At the 2015 AAPT Summer Meeting, I presented four derivations of the formula for motional emf. Such physics derivations involve the construction of explanatory frameworks involving diagrams and mathematical models. Although textbooks devote considerable space to such explanations, many teachers and students spend their time on worksheets, end-of-chapter problems, and the like. The book is reduced to a bank of solved (i.e., example) and unsolved (i.e., homework) questions, along with equations in colored boxes that presumably are to be used to answer those questions. Such an approach encourages fragmentation of knowledge, the view that there is only one right answer to a problem with the goal of physics being to find that answer (neatly boxed of course), and the inability to reason about even a slightly different (much less a novel) situation. If we are to develop scientific literacy, significant course time must be devoted to explaining the structure of and support for the models and equations we use.
Skip Nav Destination
Article navigation
IN MY OPINION|
May 01 2016
Citation
Carl E. Mungan; In defense of derivations,. Phys. Teach. 1 May 2016; 54 (5): 316–317. https://doi.org/10.1119/1.4947168
Download citation file:
Pay-Per-View Access
$40.00
Sign In
You could not be signed in. Please check your credentials and make sure you have an active account and try again.
Citing articles via
A “Perpetual Motion Machine” Powered by Electromagnetism
Hollis Williams
Sauntering Sauropods: The Preferred Walking Speeds of the Largest Land Animals That Ever Lived
Scott A. Lee, Justyna Slowiak
Jack Reacher and the Deployment of an Airbag
Gregory A. DiLisi, Richard A. Rarick
Related Content
Guard Digits vs. Roundoff Error vs. Overall Uncertainty
Phys. Teach. (November 2018)
Rolling the Black Pearl Over: Analyzing the Physics of a Movie Clip
The Physics Teacher (May 2011)
Introducing Earth's Orbital Eccentricity
Phys. Teach. (December 2015)
Mechanical Energy Change in Inertial Reference Frames
Phys. Teach. (September 2016)
Five ways of deriving the equation of motion for rolling bodies
Am. J. Phys. (December 2012)