We compare the performance of laser triangulation, phase shift triangulation and swept source optical coherence tomography (SSOCT) for quantitative nondestructive inspection. Measurement accuracies of these three optical 3D imaging techniques can be reduced to a few tens of micrometers or less, making it possible to locate and geometrically characterize defects at the micrometric scale. We consider surfaces with different optical properties and we discuss the ability of these techniques to reconstruct the surface profiles. For opaque surfaces, the three techniques provide very similar results. For semi-transparent and transparent surfaces, the accuracy achieved by SSOCT relies on the capability of detecting, selecting and classifying peaks in each axial scan (A-scan), while the performance of triangulation techniques depend on several parameters including the sensitivity and the exposition time of the camera, the positioning of the system in relation to the surface, etc. Based on these facts, a prospective discussion is attempted on the possibility to combine SSOCT and phase shift triangulation for quantitative surface inspection of objects as well as for internal geometrical characterization of semi-transparent and transparent objects.

1.
F.
Blais
, “
Review of 20 yeaers of range sensor development
”,
Journal of Electronic Imaging
13
,
231
(
2004
).
2.
F.
Blais
,
M.
Rioux
and
J.-A.
Beraldin
, “Practical considerations for a design of a high precision 3-D laser scanner system”,
Proceedings of SPIE, Optomechanical and Electro-Optical Design of Industrial Systems
, edited by
Robert J.
Bieringer
and
Kevin G.
Harding
(
SPIE
,
1988
), Vol.
0959
,
225
.
3.
M.-A.
Drouin
and
J.-A.
Beraldin
, “
Active 3-D imaging systems
”, in
3D Imaging, Analysis and Applications
, edited by
N.
Pears
,
Y.
Liu
and
P.
Bunting
(
Springer
,
London
,
2012
), p.
95
.
4.
S.
Hyun
and
B. E.
Bouma
, “Wavelength swept lasers”, in
Optical Coherence Tomography
, edited by
W.
Drexler
,
J. G.
Fujimoto
(
Springer International Publishing
,
Switzerland
,
2015
), p.
619
.
5.
J. A.
Izatt
,
M. A.
Choma
, and
A. H.
Dhalla
, “Theory of optical coherence tomography”, in
Optical Coherence Tomography
, edited by
W.
Drexler
,
J. G.
Fujimoto
(
Springer International Publishing
,
Switzerland
,
2015
), p.
65
.
7.
S.
Zhang
,
S.-T.
Yau
, “
High-resolution, real-time absolute coordinate measurement based on the phase-shifting method
”,
Optical Engineering
48
,
033604
1
(
2009
).
8.
G.
Godin
,
J.-A.
Beraldin
,
M.
Rioux
,
M.
Levoy
,
L.
Cournoyer
and
F.
Blais
, “
An assessment of laser range measurement of marble surfaces
”, in
Proceedings of the 5th Conference on Optical 3D measurement techniques
(
Vienna, Austria
,
2001
), p.
49
56
.
This content is only available via PDF.