The existing methods for estimating strain life parameters are dependent on the material’s monotonic tensile properties. However, a few of these methods yield quite complicated expressions for calculating fatigue parameters, and are specific to certain groups of materials only. The Universal Slopes method, Modified Universal Slopes method, Uniform Material Law, the Hardness method, and Medians method are a few existing methods for predicting strain-life fatigue based on monotonic tensile material properties and hardness of material. In the present study, nine methods for estimating fatigue life and properties are applied on JIS H3300 C1220 copper to determine the best methods for strain life estimation of this ductile material. Experimental strain-life curves are compared to estimations obtained using each method. Muralidharan-Manson’s Modified Universal Slopes method and Bäumel-Seeger’s method for unalloyed and low-alloy steels are found to yield batter accuracy in estimating fatigue life with a deviation of less than 25%. However, the prediction of both methods only yield much better accuracy for a cycle of less than 1000 or for strain amplitudes of more than 1% and less than 6%. Manson’s Original Universal Slopes method and Ong’s Modified Four-Point Correlation method are found to predict the strain-life fatigue of copper with better accuracy for a high number of cycles of strain amplitudes of less than 1%. The differences between mechanical behavior during monotonic and cyclic loading and the complexity in deciding the coefficient in an equation are probably the reason for the lack of a reliable method for estimating fatigue behavior using the monotonic properties of a group of materials. It is therefore suggested that a differential approach and new expressions be developed to estimate the strain-life fatigue parameters for ductile materials such as copper.

1.
Stephens
RI
,
Fatemi
A
,
Stephens
RR
,
Fuchs
HO
.
Metal fatigue in engineering
.
John Wiley & Sons
;
2001
Nov 3. p.
106
107
2.
Morrow
J.
 Cyclic plastic strain energy and fatigue of metals.
In Internal friction, damping, and cyclic plasticity
1965
Jan.
ASTM International
.
3.
Manson
SS
.
Fatigue: a complex subject—some simple approximations
.
Experimental mechanics.
1965
Jul 24;
5
(
7
):
193
226
.
4.
Testin
RA
.
Interim Report on Fatigue Behavior of High Hardness Nodular Cast Iron
.
University of Illinois
;
1973
Mar.
5.
Mitchell
MR
,
Socie
DF
,
Caulfield
EM
. Fundamentals of modern fatigue analysis.
Fracture Control Program Report No. 26
,
University of Illinois
,
USA
,
1977
, p.
385
410
.
6.
Muralidharan
U
,
Manson
SS
.
Modified universal slopes equation for estimation of fatigue characteristics
.
J Eng Mater Technol Trans Am Soc Mech Eng
1988
;
110
:
55
8
.
7.
Bäumel
Jr. A
,
Seeger
T.
Materials data for cyclic loading—supplement I
.
Amsterdam
:
Elsevier Science Publishers
;
1990
.
8.
Ong
JH
.
An improved technique for the prediction of axial fatigue life from tensile data
.
Int J Fatigue
1993
;
15
(
3
):
213
9
.
9.
Roessle
ML
,
Fatemi
A.
Strain-controlled fatigue properties of steels and some simple approximations
.
Int J Fatigue
2000
;
22
:
495
511
.
10.
Meggiolaro
MA
,
Castro
JTP
.
ViDa—a visual damagemeter to automate the fatigue design under complex loading
.
Brazilian J Mech Sci RBCM
1998
;
20
(
4
):
666
85
[in Portuguese].
11.
Meggiolaro
MA
,
Castro
JTP
.
Statistical evaluation of strain-life fatigue crack initiation predictions
.
Int J Fatigue
2004
;
26
:
463
476
.
12.
Robert
Basan
,
Domagoj
Rubeša
,
Marina
Franulovic
and
Božidar
Križan
, “
A novel approach to the estimation of strain life fatigue parameters
”,
Procedia Engineering
, Vol.
2
,
2010
, pp.
417
426
13.
Takahashi
K
,
Ando
K
,
Matsuo
K
,
Urabe
Y.
Estimation of low-cycle fatigue life of elbow pipes considering the multi-axial stress effect
.
Journal of Pressure Vessel Technology.
2014
Aug 1;
136
(
4
):
041405
.
14.
ASTM E 8M -
2004
, “Standard test methods for tension testing of metallic materials [Metric]”,
ASTM International
,
USA
.
15.
ASTM E 606 - 04
, “Standard practice for strain-controlled fatigue testing”,
ASTM International
,
USA
.
This content is only available via PDF.