The heat loss of an evacuated parabolic trough receiver of solar thermal power plants ranges typically between values below 150 and 200 W/m at 350°C. Defects, such as glass breakage by wind events and coating degradation, anti-reflection coating degradation or hydrogen accumulation in the annulus, decrease the annual electricity production. This study examines the effect of different receiver performance loss scenarios on the energetic and economic output of a modern 150-MWel–parabolic trough plant with 7.5-hours molten-salt storage, located in Ma’an, Jordan over the whole lifetime by modeling it in an extended version of the software greenius. Compared to the reference scenario, a wind event in year 5 (10, 15) causing glass envelope breakage and consequential degradation of the selective coating of 5.6% of the receivers reduces the electricity output by 5.1% (3.8%, 2.5%), the net present value is reduced by 36.5% (23.1%, 13.1%). The payback time of receiver replacement is only 0.7 years and hence this measure is recommended. The highest negative impact on performance and net present value of a project has the hydrogen accumulation scenario (50% of field affected) in event year 5 (10,15) reducing net electric output by 10.7% (8.1%, 5.4%) and the net present value by 77.0% (48.7%, 27.6%). Replacement of the receivers or even better an inexpensive repair solution is an energetically and economically sensible solution. The option of investing in premium receivers with Xe-capsule during the construction phase is a viable option if the surplus cost for premium receivers is lower than 10 to 20 percent.

1.
F.
Burkholder
, F. and
C.
Kutscher
, “
Heat Loss Testing of Schott’s 2008 PTR70 Parabolic Trough Receiver
,”
National Renewable Energy Laboratory
, Technical Report, NREL/TP-550-45633,
2009
.
2.
J.
Pernpeintner
,
B.
Schiricke
,
N.
Lichtenthäler
,
E.
Lüpfert
,
M.
Anger
,
P.
Ant
,
J.
Weinhausen
, “
Thermal and Optical Characterization of Parabolic Trough Receivers at DLR’s QUARZ Center - Recent Advances
,” in
Proceedings SolarPaces
,
Granada
2011
.
3.
P.
Eichel
,
S.
Dreyer
,
T.
Gnaedig
,
Z.
Hacker
,
S.
Janker
,
Th.
Kuckelkorn
,
K.
Silmy
,
J.
Pernpeintner
,
E.
Lüpfert
, “
Heat Loss Measurements on Parabolic Trough Receivers
,” in
Proceedings of SolarPACES Conference
,
Perpignan, France
,
2010
.
4.
H.
Price
,
R.
Forristall
,
T.
Wendelin
,
A.
Lewandowski
,
T.
Moss
,
C.
Gummo
, “
Field Survey of Parabolic Trough Receiver Thermal Performance
,” in
Proceedings of ISEC2006, ASME
,
Denver, Colorado, USA
,
2006
5.
S.
Caron
.,
M.
Röger
,
J.
Pernpeintner
, “
Transient Infrared Thermography Heat Loss Measurements on Parabolic Trough Receivers Under Laboratory Conditions
,”
Energy Procedia
, Volume
69
,
2015
, pp.
310
319
6.
F.
Burkholder
,
C.
Kutscher
,
M.
Brandemuehl
and,
E.
Wolfrum
, “
The Test and Prediction of Argon-Hydrogen and Xenon-Hydrogen Heat Conduction in Parabolic Trough Receivers
,” in
Proceedings of SolarPACES Conference
,
Granada, Spain
,
2011
7.
N.
Blair
,
A.P.
Dobos
,
J.
Freeman
,
T.
Neises
,
M.
Wagner
,
T.
Ferguson
,
P.
Gilman
,
S.
Janzou
, “
System Advisor Model, SAM, 2014.1.14: General Description
,” Technical Report NREL/TP-6A20-61019, Febr.
2014
8.
J.
Dersch
,
K.
Hennecke
,
V.
Quaschning
, „
Greenius – A Simulation Tool for Renewable Energy Utilization,“ in
Proceedings of SolarPACES Conference
,
Perpignan, France
,
2010
.
9.
J.
Dersch
,
K.
Hennecke
,
V.
Quaschning
, „
Greenius – New Options and Availability
,“ in
Proceedings of SolarPACES Conference
,
Marrakech, Morocco
,
2012
.
10.
M.
Möllenhoff
,
C.
Albers
,
M.
Werner
,
O.
Sohr
,
T.
Kuckelkorn
, “
A New Approach for Lifetime Extension of Parabolic Trough Receivers
,” in
Proceedings of SolarPACES Conference
,
Granada, Spain
,
2011
11.
L.
Moens
,
D.
Blake
,
Mechanism of Hydrogen Formation in Solar Parabolic Trough Receivers
, Technical Report NREL/TP-510-42468, Febr.
2008
12.
G.C.
Glatzmaier
, “
Measurement of Hydrogen Purge Rates in Parabolic Trough Receiver Tubes
,” in
Proceedings of SolarPACES Conference
,
Perpignan, France
,
2010
.
13.
M.
Röger
,
P.
Potzel
,
J.
Pernpeintner
,
S.
Caron
, “
A Transient Thermography Method To Separate Heat Loss Mechanisms in Parabolic Trough Receiver
,”
J. Sol. Energy Eng.
,
136
(
1
),
2014
14.
V.
Dudley
,
G.
Kolb
,
M.
Sloan
,
D.
Kearney
, “
Test Results, SEGS LS-2 Solar Collector
,”
Sandia National Laboratories
, Report SAND94-1884, Dec.
1994
15.
V.
Quaschning
,
R.
Kistner
,
W.
Ortmanns
, “
Simulation of Parabolic Trough Power Plants
,”
5th Cologne Solar Symposium
,
Cologne, Germany
, June,
2001
16.
M.C.
Stoddard
,
S.W.
Faas
,
C.J.
Chiang
,
J.A.
Dirks
, “
SOLERGY – A Computer Code for Calculating the Annual Energy from Central Receiver Power Plants
,”
Sandia National Laboratories
, Report SAND86-8060, UC-62a, May
1987
This content is only available via PDF.