Aristotle’s wheel paradox is a fascinating example of a classical puzzle that can pique a student’s interest. The existing explanations in the literature are limited to discussions of the wheel trajectory; in this paper, we study the paradox from the viewpoint of motion decomposition, an approach we consider more intuitive. The motion of the point at the wheel edge can be resolved into a uniform rectilinear motion and a uniform circular motion. By analyzing the velocity of the point on the edge of the small wheel, we conclude that when the large wheel is rolling at a constant speed without slipping, the small wheel does actually both roll and slide.
References
1.
I. E.
Drabkin
“Aristotle’s wheel: Notes on the history of a paradox
,” Osiris
9
, 162
–198
(1950
).2.
O.
Nicodemi
, “Galileo and Aristotle’s wheel
,” J. Humanist. Math.
4
, 2
–15
(2014
).3.
J.
van Leeuwen
, The Aristotelian Mechanics: Text and Diagrams
(Springer
2016
).4.
P.
Costabel
, “The wheel of Aristotle and French consideration of Galileo’s arguments
,” Math. Teach.
61
, 527
–534
(1968
).5.
D.
Ballew
, “The wheel of Aristotle
,” Math. Teach.
65
, 507
–509
(1972
).6.
E. W.
Weisstein
, “Aristotle’s Wheel Paradox
,” MathWorld—A Wolfram Web Resource, https://mathworld.wolfram.com/AristotlesWheelParadox.html.7.
P.
Veronesi
, “Classical dynamics of particles and systems
,” Nuov. Cim. A
4
, 31
–432
(1971
).8.
T.
Pritchett
, R. C.
Nelson
, T. J.
Creamer
, and B. G.
Oldaker
, “Does an ideal wheel really rotate about its instantaneous point of contact?
” Phys. Teach.
36
, 167
(March
1998
).9.
S.
Gong
and K.-L.
Ting
, “A novel wheel/tyre dynamics model and derivation of a generalized friction law
,” Proc. Inst. Mech. Eng. Part D-J. Automob. Eng.
222
, 173
–189
(2008
).© 2022 Author(s). Published under an exclusive license by American Association of Physics Teachers.
2022
Author(s)
AAPT members receive access to The Physics Teacher and the American Journal of Physics as a member benefit. To learn more about this member benefit and becoming an AAPT member, visit the Joining AAPT page.