A ternary diagram is a graphical representation used for systems with three components. They are familiar to mineralogists (who typically use them to categorize varieties of solid solution minerals such as feldspar) but are not yet widely used in the physics community. Last year the lead author began using ternary diagrams in his introductory (calculus-based) physics course in a novel context—tracking the distribution of energy in a system as it transforms among three categories (e.g., gravitational, kinetic, and thermal) or transfers among three objects (e.g., inductor, capacitor, and resistor). The ternary diagram has some significant advantages over other graphical representations of energy distributions: an entire scenario can appear in a single plot, even when using very small time steps. This also means that the plot can be used to compare relative rates of energy change during various processes. Our goal for this paper is to introduce the ternary diagram and discuss these advantages in hopes that this will stimulate broader use of ternary diagrams and further research into their educational utility.

1.
The online appendix can be found as [supplementary material] available under the “References” tab at TPT Online, http://dx.doi.org/10.1119/1.4944360 .
2.
The value of 0.89 is found in
K. C.
Maynes
,
M. G.
Compton
, and
Blaine
Baker
, “
Coefficient of restitution measurement for sports balls: An investigative approach
,”
Phys. Teach.
43
,
352
354
(
Sept.
2005
).
A nice approach to measuring elastic energy can be found in
Eric
Gettrust
, “
The energetics of bouncing (revisited): A quantitative demonstration of energy conservation during bouncing
,”
Phys. Teach.
44
,
428
429
(
Oct.
2006
).
3.
Ruth
Chabay
and
Bruce
Sherwood
, “
Computational physics in the introductory calculus-based course
,”
Am. J. Phys.
76
,
307
313
(
April
2008
).
4.
Mark
Nagurka
, “
Aerodynamic effects in a dropped Ping-Pong ball experiment
,”
Int. J. Eng. Educ.
19
(
4
),
623
630
(
2003
).
5.
Abigail R.
Daane
,
Lindsay
Wells
, and
Rachel E.
Scherr
, “
Energy Theater
,”
Phys. Teach.
52
,
291
294
(
May
2014
) and
Leslie J.
Atkins
 et al, “
Animating energy: Stop-motion animation and energy tracking representations
,”
Phys. Teach.
52
,
152
156
(
March
2014
). There are also PhET simulations relevant to the roller coaster and LRC circuit.
6.
We attempted to use data from a real roller coaster, acquired with a Vernier WDSS system during Six Flags Physics Day. However, the altimeter measurements have relatively low precision, a somewhat slow response rate, and hysteresis, as described in the WDSS spec sheet, which is available from the Vernier website. Cellphone data seem to have some of the same issues—see
R.
Vieyra
and
C.
Vieyra
, “
Analyzing forces on amusement park rides with mobile devices
,”
Phys. Teach.
52
,
149
151
(
March
2014
).
Although the simulated coaster's track shape differs from the real roller coaster analyzed in
Alberghi
 et al, “
Is it more thrilling to ride at the front or the back of a roller coaster?
Phys. Teach.
45
,
536
541
(
Dec.
2007
), our primary motivation here is not to attempt to develop the most accurate model coaster, but rather to demonstrate energy transformations on ternary diagrams.
7.
Air resistance generally is described as being proportional to velocity at low velocities and proportional to velocity squared at higher velocities—e.g., see
J.
Varriano
, “
Energy diagrams with drag forces
,”
Phys. Teach.
34
,
546
548
(
Dec.
1996
).
8.
Ternary diagrams could nicely complement the energy flow diagrams described by
A.
Hobson
, “
Energy flow diagrams for teaching physics concepts
,”
Phys. Teach.
42
,
113
117
(
Feb.
2004
), which also can be used as power diagrams.
9.
This approach is analogous to the “half-step integration method” described by
Norris W.
Preyer
, “
The coupled harmonic oscillator: Not just for seniors anymore
,”
Phys. Teach.
34
,
52
55
(
Jan.
1996
).

Supplementary Material

AAPT members receive access to The Physics Teacher and the American Journal of Physics as a member benefit. To learn more about this member benefit and becoming an AAPT member, visit the Joining AAPT page.