This study sought to investigate the purposes of students conducting thought experiments while solving physics problems. There were 12 voluntary participants in this study. They were undergraduate students at the Muhammadiyah University of Makassar in Indonesia. The participants were divided into three groups, so that each group consisted of four students. Physics problem-solving activities were used to set the necessary conditions for observing the processes of students in conducting thought experiments. The results show that while solving physics problems, students design and run thought experiments as a tool: to predict solutions to the problems, to check whether their hypothesis is true or false, and to provide further explanation about their hypothesis. Based on the results, we discuss the similarities and differences in goals between scientists and students in conducting thought experiments. We also discuss the importance and implications of thought experiments to both current and future physics teachers.

1.
Schrödinger
E.
Discussion of Probability Relations between Separated Systems
.
Math Proc Cambridge Philos Soc. 2008/10/24.
1935
;
31
(
4
):
555
63
.
2.
Mach
E.
,
Hiebert
E.N.
On Thought Experiments BT - Knowledge and Error: Sketches on the Psychology of Enquiry
. In:
Mach
E.
,
Hiebert
E.N.
, editors.
Dordrecht
:
Springer Netherlands
;
1976
. p.
134
47
.
3.
Brown
J.R.
The Laboratory of the Mind: Thought Experiments in the Natural Sciences
.
New York
:
Routledge
;
1991
.
4.
Gilbert
J.K.
,
Reiner
M.
Thought experiments in science education: potential and current realization
.
Int J Sci Educ.
2000
Mar 1;
22
(
3
):
265
83
.
5.
Gendler
T.S.
Thought Experiments Rethought-and Reperceived
.
Philos Sci.
2004
Dec 1;
71
(
5
):
1152
63
.
6.
Asikainen
M.A.
,
Hirvonen
P.E.
Probing Pre- and In-service Physics Teachers’ Knowledge Using the Double-Slit Thought Experiment
.
Sci Educ.
2014
;
23
(
9
):
1811
33
.
7.
Kösem
Ş.D.
,
Özdemir
Ö.F.
The Nature and Role of Thought Experiments in Solving Conceptual Physics Problems
.
Sci Educ.
2014
;
23
(
4
):
865
95
.
8.
Bancong
H.
,
Song
J.
Do Physics Textbooks Present the Ideas of Thought Experiments?: A Case in Indonesia
.
J Pendidik IPA Indones
Vol
7
, No
1
March
2018
DO - 1015294/jpii.v7i112257. 2018 Apr 3;
9.
Bobrytska
V.I.
,
Reva
T.D.
,
Protska
S.M.
,
Chkhalo
O.M.
Effectiveness and Stakeholders’ Perceptions of the Integration of Automated E-Learning Courses into Vocational Education Programmes in Universities in Ukraine
.
Int J Learn Teach Educ Res.
2020
;
19
(
5
):
27
46
.
10.
Clement
J.J.
The Role of Imagistic Simulation in Scientific Thought Experiments
.
Top Cogn Sci.
2009
Oct 1;
1
(
4
):
686
710
.
11.
Klassen
S.
The Science Thought Experiment: How Might it be Used Profitably in the Classroom?
Interchange.
2006
;
37
(
1
):
77
96
.
12.
Stephens
A.L.
,
Clement
J.J.
The Role of Thought Experiments in Science and Science Learning BT - Second International Handbook of Science Education
. In:
Fraser
B.J.
,
Tobin
K.
,
McRobbie
C.J.
, editors.
Dordrecht
:
Springer Netherlands
;
2012
. p.
157
75
.
13.
Einstein
A.
Zur Elektrodynamik bewegter Korper [AdP 17, 891 (1905)]
.
Ann Phys.
2005
Feb 23;
14
(
S1
):
194
224
.
This content is only available via PDF.
You do not currently have access to this content.