An approach is presented to compare two Markov Chains, particularly Continuous-Time Markov Chains (CTMC) such as to model Queueing Networks (QN). Here one may typically think of one CTMC or QN to be a solvable modification (e.g. a product form QN) of the other one, say the original, which is of practical interest but unsolvable. The approach is essentially based upon evaluating performance measures by cumulative reward structures and analytically bounding so-called bias-terms, also known as relative gains or fundamental matrix elements. A general comparison and error bound result will be provided. The approach, referred to as Markov Reward approach, is related to Stochastic Dynamic programming and

  • may lead to analytic error bounds for the discrepancy, and

  • may still apply while stochastic comparison fails

To motivate and illustrate the approach, the presentation will contain an instructive finite tandem queue example and a practical result for a real-life application of an Operation Theater-Intensive care unit system. Some remaining questions for research will be addressed briefly.

1.
N. M.
Van Dijk
, “Error bounds and comparison results: the Markov reward approach for queueing networks,” in
Queueing Networks
(
Springer
,
2011
), pp.
397
459
.
2.
P. G.
Taylor
and
N. M.
Van Dijk
, “
Strong stochastic bounds for the stationary distribution of a class of multi-component performability models
,”
Operations Research
46
,
665
674
(
1998
).
3.
N. M.
van Dijk
and
N.
Kortbeek
, “
Erlang loss bounds for OT–ICU systems
,”
Queueing Systems
63
,
253
280
(
2009
).
4.
R. J.
Boucherie
and
N. M.
van Dijk
, “
Monotonicity and error bounds for networks of Erlang loss queues
,”
Queueing systems
62
,
159
193
(
2009
).
5.
N. M.
van Dijk
and
E.
van der Sluis
, “
Call packing bound for overflow loss systems
,”
Performance Evaluation
66
,
1
20
(
2009
).
6.
N. M.
van Dijk
, “
Error bounds for state space truncation of finite Jackson networks
,”
European Journal of Operational Research
186
,
164
181
(
2008
).
7.
N. M.
Van Dijk
and
M.
Miyazawa
, “
Error bounds for perturbing nonexponential queues
,”
Mathematics of Operations Research
29
,
525
558
(
2004
).
8.
N. M.
Van Dijk
and
M. L.
Puterman
, “
Perturbation theory for Markov reward processes with applications to queueing systems
,”
Advances in Applied Probability
20
,
79
98
(
1988
).
This content is only available via PDF.
You do not currently have access to this content.