Mosque, as an Islamic religious building, has become the center of civilization since Prophet Muhammad era until Ottoman Empire. As a main religious architectural building type for Moslem’s, Mosque constantly changes through history in the dynamic process of cultural transformation especially in this modern era. The modern architecture ideology of rejecting the older architecture styles and promoting a more functional approach on building design have affected mosque’s design today. It is a fact that throughout history, Mosque Architecture has its own formal typological characteristics which was perceived as a symbol of the Muslim community. This paper discusses the controversy about modern mosque designs today by taking the case study of Jami Darussalam Mosque in Tanah Abang Jakarta. The triangular shape of the mosque visual image was criticized by some Islamic fundamentalist as being not represented a common mosque at all. Therefore, this paper takes the opportunity to approach this architectural unique case through a critical perspective by taking an issue around the problematic meaning of Modern Architectural Mosque from Semiotics point of view. By applying semiotic theory into architecture, we hope to obtain a more understanding perspective about the process of how the meaning behind a sign was emerged. In order to conduct this research, we interview the people living inside and outside of Jami Darussalam Mosque neighborhood, and we also study the typology of the mosque. The intention of this method is to resolve the controversy around the Mosque visual appearance through the process of how a meaning from a sign interpreted and whether the design also affects the religious activities inside.

1.
Barliana
,
M. S.
, “
Perkembangan Arsitektur Masjid: Suatu Transformasi Bentuk dan Ruang
,” in
Jurnal Terakreditasi Nasional HISTORIA
, Vol.
IX
, No.
2
, (
2008
).
2.
Surasetja
,
R. I.
,
Fungsi, Ruang, Bentuk dan Ekspresi dalam Arsitektur.
Hand-out Mata Kuliah Pengantar Arsitektur, Program Studi Arsitektur, Jurusan Pendidikan Teknik Bangunan, Fakultas Pendidikan Teknologi dan Kejuruan, Universitas Pendidikan Indonesia
, (
2007
).
3.
Sudikno
,
Antariksa
,
Arsitektur Dalam Dinamika Ruang, Bentuk dan Budaya
, (
Cahaya Atma Pustaka
,
Yogyakarta
,
2018
).
4.
Curtis
,
William
, J. R.,
Modern Architecture Since 1900
, (
Phaidon Press Limited
,
New York
,
1982
).
5.
Brunner
, et al, “
Kajian Penerapan Arsitektur Modern pada Bangunan Roger’s Salon, Clinic, Spa and Wellness Center Bandung
,” in
Jurnal Reka Raksa
, Vol.
I
, No.
2
, pp.
1
10
, (June
2013
).
6.
Amanaturrosyidah
,
Ochi
,
Masjid Segitiga Tanah Abang, Karya Emil yang Pernah Ditolak Warga,
(
2018
).
7.
Hermawati
S.
,
Aly
S.
, &
Hans
J.
, “
The Application of Gothic Architecture on Santo Laurensius Church Alam Sutra, Serpong
,” in
Jurnal RISA (Riset Arsitektur).
02
(
04
).
360
374
. ISSN 2548-8074, (
2018
).
8.
Fajriyanto
, “Simbol Dalam Arsitektur Masjid,” in
UNISIA
, No.
20
, pp.
86
94
. ISSN 0215-1421, (
2016
). .
9.
Jelita
,
Erviyana
,
Analisis Kitab Sunda Pegon Sifat Dua Pulug dengan Semiotika Ferdinand De Saussure dan Teori Pendekatan Objetktif Sastra, (n.d.
).
10.
Hawkes
,
Terrence
,
Structuralism and Semiotics
, (
Routledge
,
New York
,
2003
).
11.
Barthes
,
Roland
,
Elements of Semiology
, (
Hill and Wang
,
New York
,
1977
).
12.
Zoest
,
Aart.
Van
,
Semiotika, Pemakaiannya, Isinya dan Apa yang Dikerjakan dengannya (terjemahan), Unpad
,
Bandung
,
1978
).
13.
Hoed
,
Benny
H.
,
Semiotik dan Dinamika Sosial Budaya, Cet. III
, (
Komunitas Bambu
,
Yogyakarta
,
2014
).
14.
Hatta
,
Juparno
, “
Konstruksi Mitos Iluminati pada Masjid Al-Safar (Analisis Semiotika Rolande Barthes
),” in
Jurnal Ilmiah Sosiologi Agama dan Perubahan Sosial
, Vol.
13
, No.
2
, pp.
67
94
, (
2019
), http//dx.doi.org/10.14421/
15.
Asfour
,
S. O.
, “
Bridging The Gap Between The Past and The Present: A Reconsideration of mosque Architectural Elements
,” in
Journal of Islamic Architecture
, Vol.
4
, No.
2
, pp.
77
85
, (
2016
).
16.
Mustafa
,
F. A.
, &
Hassan
A. S.
, “
Mosque Layout Design: An Analytical Study of mosque Layouts in The Early Ottoman Period
,” in
Frontiers of Architectural Research
, Vol.
2
, pp.
445
456
, (
2013
).
17.
Gwadabe
,
M. M.
, &
Kyari
,
M.
,
Masjid: Muslim Sacred Space of Worship, (n.d.
).
Syahid
,
M. A. A.
, “
Translating Modern Ideas into Post-colonial mosque Architecture in Indonesia
,” in
International Journal of Built Environment and Scientific Research, Vo.
02
, No.
01
. pp.
39
46
, (
2018
).
18.
Syahid
,
M. A. A.
,
Membaca Arsitektur Masjid Modern melalui Semiotika
,
Paper UTS Sejarah & Teori Arsitektur, Master Program, Architecture Department, Faculty of Engineering, Universitas Indonesia
, (n.d.).
This content is only available via PDF.
You do not currently have access to this content.