As we typically teach in an introductory mechanics course, choosing a “good” coordinate frame with convenient axes may present a major simplification to a problem. Additionally, knowing some conserved quantities provides an extremely powerful problem-solving tool. While the former idea is typically discussed in the context of Newton's laws, the latter starts with introducing conservation of energy even later. This work presents an elegant example of implementing both aforementioned ideas in the kinematical context, thus providing a “warm-up” introduction to the standard tools used later on in dynamics. Both the choice of the (non-orthogonal) coordinate frame and the conserved quantities are rather nonstandard, yet at the same time quite intuitive to the problem at hand. Two such problems are discussed in detail with two alternative approaches. The first approach does not even require knowledge of calculus. In an online appendix,1 I also present the brute-force solution involving a coupled system of differential equations. In addition, a few exercises and another similar problem for students' “homework” are provided in the appendix.
Skip Nav Destination
Article navigation
April 2013
PAPERS|
April 01 2013
Thinking Outside of the Rectangular Box
Mikhail Kagan
Mikhail Kagan
a)
Pennsylvania State University
, Abington, PA
Search for other works by this author on:
a)
Mikhail Kagan. Dept. of Science & Engineering, Pennsylvania State University Abington, PA 19001 ; mak411@psu.edu
Phys. Teach. 51, 215–217 (2013)
Citation
Mikhail Kagan; Thinking Outside of the Rectangular Box . Phys. Teach. 1 April 2013; 51 (4): 215–217. https://doi.org/10.1119/1.4795360
Download citation file:
Pay-Per-View Access
$40.00
Sign In
You could not be signed in. Please check your credentials and make sure you have an active account and try again.
Citing articles via
Direct Observations and Measurements of Single Atoms
Natascha Hedrich, Ilia Sergachev, et al.
Using Math in Physics: 6. Reading the physics in a graph
Edward F. Redish
Where Is Half of the Universe?
Don Lincoln
Related Content
The “Finding Physics” Project: Recognizing and Exploring Physics Outside the Classroom
Phys. Teach. (November 2016)
Sparking Curiosity: How Do You Know What Your Students Are Thinking?
Phys. Teach. (November 2015)
Helping Students to Think Like Scientists in Socratic Dialogue-Inducing Labs
Phys. Teach. (January 2012)
Kinesthetic Investigations in the Physics Classroom
Phys. Teach. (February 2014)
Student understanding of the angular momentum of classical particles
Am. J. Phys. (October 2011)