews
,
J.
Margueron
, and
S.
Reddy
, arXiv e-prints arXiv:1901.09874 (
2019
), 1901.09874.
12.
V. A.
Villar
,
J.
Guillochon
,
E.
Berger
,
B. D.
Metzger
,
P. S.
Cowperthwaite
,
M.
Nicholl
,
K. D.
Alexander
,
P. K.
Blanchard
,
R.
Chornock
,
T.
Eftekhari
, et al,
Astrophys. J. Lett.
851
,
L21
(
2017
), 1710.11576.
13.
B.
Côté
,
C. L.
Fryer
,
K.
Belczynski
,
O.
Korobkin
,
M.
Chruślińska
,
N.
Vassh
,
M. R.
Mumpower
,
J.
Lippuner
,
T. M.
Sprouse
,
R.
Surman
, et al,
Astrophys. J
855
,
99
(
2018
), 1710.05875.
14.
B. D.
Metzger
,
G.
Martínez-Pinedo
,
S.
Darbha
,
E.
Quataert
,
A.
Arcones
,
D.
Kasen
,
R.
Thomas
,
P.
Nugent
,
I. V.
Panov
, and
N. T.
Zinner
,
MNRAS
406
,
2650
(
2010
), 1001.5029.
15.
J. M.
Lattimer
,
F.
Mackie
,
D. G.
Ravenhall
, and
D. N.
Schramm
,
Astrophys. J
213
,
225
(
1977
).
16.
M.-R.
Wu
,
R.
Fernández
,
G.
Martínez-Pinedo
, and
B. D.
Metzger
,
MNRAS
463
,
2323
(
2016
), 1607.05290.
17.
A.
Bauswein
,
O.
Just
,
H.-T.
Janka
, and
N.
Stergioulas
,
Astrophys. J. Lett.
850
,
L34
(
2017
), 1710.06843.
18.
A.
Bauswein
,
S.
Goriely
, and
H.-T.
Janka
,
Astrophys. J
773
,
78
(
2013
), 1302.6530.
19.
K.
Hotokezaka
,
K.
Kiuchi
,
K.
Kyutoku
,
H.
Okawa
,
Y.-i.
Sekiguchi
,
M.
Shibata
, and
K.
Taniguchi
,
Phys. Rev. D
87
,
024001
(
2013
), 1212.0905.
20.
B.
Margalit
and
B. D.
Metzger
,
Astrophys. J. Lett.
850
,
L19
(
2017
), 1710.05938.
21.
M.
Shibata
,
S.
Fujibayashi
,
K.
Hotokezaka
,
K.
Kiuchi
,
K.
Kyutoku
,
Y.
Sekiguchi
, and
M.
Tanaka
,
Phys. Rev. D
96
,
123012
(
2017
), 1710.07579.
22.
L.
Rezzolla
,
E. R.
Most
, and
L. R.
Weih
,
Astrophys. J. Lett.
852
,
L25
(
2018
), 1711.00314.
23.
D.
Radice
,
A.
Perego
,
F.
Zappa
, and
S.
Bernuzzi
,
Astrophys. J. Lett.
852
,
L29
(
2018
), 1711.03647.
24.
M.
Ruiz
,
S. L.
Shapiro
, and
A.
Tsokaros
,
Phys. Rev. D
97
,
021501
(
2018
), 1711.00473.
25.
S.
Ai
,
H.
Gao
,
Z.-G.
Dai
,
X.-F.
Wu
,
A.
Li
,
B.
Zhang
, and
M.-Z.
Li
,
Astrophys. J
860
,
57
(
2018
), 1802.00571.
26.
A.
Bauswein
,
T. W.
Baumgarte
, and
H.-T.
Janka
,
Phys. Rev. Lett.
111
,
131101
(
2013
), 1307.5191.
27.
A.
Bauswein
and
N.
Stergioulas
, arXiv e-prints (
2019
), 1901.06969.
28.
J.
Antoniadis
,
P. C. C.
Freire
,
N.
Wex
,
T. M.
Tauris
,
R. S.
Lynch
,
M. H.
van Kerkwijk
,
M.
Kramer
,
C.
Bassa
,
V. S.
Dhillon
,
T.
Driebe
, et al,
Science
340
,
448
(
2013
), 1304.6875.
29.
T.
Hinderer
,
Astrophys. J
677
,
1216
(
2008
), 0711.2420.
30.
D.
Radice
and
L.
Dai
,
European Physical Journal A
55
,
50
(
2019
), 1810.12917.
31.
S.
Köppel
,
L.
Bovard
, and
L.
Rezzolla
,
Astrophys. J. Lett.
872
,
L16
(
2019
), 1901.09977.
32.
K.
Kiuchi
,
K.
Kyutoku
,
M.
Shibata
, and
K.
Taniguchi
, arXiv e-prints (
2019
), 1903.01466.
33.
C.
Csáki
,
C.
Eröncel
,
J.
Hubisz
,
G.
Rigo
, and
J.
Terning
,
Journal of High Energy Physics
9
,
87
(
2018
).
34.
V.
Paschalidis
,
K.
Yagi
,
D.
Alvarez-Castillo
,
D. B.
Blaschke
, and
A.
Sedrakian
,
Phys. Rev. D
97
,
084038
(
2018
).
35.
E. R.
Most
,
L. J.
Papenfort
,
V.
Dexheimer
,
M.
Hanauske
,
S.
Schramm
,
H.
Stöcker
, and
L.
Rezzolla
,
Phys. Rev. Lett.
122
,
061101
(
2019
), 1807.03684.
36.
S.
Han
and
A. W.
Steiner
, arXiv e-prints (
2018
), 1810.10967.
37.
J.-E.
Christian
,
A.
Zacchi
, and
J.
Schaffner-Bielich
,
Phys. Rev. D
99
,
023009
(
2019
), 1809.03333.
38.
M.
Sieniawska
,
W.
Turczański
,
M.
Bejger
, and
J. L.
Zdunik
,
Astron. Astrophys.
622
,
A174
(
2019
), 1807.11581.
39.
G. F.
Burgio
,
A.
Drago
,
G.
Pagliara
,
H.-J.
Schulze
, and
J.-B.
Wei
,
Astrophys. J
860
,
139
(
2018
).
40.
A.
Drago
and
G.
Pagliara
,
Astrophys. J. Lett.
852
,
L32
(
2018
).
41.
V.
Dexheimer
,
R. de Oliveira
Gomes
,
S.
Schramm
, and
H.
Pais
,
Journal of Physics G Nuclear Physics
46
,
034002
(
2019
), 1810.06109.
42.
M.
Alford
,
M.
Braby
,
M.
Paris
, and
S.
Reddy
,
Astrophys. J
629
,
969
(
2005
), nucl-th/0411016.
43.
J. S.
Read
,
B. D.
Lackey
,
B. J.
Owen
, and
J. L.
Friedman
,
Phys. Rev. D
79
,
124032
(
2009
), 0812.2163.
44.
A.
Bauswein
,
N.-U. F.
Bastian
,
D. B.
Blaschke
,
K.
Chatziioannou
,
J. A.
Clark
,
T.
Fischer
, and
M.
Oertel
,
Phys. Rev. Lett.
122
,
061102
(
2019
), 1809.01116.
46.
S.
Typel
,
G.
Röpke
,
T.
Klähn
,
D.
Blaschke
, and
H. H.
Wolter
,
Phys. Rev. C
81
,
015803
(
2010
).
47.
D.
Alvarez-Castillo
,
A.
Ayriyan
,
S.
Benic
,
D.
Blaschke
,
H.
Grigorian
, and
S.
Typel
,
European Physical Journal A
52
,
69
(
2016
), 1603.03457.
48.
P.
Danielewicz
,
R.
Lacey
, and
W. G.
Lynch
,
Science
298
,
1592
(
2002
), nucl-th/0208016.
49.
M. B.
Tsang
,
Y.
Zhang
,
P.
Danielewicz
,
M.
Famiano
,
Z.
Li
,
W. G.
Lynch
, and
A. W.
Steiner
,
Physical Review Letters
102
,
122701
(
2009
), 0811.3107.
50.
C. Y.
Tsang
,
M. B.
Tsang
,
P.
Danielewicz
,
W. G.
Lynch
, and
F. J.
Fattoyev
, ArXiv e-prints (
2018
), 1807.06571.
51.
N.-B.
Zhang
,
B.-A.
Li
, and
J.
Xu
,
Astrophys. J
859
,
90
(
2018
), 1801.06855.
52.
T.
Krüger
,
I.
Tews
,
K.
Hebeler
, and
A.
Schwenk
,
Phys. Rev. C
88
,
025802
(
2013
), 1304.2212.
53.
J. M.
Lattimer
and
Y.
Lim
,
Astrophys. J
771
,
51
(
2013
).
54.
M.
Oertel
,
M.
Hempel
,
T.
Klähn
, and
S.
Typel
,
Reviews of Modern Physics
89
,
015007
(
2017
), 1610.03361.
55.
B. P.
Abbott
,
R.
Abbott
,
T. D.
Abbott
,
F.
Acernese
,
K.
Ackley
,
C.
Adams
,
T.
Adams
,
P.
Addesso
,
R. X.
Adhikari
,
V. B.
Adya
, et al,
Phys. Rev. Lett.
121
,
161101
(
2018
), 1805.11581.
56.
Z.-Y.
Zhu
,
E.-P.
Zhou
, and
A.
Li
,
Astrophys. J
862
,
98
(
2018
), 1802.05510.
57.
M. A. R.
Kaltenborn
,
N.-U. F.
Bastian
, and
D. B.
Blaschke
,
Phys. Rev. D
96
,
056024
(
2017
), 1701.04400.
58.
T.
Fischer
,
N.-U. F.
Bastian
,
M.-R.
Wu
,
P.
Baklanov
,
E.
Sorokina
,
S.
Blinnikov
,
S.
Typel
,
T.
Klähn
, and
D. B.
Blaschke
,
Nature Astronomy
2
,
980
(
2018
), 1712.08788.
59.
N.-U.
Bastian
,
D.
Blaschke
,
T.
Fischer
, and
G.
Röpke
,
Universe
4
,
67
(
2018
), 1804.10178.
60.
A.
Bauswein
and
N.
Stergioulas
,
Phys. Rev. D
91
,
124056
(
2015
), 1502.03176.
61.
K.
Hotokezaka
,
K.
Kiuchi
,
K.
Kyutoku
,
T.
Muranushi
,
Y.
Sekiguchi
,
M.
Shibata
, and
K.
Taniguchi
,
Phys. Rev. D
88
,
044026
(
2013
).
62.
A.
Bauswein
,
H.-T.
Janka
,
K.
Hebeler
, and
A.
Schwenk
,
Phys. Rev. D
86
,
063001
(
2012
), 1204.1888.
63.
J. S.
Read
,
L.
Baiotti
,
J. D. E.
Creighton
,
J. L.
Friedman
,
B.
Giacomazzo
,
K.
Kyutoku
,
C.
Markakis
,
L.
Rezzolla
,
M.
Shibata
, and
K.
Taniguchi
,
Phys. Rev. D
88
,
044042
(
2013
), 1306.4065.
64.
B. P.
Abbott
 et al (
LIGO Scientific Collaboration and Virgo Collaboration
),
Physical Review X
9
,
011001
(
2019
), 1805.11579.
65.
J.
Clark
,
A.
Bauswein
,
L.
Cadonati
,
H.-T.
Janka
,
C.
Pankow
, and
N.
Stergioulas
,
Phys. Rev. D
90
,
062004
(
2014
).
66.
J. A.
Clark
,
A.
Bauswein
,
N.
Stergioulas
, and
D.
Shoemaker
,
Classical and Quantum Gravity
33
,
085003
(
2016
), 1509.08522.
67.
K.
Chatziioannou
,
J. A.
Clark
,
A.
Bauswein
,
M.
Millhouse
,
T. B.
Littenberg
, and
N.
Cornish
,
Phys. Rev. D
96
,
124035
(
2017
), 1711.00040.
68.
H.
Yang
,
V.
Paschalidis
,
K.
Yagi
,
L.
Lehner
,
F.
Pretorius
, and
N.
Yunes
,
Phys. Rev. D
97
,
024049
(
2018
), 1707.00207.
69.
A.
Torres-Rivas
,
K.
Chatziioannou
,
A.
Bauswein
, and
J. A.
Clark
,
Phys. Rev. D
99
,
044014
(
2019
), 1811.08931.
70.
D.
Martynov
,
H.
Miao
,
H.
Yang
,
F. Hernandez
Vivanco
,
E.
Thrane
,
R.
Smith
,
P.
Lasky
,
W. E.
East
,
R.
Adhikari
,
A.
Bauswein
, et al, arXiv e-prints (
2019
), 1901.03885.
71.
S.
Banik
,
M.
Hempel
, and
D.
Bandyopadhyay
,
Astrophys. J. Supp.
214
,
22
(
2014
), 1404.6173.
72.
M.
Fortin
,
M.
Oertel
, and
C.
Providência
,
Publ. Astron. Soc. Aust.
35
(
2018
), 1711.09427.
73.
M.
Marques
,
M.
Oertel
,
M.
Hempel
, and
J.
Novak
,
Phys. Rev.
C96
,
045806
(
2017
), 1706.02913.
This content is only available via PDF.