The sunshape and mirror surface slope error are two main factors that influence the characteristics of incoming and reflected solar beams in a solar concentrator. Different optical modelling tools, however, address these two factors with different methods and simplifications. In this study, simulation methods are reviewed in five optical modelling tools, namely SolTrace, Tonatiuh, Tracer, Heliosim and SolarPILOT. A series of simple test cases are simulated in each tool to compare and verify the implementation of sunshape and slope error models separately. This strategy has successfully identified discrepancies among the tools and contributed to a better understanding of their reasons. It has also uncovered few glitches in some of those tools and contributed to improve them. It is our hope that this study will help to resolve common misconceptions, to build confidence amongst CSP researches on the accuracy of tools with which they have less experience, and to ensure better agreement in optical modelling work in future.

1.
T.
Wendelin
,
SolTRACE: A New Optical Modelling Tool for Concentrating Solar Optics
, in:
ASME 2003 Int. Sol. Energy Conf
.,
Kohala Coast, HI
,
2003
.
2.
Tonatiuh
GitHub
page: http://iat-cener.github.io/tonatiuh/
3.
Y.
Wang
,
C.-A.
Asselineau
,
J.
Coventry
, and
J.
Pye
,
2016
,
Optical performance of bladed receivers for CSP systems
,
Proceedings of the ASME 2016 Power and Energy Conference
(
2016
).
5.
D.
Potter
,
A.
Burton
, and
J.-S.
Kim
,
Optimised Design of a 1 MWt Liquid Sodium Central Receiver Syste
. In
Proceedings of 2015 Asia-Pacific Solar Research Conference
(
2015
).
6.
M.J.
Wagner
,
T.
Wendelin
,
SolarPILOT: A Power Tower Solar Field Layout and Characterization Tool
,
Solar Energy
, In press (
2017
).
7.
L.
Li
,
J.
Coventry
,
R.
Bader
,
J.
Pye
, and
W.
Lipiński
,
Optics of solar central receiver systems: a review
,
Opt. Express
24
,
A985
A1007
(
2016
)
8.
G.
Levêque
,
R.
Bader
,
W.
Lipiński
,
S.
Haussener
,
High-flux optical systems for solar thermochemistry
,
Solar Energy.
In press (
2017
)
9.
P.
Blanc
,
B.
Espinar
,
N.
Geuder
,
C.
Gueymard
,
R.
Meyer
,
R.
Pitz-Paal
,
B.
Reinhardt
,
D.
Renné
,
M.
Sengupta
,
L.
Wald
,
S.
Wilbert
,
Direct normal irradiance related definitions and applications: The circumsolar issue
,
Solar Energy.
110
(
2014
),
561
577
10.
D.
Buie
,
A. G.
Monger
, and
C.J.
Dey
,
Sunshape distributions for terrestrial solar simulations
,
Sol. Energy.
74
(
2003
),
113
122
.
11.
J.
Arvo
,
P.
Dutre
,
A.
Keller
,
H. W.
Jensen
and
A
Owen
,
Monte Carlo Ray Tracing, Siggraph
2003
12.
W.
Mendenhall
and
T.
Sincich
,
Statistics for Engineering and the Sciences
, Fifth edition
13.
B.
Belhomme
,
R.
Pitz-Paal
,
P.
Schawrzboezl
and
S.
Ulmer
(
2009
).
A New Fast Ray Tracing Tool for High-Precision Simulation of Heliostat Fields
.
Journal of Solar Energy Engineering
,
131
(
3
),
31002
(2009).
14.
R.
Flesch
,
D.M.
Quinto
,
A.
Rong
and
R.
Schwarzboezl
(
2012
).
STRAL: Fast Ray Tracing Software With Tool Coupling Capabilities for High-Precision Simulations of Solar Thermal Power Plants
. In:
Proceedings of the SolarPACES 2012 conference
.
15.
M.D.
Walzel
,
F.W.
Lipps
,
Vant-Hull
,
A solar flux density calculation for a solar tower concentrator using a two-dimensional Hermite function expansion
,
Sol. Energy.
19
(
1977
)
239
256
16.
T.A.
Dellin
, An improved Hermite expansion calculation of the flux distribution from heliostats: SAND79-8619,
Sandia National Laboratory
,
Livermore, CA
,
1979
17.
B.L.
Kistler
, A user’s manual for DELSOL3: A computer code for calculating the optical performance and optimal system design for solar thermal central receiver plants,
Sandia National Laboratory
,
Albuquerque, NM
,
1986
This content is only available via PDF.