Gay-Lussac’s law states that the pressure of an ideal gas is directly proportional to its absolute temperature if the volume is constant. Students observe this relationship by taking measurements on the pressure of gas in a flask or metal sphere at different temperatures and then extrapolate the data to estimate absolute zero. In our college physics classes, we noticed that student estimates were always near −280 °C (vs. the correct value of −273.15 °C) when using a 125-ml flask or −315 °C with a 25-ml flask. In fact, instructor’s notes from Vernier and Carolina Supply provide estimates of −283 °C and −289 °C for absolute zero, respectively. Additional work has shown that the primary problem with the Gay-Lussac experiment is that the volume in the measurement system outside the heated flask or sphere must be minimized to get estimates of absolute zero close to the theoretical value. Increasing the flask or sphere size can minimize the error in this experiment. While these observations have been noted, these researchers did not present the full theory to explain this effect, or how to account for the volume outside the heated flask. Here we derive the theory for two connected volumes at two different temperatures and show why many experiments provide estimates of absolute zero that are too low. We also provide two alternative ways to estimate absolute zero using the two-volume model. These methods provide significant reduction in error and provide an excellent learning experience for students in introductory physics or chemistry classes.
Skip Nav Destination
,
Article navigation
January 2019
PAPERS|
January 01 2019
Improved Gay-Lussac Experiment Considering Added Volumes
Joel D. Krehbiel
Joel D. Krehbiel
Hesston College
, Hesston, KS
Search for other works by this author on:
Nelson Kilmer
Joel D. Krehbiel
Hesston College
, Hesston, KSPhys. Teach. 57, 21–25 (2019)
Citation
Nelson Kilmer, Joel D. Krehbiel; Improved Gay-Lussac Experiment Considering Added Volumes. Phys. Teach. 1 January 2019; 57 (1): 21–25. https://doi.org/10.1119/1.5084921
Download citation file:
Pay-Per-View Access
$40.00
Sign In
You could not be signed in. Please check your credentials and make sure you have an active account and try again.
Citing articles via
A “Perpetual Motion Machine” Powered by Electromagnetism
Hollis Williams
Challenging ChatGPT with Different Types of Physics Education Questions
Víctor López-Simó, Mikael Frank Rezende, Jr.
Related Content
What Gay-Lussac didn’t tell us
Am. J. Phys. (January 2011)
Kitchen Physics: Lessons in Fluid Pressure and Error Analysis
Phys. Teach. (February 2017)
Studying Avogadro’s Law with Arduino
Phys. Teach. (December 2019)
Using a modified Boyle’s law experiment to estimate the density of salts
Phys. Teach. (January 2019)
Revisiting the round bottom flask rainbow experiment
Am. J. Phys. (January 2018)