Among the many perplexing results of quantum mechanics is one that contradicts a result from introductory physics: the possibility of finding a quantum particle in a region that would be forbidden classically by energy conservation.1 An especially interesting example of this phenomenon with practical applications is quantum tunneling.2,3 Here we investigate the reasons for this puzzling result by focusing on the difference between how quantities like kinetic and potential energy are represented mathematically in classical and quantum mechanics. In quantum mechanics, physical observables, like energy, are represented by operators rather than real numbers. The consequences of this difference will be illustrated explicitly using a toy model in which the kinetic and potential energy operators are represented by 2 × 2 matrices, which do not commute like their classical analogs. This model will then illustrate how classically perplexing results, like a quantum particle being found in the forbidden region,...
Skip Nav Destination
Article navigation
January 2025
PAPERS|
January 01 2025
How Can a Quantum Particle be Found in a Classically Forbidden Region?
Special Collection:
Quantum Topics in the Introductory Physics Classroom
Dennis Krause
;
Dennis Krause
Wabash College
, Crawfordsville, IN
Search for other works by this author on:
Nikolai Jones
Nikolai Jones
Wabash College
, Crawfordsville, IN
Search for other works by this author on:
Dennis Krause, Wabash College, Crawfordsville, IN; [email protected]
Phys. Teach. 63, 16–19 (2025)
Citation
Dennis Krause, Nikolai Jones; How Can a Quantum Particle be Found in a Classically Forbidden Region?. Phys. Teach. 1 January 2025; 63 (1): 16–19. https://doi.org/10.1119/5.0166989
Download citation file:
Pay-Per-View Access
$40.00
Sign In
You could not be signed in. Please check your credentials and make sure you have an active account and try again.
173
Views
Citing articles via
A “Perpetual Motion Machine” Powered by Electromagnetism
Hollis Williams
Jack Reacher and the Deployment of an Airbag
Gregory A. DiLisi, Richard A. Rarick
Sauntering Sauropods: The Preferred Walking Speeds of the Largest Land Animals That Ever Lived
Scott A. Lee, Justyna Slowiak
Related Content
Magnetic Symmetry and “Forbidden” Effects
American Journal of Physics (February 1964)
One step beyond the electric dipole approximation: An experiment to observe the 5p → 6p forbidden transition in atomic rubidium
Am. J. Phys. (January 2018)
Breaking the sound barrier: Tunneling of acoustic waves through the forbidden transmission region of a one-dimensional acoustic band gap array
American Journal of Physics (July 2002)
Analytic, graphical, and geometric solutions for photonic band gaps
American Journal of Physics (November 2004)
Three Misconceptions About Radiation — And What We Teachers Can Do to Confront Them
Phys. Teach. (September 2014)