The expansion of the mosque is a common practice that aims to provide additional space for the increase in congregation members as well as to improve the facilities of the mosque. However, there are some issues and challenges that have to be faced in the expanding of heritage mosques. Some mosques in Malaysia have been designated as heritage sites and have been gazette under the National Heritage Act 2005 (Act 645). Act 645 has stipulated that any new development including expansion must comply with certain conditions as a heritage site. Department of National Heritage (DNH) has provided guidelines related to new developments at heritage sites in the Heritage Building Conservation Guidelines 2017. Although guidelines have been made available, reports from DNH indicate that issues involving the expansion works of heritage mosques continue to arise. There is dissatisfaction among the community of heritage mosques over the restriction made by DNH upon their expansion proposal. While DNH sees the expansion as potentially affecting the heritage value of the mosque, in contrary the mosque community sees it as important in continuation of using it. The purpose of this study is to discuss the issues and challenges surrounding the problems in the expansion of heritage mosques in Malaysia. This is a library-based study, follows qualitative approach by analyzing laws and guidelines in Malaysia that govern heritage sites development. The study results found that the conflict of values involving various stakeholders on the heritage mosque, the absence of clear criteria in the existing guidelines and the absence of community involvement in the evaluation process are the factors in the issue of expanding heritage mosques in Malaysia.

1.
Spahic
Omer
, “History and Theory of Islamic Architecture” (
IIUM Press
,
Gombak, Kuala Lumpur
,
2019
).
2.
N.A.
Baharudin
and
Ismail
,
Procedia Soc. Behav. Sci.
153
106
120
(
2014
).
3.
Norliza Mohd
Isa
, “Mosque Expansion and Renovations in Middle Class Housing Area”, (
Universiti Teknologi Malaysia
,
2007
).
4.
Z.
Guzmán-Torres
, “Historic Buildings and Contemporary Additions:
The Elements of a Cohesive Design Relationship”
(
University of Maryland
,
College Park
,
2009
).
5.
Hossam
Mahdy
, “
Guidelines for the Management of Historic Mosques
” (
International Conference on Mosque Architecture
,
2019
).
6.
Aidatul Fadzlin
Bakri
,
Norhati
Ibrahim
,
Sabarinah Sh
Ahmad
,
Nurulhusna Qamaruz
Zaman
, “
Valuing Built Cultural Heritage in a Malaysian Urban Context
” (
Asian Conference on Environment-Behaviour Studies
,
2014
).
7.
Government of Malaysia
, National Heritage Act 2005 (Act 645) (
The Commissioner of Law Revision Malaysia
,
2006
).
8.
Hasan-Uddin
Khan
,
Archnet-IJAR
,
9
1
1
17
(
2015
).
9.
Wijesuriya
Gamini
“Living Heritage-People Centered Approaches; Annexe-1, A summary.” (
ICCROM
,
Italy
,
2015
).
10.
Jokilehto
,
J.
Firenze: Edizioni Polistampa
,
21
36
(
2010
).
11.
Nigel
Walter
, “To Live is to Change-Tradition, Narrative and Community in the Conservation of Church Buildings” (
University of York Archaeology
,
2017
).
12.
Azni Mohd
Dian
,
Nuraisyah Chua
Abdullah
, “
Public Participation in Heritage Sites Conservation in Malaysia: Issues and challenges
” (
AMER International Conference on Quality of Life
,
2013
).
13.
Government of Malaysia
, “CMP and SAP Melaka & George Town, Historic Cities of the Straits of Malacca”, (
Government of Malaysia
,
2011
).
14.
Department of National Heritage
, “Guideline on Heritage Building Conservation” (
Kementerian Pelancongan dan Kebudayaan Malaysia
,
2017
).
15.
Ioannis
Poulios
, “Living sites: The Past in the Present - The monastic site of Meteora, Greece Towards a New Approach to Conservation” (
University College London
,
2008
).
16.
R. W.
Khalaf
, “The Search for the Meaning of ‘Compatibility’ Between New Construction and Heritage in Historic Areas: An Exploratory Study” (
The Historic Environment: Policy & Practice
,
2016
).
17.
Leila
Soosani
, “Questioning the Compatibility of the Infill Architecture in Historic Environment, Case Study:
Walled City of Nicosia”
(
Eastern Mediterranean University
,
Gazimağusa, North Cyprus
,
2013
).
19.
ICOMOS
, The Burra Charter – The Australia ICOMOS Charter for Places of Cultural Significance (
Australia
,
1999
).
This content is only available via PDF.
You do not currently have access to this content.