Carl E. Mungan proposed the following problem1:

Some teenagers are exploring the outer perimeter of a castle. They notice a spy hole in its wall, across the moat a horizontal distance x and vertically up the wall a distance y. They decide to throw pebbles at the hole. One girl wants to use physics to throw with the minimum speed necessary to hit the hole. What is the required launch speed v and launch angle above the horizontal? The situation is sketched in Fig. 1.

Fig. 1.

The trajectory of a stone launched with optimal speed v and angle θ such that it passes through a hole located at rectangular coordinates (x, y) relative to the launch point. In polar coordinates, the hole is located at (r, ϕ).

Fig. 1.

The trajectory of a stone launched with optimal speed v and angle θ such that it passes through a hole located at rectangular coordinates (x, y) relative to the launch point. In polar coordinates, the hole is located at (r, ϕ).

Close modal
The solution is
(1)
and
(2)
Equation (1) may be rewritten as
(3)

An alternative version of this problem is2,

Find the maximum r and corresponding θ for given v and ϕ,

to which the solution, equivalent to Eqs. (1)(3), can be found in Refs. 3 and 4. An elegant non-calculus solution of this problem, as pointed out by French,5 was presented in a 1927 textbook.6 Similar problems can be found in a modern textbook.7 

Another related problem is

Find the envelope of the projectile motion in the uniform gravitational field for the fixed initial speed v of the projectile.

The solution to this problem,8,9
(4)
is a parabola of safety, which separates the interior zone, where the projectile can reach, from an unattainable one; i.e., this parabola represents the maximum locus of the projectile as a function of ϕ. In polar coordinates, Eq. (4) is identical to Eq. (3).
1.
C. E.
Mungan
, “
Optimizing the launch of a projectile to hit a target
,”
Phys. Teach.
55
,
528
529
(
2017
).
2.
J. D.
Marx
, “
A unifying rule for maximizing the range or minimizing the launch and impact speed of a projectile along a tilted plane
,”
Phys. Teach.
61
,
739
741
(
2023
).
3.
H. A.
Buckmaster
, “
Ideal ballistic trajectories revisited
,”
Am. J. Phys.
53
,
638
641
(
1985
).
4.
H.
Van Dael
and
H.
Bert
, “
Range of a projectile
,”
Am. J. Phys.
47
,
466
(
1979
).
5.
A. P.
French
, “
Projectile range on an inclined plane
,”
Am. J. Phys.
52
,
299
(
1984
).
6.
S. L.
Loney
,
The Elements of Statics and Dynamics
, 5th ed. (
Cambridge University Press
,
Cambridge
,
1927
).
7.
R. A.
Serway
and
J.
Jewett
,
Physics for Scientists and Engineers
, 6th ed. (
Thomson, Brooks/Cole
,
2004
), pp.
91
, 109 (problem #72).
8.
J.
Rossel
,
Physique générale
(
Ed. Du Griffon
,
Paris
,
1960
).
9.
M.
Bass
et al., “
The envelope of projectile trajectories
,”
Eur. J. Phys.
23
,
637
(
2002
).