A gantry crane is a device used for transporting heavy loads in many industrial areas. The device has a crucial challenge in the positioning of the trolley that can reduce work efficiency and cause work accidents. Many studies have proposed to solve that problem using Linear Quadratic Regulation (LQR), Proportional Integral Derivative (PID), and Particle Swarm Optimization (PSO) control methods due to their simplicity and robustness. However, these three methods are required further research to find the performance comparison. This study aims to compare the performance and robustness of LQR, PID-Manual and PID-PSO. This research was conducted by simulating the dynamic model of a gantry crane using MATLAB software. A dynamic model of the 2-D gantry crane prototype is derived using Newton’s 2nd Law and the simulation results show that the LQR is better than the PID-Manual and PID-PSO in all performance but with a specific flaw in the rise time value. The LQR controller is also able to maintain the performance of the gantry crane for various conditions, i.e. load mass and cable length variations.

1.
M. S.
Omar
,
H. I.
Jaafar
,
R.
Ghazali
,
S. H.
Mohamad
, and
K. A. M.
Annuar
, “
Investigation of Single Cart Gantry Crane System Performance using Scheduling Algorithm
,”
Int. J. Soft Comput. Eng.
, no.
6
, pp.
2231
2307
,
2015
.
2.
H. I.
Jaafar
,
S. Y. S.
Hussien
,
R.
Ghazali
, and
Z.
Mohamed
, “
Optimal tuning of PID+PD controller by PFS for Gantry Crane System
,”
2015 10th Asian Control Conf. Emerg. Control Tech. a Sustain. World, ASCC 2015
,
2015
, doi: .
3.
Z.
Wu
,
X.
Xia
, and
B.
Zhu
, “
Model predictive control for improving operational efficiency of overhea cranes
,”
Nonlinear Dyn.
, vol.
79
, no.
4
, pp.
2639
2657
,
2015
, doi: .
4.
M. I.
Solihin
,
Wahyudi
, and
A.
Legowo
, “
Fuzzy-tuned PID anti-swing control of automatic gantry crane
,”
JVC/Journal Vib. Control
, vol.
16
, no.
1
, pp.
127
145
,
2010
, doi: .
5.
H.
Lee
and
S.
Cho
, “
A New Fuzzy-Logic Anti-Swing Control for Industrial Three-Dimensional Overhead Cranes
,” pp.
2956
2961
,
2001
.
6.
Q.
Wu
,
X.
Wang
,
L.
Hua
, and
M.
Xia
, “
Dynamic analysis and time optimal anti-swing control of double pendulum bridge crane with distributed mass beams
,”
Mech. Syst. Signal Process.
, vol.
144
, p.
106968
,
2020
, doi: .
7.
N. D.
Zrnić
,
V. M.
Gašić
, and
S. M.
Bošnjak
, “
Dynamic responses of a gantry crane system due to a moving body considered as moving oscillator
,”
Arch. Civ. Mech. Eng.
, vol.
15
, no.
1
, pp.
243
250
,
2015
, doi: .
8.
M.
Nazemizadeh
, “
A LQR Optimal Method to Control the Position of an Overhead Crane
,”
IAES Int. J. Robot. Autom.
, vol.
3
, no.
4
, pp.
252
258
,
2014
, doi: .
9.
M. I.
Solihin
,
Wahyudi
,
M. A. S.
Kamal
, and
A.
Legowo
, “
Optimal PID controller tuning of automatic gantry crane using PSO algorithm
,”
Proceeding 5th Int. Symp. Mechatronics its Appl. ISMA 2008
, pp.
25
29
,
2008
, doi: .
10.
S. Y. Syed
Hussien
,
H. I.
Jaafar
,
R.
Ghazali
, and
N. R. Abdul
Razif
, “
The effects of auto-tuned method in PID and PD control scheme for gantry crane system
,”
Int. J. Soft Comput. Eng.
, vol.
4
, no.
6
, pp.
121
125
,
2015
, [Online]. Available: http://eprints.utem.edu.my/14047/1/%5B1%5D_F2492014615.pdf.
11.
H. I.
Jaafar
et al, “
Optimal performance of a nonlinear gantry crane system via priority-based fitness scheme in binary PSO algorithm
,”
IOP Conf. Ser. Mater. Sci. Eng.
, vol.
53
, no.
1
,
2013
, doi: .
12.
M. I.
Solihin
,
L. F.
Tack
, and
M. L.
Kean
, “
Tuning of PID Controller Using Particle Swarm Optimization (PSO
),”
Int. J. Adv. Sci. Eng. Inf. Technol.
, vol.
1
, no.
4
, p.
458
,
2011
, doi: .
13.
M. I.
Solihin
,
Wahyudi
,
M. A. S.
Kamal
, and
A.
Legowo
, “
Objective function selection of GA-based PID control optimization for automatic gantry crane
,”
Proc. Int. Conf. Comput. Commun. Eng. 2008, ICCCE08 Glob. Links Hum. Dev.
, pp.
883
887
,
2008
, doi: .
14.
Y. P.
Zhou
,
L. J.
Tang
,
J.
Jiao
,
D. D.
Song
,
J. H.
Jiang
, and
R. Q.
Yu
, “
Modified particle swarm optimization algorithm for adaptively configuring globally optimal classification and regression trees
,”
J. Chem. Inf. Model.
, vol.
49
, no.
5
, pp.
1144
1153
,
2009
, doi: .
15.
H. I.
Jaafar
and
Z.
Mohamed
, “
PSO-tuned PID controller for a nonlinear double-pendulum crane system
,”
Commun. Comput. Inf. Sci.
, vol.
752
, pp.
203
215
,
2012
, doi: .
16.
S. Y. S.
Hussien
,
R.
Ghazali
,
H. I.
Jaafar
, and
C. C.
Soon
, “
Robustness analysis for PID controller optimized using PFPSO for underactuated gantry crane system
,”
Proc. - 5th IEEE Int. Conf. Control Syst. Comput. Eng. ICCSCE 2015
, no. November, pp.
520
525
,
2015
, doi: .
This content is only available via PDF.
You do not currently have access to this content.